Decision
Reasons for decision
I am not satisfied that use of the Trade Mark by the Holder would be contrary to law. Therefore, the Opponent has not established the ground of opposition under s 42(b) in respect of the Subset Goods.Decision I find that the Opponent has failed to establish any of the grounds of opposition it nominated in the SGP. Accordingly, extension of protection of the Holder’s Mark may proceed not less than one month from the date of this decision. If the Registrar is served with a notice of appeal, I direct that extension of protection of the IRDA shall not occur until either the appeal is withdrawn or discontinued. Otherwise, the disposition of the application should be in accordance with the Court’s order or direction.Costs Both parties have sought costs. It is usual for costs to follow the event, and I see no reason to depart from that principle here. I award costs against the Opponent under s 221 in the relevant amounts under Schedule 8 of the RegulationsAnne MakrigiorgosHearing OfficerDelegate of the Registrar of Trade Marks24 February 2025Annexure AClass 3: Non-medicated cosmetics and toiletry preparations; non-medicated dentifrices; perfumery, essential oils; bleaching preparations and other substances for laundry use; cleaning, polishing, scouring and abrasive preparations; air fragrancing preparations; bleaching preparations [decolorants] for household purposes; chemical cleaning preparations for household purposes; cleaning preparations; detergents, other than for use in manufacturing operations and for medical purposes; fumigation preparations [perfumes]; toiletries; cosmetics; skin cleansing preparations; skin care preparations; hair cleansing preparations; hair care preparations; shower gel; body lotion; body butter; beauty masks; hand cream; lip balm; make-up; soap; hand wash, sun protection cream; reed diffusers; scented sachets; scented room sprays; pot pourri oil; perfume; cleaning sprays; cleaning fluids; cleaning substances for household use; cleaning preparations for household purposes; cleaning preparations for patios, paths, driveways, fencing and decking; mould removing preparations.Class 4: Candles; tea lights; candles; scented candles; nightlights [candles]; wicks for lighting; wicks for candles; Christmas tree candles; wax; candle wax; wax for lighting; beeswax; firelighters; firewood; fuel; lamp wicks; lubricants; wood briquettes.Class 6: Metal materials for building and construction; small items of metal hardware; metal containers for storage; metal storage sheds; sheds [buildings] of metal; bicycle sheds [structures] of metal; stores [strong rooms] of metal; metal screens [other than furniture]; metal fence panels; sheds [buildings] of metal; arches of metal; metal structures; metal lock boxes; securing wire for plants; wire nets and gauzes; wire; pergolas of metal; garden arches of metal; obelisks of metal; baskets of metal; cabins made of metal; cold frames of metal; metal greenhouses; trellis of metal; metal fencing; gates of metal; blinds of metal; compost bins of metal; arbours of metal; insect screens; baskets of metal.Class 8: Hand tools and implements, hand operated; garden tools and equipment (hand-operated); manicure sets; pedicure sets; pincers; knives, forks and spoons being cutlery; trowels; weeding forks; digging forks; rakes; secateurs; pruners; hoes; spades; shovels; hand-operated cultivators for gardening; shears; scissors; tool belts; tool bags [filled]; hand-operated garden tools; sprays [hand-operated tools]; agricultural sprayers [hand operated]; razors; nippers; trowels; insecticide vaporizers; lawn aerators (hand-operated); spiked rollers (hand-operated tools) for use in soil aeration; dibbers; lawn edgers; fruit pickers [hand tools]; forks; knives; loppers [hand tools]; hand saws; fertilizer scoops; shears; weeding tools [hand operated]; cake cutters.Class 9: Apparatus and instruments for recording, transmitting, reproducing or processing sound, images or data; recorded and downloadable media; bags adapted for laptops; downloadable computer software applications; decorative magnets; downloadable graphics for mobile phones; downloadable image files; audio visual recordings; audio recordings; video recordings; downloadable e-books; downloadable educational course materials; downloadable podcasts; downloadable sound recordings; compact discs; downloadable electronic publications; downloadable electronic publications relating to gardens, gardening and horticulture; downloadable instructional material; cases for mobile phones and tablet computers; covers for mobile phones and tablet computers; spectacles; sunglasses; cases for spectacles; cases for sunglasses; protective eyewear; gloves for protection against accidents; knee-pads for workers; protective helmets; protective masks; science sets for children being teaching apparatus; protective clothing; rain gauges; thermometers; kitchen scales; virtual