Kirk v Commonwealth of Australia

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kirk v Commonwealth of Australia [2025] FCA 838

File number: NSD 1535 of 2024
Judgment of: MCDONALD J
Date of judgment: 24 July 2025
Catchwords: ADMINISTRATIVE LAW – application for declaratory relief – applicant held office as senior member of Administrative Appeals Tribunal when appointed as deputy judge of Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum Chamber of United Kingdom – whether applicant was not entitled to be paid remuneration in respect of position as senior member by reason of s 7(12) of Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973 (Cth) – whether applicant came to “hold[] a judicial office in the service of the Government of … a country other than Australia” upon appointment as deputy judge or at later date – whether applicant entered into service of United Kingdom Government upon appointment or at later date – application dismissed with costs
Legislation:

Constitution s 44

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) ss 8, 9

Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 174

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia Act 2021 (Cth) ss 11, 16, 19, 20, 23, 115, 120, 121

Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) ss 6, 11

Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973 (Cth) ss 3, 4, 5, 7, 9, 17

Remuneration Tribunals Act 1974 (Cth) s 9

Constitutional Reform Act 2005 (UK) s 109, Sch 14

Promissory Oaths Act 1868 (UK) ss 2, 4, 7

Tribunals, Courts and Enforcement Act 2007 (UK) ss 3, 5, 31, Sch 3

Cases cited:

BP Exploration Co (Libya) Ltd v Hunt [1980] 1 NSWLR 496

CIC Insurance Ltd v Bankstown Football Club Ltd (1997) 187 CLR 384

Comptroller-General of Customs v Pharm-A-Care Laboratories Pty Ltd (2020) 270 CLR 494; [2020] HCA 2

Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Jayasinghe (2017) 260 CLR 400; [2017] HCA 26

Neilson v Overseas Projects Corporation of Victoria Ltd (2005) 223 CLR 331; [2005] HCA 54

NSW Associated Blue-Metal Quarries Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1955) 94 CLR 509

Re Canavan (2017) 263 CLR 284; [2017] HCA 45

Re Gallagher (2018) 263 CLR 460; [2018] HCA 17

SAS Trustee Corporation v Miles (2018) 265 CLR 137; [2018] HCA 55

Sykes v Cleary (1992) 176 CLR 77

SZTAL v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2017) 262 CLR 362; [2017] HCA 34

Division: General Division
Registry: New South Wales
National Practice Area: Administrative and Constitutional Law and Human Rights
Number of paragraphs: 140
Date of hearing: 12 May 2025
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr B W Rayment KC with Ms A M Poljak
Solicitor for the Applicant: Maurice Blackburn Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr B K Lim with Mr D J Rowe
Solicitor for the Respondent: Australian Government Solicitor

ORDERS

NSD 1535 of 2024
BETWEEN:

LINDA KIRK

Applicant

AND:

COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA

Respondent

ORDER MADE BY:

MCDONALD J

DATE OF ORDER:

24 JULY 2025

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.The applicant’s amended originating application dated 11 December 2024 be dismissed.

2.The applicant pay the costs of the respondent, to be agreed or…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kirk v Commonwealth of Australia and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FCA 838
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kirk v Commonwealth of Australia, the applicant, Dr Kirk, sought declaratory relief regarding her entitlement to remuneration while holding the position of a senior member of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) and concurrently being appointed as a deputy judge of the Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum Chamber in the United Kingdom. The court was tasked with determining whether Dr Kirk was entitled to remuneration for her position as a senior member of the AAT considering her overseas judicial appointment, and whether this appointment constituted holding a judicial office in the service of the Government of a country other than Australia.

The court considered the legislative provisions under the Remuneration Tribunal Act 1973 (Cth), particularly section 7(12), which disapplies certain remuneration provisions for individuals holding judicial offices outside Australia. The primary issue was the interpretation of "holding a judicial office" and whether it applied to part-time or full-time positions. The court found that the term "holds a judicial office" was not limited to full-time positions, as the Act itself contemplates offices being held on either a part-time or full-time basis. Therefore, the court held that Dr Kirk held the judicial office of deputy judge from the date of her appointment, and this appointment constituted holding a judicial office in the service of the Government of a country other than Australia.

Consequently, the court dismissed Dr Kirk's application for declaratory relief, holding that she was not entitled to remuneration for her position as a senior member of the AAT from 21 May 2024 to 13 October 2024, except as provided by regulation. The court also ordered Dr Kirk to pay the respondent's costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The applicant’s amended originating application dated 11 December 2024 be dismissed.

