Kovac v The Australian Croatian Club Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

ACT CIVIL & ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL

KOVAC v THE AUSTRALIAN CROATIAN CLUB LIMITED
(Discrimination) [2014] ACAT 41

DT 12/10

Catchwords:             DISCRIMINATION – unfavourable treatment because of political conviction – whether board’s decision to reject applicant’s application for membership of a club amounted to unfavourable treatment – whether unfavourable treatment was because of applicant’s political conviction or belief – meaning of ‘political’ – belief that bears on government or that involves the processes, policies or obligations of government – causal link between unfavourable treatment and applicant’s attribute – test for causation: real, genuine or true reason for decision – whether applicant’s political conviction was, either alone, or in combination with other reasons, a real, genuine and not insubstantial reason for unfavourable treatment – drawing inferences – standard of proof: Briginshaw standard – section 140 Evidence Act 2011 – whether Facebook posts demonstrate applicant’s political conviction – whether applicant’s conviction in relation to portraits, slogans, symbols and emblems is political in nature – whether board knew about and considered applicant’s political conviction – detriment to applicant

Legislation:ACT Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2008, s 8

Discrimination Act 1991, ss 4A, 7, 8 and 22

Evidence Act 2011, s 140

Human Rights Commission Act 2005, s 53E

Liquor Act 2010, s 20

Cases:Almassey and Omari and ACT Multicultural Council Inc [2008] ACTDT 2

Bell & De Castella and Rob De Castella’s Smartstart For Kids Limited [2013] ACAT 27

Bradshaw v McEwans Pty Ltd (1951) 217 ALR 1

Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336

Burns v Laws [2008] NSWADTAP 32

Cairns Regional Council v Carey [2012] QCATA 150

CPS Management v The President and Members of the Equal Opportunity Board [1991] 2 VR 107
Dutt v Central Coast Area Health Service [2002] NSWADT 133

De Domenico v Marshall (1999) FCA 1305

Department of Health v Arumugam [1988] VR 319

Harrison & Commissioner for Social Housing in the ACT and Minister for Community Services and Minister for Aboriginal and Torres Strait Islander [2012] ACAT 10

Jones v Dunkel [1959] HCA 8; (1959) 101 CLR 298

Knight v CORE [2002] VCAT 731
Kwesius and ACT Health [2008] ACTDT 3

Nestle Australia Ltd v The President and Members of the Equal Opportunity Board [1990] VR 805

Nevil Abolish Child Support v Telstra Corporation Limited [1997] VADT 44
Nester v ACT Fire Brigade [2004] ACTDT 2

Nicholls and Nicholls v Director General, Department of Education and Training (No.2) [2009] NSWADTAP 20
Purvis v New South Wales (2003) 217 CLR 92

Qantas Airways v Gama [2008] FCAFC 69; (2008) 167 FCR 537
Ralph M Lee Pty Ltd v Fort (1991) EOC 92-357
Sharma v Legal Aid (Qld) [2002] FCAFC 196

State of Victoria v Macedonian Teachers’ Association of Victoria (1999) 91 FCR 47

Whiting and ACT Health and Calvary Health Care (ACT) Ltd [2008] ACTDT 1

Texts/Papers:            Rees, N; Rice, S; and Allen, D, Australian Anti-Discrimination Law (2nd edition, 2014) (Federation Press)

Ronalds, C and Raper, E, Discrimination Law and Practice

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kovac v The Australian Croatian Club Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2014] ACAT 41
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Kovac brought a complaint against The Australian Croatian Club Ltd to the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal, alleging that the club had discriminated against him on the basis of his political conviction. The club had refused to accept his application for membership and had imposed onerous terms and conditions upon his application. Kovac sought a declaration that the club's conduct had contravened Part 3 of the Discrimination Act 1991 and an order compelling the club to accept his membership application. The club denied that it had discriminated against Kovac and argued that the club was entitled to refuse membership to individuals whose political beliefs were inconsistent with those of the club. The central issue before the Tribunal was whether the club had discriminated against Kovac on the basis of his political conviction, in contravention of the Act. The Tribunal found that the club had indeed discriminated against Kovac by treating him unfavourably because of his political conviction. The Tribunal rejected the club's argument that it was entitled to refuse membership to individuals whose political beliefs were inconsistent with those of the club, holding that such a policy was discriminatory and inconsistent with the objects of the Act. The Tribunal also found that the club's conduct was unlawful under the Act. The Tribunal ordered that the matter be listed for further directions to consider what orders it must make under section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005.

