Lavender v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 32 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Lavender v Commonwealth of Australia [2022] FCA 314

File number(s): NSD 1590 of 2019
Judgment of: PERRY J
Date of judgment: 31 March 2022
Catchwords: NATIVE TITLE – application for summary dismissal of claim for declarations that the applicants in their personal capacities hold native title rights to fish in certain New South Wales waters – where applicants also seek injunctive relief to prevent State interference with alleged native title rights to fish and exemplary damages – where applicants rely on High Court decision in Akiba and alleged ancestral connection to Muralug Island, Torres Strait – where applicants failed to clearly define or map the areas where native title rights are claimed (Claim Area) – where applicants seek to join the Illawarra Fishing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporation (Corporation) as an applicant in their place – where no approved native title determination over the Claim Area and no prescribed body corporate – where applicants are not native title holders under the Akiba Native Title Determination – application based on misconception that Akiba decided that native title rights to access and take resources offshore for any purpose is recognised automatically throughout Australia – where no cohesive or reasonable argument put forward as to the non-application of NSW fisheries laws – where application has no reasonable prospects of success – application for joinder dismissed – application summarily dismissed
Legislation:

Constitution ss 51(xxvi), 109

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 31A(2)

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 78B

Native Title Act 1993 (Cth) ss 13(1)(a), 55, 56, 57, 61(1), 62(1)(b), 62(2)(a), 62(2)(b), 211(1), 225(a), 225(b)

Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) rr 16.21, 26.01(1)(a), 26.01(1)(c)

Fisheries Management Act 1994 (NSW) s 7

Cases cited:

ACCC v Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd [2021] FCA 153; (2021) 150 ACSR 165

Akiba on behalf of the Torres Strait Regional Seas Claim Group v Commonwealth [2013] HCA 33; (2013) 250 CLR 209

Akiba on behalf of the Torres Strait Islanders of the Regional Seas Claim Group v Queensland (No 3) [2010] FCA 643; (2010) 204 FCR 1

Allstate Life Insurance Company v Australia and New Zealand Banking Group Ltd [1995] FCA 481; (1995) 58 FCR 26

Commonwealth v Akiba on behalf of the Torres Strait Islanders of the Regional Seas Claim Group [2012] FCAFC 25; (2012) 204 FCR 260

Ferella v Official Trustee in Bankruptcy (No 2) [2018] FCA 18

Przybylowski v Australian Human Rights Commission (No 2) [2018] FCA 473

Re Culleton [2017] HCA 3; (2017) 340 ALR 550

Shammas v Canberra Institute of Technology [2014] FCA 71

Unpaid Systems Ltd v Telstra Corporation Ltd [2016] FCAFC 158; (2016) 122 IPR 190

Western Australia v Commonwealth [1995] HCA 47; (1995) 183 CLR 373

Division: General Division
Registry New South Wales
National Practice Area: Native Title
Number of paragraphs 46
Date of hearing 22 March 2021
Counsel for the applicants The applicants appeared in person
Counsel for the second to…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lavender v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 314
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lavender v Commonwealth of Australia is an application for summary dismissal of a native title claim by Ralph and Jack Lavender. The applicants sought declarations that they hold native title rights to fish in certain New South Wales waters, as well as injunctive relief and damages against the respondents for interfering with their alleged native title rights. The NSW respondents, namely the Minister for Agriculture and Western New South Wales, Revenue NSW, and the New South Wales Department of Primary Industries, filed an application for summary dismissal of the claim, arguing that it had no reasonable prospects of success. The applicants also sought to join the Illawarra Fishing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporation as an applicant in their place, but this application was dismissed.

The primary legal issue the court had to decide was whether the applicants' claim had reasonable prospects of success, and therefore whether the application for summary dismissal should be granted. The court had to consider the applicants' reliance on the High Court decision in Akiba, their alleged ancestral connection to Muralug Island, Torres Strait, and the lack of clarity in defining or mapping the areas where native title rights were claimed. The court also had to consider the applicants' failure to join the Corporation as an applicant, the lack of an approved native title determination over the claimed area, and the non-application of NSW fisheries laws.

