Kallimanis and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 45 min read

Kallimanis and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) [2020] AATA 1796 (11 June 2020)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2018/2681

2019/2338

Re:Eftimios Kallimanis

APPLICANT

AndLinfox Australia Pty Ltd

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Deputy President J W Constance
Dr L Bygrave, Member

Date:11 June 2020

Place:Sydney

APPLICATION 2018/2681

The reviewable decision, made by Linfox Australia Pty Ltd on 8 May 2018, that Mr Kallimanis had no present entitlement to payment of compensation for medical treatment expenses and incapacity benefits pursuant to sections 16 and 19 respectively of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) arising from an accepted left elbow condition, is affirmed.

APPLICATION 2019/2338

The reviewable decision, made by Linfox Australia Pty Ltd on 12 April 2019, denying liability to compensate Mr Kallimanis pursuant to the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) for claimed conditions of left ulnar neuritis, left axillary nerve lesion and left lateral epicondylitis, is affirmed.

...........................[SGD]...........................................

Deputy President J W Constance

CATCHWORDS

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – application for review of decision affirming determination that Applicant not presently entitled to payments for incapacity benefits and medical expenses in respect of accepted left elbow condition – where Tribunal satisfied Applicant has not been incapacitated for work as a result of the accepted injury since the decision that the Applicant had no present entitlement – decision affirmed

WORKERS’ COMPENSATION – application for review of decision denying liability for claimed conditions – left ulnar neuritis – left axillary nerve lesion – left lateral epicondylitis – where Tribunal not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that the conditions were contributed to, to a significant degree, by the Applicant’s employment – decision affirmed

LEGISLATION

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) ss 4, 5A, 5B, 14, 16, 19

CASES

Canute v Comcare [2006] HCA 47; (2006) 226 CLR 535

Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May [2016] HCA 19; (2016) 257 CLR 468

REASONS FOR DECISION

Deputy President J W Constance
Dr L Bygrave, Member

11 June 2020

Part 1
A. Introduction [1]
B. Background [10]
C. The relevant provisions of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (Cth) [27]
Part 2: Application 2018/2681
A. Issues for determination [35]
B. Evidence of medical professionals [36]
C. Discussion [47]
Issue 1: Is Linfox liable to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the cost of any medical treatment obtained by him in relation to the compensable injury on or since 26 March 2018? [49]
Issue 2: Has Mr Kallimanis been incapacitated for work as a result of the compensable injury on, or at any time since, 26 March 2018? [55]
Part 3: Application 2019/2338
A. Issues for determination [63]
B. Evidence of Mr Kallimanis [69]
C. Discussion [79]
Issue 1: Is Linfox liable to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the claimed injury described as “ulnar neuritis at left arm”? [79]
Issue 2: Is Linfox liable to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the claimed injury described as “lateral epicondylitis at left elbow”? [110]
Issue 3: Is Linfox…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kallimanis and Linfox Australia Pty Ltd (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] AATA 1796
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application by Mr. Kallimanis to review a decision by Linfox Australia Pty Ltd that affirmed a prior determination. The prior determination had found that Mr. Kallimanis was not presently entitled to compensation for incapacity benefits and medical expenses related to an accepted left elbow condition. Additionally, the review sought to challenge the denial of liability for claimed conditions including left ulnar neuritis, left axillary nerve lesion, and left lateral epicondylitis. The case was heard by Deputy J W Constance P.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr. Kallimanis had been incapacitated for work as a result of the accepted injury since the decision that he had no present entitlement, and whether Linfox was liable to compensate him for the claimed conditions of left ulnar neuritis, left axillary nerve lesion, and left lateral epicondylitis. Specifically, the Tribunal had to determine if these conditions were contributed to, to a significant degree, by Mr. Kallimanis' employment.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision that Mr. Kallimanis was not presently entitled to incapacity benefits or medical expenses for the accepted left elbow condition, finding that he had not been incapacitated for work since the previous determination. Regarding the claimed conditions, the Tribunal was not satisfied on the balance of probabilities that left ulnar neuritis, left axillary nerve lesion, or left lateral epicondylitis were contributed to to a significant degree by his employment. The reasoning for this included a lack of sufficient medical evidence to establish a significant contribution from employment for the lateral epicondylitis, and insufficient evidence to justify a finding that the axillary nerve lesion was an injury other than a disease, or that it arose out of or in the course of employment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

