Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd v Kelly; Kelly v Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 78 min read

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY A MEMBER

CITATION:

Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd v Kelly; Kelly v Lazio Formwork PTY LTD [2023] NSWPICPD 40

APPELLANT:

Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd (A1-W3685/22)

John Kelly (A2-W3685/22)

RESPONDENT:

John Kelly (A1-W3685/22)

Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd (A2-W3685/22)

INSURER:

GIO General Ltd

FILE NUMBER:

A1-W3685/22

A2-W3685/22

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:

Deputy President Michael Snell

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:

17 July 2023

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1. Leave is granted to the employer, pursuant to s 352(3A) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, to bring an interlocutory appeal in matter no. A1-W3685/22.

2. To the extent that it is necessary, leave is granted to the worker pursuant to s 352(3A) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998, to bring an interlocutory appeal in matter no. A2‑W3685/22.

3. The time for the worker to bring an appeal in matter no. A2-W3685/22 is extended to 17 April 2023, pursuant to s 352(4) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998.

4.     The employer’s appeal in matter no. A1‑W3685 succeeds.

5.     The worker’s appeal in matter no. A2‑W3685 fails.

6.     The Member’s decision dated 13 September 2022 is revoked.

7.     In lieu thereof, there is an award for the respondent (the employer).

CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION – Factual error; extension of time to appeal – application of Bryce v Department of Corrective Services [2009] NSWCA 188; Yacoub v Pilkington (Australia) Ltd [2007] NSWCA 290; the duty to give reasons – Soulemezis v Dudley (Holdings) Pty Ltd (1987) 10 NSWLR 247; Pollard v RRR Corporation Pty Ltd [2009] NSWCA 110; alleged denial of procedural fairness – Dranichnikov v Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs [2003] HCA 26; 197 ALR 389; s 322A of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998 – application of Merchant v Shoalhaven City Council [2015] NSWWCCPD 13; Galluzzo v Little [2013] NSWCA 116; injury pursuant to s 4 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 – the ‘disease’ provisions; application of Crisp v Chapman (1994) 10 NSWCCR 492

HEARING:

14 April 2023

REPRESENTATION:

Appellant/Employer:

Mr Andrew Parker, counsel

Bartier Perry

Respondent/Worker:

Mr B McManamey, counsel

MTM Legal

DECISION UNDER APPEAL

MEMBER:

Mr P Young

DATE OF MEMBER’S DECISION:

13 September 2022

INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

  1. John Kelly (the worker) performed physically hard work in the building industry, erecting and dismantling formwork, from about 1984. He worked with multiple employers over the years. On 1 July 1988, while working with Daros Constructions, he fell from formwork injuring his spine, right leg and a middle finger. He said he had three weeks off work and then resumed working with intermittent back and neck pain, which worsened with time. He suffered an injury to his back in August 1992 while carrying timber upstairs at a site at Macquarie Shopping Centre. He worked with Fast Form at that time. He stated that he was off work for eight…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd v Kelly; Kelly v Lazio Formwork Pty L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] NSWPICPD 40
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd v Kelly; Kelly v Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd, the dispute arose from a workers' compensation claim, with both parties contesting the decision made by the Commission. The court was tasked with reviewing the merits of the Commission's determination, particularly focusing on the procedural and legal correctness of the decision-making process. The primary legal issues that the court had to address included whether there was a factual error in the Commission's findings, the application of the duty to give reasons under Rule 78 of the Rules, and the alleged denial of procedural fairness. Specifically, the court had to determine whether the Commission's reasons sufficiently engaged with relevant legal principles and whether there was a procedural error that warranted redetermination of the case.