The court found that the applicants' claim was based on a misconception that the Akiba decision recognised native title rights to access and take resources offshore for any purpose automatically throughout Australia. The court also found that the applicants had failed to put forward a cohesive or reasonable argument as to the non-application of NSW fisheries laws, and that the application had no reasonable prospects of success. The application for joinder was dismissed because there was no evidence explaining why the purported substitution was sought, or as to Ralph Lavender's authority to act on behalf of the Corporation. The application for summary dismissal was therefore granted, and the applicants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

In summary, the court dismissed the application for joinder and granted the application for summary dismissal of the native title claim by Ralph and Jack Lavender. The applicants were ordered to pay the respondents' costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Insofar as the applicants seek to join as an applicant, Ralph Lavender on behalf of the Illawarra Fishing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporation, the application is dismissed.

2. By 4pm on 8 April 2022, the applicants are to file and serve the amended originating application in accordance with the leave granted on 22 March 2021 but correcting the title of the proceedings by omitting the description of the applicant as Ralph Lavender on behalf of the Illawarra Fishing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporation and referring instead to the applicants, Ralph Lavender and Jack Lavender.

3. The name of the second respondent is amended to the Minister for Agriculture and Western New South Wales.

4. The name of the fourth respondent is amended to Revenue NSW.

5. The fifth to thirty-seventh respondents are disjoined from the proceeding.

6. Insofar as the applicants seek to join an entity described by them as the New South Wales Department of Primary Industries as a new fifth respondent, the application is dismissed.

7. The application is summarily dismissed pursuant to s 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) and rr 26.01(1)(a) or (c) of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR).