2. The applicant pay the costs of the respondent, to be agreed or taxed.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

It follows that, in the period from 21 May 2024 to 13 October 2024, Dr Kirk was not entitled to any remuneration in respect of her holding or exercising the duties of a senior member of the AAT by virtue of the operation of s 7(12) of the Remuneration Tribunal Act, except as provided by regulation. Dr Kirk is not entitled to the declaratory relief she seeks, and her originating application should be dismissed with costs.FACTUAL BACKGROUND The essential facts are agreed between the parties. The following summary of the factual background is largely based on the Statement of Agreed Facts. The Statement of Agreed Facts was supplemented by affidavit evidence of Dr Kirk, which was not challenged. By letter dated 10 April 2024, sent to her by email, Dr Kirk was offered an appointment as a fee-paid deputy judge of the Upper Tribunal. The letter included the following:Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum ChamberI am pleased to tell you that the Senior President of Tribunals’ [sic] is willing to offer you an appointment as a Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber). You must be prepared to sit at Field House in London but may also be asked to sit in other venues as and when required.All Deputy Judges of the Upper Tribunal are also, or if already appointed remain, Fee-paid Judges of the First-tier Tribunal and you may be deployed to undertake work there in suitable cases.…Data ProtectionI can confirm that the Judicial Office (JO) holds personal data relating to you on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice. Your personal data is processed because you are a member of the Judiciary, and the JO holds judicial HR records. … If the JO is asked to confirm the names of serving judicial office-holders, then your name could be disclosed. This could happen, for example, as part of a response to a request made under the Freedom of Information Act. …Lord Chancellor’s Terms and Conditions of ServiceI enclose a copy of the generic Terms and Conditions of Appointment for all Fee-paid Tribunal members and ask that you please note the contents. However, I must mention that Office holders are usually required to make themselves available for a minimum of 15 days a year on tribunal business. This figure may be varied from time to time, in accordance with business needs either generally or for certain categories of office. Where a different sitting level is required, it will be specified in the recruitment material or otherwise notified. His Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) will try to allocate sittings equally but cannot guarantee a minimum number of days in any year. A maximum number of days may be set where business needs dictate. You must be prepared to sit in London but may also be asked to sit in other locations.You are appointed on a four-year term which may be renewed subject to the office holder’s agreement, unless a question of cause for non-renewal is raised, or you no longer satisfy the conditions or qualifications for appointment. Should your appointment be renewed for one or more further periods, your compulsory retirement date will be … 5/24/2042.…TrainingTraining will be provided. Successful candidates, after appointment, will have access to the Judicial College training prospectus. Successful candidates who are not already judicial office holders will be required to attend a judicial skills training course although an exact date and venue have yet to be confirmed.…PensionAs of 1st April 2022, the Judicial Pension Scheme 2022 (JPS 2022) is the only judicial pension scheme open to accrual. It is open to all eligible fee-paid and salaried judicial office holders, except where terms and conditions are specifically nonpensionable. …The JPS 2022 is unregistered for tax purposes which means that pension benefits accrued in it will not count towards the Lifetime and Annual Allowances. Several of its features flow from this tax status, including the uniform contribution rate of 4.26%. The main features of JPS 2022 are a pension scheme design based on career average earnings with unreduced benefits payable from your State Pension Age and no service cap.Alternatively, it is possible to opt out of JPS 2022 membership should you so wish to. …Please note on accepting the appointment unless the Pensions team hear from you within 1 month of the date of this letter the default option of joining the JPS 2022 will be applied from your date of appointment and contributions will be deducted from salary/fees earned.…Next stepsI should be grateful if you would let me know no later than 24 April 2024 whether you wish to accept this offer of appointment. …When written confirmation of your acceptance has been received, we will send a formal letter of appointment. Until then, the Lord Chancellor would be grateful if you would treat this letter as strictly confidential and, besides anyone involved with the appointment or training arrangements, only mention the matter to your family, Head of Chambers/Partners and your accountant.(Emphasis in original.)