The court meticulously examined the Commission's reasoning, particularly in relation to Section 322A of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. The Member's reasons were found lacking as they did not meaningfully address this section or the overall legislative scheme. The employer's argument was bolstered by the decision in Merchant v Shoalhaven City Council, which was pertinent to the case at hand. The court found that the failure to consider Merchant constituted a significant error, as it was directly relevant to the argument presented. Furthermore, the court highlighted that the reasoning process of the Member did not adequately address the applicable law, which is a critical component of Rule 78. The submissions from both parties underscored the importance of properly engaging with relevant legal authorities.

As a result of the court's findings, it was determined that the Commission's decision contained a factual error and failed to provide adequate reasons as required by Rule 78. Consequently, the court ruled that the matter should be redetermined. This decision underscores the necessity for decision-makers to thoroughly engage with relevant legal precedents and to provide comprehensive reasons that reflect an understanding of the applicable law. The court's decision emphasized the importance of procedural fairness and the duty to give reasons in administrative law, ensuring that all relevant legal issues are appropriately addressed.

The final orders of the court included the redetermination of the case by a different Member of the Commission, ensuring that the new determination would be based on a proper application of the law and the provision of adequate reasons. The costs of the appeal were also awarded to the applicant, Lazio Formwork Pty Ltd, reflecting the significance of the errors identified in the original decision.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Rule 78 of the Rules provides:“78 Statement of reasons for decision(1) This rule applies only in relation to the following applicable proceedings—(a)Commission proceedings,(b)merit review proceedings.(2) A determination of the appropriate decision-maker in applicable proceedings to which this rule applies is to be accompanied by a brief statement of the appropriate decision-maker’s reasons for the determination that includes the following—(a)the appropriate decision-maker’s findings on material questions of fact, referring to the evidence or other material on which those findings were based,(b)the appropriate decision-maker’s understanding of the applicable law,(c)the reasoning processes that led the appropriate decision-maker to the conclusions made.” The Member’s reasons dealing with s 322A of the 1998 Act failed to engage in any meaningful way with the section and the scheme of the legislation. The employer relied on the decision of Keating P in Merchant, which dates back to 2015, and which has been applied in the Commission, including the former WCC. The decision in Merchant was on point and supported the employer’s argument. Mr Parker submitted that proper reasons at least would have required a consideration of Merchant and Tokich and why s 322A did not prevent the referral.[159] The following exchange occurred at the oral hearing on 14 April 2023:“MR PARKER: … this type of submission has been made in a number of cases, but perhaps the most relevant one is in Merchant – now, this was the specific submission made in Merchant, and effectively the same submission made to Member Young by the worker. And if I can just transgress back into what I was saying about why there’s an error, there must be at least an error. One would [have] expected the Member to have dealt with this, at least this part of Merchant. When one party says that it’s essentially binding, or very powerful dicta, right on point, dealing with this particular submission, the other party seems to accept it does – it’s the same submission, but it’s not binding, which was – which, in fairness to my friend, what he said – you would expect a Member to turn his mind to it and specifically address it. DEPUTY PRESIDENT: It wasn’t addressed at all, was it?MR PARKER: No. That must be an error. That must be jurisdiction for this court to intervene.”[160] [159] See T2 18.28–20.2.[160] T2 24.23–25.9. When the worker’s counsel addressed at the oral hearing the following was said:“MR McMANAMEY: … the common view of the parties is that if you find error, that the matter should be redetermined, I propose to limit my submission as to what actually is the correct legal position.DEPUTY PRESIDENT: Is there tacit acceptance, from your perspective, that redetermination is needed, that error is demonstrated? MR McMANAMEY: I don’t wish to be heard and I’m not saying anything as to whether or not there was an error in the first place, other than the submission which is, whatever error there may have been, the outcome is nonetheless correct, subject to the costs. DEPUTY PRESIDENT: I mean, the reason[s] the argument on its own would seem fairly powerful in the circumstances - - -MR McMANAMEY: I think that’s fair, Deputy President, from that.DEPUTY PRESIDENT: All right.MR McMANAMEY: I think it’s a question, really, of what is the approach.”[161][161] T2 30.2–27.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established