On 30 April 2019 Mr Kallimanis applied to the Tribunal to review this decision.[10][10] Exhibit R2, 3.B. BACKGROUND Unless stated otherwise the findings of fact in these reasons are based on the evidence of Mr Kallimanis. We are satisfied of the facts found on the balance of probabilities. Mr Kallimanis provided a statement dated 22 July 2019[11] and gave evidence at the hearing.[11] Exhibit A1. Mr Kallimanis is 57 years old. He commenced employment with Linfox in 2011. In his statement Mr Kallimanis described the circumstances of his being injured as follows:… I was moving a crate so that it would sit on a pallet correctly. I did not realise how heavy the crate was. It did not have a “heavy item” sticker on it. When I went to lift and slide the crate, I felt sudden severe pain in my left elbow.[12][12] Exhibit A1, [19]. He provided more detail when he gave evidence:Mr Kallimanis: I had proceeded to lift it up a little bit and then, slide it over as well because the pallet had its legs were inside the actual pallet groove. It was unsafe. So, I lift and slide it. It wasn’t more than so much, just to get enough room over. … Just a couple of centimetres, just to get it away – out of the groove, because it was pinned in the groove.…Counsel for the Respondent: When you say “sliding”, was the weight of whatever it was still partially supported by the pallet itself?Mr Kallimanis: Yes. It was – yes, but, it was hanging over.Counsel for the Respondent: And you were seeking to realign it?Mr Kallimanis: Realign it to make it more safe.[13][13] Transcript, 5 November 2019, 37. The injury was diagnosed as a rupture of a tendon in the left bicep.[14] On 19 January 2017 the rupture was surgically repaired by Dr Yeoh.[15][14] Exhibit R1, 49. [15] Exhibit R1, 122. Linfox accepted liability to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the injury. He was paid compensation for medical expenses and loss of earnings. Mr Kallimanis was off work for about three months following the injury. During this time he received physiotherapy as prescribed by his doctors. He returned to work on light duties and restricted hours. He gradually progressed to full-time hours but remained on restricted duties as the injury to his bicep prevented heavy lifting. Linfox continued to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the injury. Mr Kallimanis said that:·for months after the biceps repair surgery he continued to suffer pain and restriction of movement in his left elbow and tingling in the fingers of his left hand;·about mid-2017 he began to experience pain in his left shoulder such that he felt that his left arm was becoming useless; he had not experienced this pain previously;·he continues to take Panadeine Forte for pain in his left bicep, elbow and shoulder.[16][16] Exhibit A1. There is disagreement between the parties as to when Mr Kallimanis began to experience pain in his left shoulder. We will refer to this evidence in more detail in Part 3 of these reasons. In January 2018 Mr Kallimanis had an ultrasound guided injection into his left cubital tunnel (part of the elbow) on the recommendation of Dr Yeoh.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In his report of 23 February 2018 Dr Steadman expressed the opinion that Mr Kallimanis no longer suffered from any restriction arising from the injury to his bicep. In his view, Mr Kallimanis was “in a position to resume normal work activities and work judiciously with any lifting.”[30] On 17 September 2018 Dr Steadman confirmed that no further treatment was required for the bicep tendon injury.[31] [30] Exhibit R1, 260.[31] Exhibit R1, 299.Evidence of Dr Pillemer, Orthopaedic Surgeon Dr Pillemer assessed Mr Kallimanis at the request of his Solicitors on 16 August 2018 and 16 May 2019. Dr Pillemer provided reports dated 16 August 2018,[32] 26 November 2018,[33] 16 May 2019[34] and 26 September 2019.[35] He gave evidence at the hearing.[32] Exhibit R2, 286.[33] Exhibit R2, 314.[34] Exhibit A6.[35] Exhibit A7. Following his assessment of Mr Kallimanis on 16 August 2018, Dr Pillemer reported that:·Mr Kallimanis was aware of slight stiffness in his left elbow;·he had a full range of extension, pronation and supination in the elbow;·flexion of the elbow was restricted to 120 degrees. Following his assessment of Mr Kallimanis in May 2019, Dr Pillemer noted that Mr Kallimanis’ “main injury was the rupture of the distal insertion of his biceps tendon, which has been repaired satisfactorily but with slight breakdown of the repair as noted. He has however regained an almost full range of elbow movements.”[36][36] Exhibit A6, 3.C. DISCUSSION Although applications such as the one before us are commonly referred to as applications to review “cease effects” decisions, it is not necessary that we be satisfied that the compensable injury no longer has any effect at all on Mr Kallimanis. There is undisputed evidence that there has been a slight breakdown in the repair of the tendon and that this has caused “bunching” of the tendon towards the shoulder. However, Dr Pillemer and Dr Steadman gave evidence concurrently and agreed that the actual rupture of the tendon had been repaired with a “satisfactory” result.[37][37] Transcript, 6 November 2019. 116. The issues before us are whether Mr Kallimanis has required medical treatment for the injury and whether he has been incapacitated for work as a result of the injury at any time since Linfox decided it was no longer liable to compensate him in respect of any claims in this regard.Issue 1: Is Linfox liable to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the cost of any medical treatment obtained by him in relation to the compensable injury on or since 26 March 2018? Section 16 of the Act requires Linfox to compensate Mr Kallimanis “in respect of the cost of medical treatment obtained in relation to the injury (being treatment that it was reasonable for the employee to obtain in the circumstances)”. We are satisfied that since 26 March 2018 and at the date of these reasons, there was no medical treatment obtained by Mr Kallimanis in relation to the injury that it was reasonable for him to obtain.Reasoning

