Commissioner of Taxation v Jayasinghe

Link copied
Case Copied 36 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

KIEFEL CJ,
GAGELER, KEANE, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ

COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION  APPELLANT

AND

KAMAL JAYASINGHE   RESPONDENT

Commissioner of Taxation v Jayasinghe

[2017] HCA 26

9 August 2017

S275/2016

ORDER

1.Appeal allowed.

2.Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 9 June 2016 and in its place order that:

(a)the appeal to that Court be allowed; and

(b)the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 29 June 2015 be set aside and in its place order that the decision under review be affirmed.

On appeal from the Federal Court of Australia

Representation

J O Hmelnitsky SC with T L Phillips for the appellant (instructed by Australian Government Solicitor)

A H Slater QC with L McBride for the respondent (instructed by Balazs Lazanas & Welch LLP)

Notice:  This copy of the Court's Reasons for Judgment is subject to formal revision prior to publication in the Commonwealth Law Reports.

Income tax – International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963 (Cth) ("the IOPI Act"), s 6(1)(d)(i) – Whether taxpayer "holds an office in" an international organisation to which the IOPI Act applies – Whether taxpayer entitled to exemption from taxation on salaries and emoluments.

Income tax – Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), Sched 1, s 357-60(1) – Taxation Determination TD 92/153 – Whether Commissioner bound to exempt taxpayer from taxation.

Words and phrases – "expert on mission", "incidents of the relationship", "international organisation", "person who holds an office", "skills and expertise", "specialist services", "terms of engagement".

International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963 (Cth), s 6(1)(d), Fourth Schedule, Pt I.
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth), Sched 1, s 357-60(1).
United Nations (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 1986 (Cth), reg 10.
Taxation Determination TD 92/153.
Convention on the Privileges and Immunities of the United Nations [1949] ATS 3, Art V, s 18.

  1. KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ. Section 6(1)(d)(i) of the International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963 (Cth) ("the IOPI Act") provides for the conferral of particular privileges and immunities upon a person "who holds an office in an international organisation to which [the IOPI Act] applies". One privilege is "[e]xemption from taxation on salaries and emoluments received from the organisation"[1]. The United Nations ("the UN") is an international organisation to which the IOPI Act applies[2].

    [1]See cl 2 of Pt I of the Fourth Schedule to the IOPI Act.

    [2]See the definition of "international organisation to which this Act applies" in s 3(1) of the IOPI Act; reg 3 of the United Nations (Privileges and Immunities) Regulations 1986 (Cth).

  2. Under an Individual Contractor Agreement, the respondent, Mr Kamal Jayasinghe, was engaged by the United Nations Office for Project Services ("UNOPS"), an operational arm of the UN, as a "project manager" in the building of a 190 kilometre gravel road in Sudan.

  3. Two questions were raised on appeal to this Court. The first is whether, in the income years ended 30…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Commissioner of Taxation v Jayasinghe and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] HCA 26
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The High Court of Australia heard an appeal from the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia concerning the tax liability of Mr Jayasinghe, an Australian resident engaged by the United Nations Office for Project Services (UNOPS) to work in Sudan. The dispute centred on whether Mr Jayasinghe was entitled to an exemption from Australian income tax on the salaries and emoluments he received from UNOPS, pursuant to the *International Organisations (Privileges and Immunities) Act 1963* (Cth) (IOPI Act).

The primary legal issue before the High Court was the proper construction of section 6(1)(d)(i) of the IOPI Act, which provides for the conferral of privileges and immunities, including exemption from taxation on salaries and emoluments, upon a person who "holds an office in an international organisation to which this Act applies". The court was required to determine whether Mr Jayasinghe's engagement as an individual contractor by UNOPS, under an "Individual Contractor Agreement" to perform specific project management tasks, constituted holding an "office" within the meaning of this provision. A secondary issue involved whether the Commissioner of Taxation was bound by Taxation Determination TD 92/153 in light of the circumstances.

