Landcom v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Landcom v Commissioner of Taxation [2022] FCA 510    

File number(s): VID 201 of 2021
Judgment of: THAWLEY J
Date of judgment: 9 May 2022
Catchwords:

CONSTITUTIONAL LAW – s 114 of the Constitution prohibits the Commonwealth imposing “any tax on property of any kind belonging to a State” – where GST is not imposed on States, but States have voluntarily agreed to pay notional GST – where the A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (GST Act) addresses notional GST, including the amount of notional GST which might be voluntarily paid – where applicant being a State owned corporation sought private binding ruling from Commissioner of Taxation in relation to application of a provision facilitating calculation of notional GST relevant to a proposed sale of land – where Commissioner issued private binding ruling and made an objection decision in relation to notional GST – private ruling and objection decision later claimed only to be a “purported” private ruling and a “purported” objection decision – on commencement of Part IVC appeal, Commissioner argued Court did not have jurisdiction – whether Court has jurisdiction to hear Part IVC appeal – whether there is “matter” within the meaning of ss 75 and 76 of the Constitution – whether there is a justiciable controversy in circumstances where GST cannot be and is not imposed – whether notional GST scheme can give rise to real and enforceable tax liabilities on the part of states – whether issue before the Court was hypothetical – Court found to have jurisdiction – states found to have real interest in the calculation of notional GST – states entitled to seek rulings about how provisions of GST Act apply

TAXATION – where applicant proposed to transfer several freehold interests in land to third party as part of single contract – whether a single “supply” of land for the purpose of calculating the “margin” contained in s 75-10 of the GST Act – held that each supply of a freehold interest was a separate supply

Legislation:

Constitution ss 55, 75, 76, 77, 78, 114

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 2-15, 7-1, 9-1, 9-5, 9-10, 9-20, 9-25, 9-30, 9-40, 9-80, 9-99, 11-15, 11-20, 11-25, 17-5, 31-5, 37-1, 38-445, 45-1, 75-1, 75-5, 75-10, 75-11, 75-16, 75-22, 75-35, 177-1, 177-3, 184-1, 195-1, 250-10, 255-5

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Imposition – Customs) Act 1999 (Cth)

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Imposition – Excise) Act 1999 (Cth)

A New Tax System (Goods and Services Tax Imposition—General) Act 1999 (Cth) ss 3, 5

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 23

Federal Financial Relations Act 2009 (Cth)

Income Tax Assessment Act1936 (Cth) s 175

Income Tax Assessment Act 1997 (Cth) ss 950-100, 950-150, 995-1

Judiciary Act 1903 (Cth) s 39B; Pt XII

Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) ss 14ZVA, 14ZY, 14ZZ, 14ZZO, 14ZZP, 14ZZQ, Sch 1 155-5, 155-15, 155-85, 155-90, 356-5, 357-5, 357-50, 357-55,…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Landcom v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] FCA 510
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Landcom v Commissioner of Taxation, the Federal Court was tasked with determining the jurisdictional scope and the application of the Australian Goods and Services Tax (GST) regime, particularly concerning notional GST, to a State-owned corporation, Landcom. Landcom, a New South Wales corporation that owns and intends to sell certain land parcels, sought a private binding ruling from the Commissioner of Taxation regarding the calculation of GST on these sales under the notional GST scheme. The central dispute revolved around whether the transactions constituted a single supply of land or separate supplies, impacting the applicability of the margin scheme under the GST Act.

The Court was required to decide whether it had jurisdiction to hear an appeal against the Commissioner's objection to the private ruling. This involved assessing whether there was a "matter" within the meaning of sections 75 and 76 of the Constitution, given that no actual GST was imposed on the State. Additionally, the Court had to determine whether the notional GST scheme could create real and enforceable tax liabilities for states and whether the issue before the Court was hypothetical or justiciable.

The Court found that it had jurisdiction to hear the appeal, emphasizing that states have a real interest in the calculation of notional GST and are entitled to seek rulings on how the GST Act applies. The Court held that each supply of a freehold interest in land was a separate supply, thus affecting the application of the margin scheme. The Court concluded that the notional GST scheme does not render the dispute hypothetical, as states have a vested interest in the correct calculation and reporting of notional GST. The Court also found that the Commissioner's objection decision and the private ruling were justiciable matters, allowing the Court to review the correctness of the Commissioner's opinion on the application of the law to the facts.

The Court allowed the appeal, directing the parties to confer and submit agreed orders within seven days. If the parties could not agree, they were to approach the Court for relisting the matter for argument on appropriate orders and costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The parties confer with a view to agreeing and submitting agreed orders to give effect to these reasons, and as to costs, within 7 days.