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 17 January 2019 Linfox denied liability to compensate Mr Kallimanis for the above conditions.[8] On 12 April 2019 Linfox decided to affirm the determination of 17 January 2019 (the second reviewable decision).[9][8] Exhibit R2 p.322.[9] Exhibit R2, 348. On 30 April 2019 Mr Kallimanis applied to the Tribunal to review this decision.[10][10] Exhibit R2, 3.B. BACKGROUND Unless stated otherwise the findings of fact in these reasons are based on the evidence of Mr Kallimanis. We are satisfied of the facts found on the balance of probabilities. Mr Kallimanis provided a statement dated 22 July 2019[11] and gave evidence at the hearing.[11] Exhibit A1. Mr Kallimanis is 57 years old. He commenced employment with Linfox in 2011. In his statement Mr Kallimanis described the circumstances of his being injured as follows:… I was moving a crate so that it would sit on a pallet correctly. I did not realise how heavy the crate was. It did not have a “heavy item” sticker on it. When I went to lift and slide the crate, I felt sudden severe pain in my left elbow.[12][12] Exhibit A1, [19]. He provided more detail when he gave evidence:Mr Kallimanis: I had proceeded to lift it up a little bit and then, slide it over as well because the pallet had its legs were inside the actual pallet groove. It was unsafe. So, I lift and slide it. It wasn’t more than so much, just to get enough room over. … Just a couple of centimetres, just to get it away – out of the groove, because it was pinned in the groove.…Counsel for the Respondent: When you say “sliding”, was the weight of whatever it was still partially supported by the pallet itself?Mr Kallimanis: Yes. It was – yes, but, it was hanging over.Counsel for the Respondent: And you were seeking to realign it?Mr Kallimanis: Realign it to make it more safe.[13][13] Transcript, 5 November 2019, 37. The injury was diagnosed as a rupture of a tendon in the left bicep.[14] On 19 January 2017 the rupture was surgically repaired by Dr Yeoh.[15][14] Exhibit R1, 49. [15] Exhibit R1, 122. Linfox accepted liability to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the injury. He was paid compensation for medical expenses and loss of earnings. Mr Kallimanis was off work for about three months following the injury. During this time he received physiotherapy as prescribed by his doctors. He returned to work on light duties and restricted hours. He gradually progressed to full-time hours but remained on restricted duties as the injury to his bicep prevented heavy lifting. Linfox continued to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the injury. Mr Kallimanis said that:·for months after the biceps repair surgery he continued to suffer pain and restriction of movement in his left elbow and tingling in the fingers of his left hand;·about mid-2017 he began to experience pain in his left shoulder such that he felt that his left arm was becoming useless; he had not experienced this pain previously;·he continues to take Panadeine Forte for pain in his left bicep, elbow and shoulder.[16][16] Exhibit A1.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Although not clear, this appears to be an argument in support of the proposition that the epicondylitis is a disease within the meaning of section 5B of the Act2.7.4 Consideration Counsel for Mr Kallimanis put that the “obvious inference is that the Applicant has since recovered from this condition.”