Kiefel v State of Victoria

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kiefel v State of Victoria [2013] FCA 1398

Citation: Kiefel v State of Victoria [2013] FCA 1398
Parties: JAMES KIEFEL (BY HIS NEXT FRIEND, WENDY KIEFEL) v STATE OF VICTORIA (DEPARTMENT OF EDUCATION AND EARLY CHILDHOOD DEVELOPMENT)
File numbers: VID 2 of 2011
VID 250 of 2011
Judge: TRACEY J
Date of judgment: 20 December 2013
Catchwords: HUMAN RIGHTS – Discrimination – minor with disability – educational services – consideration of direct and indirect discrimination before and after the 2009 amendments to the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) – direct discrimination – whether aggrieved person treated less favourably in circumstances that are not materially different – whether failure to provide reasonable adjustments has the effect that person with disability is treated less favourably in circumstances that are not materially different – ground not made out – indirect discrimination – whether aggrieved person required to comply with requirement or condition with which a substantially higher proportion of persons without disability are able to comply – whether requirement or condition imposed upon an aggrieved person are unreasonable – reasonable degree of precision necessary in formulation – requisite precision absent – ground not made out – alleged breach of Disability Standards for Education – no contravention of standards – application dismissed
Legislation:

Australian Human Rights Commission Act 1986 (Cth)
Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) ss 4, 5, 6, 11, 22, 31, 32, 34, Part 2
Disability and Discrimination and Other Human Rights Legislation Amendment Act 2009 (Cth)
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 140
Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission Act 1986 (Cth) ss 46PH, 46PO
Sex Discrimination Act 1984 (Cth)

Commonwealth, Disability Discrimination and Other Human Rights Legislation Amendment Bill 2008, Explanatory Memorandum (2008) 7, 8   
Disability Standards for Education 2005 Parts 3, 4, 5, 6, 7

Cases cited: Australian Medical Council v Wilson (1996) 68 FCR 46 – cited
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336 – cited
Catholic Education Office v Clarke (2004) 138 FCR 121 – discussed
Charles v Fuji Xerox Australia Pty Ltd (2000) 105 FCR 573 – followed
Forbes v Australian Federal Police (Commonwealth of Australia) [2004] FCAFC 95 – cited
Melbourne Corporation v The Commonwealth (1947) 74 CLR 31 – cited
Minns v New South Wales (Department of Education and Training) [2002] FMCA 60 – cited
New South Wales (Department of Education) v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (2001) 186 ALR 69 – cited
Purvis v State of New South Wales(Department of Education and Training) (2003) 217 CLR 92 – considered, discussed
Qantas Airways Limited v Gama (2008) 167 FCR 537 – considered
Re AEU; Ex parte Victoria (1995) 184 CLR 188 – cited
Sievwright v Victoria [2012] FCA 118 – considered
Sluggett v Human Rights and Equal Opportunity Commission (2002) 123 FCR 561 – considered
Tate v Rafin [2000] FCA 1582 – cited
Walker v State of Victoria (2011) 279 ALR 284 – considered
Walker v State of Victoria [2012] FCAFC 38 – considered
Zhang v University of Tasmania (2009)…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kiefel v State of Victoria and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2013] FCA 1398
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Kiefel v State of Victoria, the plaintiff, Mrs. Kiefel, brought a claim on behalf of her son, James, against the State of Victoria regarding the provision of educational services. James, who has been diagnosed with autism spectrum disorder and language disorders, alleged that the Department of Education and Training failed to provide reasonable adjustments as required under the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth). The court had to determine whether the Department's actions constituted direct or indirect discrimination against James, and whether there was a contravention of the Disability Standards for Education. The plaintiff contended that the Department's failure to provide reasonable adjustments amounted to both direct and indirect discrimination, and that there was a breach of the Disability Standards.

The court found that the Department had indeed provided reasonable adjustments, albeit not to the standard James claimed. Therefore, there was no factual basis for a claim of direct discrimination. Regarding indirect discrimination, the court found that James was not required to comply with any requirement or condition with which a substantially higher proportion of persons without disability are able to comply. Additionally, the court concluded that the Disability Standards were not contravened as the Department had acted in accordance with the standards.

Based on the findings, the court dismissed the application. The court held that the Department had not discriminated against James in contravention of the Disability Discrimination Act 1992 (Cth) or the Disability Standards for Education. The court also made an order regarding costs, requiring either party to file written submissions if they wished to challenge the usual order as to costs. The submissions were to be no more than five pages, with answering submissions also limited to five pages.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. If either party wishes to submit that the usual order as to costs should not be made that party should file and serve written submissions (of no more than five pages) on or before 31 January 2014. Any answering submissions (also limited to five pages) be filed and served on or before 7 February 2014.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

