Leeder v The State of Western Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 64 min read

JURISDICTION     :   SUPREME COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

TITLE OF COURT  :   THE COURT OF APPEAL (WA)

CITATION:   LEEDER -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2008] WASCA 192

CORAM:   BUSS JA

MILLER JA
NEWNES AJA

HEARD:   23 MAY 2008

DELIVERED          :   19 SEPTEMBER 2008

FILE NO/S:   CACV 56 of 2007

BETWEEN:   RICHARD ALVIN LEEDER

Appellant

AND

THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA
Respondent

ON APPEAL FROM:

Jurisdiction              :  DISTRICT COURT OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA

Coram  :STAVRIANOU DCJ

Citation  :LEEDER -v- THE STATE OF WESTERN AUSTRALIA [2007] WADC 16

File No  :CIV 512 of 2005

Catchwords:

Negligence - Personal injury - Assault of prison officer by prisoner - Claim by prison officer that employer negligent in failing to warn him of prisoner's previous aggressive conduct - Finding of trial judge that warning was given - Finding that warning would not have prevented assault - Findings not open to trial judge on the evidence - Failure by trial judge to explain why evidence of defendant's medical witnesses preferred to that of plaintiff's medical witnesses - Obligation to assess effect of inaccuracies in medical history on opinion given by medical witness - Requirement to give adequate reasons for decision

Legislation:

Nil

Result:

Appeal allowed
Order for retrial on damages

Category:    B

Representation:

Counsel:

Appellant:     Mr G Droppert

Respondent:     Mr D M G Burton

Solicitors:

Appellant:     CLP Lawyers

Respondent:     SRB Legal

Case(s) referred to in judgment(s):

Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] NSWCA 131

Amaca Pty Ltd v Hannell (2007) 34 WAR 109

Beer v Duracraft Pty Ltd [2004] WASCA 192

Bennett v Minister of Community Welfare (1992) 176 CLR 408

Dobler v Halverson [2007] NSWCA 335

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118

Leeder v The State of Western Australia [2007] WADC 16

Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Hamsher (1992) 35 FCR 359

Mount Lawley Pty Ltd v Western Australian Planning Commission (2004) WAR 273

Williams v The Minister Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 and The State of New South Wales [2000] NSWCA 255

  1. BUSS JA:  I agree with Newnes AJA.

  2. MILLER JA:  I agree with Newnes AJA.

  3. NEWNES AJA:  This appeal arises out of an incident at the Hakea Prison on 1 February 2000 in which the appellant, then a prison officer employed by the respondent at the prison, was injured as a result of being assaulted by a prisoner (Willett) after he had opened the door to Willett's cell to allow a nurse into the cell to assess Willett.

  4. The appellant subsequently brought an action for damages against the respondent alleging that his injuries were caused by the negligence of the respondent as the occupier or controller of the prison.  The appellant said that as a result of the assault he suffered, among other things, an injury to his spine and a major depressive illness, resulting in his total, or substantial, and permanent incapacity for work.

  5. The respondent denied that it was negligent in any respect but said that, if it was…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Leeder v The State of Western Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] WASCA 192
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Leeder v The State of Western Australia, the plaintiff, Leeder, brought a claim against the State of Western Australia for negligence, alleging that the defendant failed to warn him of a prisoner's previous aggressive conduct, which led to an assault on him while he was a prison officer. The trial judge found that a warning had indeed been given but determined that such a warning would not have prevented the assault. Additionally, the trial judge preferred the evidence of the defendant's medical witnesses over that of the plaintiff's medical witnesses without adequately explaining the reasons for this preference, nor did the trial judge assess the impact of inaccuracies in the medical history on the opinions given by the medical witnesses.

The primary legal issues before the court involved the correctness of the trial judge's findings of fact and the adequacy of the reasons provided for preferring certain medical evidence over others. The court needed to determine whether the trial judge had erred in his findings, particularly regarding the causation of the broken window and the preference for certain medical evidence. The court also had to consider whether the trial judge had adequately justified his decision and fulfilled his obligation to provide sufficient reasons for his conclusions.

The court concluded that the trial judge had erred in finding that the window was not broken by Willett, as the only plausible conclusion based on the evidence was that Willett broke the window while in the cell. Furthermore, the trial judge failed to adequately explain why he preferred the defendant's medical evidence over the plaintiff's and did not assess the effect of inaccuracies in the medical history on the medical opinions. The Full Federal Court emphasized that an appellant must demonstrate that a factual error was made by the trial judge, rather than merely showing an alternative finding was possible. The court found that the trial judge had not sufficiently justified his preference for certain medical evidence, thus failing to meet the obligation to provide adequate reasons for his decision.

As a result of these errors, the appeal was allowed, and the matter was ordered to be retried on the issue of damages.

Orders

Orders of the court

Appeal allowed

Order for retrial on damages

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As the appeal turns substantially on the learned trial judge's findings of fact, it must also be recognised that the onus which lies on an appellant who appeals against findings of fact goes beyond merely showing that an alternative finding was available on the facts. The appellant must show that a factual error was made by the learned trial judge. As the Full Federal Court said in Minister for Immigration, Local Government and Ethnic Affairs v Hamsher (1992) 35 FCR 359:The court must be satisfied that the judgment of the trial judge is erroneous and it may be so satisfied if it reaches the conclusion that the trial judge failed to draw inferences that should have been drawn from the facts established by the evidence. The court is unlikely to be satisfied if all that is shown is that the trial judge made a choice between competing inferences, being a choice the court may not have been inclined to make but not a choice the trial judge should not have made [369]. See also Williams v The Minister Aboriginal Land Rights Act 1983 and The State of New South Wales [2000] NSWCA 255 [60]; Adler v Australian Securities and Investments Commission [2003] NSWCA 131 [17]; Dobler v Halverson [2007] NSWCA 335 [52]. Against that background, I turn to the specific grounds of appeal relied upon by the appellant. As I have mentioned, it was not in issue that following the incident with Mr Pulford, Willett was placed in cell C5 at about 3.50 pm on 31 January 2000. At 6.35 pm, after his evening meal, Willett was moved to cell C3. Mr White accepted, on the basis of the repair request he prepared on 31 January 2000, that the window had been broken by the time he left work that day at 7.30 pm. In cross‑examination he accepted that it must have been broken after Willett was placed in the cell and that logically the only explanation was that Willett broke the window some time between 3.50 pm and 6.35 pm, when he was moved to C3. There was no evidence that any other prisoner was placed in C5 that day after Willett was moved out of it at 6.35 pm. Mr White said in evidence that a prisoner would not be left in a cell with a broken window. There was also no evidence to suggest that the window might have been broken by some other prisoner from outside C5. It was, of course, for the appellant to satisfy the trial judge on the balance of probabilities that Willett broke the window. It was not incumbent upon the respondent to establish that the window was broken by someone other than Willett, or to show how it came to be broken or by whom it was broken. But on the evidence, the only conclusion reasonably open was that the window was broken by Willett. With respect, in the absence of any other plausible possibility, it was not sufficient for the learned trial judge simply to say that he was not satisfied the window was broken by Willett. In my view, in so concluding, the learned trial judge erred. He should have found as a fact that the window was broken by Willett while he was in cell C5.