Lancaster v Department of Education and Training

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

WORKERS COMPENSATION COMMISSION

DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR

CITATION:Lancaster v Department of Education and Training [2007] NSWWCCPD 46

APPELLANT:  Robert Lancaster

RESPONDENT:  Department of Education and Training

INSURER:NSW Treasury Managed Fund

FILE NUMBER:  WCC21812-05

DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION:          26 April 2006

DATE OF APPEAL DECISION:  13 February 2007

SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Psychological injury; section 4 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987

PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER:  Acting Deputy President Anthony Candy

HEARING:On the papers

REPRESENTATION:  Appellant:      Higgins & Higgins, Lawyers

Respondent:   Leslie Hargrave, Lawyers

ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:  (1)        The decision of the Arbitrator dated 26 April 2006 is revoked and the matter is remitted to another Arbitrator for determination afresh in accordance with these reasons together with the other outstanding claims by the worker.

(2)The respondent/employer is to pay the costs of the appellant/worker.

BACKGROUND TO THE APPEAL

  1. Robert Lancaster (‘the worker’) was employed by the Department of Education and Training (‘the employer’) as an E.S.L. (English as a Second Language) teacher at Hassall Grove Public School.

  2. On the afternoon of 21 December 2004, the last day of the school term, the worker was asked to attend the office of the Principal, Mr Ian Chambers.  The reason for this was to tell the worker of complaints which had been made about his behaviour by two female staff members at the school, Ms Bronwen Heap and Ms Raquel Gonzalez.

  3. The worker was given a letter from the Principal which referred to the use of inappropriate language by the worker to these ladies. The worker the following day replied in writing seeking details of the complaints against him and setting out his relationship with the two identified staff members. This letter was not, it appears, received by the Principal until the first day of the school term 2005.  The worker complained of not being told details of the complaints made against him and sought that the situation be addressed promptly upon his return to work in 2005.  He said that over the holiday period he was worried constantly about the stressful situation and was upset, anxious, depressed and his sleep was disturbed, allegedly sleeping a maximum of only 2 ½ hours per night.

  4. When the worker returned to the school at the beginning of Term 1 in 2005, he spoke to the Principal and asked that the situation be resolved face-to-face with the complainant, Ms Gonzalez. Ms Heap was no longer at the school.  He also sought specific notification as to what it was he allegedly said and did and he requested a right of reply.  He and Ms Gonzalez continued to work at the school that year.  There was no response to his request until three weeks later when a meeting was organised between the worker and Ms Leah Pollett, the District Welfare Officer.  At this stage the worker says he almost collapsed at school after feeling dizzy and faint from continual lack of sleep.  He saw his local medical practitioner, Dr…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lancaster v Department of Education and Training and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2007] NSWWCCPD 46
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Lancaster v Department of Education and Training, the primary focus was on the admissibility of new evidence presented during an appeal. The court was tasked with determining whether the fresh evidence, specifically reports from a psychologist, Mr. C.R. Camacho, dated 26 June 2006 and 31 July 2006, could be admitted in the appeal proceedings. The primary legal issue was whether the new evidence met the criteria set out in Practice Direction No.6 for admitting fresh evidence on appeal. This involved assessing whether the new evidence could not reasonably have been obtained earlier and whether its admission would result in substantial injustice.

The court examined the rationale provided by the solicitors for the worker, who sought to introduce Mr. Camacho’s reports as they were not available at the time of the original arbitration proceedings. The court highlighted that the reason provided for the admission of the fresh evidence was insufficient, as it merely stated that the evidence was "not received before the filing of the appeal." The court noted that the psychologist's reports could not have been available prior to the appeal, given that the assessment was conducted on 13 June 2006, well after the original arbitration proceedings. However, the court further scrutinized the necessity and probative value of the evidence. The arbitrator had pointed out a deficiency in the absence of a psychologist's report supporting the worker’s claim, which the new evidence aimed to address. The court also considered the factors outlined in McMahon, including the potential for substantial injustice, the impossibility of discovering the evidence earlier, and its high probative value. Ultimately, the court found that the reason provided for the admission of the new evidence did not adequately demonstrate that the evidence was crucial for the appeal, thereby denying the application to admit the fresh evidence.