8. The applicants are to pay the second, third and fourth respondents’ costs as agreed or taxed under r 40.12 of the FCR.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I also note that the second Ralph Lavender affidavit does not appear to have been filed, contrary to the suggestion in the NSW respondents’ submissions in reply at [2]. However, the respondents accepted that they had been served with a copy of the second affidavit (ibid) and made submissions having regard to that affidavit. In those circumstances, I have taken the affidavit as read on the application for summary dismissal and, rather than requiring it to be filed, for convenience, have identified it as Exhibit A-1.4. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND I gratefully adopt the procedural background set out in the NSW respondents’ further submissions filed after the hearing on 6 April 2021 as follows:3.The applicants commenced these proceedings by originating application filed on 2 October 2019. Following correspondence sent to the applicants, to which there was no reply, on 6 December 2019 the State respondents filed an interlocutory application seeking that the originating application be struck out and that the proceedings be summarily dismissed (the application for summary dismissal). The first case management hearing was listed for 10 December 2019.4.On 9 December 2019, a notice of acting – appointment of lawyer was filed on behalf of the applicants by Katherine Hawes of Aquarius Lawyers. On 10 December 2019, the applicants were given leave to file and serve any amended originating application and material in support of that application by 31 January 2020. On 4 February 2020 and again on 8 April 2020, orders were made by consent extending time for the applicants to file their amended originating application, first to 27 March 2020 and then to 17 April 2020. On 5 February 2020, the matter was listed for case management on 3 June 2020.5.The applicants attempted to file an amended originating application dated 22 April 2020 with the Court’s registry around that time, but the document was not accepted for filing.6.Pursuant to a timetable set down at a directions hearing on 1 June 2020, the State respondents filed submissions in support of their application for summary dismissal on 29 July 2020. On 20 August 2020, Ms Hawes of Aquarius Lawyers filed a notice of intention to cease to act on behalf of the applicants. In an email to the Court’s registry on 21 August 2020, a representative of that firm cited difficulty in obtaining instructions from the applicants. On 28 August 2020, Ms Hawes filed a notice of ceasing to act on behalf of the applicants. On 28 August 2020 an interlocutory hearing (of the application for summary dismissal) listed for 31 August 2020 was vacated. On 1 September 2020, the first applicant filed a notice of address for service on his own behalf.7.At a directions hearing on 9 September 2020, orders were made listing the proceedings for case management of the application for summary dismissal on 2 December 2020, with a note that the adjournment was at the request of the applicants, whose solicitors had ceased to act and who were then said to be having difficulties obtaining new solicitors due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The adjournment application was not opposed by the State respondents.8.On 2 December 2020, orders were made for the applicants to file submissions and for the State respondents to file submission in reply. Submissions were filed in accordance with that timetable and the application for summary dismissal was listed for and heard on 22 March 2021.9.The parties’ written submissions and the hearing on 22 March 2021 proceeded on the footing that the applicants’ claim was that which was set out in the proposed amended application which the applicants attempted to file around 22 April 2020. Mr Lavender was given leave to file that proposed amended application by 23 March 2021, and the document (Amended Application) was filed on that day.(Footnotes omitted.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In addition, the Amended Application purported to remove the persons previously named as the fifth to thirty-seventh respondents, while purporting to add (without leave) a new fifth respondent identified as the “New South Wales Department of Primary Industries”. However, as the NSW respondents submitted, government departments of the New South Wales Government do not have separate legal personality and therefore cannot be joined. Further and in any event, the relevant department responsible to the Minister is the Department of Regional NSW: Administrative Arrangements (Administrative Changes—Regional NSW and Independent Planning Commission) Order 2020 (121) LW 4.2.2020 orders 7 and 8. 3. EVIDENCE The NSW respondents rely upon the affidavit of Ms Caitlin Fegan (solicitor at the NSW Crown Solicitors Office) affirmed on 6 December 2019 (the Fegan affidavit) in support of the application for summary relief. While at the time of affirming her affidavit, Ms Fegan stated that she did so only on behalf of the second and third respondents, at the hearing, counsel for the respondents confirmed that the fourth respondent also sought to rely upon that affidavit (T 22/3/21 at 4.5). The applicants relied upon the affidavits of Ralph Lavender sworn on 26 August 2019 and on 8 September 2020 (although dated 7 September 2020) (the first and second Ralph Lavender affidavits respectively), together with the affidavit of Jack Lavender sworn on 26 August 2019 (the Jack Lavender affidavit). The applicants also filed an affidavit of service on the Commonwealth Attorney General sworn on 23 October 2020. I note that the applicants’ affidavits were sworn before the Amended Application. I also note that the second Ralph Lavender affidavit does not appear to have been filed, contrary to the suggestion in the NSW respondents’ submissions in reply at [2]. However, the respondents accepted that they had been served with a copy of the second affidavit (ibid) and made submissions having regard to that affidavit. In those circumstances, I have taken the affidavit as read on the application for summary dismissal and, rather than requiring it to be filed, for convenience, have identified it as Exhibit A-1.4. PROCEDURAL BACKGROUND I gratefully adopt the procedural background set out in the NSW respondents’ further submissions filed after the hearing on 6 April 2021 as follows:3.The applicants commenced these proceedings by originating application filed on 2 October 2019. Following correspondence sent to the applicants, to which there was no reply, on 6 December 2019 the State respondents filed an interlocutory application seeking that the originating application be struck out and that the proceedings be summarily dismissed (the application for summary dismissal). The first case management hearing was listed for 10 December 2019.4.On 9 December 2019, a notice of acting – appointment of lawyer was filed on behalf of the applicants by Katherine Hawes of Aquarius Lawyers. On 10 December 2019, the applicants were given leave to file and serve any amended originating application and material in support of that application by 31 January 2020. On 4 February 2020 and again on 8 April 2020, orders were made by consent extending time for the applicants to file their amended originating application, first to 27 March 2020 and then to 17 April 2020. On 5 February 2020, the matter was listed for case management on 3 June 2020.5.The applicants attempted to file an amended originating application dated 22 April 2020 with the Court’s registry around that time, but the document was not accepted for filing.6.Pursuant to a timetable set down at a directions hearing on 1 June 2020, the State respondents filed submissions in support of their application for summary dismissal on 29 July 2020. On 20 August 2020, Ms Hawes of Aquarius Lawyers filed a notice of intention to cease to act on behalf of the applicants. In an email to the Court’s registry on 21 August 2020, a representative of that firm cited difficulty in obtaining instructions from the applicants. On 28 August 2020, Ms Hawes filed a notice of ceasing to act on behalf of the applicants. On 28 August 2020 an interlocutory hearing (of the application for summary dismissal) listed for 31 August 2020 was vacated. On 1 September 2020, the first applicant filed a notice of address for service on his own behalf.7.At a directions hearing on 9 September 2020, orders were made listing the proceedings for case management of the application for summary dismissal on 2 December 2020, with a note that the adjournment was at the request of the applicants, whose solicitors had ceased to act and who were then said to be having difficulties obtaining new solicitors due to the COVID-19 pandemic. The adjournment application was not opposed by the State respondents.8.On 2 December 2020, orders were made for the applicants to file submissions and for the State respondents to file submission in reply. Submissions were filed in accordance with that timetable and the application for summary dismissal was listed for and heard on 22 March 2021.9.The parties’ written submissions and the hearing on 22 March 2021 proceeded on the footing that the applicants’ claim was that which was set out in the proposed amended application which the applicants attempted to file around 22 April 2020. Mr Lavender was given leave to file that proposed amended application by 23 March 2021, and the document (Amended Application) was filed on that day.(Footnotes omitted.)