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

For these reasons, if it were necessary for me to decide whether Dr Kirk held the judicial office of deputy judge of the Upper Tribunal from the date of her appointment by reference to the meaning of that concept in Australia, I would hold that she did.Conclusion For the reasons explained above, I conclude that Dr Kirk has held the office of deputy judge of the Upper Tribunal from 21 May 2024 onwards.ISSUE 2: DOES S 7(12) OF THE REMUNERATION TRIBUNAL ACT ONLY APPLY TO PERSONS WHO HOLD JUDICIAL OFFICE ON A FULL-TIME BASIS? Dr Kirk submits that the reference to a person who “holds a judicial office” in s 7(12) should be construed as meaning only a person who holds judicial office on a full-time basis. The ordinary meaning of the words “holds a judicial office” extends to the holding of a judicial office whether on a part-time or full-time basis. There is no basis in the text of s 7(12) to read down or confine the application of the expression so as to restrict it to persons who hold judicial office on a full-time basis. It is apparent from the terms of various provisions of the Remuneration Tribunal Act that it contemplates that “offices” may be held on either a part-time or a full-time basis. For example, s 4(2) provides that the Remuneration Tribunal itself is to “consist of three members appointed by the Governor-General on a part-time basis”, and s 4(3) states that a member “holds office” for a period not exceeding five years. This context supports the conclusion that references in the Remuneration Tribunal Act to persons who “hold” an “office” are, generally speaking, not limited to persons who hold an office on a full-time basis. That the expression “if the person holds a judicial office” in s 7(12) extends to the situation of a person who holds judicial office whether on a full-time or a part-time basis is further reinforced by the consideration that, in several subsections within s 7, specific reference is made to public offices being held on either a full-time basis or a part-time basis: see s 7(3AA), (3C), (11), (12A). That is, where it is intended to limit the application of particular subsections to persons who hold offices only on a full-time basis or only on a part-time basis, that limitation appears expressly from the language used in the Remuneration Tribunal Act. Again, the immediate context of s 7 tends to confirm that, had it been intended that s 7(12) should be limited in its application to persons who hold foreign judicial office on a full-time basis, it is to be expected that express language to that effect would have been used. I do not accept Dr Kirk’s submission that, in order for the operation of s 7(12) to “make sense”, it is necessary to construe the expression “holds a judicial office” as limited to the holding of a judicial office on a full-time basis. As explained at [47]-[48] above, the effect of s 7(12) is to disapply s 7(9) in relation to the persons to whom it applies (except as prescribed by regulation), and to return control over the fixing of the remuneration (if any) to be paid to such persons to the executive government.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

By letter dated 10 April 2024, sent to her by email, Dr Kirk was offered an appointment as a fee-paid deputy judge of the Upper Tribunal. The letter included the following:Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal, Immigration and Asylum ChamberI am pleased to tell you that the Senior President of Tribunals’ [sic] is willing to offer you an appointment as a Deputy Judge of the Upper Tribunal (Immigration and Asylum Chamber). You must be prepared to sit at Field House in London but may also be asked to sit in other venues as and when required.All Deputy Judges of the Upper Tribunal are also, or if already appointed remain, Fee-paid Judges of the First-tier Tribunal and you may be deployed to undertake work there in suitable cases.…Data ProtectionI can confirm that the Judicial Office (JO) holds personal data relating to you on behalf of the Lady Chief Justice. Your personal data is processed because you are a member of the Judiciary, and the JO holds judicial HR records. … If the JO is asked to confirm the names of serving judicial office-holders, then your name could be disclosed. This could happen, for example, as part of a response to a request made under the Freedom of Information Act. …Lord Chancellor’s Terms and Conditions of ServiceI enclose a copy of the generic Terms and Conditions of Appointment for all Fee-paid Tribunal members and ask that you please note the contents. However, I must mention that Office holders are usually required to make themselves available for a minimum of 15 days a year on tribunal business. This figure may be varied from time to time, in accordance with business needs either generally or for certain categories of office. Where a different sitting level is required, it will be specified in the recruitment material or otherwise notified. His Majesty’s Courts and Tribunals Service (HMCTS) will try to allocate sittings equally but cannot guarantee a minimum number of days in any year. A maximum number of days may be set where business needs dictate. You must be prepared to sit in London but may also be asked to sit in other locations.You are appointed on a four-year term which may be renewed subject to the office holder’s agreement, unless a question of cause for non-renewal is raised, or you no longer satisfy the conditions or qualifications for appointment. Should your appointment be renewed for one or more further periods, your compulsory retirement date will be … 5/24/2042.…TrainingTraining will be provided. Successful candidates, after appointment, will have access to the Judicial College training prospectus. Successful candidates who are not already judicial office holders will be required to attend a judicial skills training course although an exact date and venue have yet to be confirmed.…PensionAs of 1st April 2022, the Judicial Pension Scheme 2022 (JPS 2022) is the only judicial pension scheme open to accrual. It is open to all eligible fee-paid and salaried judicial office holders, except where terms and conditions are specifically nonpensionable. …The JPS 2022 is unregistered for tax purposes which means that pension benefits accrued in it will not count towards the Lifetime and Annual Allowances. Several of its features flow from this tax status, including the uniform contribution rate of 4.26%. The main features of JPS 2022 are a pension scheme design based on career average earnings with unreduced benefits payable from your State Pension Age and no service cap.Alternatively, it is possible to opt out of JPS 2022 membership should you so wish to. …Please note on accepting the appointment unless the Pensions team hear from you within 1 month of the date of this letter the default option of joining the JPS 2022 will be applied from your date of appointment and contributions will be deducted from salary/fees earned.…Next stepsI should be grateful if you would let me know no later than 24 April 2024 whether you wish to accept this offer of appointment. …When written confirmation of your acceptance has been received, we will send a formal letter of appointment. Until then, the Lord Chancellor would be grateful if you would treat this letter as strictly confidential and, besides anyone involved with the appointment or training arrangements, only mention the matter to your family, Head of Chambers/Partners and your accountant.(Emphasis in original.)