reality software and hardware; augmented reality software and hardware; computer software and application software in the field of artificial intelligence (AI); photographic slides.Class 11: Apparatus and installations for lighting; apparatus and installations for heating; apparatus and installations for cooking; electric candles; flameless candles; Christmas lights [other than candles]; hot water bottles; fitted fabric covers for hot water bottles; ornamental fountains; irrigation apparatus for horticulture use; automatic watering installations; garden sprinklers [automatic]; lamps; lampshades; lamp fittings; lamp stands; lamp bases; electric propagators [heating installations]; fire pits; cooking grills; barbecue grills; barbecues; Christmas lights [other than candles]; LED candles; LED lamps; LED lightening installations.Class 16: Paper, cardboard; printed matter; bookbinding material; stationery; drawing materials and materials for artists; paint brushes; instructional and teaching material; instructional and teaching material for gardening and horticulture; plastic materials for packaging (not included in other classes); printers' type; printing blocks; books; books relating to gardening and horticulture; educational books; education books relating to gardening and horticulture; fictional books; factual books; factual and instructional books relating to gardening and horticulture; recipe books; guide books; prints; prints relating to gardening and horticulture; canvas prints; prints of paintings, lithographs; photographs; photographs relating to gardening and horticulture; framed photographs; paintings; paintings relating to gardening and horticulture; framed paintings; lithographs; framed lithographs; printed illustrations; postcards; greetings cards; correspondence cards; books; photograph albums; books of images, photographs, lithographs, illustrations, prints and paintings; memo pads; diaries; calendars; advent calendars; address books; invitation cards; stickers; notebooks; shopping lists, printed; cards; posters; publications; brochures; booklets; pamphlets; periodicals; papers; leaflets; magazines; journals; jotters; writing materials; writing cases; writing implements; writing sets; pens; blotters; address books; pencil cases; pen sets; pencil sets; clipboards; lining paper for drawers; scented lining paper for drawers; desk pads; flower pot covers of paper; albums; table cloths, table linen and table napkins, all of paper; paper, pads and books, all for writing or for drawings; wrapping paper; gift wrap; instructional and teaching material relating to horticulture; gift bags; gift boxes; gift tags; tissue paper; paper shopping bags; paper bags and sacks; place mats of paper; paper coasters; paper lunch bags; plastic films for wrapping; paper handkerchiefs; paper towels; decorative boxes made of paper; plastic films for wrapping; plastic films for packaging; score-cards; score pads.Class 18: Leather and imitations of leather; luggage and carrying bags; umbrellas and parasols; walking sticks; collars, leashes and clothing for animals; bags; cosmetic bags; make-up bags; handbags made of polyvinyl chloride; tool bags, empty; canvas bags; tote bags; backpacks; bags; toiletry bags; wallets; credit card holders; purses; handbags; hiking sticks; key cases; rucksacks; shopping bags; travelling bags.Class 19: Building materials (non-metallic); non-metallic transportable buildings; monuments, not of metal; bird baths [structures, not of metal]; chicken-houses, not of metal; works of art of stone, concrete or marble; lime; limestone; garden sheds of wood; garden sheds of non-metallic materials; sheds; bicycle sheds [structures] of non-metallic materials; sand; gravel; grit; paving stones; huts; stones; curb stones; wooden buildings; buildings (non-metallic -) in the form of cabins; pergolas (non-metallic); garden arches (non-metallic); obelisks (non-metallic); non-metallic cold frames; non-metal greenhouse frames; trellises, not of metal; non-metallic fencing; non-metal gates; tiles; non-metallic laminates being building materials; monuments, not of metal; huts; greenhouses, transportable, not of metal; outdoor blinds, not of metal and not of textile; insect screens.Class 20: Furniture; outdoor furniture; mirrors; picture frames; containers, not of metal, for storage or transport; works of art of wood, wax, plaster or plastic; bins, not of metal; nesting boxes; wind chimes; flower-pot pedestals; kennels for household pets; bean bags; stools; kneeling stools; kneeling frames in the nature of stools; seat pads; chair pads; wicker baskets; hampers [baskets]; storage baskets [furniture]; crates; seats; tables; covers (shaped -) for furniture; table tops; cushions; indoor blinds; personal compact mirrors; compost bins of plastic; plant markers of wood; non-metallic hanging baskets for flower, other than for household purposes; cushions for kneeling or sitting on; pads