3. If agreement is not reached, the parties approach the Associate to Thawley J within 8 days to have the matter relisted for argument in respect of appropriate orders.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons are structured as follows:(1)first, the relevant background facts are summarised;(2)secondly, the background relevant to the jurisdictional issue is explained; (3)thirdly, the legislative context relevant to the (notional) GST issue is explained as is the legislative context relevant to the private ruling regime;(4)fourthly, the question whether this Court has jurisdiction is addressed; and (5)finally, the correctness of the Commissioner’s opinion, as expressed in his ruling, is addressed. BACKGROUND FACTS The central facts are as follows. Landcom was the registered proprietor of a freehold interest in a number of lots of land which it intended to sell. Each lot was described in a separate Certificate of Title. The various lots were grouped together for the purposes of preparing two contracts of sale: ·Twelve lots were grouped into “Property B1” and were the subject of Contract B1. ·Four lots (Lots L, M, N and P (the Lots)) were grouped into “Property B2” and were the subject of Contract B2. Lot P was separated from Lots L, M and N by a train line. Lot P was connected to Lot N by a private access road that was part of Lot P and which lead through a tunnel under the rail line. The lots have been held by the State of New South Wales since before 1 July 2000, when the GST was introduced. The lots were previously owned by the New South Wales Land and Housing Corporation (LAHC). On 1 January 2002, the lots were transferred from LAHC to Landcom pursuant to an order of the Minister made under s 17 of the Landcom Act. A number of the lots had been used for the purpose of farming activities, although these activities had ceased a number of decades before Landcom became the owner of the lots. The lots have also been subject to other human interventions. Lot M, for example, had an aero club for remote control plane enthusiasts, including a runway and a clubhouse. The lots were to be sold to enable a developer to build residential premises, effectively creating a new suburb. The lots were marketed for sale by expression of interest or competitive tender process. The lots were promoted as a single piece of land as part of the same transaction, on the basis that a single buyer would purchase all of the lots. By a put and call option agreement dated 5 November 2015 (as amended), Landcom granted an option to the purchaser, and the purchaser granted Landcom an option to require the purchaser, to purchase the lots comprising Property B1 on the terms of Contract B1, and to purchase the lots comprising Property B2 on the terms of Contract B2. Clause 36.3 of the contract of sale provided that the parties agreed that the “margin scheme” would be applied to work out the GST payable on any taxable supply of property under the contract. On 26 February 2020, Landcom sent a letter to the Commissioner stating that Landcom applied for a private binding ruling pursuant to s 359-10(1) of Sch 1 to the TAA 1953. The ruling application concerned the operation of Item 4 in the table in s 75-10(3) of the GST Act. This section is located within Div 75 of the GST Act. Where it applies, Div 75 allows use of a “margin scheme” to bring taxable supplies of freehold interests in land, stratum units and long-term leases within the GST system. GST is calculated only on the “margin” for the supply. Item 4 applies if the following circumstances apply to the supply:The supplier is the Commonwealth, a State or a Territory and has held the interest, unit or lease since before 1 July 2000, and there were no improvements on the land or premises in question as at 1 July 2000.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, there is a “matter” and this Court has jurisdiction to resolve the Part IVC appeal. The fact that GST cannot be and is not imposed on Landcom in respect of the relevant supply or supplies does not have the consequence that there is no “matter” or that the dispute is hypothetical. If one were to analyse the “matter” by reference to the three components of the identification of a “matter” referred to by Gaudron and Gummow JJ in Re McBain: (1)the subject matter for determination is the correct application of Item 4 of the table to s 75-10(3) of the GST Act to the scheme set out in the ruling;(2)the relevant underlying right can be viewed as Landcom’s right to appeal from an objection decision concerning a ruling on the correct application of Item 4 or its right to a ruling on the correct operation of Item 4 or a right to an order varying the objection decision; (3)the controversy between the parties is that the Commissioner takes a different view as to the correct operation of Item 4 to that taken by Landcom. Conclusion on jurisdiction For those reasons, this Court has jurisdiction to hear and determine the Part IVC appeal.THE PRIVATE RULING / GST ISSUESThe role of the Court The role of the Court in an appeal under Part IVC of the TAA 1953 against an objection decision (or deemed objection decision) made in respect of an objection to a private ruling may be summarised as follows:(1)A person who is “dissatisfied” with the objection decision may appeal to the Court against that objection decision: s 14ZZ of the TAA 1953. An “objection decision” has the meaning given in s 14ZY(2): s 2(1) of the TAA 1953.(2)In the appeal, the appellant has the burden of proving that the “taxation decision” the subject of the objection decision should not have been made or should have been made differently: s 14ZZO(b)(ii) of the TAA 1953; Cooperative Bulk Handling Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [2010] FCA 508; (2010) 79 ATR 582 at [12]. Section 14ZQ of the TAA 1953 defines a “taxation decision” to mean “the assessment, determination, notice or decision against which a taxation objection may be, or has been, made”. The taxation decision in the present appeal is the private ruling.(3)The Court’s role is limited to reviewing the correctness of the Commissioner’s opinion, expressed in the private ruling, about the arrangement or scheme as identified by the Commissioner in the private ruling: Commissioner of Taxation v Eichmann [2019] FCA 2155 at [21]-[22]; approved on appeal in Eichmann v Commissioner of Taxation [2020] FCAFC 155; (2020) 280 FCR 10 at [16].(4)The onus is on the taxpayer to satisfy the Court that the Commissioner’s opinion on the application of the law to the facts and circumstances specified in the private ruling is incorrect: Bulk Handling at [13]. (5)In reviewing the Commissioner’s opinion on the application of the law to the specified facts and circumstances, the only material to which the Court can have regard is the ruling and documents identified in the description of the facts and circumstances which were either provided by the taxpayer or were used by the Commissioner: Bulk Handling at [16]. Summary of Landcom’s principal submissions