[94] We do not accept this proposition. Mr Kallimanis was adamant that he continues to suffer from numbness from the inside to the outside of his elbow, distinct from the pains felt down his left forearm and up to his shoulder.[94] Applicant’s Written Submissions dated 4 December 2019, [68]. Taking into account that Dr Yeoh and Dr Annett differed as to the diagnosis of the condition and that neither gave evidence at the hearing, we cannot be satisfied that Mr Kallimanis’ employment contributed to the condition to a significant degree. In reaching this conclusion we note that “significant” means “substantially more than material”[95] and therefore imposes a higher threshold than had been required before the amendment to the Act in 2007.[95] Subsection 5B(3). We have also taken into account the evidence of Dr Steadman. He is a Consultant Orthopaedic Surgeon with a detailed knowledge of conditions relating to the elbow. Considering his evidence and the evidence of Dr Pillemer, who could not explain how the condition occurred, we cannot be satisfied on the balance of probabilities that Mr Kallimanis’ employment made the required contribution to his ailment.2.7.5 Has Mr Kallimanis suffered an injury “other than a disease”? There is insufficient evidence to justify a finding that the lateral epicondylitis is an injury other than a disease. Although Mr Kallimanis gave evidence that he suffered a feeling of numbness in his elbow from the time of his moving the crate, this is unsupported by the medical evidence. Dr Yeoh’s diagnosis was based on the probability that Mr Kallimanis did not use his elbow properly after his injury. There was no explanation as to why this may have been so. Dr Annett diagnosed a chronic pain syndrome. Neither of the above diagnoses is consistent with the type of “physiological change” referred to by the High Court in Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission v May set out in paragraph 67 to 69 of these reasons. Furthermore, even if we had been satisfied that it was appropriate to consider the condition under paragraph 5A(1)(b), taking into account the evidence of Dr Steadman, we would not have been satisfied, on the balance of probabilities, that the condition arose out of, or in the course of, Mr Kallimanis’ employment.2.8 Conclusion Linfox is not liable to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the condition of lateral epicondylitis of the left elbow.Issue 3: Is Linfox liable to compensate Mr Kallimanis in respect of the claimed injury described as “axillary nerve lesion at left arm”?3.1 What is the axillary nerve? Dr Pillemer and Dr Steadman agreed on the following description of the anatomy of the axillary nerve:… it wraps around the … surgical neck of the humerus and it’s got several branches. There is a branch posteriorly that supplies the posterior head and the sensory branch and we in fact call it the “regimental badge” a bit like a soldier has on the sort of top of their arm and so a classic axillary nerve palsy will cause loss of sensation in that area and it’s true that we see it more commonly after dislocation or fracture around the surgical neck.[96][96] Transcript, 6 November 2019, 126.