The High Court allowed the appeal, setting aside the decision of the Full Federal Court and the Administrative Appeals Tribunal. The Court reasoned that the terms of Mr Jayasinghe's engagement as an individual contractor, which stipulated he was engaged in his individual capacity as an independent contractor, lacked the necessary incidents of holding an "office" for the purposes of the IOPI Act. The Court emphasised that the relationship was one of a contractor providing specialist services for a defined task, rather than an appointment to a position or role within the organisation's structure. Consequently, Mr Jayasinghe was not entitled to the tax exemption provided by section 6(1)(d)(i) of the IOPI Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. Appeal allowed.

2. Set aside the order of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia made on 9 June 2016 and in its place order that:

(a) the appeal to that Court be allowed; and

(b) the decision of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal made on 29 June 2015 be set aside and in its place order that the decision under review be affirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

These reasons will set out the relevant facts, the assessments issued by the Commissioner and the decisions below, consider the applicable legislative framework and the proper construction of s 6(1)(d)(i) of the IOPI Act and then turn to address TD 92/153.Facts Mr Jayasinghe is a qualified civil engineer. During the relevant income years, he was an Australian resident and, for parts of those years, he was engaged by UNOPS to work in Sudan as a project manager. Mr Jayasinghe worked in Sudan from approximately 13 October 2009 until 31 December 2010 and again from 28 June 2011 until 31 December 2011. Mr Jayasinghe was engaged under an "Individual Contractor Agreement". The two periods were covered by three Individual Contractor Agreements, which were relevantly in substantively similar terms[4].[4]The first Individual Contractor Agreement commenced on 13 October 2009 and expired "without prior notice upon satisfactory completion of the services", but no later than 12 October 2010. The second Individual Contractor Agreement commenced on 13 October 2010 and expired "without prior notice upon satisfactory completion of the services", but no later than 10 January 2011. The third Individual Contractor Agreement commenced on 28 June 2011 and expired "without prior notice upon satisfactory completion of the services", but no later than 31 December 2011. Each Individual Contractor Agreement was deemed to comprise four documents, in the following order of priority – the Individual Contractor Agreement, the General Terms and Conditions of Individual Contractor Agreements in Annex A, the Terms of Reference in Annex B and the Individual Contractor Agreement Policy[5]. Annexes A and B were both an "integral part" of the Individual Contractor Agreement.[5]For convenience, in these reasons a reference to "Individual Contractor Agreement" is to each Individual Contractor Agreement that applied during the relevant period and the documents that were deemed to form part of each of them. An Individual Contractor Agreement was used to engage a person in their individual capacity "to perform a specific task or deliver a specific piece of work"; it could not be used to engage a person "[t]o perform regular core functions". Functions "discharged to implement a project or a portfolio of related projects" were not normally considered core functions. Mr Jayasinghe was engaged by UNOPS as an individual contractor to provide specialist services in Sudan. His functional title was "Project Manager". His task was "[c]ompletion of the road … on time and under budget"[6]. His supervisor was the Head of Programme. Upon certification that the services had been satisfactorily performed in accordance with the Individual Contractor Agreement, Mr Jayasinghe was to be paid a monthly fee by UNOPS.[6]From 28 June 2011, his task was, in general terms, to prepare and issue regular project reports and maintain diaries and progress reports. Under the Individual Contractor Agreement, Mr Jayasinghe had the legal status of an independent contractor of UNOPS, serving in his individual capacity. He had no authority or other right to enter into any legal or financial commitments or incur any obligations on behalf of UNOPS and was responsible for paying any tax levied by the Australian Government on his UNOPS earnings.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