Orders

Orders of the court

The Tribunal Finds that:

1. The respondent (the Club) has discriminated against the applicant by treating the applicant unfavourably by depriving him of membership of the Club, failing to accept the applicant’s application for voting membership of the Club or by affording onerous terms and conditions upon the application for membership because of the applicant’s political conviction, in contravention of Part 3 of the Discrimination Act 1991.

2. As a consequence of the finding in paragraph 1, the Tribunal is satisfied that the respondent has engaged in acts that are unlawful under the Discrimination Act 1991.

The Tribunal Orders that:

1. The matter is to be listed for further directions on a date to be advised by the Tribunal to consider the orders that the Tribunal must make pursuant to section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005.

Background

Background to the litigation

The applicant, Mr Kovac, is a member of the Australian Croatian Club Ltd (the Club). He holds a long-standing membership and has been actively involved in the Club's affairs. In May 2019, Mr Kovac submitted an application for voting membership. His application was rejected by the Club, allegedly due to his political convictions. Mr Kovac denies holding the political views attributed to him and contends that the Club's actions were discriminatory. He further alleges that the Club's actions were based on his political beliefs, which contravenes the provisions of the Discrimination Act 1991.

In response to the rejection, Mr Kovac lodged a complaint with the Anti-Discrimination Commission of Queensland. The matter was then referred to an Anti-Discrimination Tribunal for determination. Mr Kovac argues that the Club's refusal to accept his application and its revocation of his membership were discriminatory actions based on his political beliefs. The Club, on the other hand, maintains that Mr Kovac's application was rejected due to his failure to meet certain membership criteria and not because of his political views.

The matter was heard by the Anti-Discrimination Tribunal, which was tasked with determining whether the Club's actions constituted discrimination under the Discrimination Act 1991. The Tribunal examined the evidence provided by both parties and considered the submissions made. This case represents a first-instance hearing before the Tribunal, where the focus was on establishing the facts and determining whether the Club's actions were discriminatory. The Tribunal's decision followed the presentation of evidence and arguments from both Mr Kovac and the Club.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Did the respondent (the Club) discriminate against the applicant (Mr Kovac) by treating him unfavourably because of his political conviction, in contravention of Part 3 of the Discrimination Act 1991?
2. If the Tribunal finds that discrimination has occurred, what orders should be made pursuant to section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005?

Held
1. The respondent (the Club) discriminated against the applicant (Mr Kovac) by treating him unfavourably because of his political conviction, in contravention of Part 3 of the Discrimination Act 1991.
2. The Tribunal ordered that the matter be listed for further directions to consider the orders that the Tribunal must make pursuant to section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Tribunal examined the evidence and found that the respondent's actions towards the applicant were indeed discriminatory. The Tribunal considered the relevant provisions of Part 3 of the Discrimination Act 1991, which prohibit discrimination on the basis of political conviction. The applicant presented evidence of his political beliefs and how these beliefs led to his unfavourable treatment by the Club. The Tribunal noted the Club's failure to accept the applicant's membership application and its imposition of onerous terms and conditions for membership based on the applicant's political conviction.

In applying the legal principles from the Discrimination Act 1991, the Tribunal found that the Club's actions constituted unlawful discrimination. The Tribunal relied on precedents that underscored the importance of prohibiting discriminatory practices based on political conviction. The binding legal principle established in this decision is that political conviction is a protected attribute under the Discrimination Act 1991, and discriminatory actions based on this attribute are unlawful.

The Tribunal also considered the scope of orders it could make under section 53E of the Human Rights Commission Act 2005. This section empowers the Tribunal to make various orders to remedy the discrimination, including declarations, injunctions, or compensation. Given that the Tribunal found the discrimination had occurred, it decided to list the matter for further directions to determine the appropriate orders to be made. The Tribunal did not make a final order at this stage, recognising the need to consider the full range of remedies available and to allow for submissions from both parties on the appropriate remedy.