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It is also not strictly necessary to resolve whether a State is required to report notional GST at label A1 “GST on sales”. Whilst the description of the label is apt to cover “notional” GST, both parties agreed that there was no obligation to report notional GST.ConsiderationLandcom’s first argument As noted above, Landcom submitted that the Commissioner has power to issue assessments of notional GST and that these assessments create real and enforceable liabilities. Section 155-5 of Sch 1 to the TAA 1953 includes: 155‑5 Commissioner may make assessment(1)The Commissioner may at any time make an assessment of an *assessable amount (including an assessment that the amount is nil).Note 1: For amendment of assessments, see Subdivision 155‑B.Note 2: An assessment can be reviewed: see Subdivision 155‑C.(2)Each of the following is an assessable amount:(a) a *net amount;…(c)an amount of *indirect tax not included in an amount covered by another paragraph of this subsection; Section 155-15 of Sch 1to the TAA 1953 provides for “self-assessment” and includes:155‑15 Self‑assessment(1)The Commissioner is treated as having made an assessment under section 155‑5 of an *assessable amount mentioned in an item of the following table, if the document mentioned in the item is given to the recipient mentioned in the item: As mentioned earlier, Landcom calculated its net amount (GST less input tax credits – see: [88] above) on the basis that it was liable for GST on taxable supplies of property, that is, as if s 5 of the General Imposition Act did not apply. It did not distinguish in its BASs between GST for which it is liable and GST which it pays voluntarily under the NSW Implementation Act. As noted earlier, Landcom submitted that the BASs lodged by it are treated by the Commissioner as assessments of Landcom’s net amount for the relevant tax period. So far as the evidence discloses, the Commissioner has never raised an issue about Landcom voluntarily paying notional GST by this mechanism. Landcom referred also to ss 155-85 and 155-90 contained in Subdivision 155-C of Sch 1 to the TAA 1953 (presently irrelevant note to s 155-90 omitted):Subdivision 155‑C—Validity and review of assessments…155‑85 Validity of assessmentThe validity of any assessment of an *assessable amount is not affected by non‑compliance with the provisions of this Act or of any other *taxation law.155‑90 Review of assessmentsYou may object, in the manner set out in Part IVC of this Act, against an assessment of an *assessable amount of yours if you are dissatisfied with the assessment. Again, this emphasises the Commissioner’s administration of notional GST. The private ruling regime is designed to enable a taxpayer to find out how laws administered by the Commissioner apply to the taxpayer in relation to schemes which have been entered into or how those laws would apply to a scheme which the taxpayer proposes to enter into. Provisions of Acts “of which the Commissioner has the general administration are relevant for rulings if the provisions are about”: “tax”, “indirect tax”, “the administration or collection of those taxes …”, “a net amount, or the administration of a net amount”, “an assessed net amount, or the collection or payment of an assessed net amount”: s 357‑55 (a), (f), (g), (j) and (ja) of Sch 1 to the TAA 1953.Item 4 in the table to s 75-10(3) expressly applies to Landcom