KIEFEL CJ, KEANE, GORDON AND EDELMAN JJ (dissent) GAGELER J
While Mr Jayasinghe was engaged by UNOPS, he held a "UNOPS ID Card". The back of the card contained a request that "all those whom it may concern … extend to the bearer the courtesies, facilities, privileges and immunities which pertain to his/her office, and … facilitate, by all suitable means the journeys and missions on which he (or she) is engaged. If found, please return to the UN Security Office".Assessments and decisions below In September 2013, notices of amended assessment were issued to Mr Jayasinghe for his earnings from UNOPS in the income years ended 30 June 2010 and 30 June 2011. Mr Jayasinghe lodged an objection to those assessments. The Commissioner disallowed the objection. Mr Jayasinghe applied to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal for a review of the Commissioner's decision. The Tribunal set aside the Commissioner's decision[9]. The Tribunal concluded that the substance of the relationship between Mr Jayasinghe and UNOPS, and the obligations created and implemented in carrying out the project, were such that he was the holder of an office within the meaning of s 6(1)(d) of the IOPI Act and that Mr Jayasinghe was a person who worked as an employee of UNOPS and was therefore entitled to the benefit of TD 92/153.[9]Re Jayasinghe and Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 101 ATR 476. A majority of the Full Court of the Federal Court of Australia (Pagone and Davies JJ, Allsop CJ dissenting) dismissed an appeal by the Commissioner[10]. The majority upheld the Tribunal's construction of s 6(1)(d)(i) of the IOPI Act and held that TD 92/153 applied to exempt Mr Jayasinghe from taxation. [10]Federal Commissioner of Taxation v Jayasinghe (2016) 103 ATR 357.The IOPI Act[11][11]The legislative history of the IOPI Act was relevantly described by this Court in Macoun v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 257 CLR 519 at 527-530 [23]-[37]; [2015] HCA 44. Section 6 of the IOPI Act, titled "Privileges and immunities of certain international organisations and persons connected therewith", relevantly provides for the conferral, by regulations, of privileges and immunities on entities and persons in the following terms:"(1)Subject to this section, the regulations may, either without restriction or to the extent or subject to the conditions prescribed by the regulations:(a)confer upon an international organisation to which this Act applies: …(b) confer:(i)upon a person who holds, or is performing the duties of, an office prescribed by the regulations to be a high office in an international organisation to which this Act applies all or any of the privileges and immunities specified in Part I of the Second Schedule; and(ii)upon a person who has ceased to hold, or perform the duties of, such an office the immunities specified in Part II of the Second Schedule;(c) confer:(i)upon a person who is accredited to, or is in attendance at an international conference convened by, an international organisation to which this Act applies as a representative of:(A) a country other than Australia;(B)another international organisation to which this Act applies; or(C)an overseas organisation to which this Act applies;all or any of the privileges and immunities specified in Part I of the Third Schedule; and(ii)upon a person who has ceased to be accredited to such an organisation, or has attended such a conference, as such a representative the immunities specified in Part II of the Third Schedule;(d) confer:(i)upon a person who holds an office in an international organisation to which this Act applies (not being an office prescribed by the regulations to be a high office) all or any of the privileges and immunities specified in Part I of the Fourth Schedule[[12]]; and[12]Clause 2 of Pt I of the Fourth Schedule to the IOPI Act provides for "[e]xemption from taxation on salaries and emoluments received from the organisation".(ii)upon a person who has ceased to hold such an office the immunities specified in Part II of the Fourth Schedule; and(e) confer:(i)upon a person who is serving on a committee, or is participating in the work, of an international organisation to which this Act applies or is performing, whether alone or jointly with other persons, a mission on behalf of such an organisation all or any of the privileges and immunities specified in Part I of the Fifth Schedule; and (ii)upon a person who has served on such a committee or participated in such work or has performed such a mission the immunities specified in Part II of the Fifth Schedule.(2)Regulations made for the purposes of this section may be of general application or may relate to:(a)particular international organisations to which this Act applies;(b)particular offices or classes of offices;(c)particular conferences, committees or missions or classes of conferences, committees or missions; or(d)representatives of particular countries, of particular international organisations to which this Act applies or of particular overseas organisations to which this Act applies." (emphasis added)

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Established by: GAGELER J

Full text does not contain this section.