Consequently, the court ruled against the admission of the psychologist’s reports as new evidence in the appeal. The court concluded that the reason provided for the introduction of the fresh evidence was inadequate, as it did not sufficiently demonstrate the necessity or probative value of the reports. The court emphasized that the decision to admit new evidence should be based on a thorough analysis of the factors relevant to the specific case, including the potential for injustice and the impossibility of obtaining the evidence earlier. The final order was to deny the application to admit the fresh evidence, thereby maintaining the outcome of the original arbitration proceedings.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Practice Direction No.6 sets out the process for seeking leave of the Commission to give ‘new evidence’ on appeal. It provides as follows:“New EvidenceWhere a party seeks leave to give new evidence in relation to the decision appealed against, that party must serve a copy of the new evidence on the other parties to the dispute when serving the Application or Opposition.In general, the Commission will allow new evidence to be introduced only where it can be demonstrated that the new evidence could not reasonably have been obtained by the party and tendered in proceedings before the Arbitrator and that failure to allow the new evidence would cause a substantial injustice in the circumstances of the individual case.” Practice Direction No.6 also provides that if new evidence is sought to be relied upon, the Application or Opposition to the Appeal must contain:“ -a schedule of the new evidence, -a copy of the new evidence, -a brief outline of the new evidence and the reasons why it was not given in the proceedings before the Arbitrator, and -submissions why the new evidence should be admitted.” The solicitors for the worker on 6 October 2006 sought leave to admit reports of a psychologist, Mr C.R. Camacho, dated 26 June 2006 and 31 July 2006. The reason given in support of the Application to Admit the Fresh Evidence is: “Not received before the filing of the appeal”. It is clear from the earlier of those reports that the psychologist was asked on 8 June 2006 to make a psychological and whole person assessment according to the AMA Guides to Permanent Assessment 5th Edition and the WorkCover Guidelines 2002. The reason given in support of the admission of these reports is inadequate. Obviously the report could not have been available to be put into evidence before the Arbitrator since it had not at that stage been obtained. The purpose of seeking to have Mr Camacho’s reports admitted is to meet a deficiency in the evidence which was pointed out by the Arbitrator, that is, the absence of a report from a psychologist supportive of the worker’s claim. Mr Camacho’s reports deal with his assessment of the worker at the time he saw him, namely 13 June 2006. The question of fresh evidence on appeal was discussed by Deputy President Fleming in Christopher Michael McMahon v Anthony Lagana and Joseph Lavella t/as the Vessel “Nimble II” [2003] NSWWCCPD 22 (‘McMahon) at [11-12]:“11.Principles relevant to the exercise of the discretion to admit new evidence in relation to proceedings before the Commission were discussed in the matters of Ross v Zurich Workers Compensation Insurance [2002] NSWWCCPD 7 and Shipman Pty Ltd v Matters [2003] NSWWCCPD 19. Factors, weighing in favour the exercise of discretion to admit fresh evidence in an appeal against the decision of an arbitrator in the Commission include that:(i) if the request if refused a substantial injustice will result to the party who seeks to have the evidence admitted, Radnedge v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1987) 9 NSWLR 235,(ii) the evidence could not have been discovered, with reasonable diligence, at the time of the original proceedings, Radnedge v Government Insurance Office of NSW (1987) 9 NSWLR 235; Glover v Australian Ultra Concrete Floors Pty Ltd [2003] NSWCA 80, and(iii) the evidence is of such probative value that there is a high degree of probability that it would lead to a different outcome in the case; Greater Wollongong City Council v Cowan (1955) 93 CLR 435, Warr v Santos [1973] 1 NSWLR 432, Harrison v Schipp (2002) 54 NSWLR 738; Atkins v National Australia Bank (1994) 34 NSWLR 155.12.Factors weighing against the exercise of discretion to admit fresh evidence in the appeal include:(iv) the interest in the finality of litigation and the importance of the ability of a successful party to rely on the outcome of the proceedings, Litynski v Albion Steel Pty Ltd (1994) 10 NSWCCR 287, (v) the prejudice ,if any, that may result to the other party, particularly if the fresh evidence raises new arguments in the appeal, and(vi) the intention of the legislative scheme in relation to the nature of the proceedings.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established