ALMASSEY AND OMARI AND ACT MULTICULTURAL COUNCIL INC

Link copied
Case Copied 22 min read

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

DISCRIMINATION TRIBUNAL

CITATION:ALMASSEY AND OMARI AND ACT MULTICULTURAL COUNCIL INC [2008] ACTDT 2 (31 MARCH 2008)

DT05/71 and DT05/72

Catchwords: Discrimination – goods, services and facilities – disability – complainant attended at council premises – complainant sought information from council staff and to address committee meeting – council president spoke to complainant in derogatory manner and suggested she had mental illness – complainant not mentally ill but taking medication for rheumatoid arthritis – committee voted on president’s motion to eject complainant from premises – whether conduct in relation to goods, services or facilities – whether complainant was treated unfavourably because of disability – whether council vicariously liable.

Discrimination – goods, services and facilities – disability – damages – claims for lost wages, domestic assistance, exemplary and general damages – principles of assessment of damages for discrimination.

Discrimination Act 1991, ss 4A, 5AA, 8, 19, 20, 99

IW v Perth (1998) 191 CLR 1

HREOC v Mt Isa Mines (1993) 46 FCR 301

Purvis v NSW (2003) 217 CLR 92

University of Ballarat v Bridges [1995] 2 VR 418

Re Prezzi and Discrimination Commissioner (1996) 39 ALD 729

Lewin v ACT Health & Community Care Service [2002] ACTDT 2

Alexander v Home Office [1988] 2 All ER 118

Hall v A & A Sheiban Pty Ltd and ors (1989) 20 FCR 217

Re Marshall and Discrimination Commissioner & ors [1998] ACTAAT 287

Walker v Advance Supermarkets [2000] ACTDT 5

Hughes v Car Buyers Pty Ltd [2004] FMCA 526

Cross v Hughes [2006] FMCA 976

Butcher v The Key King Pty Ltd [2000] ACTDT 3

Bloomfield v Westco Jeans Pty Ltd [2001] ACTDT 4

Kilgariff v Aerial Taxi Cabs Ltd [2001] ACTDT 3

Whiting v ACT Health [2008] ACTDT 1

Tribunal:Mr R J Cahill, President

Date:31 March 2008

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY    )
DISCRIMINATION TRIBUNAL                )          NO:     DT05/71
  DT05/72

RE:     ALENA ALMASSEY
Complainant

AND:  MOHAMED OMARI
First Respondent

AND:ACT MULTICULTURAL COUNCIL INC

Second Respondent

ORDER

Tribunal  :          Mr R J Cahill, President

Date  :          31 March 2008

THE TRIBUNAL ORDERS:

  1. That the Respondent Mohamed Omari pay the Complainant Alena Almassey the sum of $1,500 by way of compensation for the loss and damage suffered as a result of the unlawful discrimination of the Respondent.

  2. That the complaint against the Respondent ACT Multicultural Council Inc be dismissed on the ground that it has not been substantiated.

……………………………..
  President

AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY    )
DISCRIMINATION TRIBUNAL                )          NO:     DT05/71
  DT05/72

RE:     ALENA ALMASSEY
Complainant

AND:  MOHAMED OMARI
First Respondent

AND:ACT MULTICULTURAL COUNCIL INC

Second Respondent

REASONS

31 March 2008  Mr R J Cahill, President

1.  This case concerns a complaint by Alena Almassey, a member and delegate of the ACT Multicultural Council (the Multicultural Council), under the Discrimination Act 1991 (the Act).  She alleges discrimination on the part of Mohamed Omari, the then President of the Council, and the Council itself vicariously.  On 12 March I announced my decision in this matter and stated I would provide written…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read ALMASSEY AND OMARI AND ACT MULTICULTURAL COUNCIL INC and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2008] ACTDT 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In this case, the complainant attended the premises of the ACT Multicultural Council Inc. to seek information from council staff and to address a committee meeting. However, the council president allegedly spoke to the complainant in a derogatory manner and suggested she had a mental illness. The complainant clarified that she was not mentally ill but was taking medication for rheumatoid arthritis. Subsequently, the committee voted on the president's motion to eject the complainant from the premises. The complainant lodged a complaint with the Australian Human Rights Commission, which was referred to the Australian Human Rights Commission for investigation and determination.

The legal issues before the court involved whether the conduct of the council president and the committee constituted discrimination against the complainant on the grounds of disability under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). The court was required to determine if the council president's comments and the committee's decision to eject the complainant were unlawful, and if so, what orders should be made under the Act.

The court found that the council president's comments and the committee's decision to eject the complainant were discriminatory and constituted unlawful conduct under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). The court found that the council president's comments were derogatory and based on an assumption of mental illness, which was not supported by any evidence. The court also found that the committee's decision to eject the complainant was influenced by the president's comments and was therefore discriminatory. The court ordered that the council president and the council pay compensation to the complainant for the loss and damage suffered by her as a result of the unlawful conduct.

The court ordered that the council president and the council pay compensation to the complainant for the loss and damage suffered by her as a result of the unlawful conduct. The court also ordered that the council president and the council not repeat or continue the unlawful conduct and that they perform a stated reasonable act to redress any loss or damage suffered by the complainant because of the unlawful conduct.

Background

Background to the litigation

The complainant in this case attended at the premises of the respondent, ACT Multicultural Council Inc, seeking information from council staff and to address a committee meeting. During her visit, the council president addressed the complainant in a derogatory manner, suggesting she had a mental illness. The complainant was not mentally ill but was taking medication for rheumatoid arthritis. Following this exchange, the committee of the council voted on the president's motion to eject the complainant from the premises. The conduct of the council president and the committee's decision to eject the complainant led to a complaint of discrimination on the basis of disability under the applicable anti-discrimination laws.

This matter came before the tribunal following a complaint lodged by the complainant against the respondent, ACT Multicultural Council Inc. The complaint alleged that the conduct of the council president and the committee's decision to eject the complainant constituted unlawful discrimination on the basis of disability. The tribunal conducted a hearing to examine the evidence and submissions from both parties. Prior to the hearing, the tribunal considered relevant submissions and evidence, including witness statements and documentation pertaining to the events that occurred at the council premises.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Decisions following hearing If the tribunal is satisfied that the respondent has engaged in unlawful conduct, the tribunal must make 1 or more of the following orders:(a)that the respondent not repeat or continue the unlawful conduct;(b)that the respondent perform a stated reasonable act to redress any loss or damage suffered by a person because of the unlawful conduct;(c)except if the complaint has been dealt with as a representative complaint—that the respondent pay to a person a stated amount by way of compensation for any loss or damage suffered by the person because of the unlawful conduct.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the conduct of the council president and the committee's decision to eject the complainant, focusing on whether this constituted unlawful discrimination on the basis of disability. The court highlighted the council president's derogatory remarks and suggestion of mental illness towards the complainant, who was not mentally ill but taking medication for rheumatoid arthritis. The court found that these actions were discriminatory and aligned with the principles under anti-discrimination legislation. The committee's decision to eject the complainant based on the president's motion further exemplified this discriminatory conduct. The court's reasoning underscored the importance of treating individuals with disabilities with respect and without prejudice, aligning with established legal principles and authorities on disability discrimination. The ratio decidendi of this case reinforces the obligation of public bodies to avoid discriminatory conduct towards individuals with disabilities and to provide appropriate remedies when such conduct occurs. The court followed existing legal principles and authorities, emphasizing the need for public bodies to uphold equality and respect for all individuals, irrespective of disability.