This, unfortunately, is yet another case in which well-meaning parents have wrongly been led to believe that redress is available under the DDA for what they perceived to be deficiencies in the manner in which educational services have been provided to their children by the State of Victoria. BACKGROUND James was born on 1 September 1999. It was common ground that he suffers from autism spectrum disorder (“ASD”) and language disorders, both in a receptive and expressive capacity. Expert evidence indicated that James consistently exhibited certain symptoms of ASD including difficulty in concentration and attention, anxiety, limited speech, avoidance of non-preferred tasks and bouts of aggression. When distressed he could strike out at those near him. On occasions he would bite others or pull their hair. Such behaviour occurred from time to time in both domestic and school settings. James was also prone to loud outbursts which could be disconcerting for those around him. It was alleged by the Department and disputed by James, that he suffers from an intellectual disability. The Department called expert evidence in support of its position. Ms Janette Hibberd, a psychologist, assessed James and concluded that he had a low IQ, indicative of an intellectual disability. Using the WISC-IV intelligence test, Ms Hibberd derived scores in the “extremely low” range for verbal comprehension, perceptual reasoning and working memory. Using the Vineland Adaptive Behaviour Scales, Ms Hibberd found that James functioned at a low adaptive level with a mild deficit. Ms Hibberd’s overall conclusion was that James presented with an intellectual disability in the mild range. Ms Hibberd agreed that James could learn with support. James was also assessed by Dr Catherine Marraffa, who concluded that James had an intellectual disability. James’ pleaded case did not allege nor agree that he had an intellectual disability. He contended, throughout the course of the hearing, that the WISC-IV test was “invalid” as a means of assessing him because he was “non-verbal”. James called expert evidence from Associate Professor Judah Axe and Ms Dianné Perrett-Abrahams about the effectiveness of the test. Neither expert had assessed James in person and both contended that there is difficulty in obtaining accurate test results for children with severe autism. Mrs Kiefel also stated that IQ tests “are unreliable for children with language disorders”, “biased” and “unethical”. Despite this, in closing submissions, those acting for James acknowledged that James may have a mild intellectual disability. It was not in dispute that each of the conditions attributed to James as part of his own case or by the Department constituted disabilities within the meaning of the DDA. Because of the view I have taken about other aspects of James’ case it will not be necessary for me to seek to resolve the limited differences between the parties as to the diagnosis of his medical conditions.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

This aspect of James’ case is confined to events which occurred during the latter part of his enrolment at Essex Heights. The reasonable adjustments which it is alleged that the Department failed to provide to James during this period were the same reasonable adjustments which founded his complaints of direct discrimination during this period. As I have already found, these reasonable adjustments were, in fact, made or provided, albeit not to the standard to which James claimed an entitlement. There is, therefore, no factual foundation for any claim that James was not provided with the pleaded reasonable adjustments after August 2009.Conclusion on Indirect Discrimination Claim Having regard to the findings which I have made it is not necessary that I examine other elements of the statutory definition of indirect discrimination such as the identification of comparator groups or the reasonableness of alleged requirements or conditions. James’ claims that the Department contravened ss 6 and 22 of the DDA between 2005 and 2010 must fail.DISABILITY STANDARDS Section 31 of the DDA empowers the Minister to formulate disability standards, inter alia, in relation to the education of persons with a disability. The Minister has formulated and published standards for education. He did so in 2005. They are entitled Disability Standards for Education 2005 (“the Disability Standards”). They came into operation on 18 August 2005. They applied from that date. They did not, therefore, apply at all stages of James’ primary education. The Disability Standards impose an obligation on education providers to “take reasonable steps to ensure that students with disabilities are provided with opportunities to realise their individual potential through their participation in education and training on the same basis as students without disabilities, and that they are not subject to discrimination”: see Disability Standards for Education 2005 Guidance Notes at [4]. The Disability Standards provide a process by which this obligation can be met: see 4.2(3), 5.2(2), 6.2(2) and 7.2(5), 7.2(6). Any breach of the Disability Standards is a contravention of s 32 of the DDA. If an education provider can demonstrate that it has acted in accordance with a disability standard then Part 2 of the DDA does not apply and the provider’s conduct is deemed to be lawful under the DDA. James alleged that the Department contravened s 32 of the DDA by breaching the particular Disability Standards which are mentioned in paragraphs 67–70 of the FCSOC. Particulars of the allegations are as follows:“67. The discrimination was contrary to Part 3 of the Disability Standards in that:a. since 2005 it was reasonable for the [Department] to provide the reasonable adjustments to James, but it did not do so (Part 3.4);b. since 2005, it was reasonable for the [Department] to make proper enquiries as to what adjustments were required for James, but it did not do so (Part 3.4(2));c. since 2005, it was reasonable to procure the opinions of expert professionals by way of their involvement in Program Support Group meetings but that did not occur (Parts 3.4 and 3.5);d.since 2005, it was reasonable for James to be taught by someone trained and familiar with his disabilities but that did not occur except where employed by James’ parents (Part 3.4);e.since 2005 it was reasonable to consult James’ Next Friend and to ascertain, give consideration to, and take account of, her views on reasonable adjustment, but that process did not occur at all (Part 3.5);f.the Act, as beneficial human rights legislation, anticipates that consultation will be meaningful. 68. The discrimination was contrary to Part 5 of the Disability Standards in that:a.the [Department] did not take reasonable steps to ensure that James was able to participate in the courses or programs provided by it, and use the facilities and services provided by it on the same basis as a student without a disability, and without experiencing discrimination (Part 5.2(1)).b.the [Department] refused, neglected or failed to engage with relevant professionals following consultation with James’ associate (Part 5.2(2)(a)) and as a result was unwilling or unable to make informed decisions in relation to further adjustments as required pursuant to Part 5.2(2)(b) & (c). 69.The discrimination was contrary to Part 6 of the Disability Standards in that the [Department] did not adequately design or modify the curriculum to enable James to participate in the learning experiences of the program on the same basis as students without the disability (Part 6 (1)(2) & (3)). 70.The discrimination was contrary to Part 7 of the Disability Standards in that:a.the [Department] did not take reasonable steps to ensure [James] had access to the service (Part 7.2 (2)) in that it did not provide [him] with the specialised support he required (the reasonable adjustment);b.the [Department] did not actively seek specialist support in order to implement recommendations James’ treating practitioners made (Part 7.2(3));c.the [Department] refused neglected or failed to implement remedial assistance to address James’ poor academic achievement (Part 7.2(2) & (3));d.the [Department] did not comply with Part 7.3(b) & (d) of the standards, in that it did not provide or facilitate:i.the specialised services of staff trained in James’ disabilities; or ii.attendance to James’ program by expert medical professionals.”

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established