for kneeling or sitting on; kneelers; water butts, not of metal.Class 21: Household or kitchen utensils and containers; cookware and tableware, except forks, knives and spoons; combs and sponges; brushes, except paintbrushes; brush-making materials; articles for cleaning purposes; unworked or semi-worked glass (except glass used in building); glassware, porcelain and earthenware; bird baths; birdcages; cages for household pets; cosmetic utensils; gardening gloves; indoor terrariums [plant cultivation]; sprinklers for watering flowers and plants; syringes for watering flowers and plants; watering cans; cool bags; lunch boxes; fitted toilet bags; thermal insulated bags for food or beverages; oven gloves; mugs; ceramic mugs; cups; tea cosies; place mats, not of paper or textile; place mats of plastic; fitted cosmetic bags; plates; bowls; napkin holders; trays; potting trays; baskets for household purposes; plates; litter baskets; laundry baskets; plant baskets; fitted picnic baskets; flasks; tea sets; perfume bottles; perfume sprayers; cake stands; biscuit barrels; toast racks; pottery; cleaning articles; buckets; watering cans; waste baskets; bird feeding tables; sprinklers; lawn sprinklers; insect traps; coasters (tableware); drinking vessels; vacuum flasks; bottles; chopping boards; food storage containers; picnic crockery; toothbrushes; jugs; vases; goblets; flower pots; plant pots; pots; planters of earthenware; planters of porcelain; planters of clay; tumblers; window boxes; repotting containers for plants; containers for flowers; serving utensils.Class 24: Textiles; textile material; bed and table covers; curtains of textile or plastic; shower curtains of textile or plastic; sleeping bags; tea towels; place mats, not of paper; table cloths not of paper; table napkins of textile; towels; bed linen; textile coasters; fleece made from polyester; textile handkerchiefs; covers [loose] for furniture; fabrics for textile use; picnic blankets; fleece made from polyester; insect protection mesh; wall hangings; decorative wall hangings of textile.Class 25: Clothing, footwear, headgear; aprons; sandals; boots; slippers; scarves; socks; caps; shoes; shirts; nightwear; eye masks; sleep masks; belts [clothing]; coats; earmuffs [clothing]; hats; headbands [clothing]; jackets [clothing]; jerseys [clothing]; leggings [trousers]; outer clothing; overalls; shawls; tee-shirts; trousers; waterproof clothing; children's clothing; wellington boots.Class 27: Carpets, rugs, mats and matting, linoleum and other materials for covering existing floors; wall hangings (non-textile); wallpaper; artificial turf; artificial grass; wallcoverings; vinyl wall coverings; door mats; bath mats; mural hangings (non-textile).Class 28: Games, toys and playthings; video game apparatus; gymnastic and sporting articles; decorations for Christmas trees; playing cards; card games; Christmas trees of synthetic material; toy tea sets; Christmas crackers; swings; balls for games; building games; jigsaw puzzles; scale model kits; toy models.Class 29: Meat, fish, poultry and game; meat extracts; preserved, frozen, dried and cooked fruits and vegetables; jellies, jams, compotes; eggs; milk, cheese, butter, yogurt and other milk products; cream [dairy products]; oils and fats for food; fruit spreads; nut-based spreads; vegetable preserves; vegetable pastes; fruit preserves; marmalade; meat preserves; preserves, pickles; processed seeds; nuts, prepared; olives, prepared; potato based snack foods; fruit based snack foods; nut based snack foods; seed based snack foods; vegetable based snack foods; turkey.Class 30: Coffee, tea, cocoa and coffee substitutes; rice, pasta and noodles; tapioca and sago; flour and preparations made from cereals; bread, pastries and confectionery; chocolate; ice cream, sorbets and other edible ices; sugar, honey, treacle; yeast, baking-powder; salt, seasonings, spices, preserved herbs; vinegar, sauces and other condiments; ice [frozen water]; spices; ice; chocolates; nougat; sweets; boiled sweets; fruit jellies; candy; fudge; toffee; truffles; flakes of chocolate; chutneys; savoury sauces, chutneys and pastes; biscuits; cookies; cakes; cereal-based snack food; chocolate-based beverages; chocolate-based spreads; chutneys [condiments]; coffee-based beverages; condiments; crackers; ice cream; oat-based food; rice-based snack food; sandwiches; sweets; tea-based beverages; herbal teas; fruit sauces.Class 31: Grains and agricultural, horticultural and forestry products not included in other classes; fresh fruits and vegetables; seeds; seedlings; grasses; natural plants and flowers; foodstuffs for animals; malt; plants; grafted plants and flowers; hybrid plants and flowers; genetically modified plants and flowers; trees; shrubs; foliage plants; house plants; bulbs; tubers; corns; fresh herbs; hedging plants; turf; bird food; mulch; bark mulches; turkeys [live]; fresh cut wreaths; fresh cut garlands.