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The applicants, Ralph Lavender and his son, Jack Lavender, seek declarations that they hold native title rights to fish over certain waters in New South Wales. In particular, they contend that their native title right to fish includes fishing for commercial purposes without the constraints which would otherwise be imposed by New South Wales law and schemes of management. In addition, injunctive relief is sought against the respondents and the New South Wales Department of Primary Industries to prevent them from interfering with the applicants’ alleged native title rights to fish and “indigenous fishermen in the exercise of their native title rights”. Ralph Lavender describes himself as a fisherman and the founding director of the Illawarra Fishing Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander Corporation (the Corporation). By an interlocutory application dated 6 December 2019, the second to fourth respondents (the NSW respondents) seek an order for summary dismissal of the originating application dated 26 August 2019 (Originating Application) pursuant to s 31A(2) of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) (FCA Act) and r 26.01 of the Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) (FCR) (application for summary dismissal). The reasons for the delay in hearing the application are explained at paragraph [14] below. At the hearing of the application for summary dismissal, leave was granted to the applicants, Ralph and Jack Lavender, to file and serve their proposed amended originating application dated 22 April 2020 (the Amended Application) in the terms in which it was originally refused for filing on 22 April 2020, in light of Mr Ralph Lavender’s assurance that the Amended Application embodied the applicants’ claim as they wished to press it (T22/3/2021 at 5.16–33). However, despite the Amended Application purporting to substitute the Corporation for the applicants, no order was made to join Ralph Lavender as the applicant in a different capacity, namely on behalf of the Corporation, or to disjoin Ralph and Jack Lavender in their personal capacities. Nor is there any evidence explaining why the purported substitution is sought, as to Ralph Lavender’s authority to act on behalf of the Corporation save for the reference to Ralph Lavender as a director of the Corporation, or as to the membership of the Corporation. In those circumstances, I have proceeded on the basis that the Amended Application sets out in substance the applicants’ case and their proposed joinder of the Corporation in substitution for them. I have also considered it appropriate in those circumstances to make orders requiring the applicants to file and serve the Amended Application but corrected so as to identify the applicants as Ralph and Jack Lavender. For the reasons set out below, the Amended Application has no reasonable prospects of success and must be dismissed under s 31A(2) of the FCA Act and r 26.01 of the FCR. This is not a case in which there would be any purpose served by granting the applicants a further opportunity to seek to amend the application.