JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construction Commission

Link copied
Case Copied 40 min read

QUEENSLAND CIVIL AND
ADMINISTRATIVE TRIBUNAL


CITATION:

JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd & Ors v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2018] QCAT 333

PARTIES:

JM KELLY BUILDERS PTY LTD
and
KAWANA JOINERY CO PTY LTD
and
BURNS AND TWIGG PTY LIMITED
BPM COWLRICK PTY LIMITED
(applicants)

v

QUEENSLAND BULDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSSION

(respondent)

APPLICATION NO/S:

OCR099-16; OCR100-16; OCR101-16; OCR102-16; OCR103-16; OCR104-16; OCR105-16; OCR106-16; OCR107-16

MATTER TYPE:

Occupational regulation matters

DELIVERED ON:

9 October 2018

HEARING DATE:

26 February 2018 to 2 March 2018; 11 June 2018;
22 June 2018

HEARD AT:

Brisbane

DECISION OF:

Member Gardiner

ORDERS:

1.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

2.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise Kawana Joinery Co Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

3.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise Burns and Twigg Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

4.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise BPM Cowlrick Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

5.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise John Geoffrey Murphy as an excluded individual is set aside.

6.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

7.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise Kawana Joinery Co Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

8.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise Burns and Twigg Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

9.   The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise BPM Cowlrick Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

CATCHWORDS:

PROFESSIONS AND TRADES – BUILDERS – LICENSES AND REGISTRATION – OTHER MATTERS – where son in family business was entitled ‘General Manager’ but had no other formal position – whether excluded individual because he was influential – whether individual was influential person for other companies in group construction company – interpretation of words ‘control’ and ‘substantially influence’

Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1991 (Qld), s 3, s 3A, s 4AA, s 56AC
Queensland Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2009 (Qld), s 24

Commissioner for Superannuation v Scott (1987) 71 ALR 408
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Crocker v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2015] QCAT 39
Hancock v Rinehart (2015) 106 ACSR 207
McClintock v Queensland Building Services Authority [2011] QCATA 310
Queensland Building and Construction Commission v Arthurs [2014] QCA 307
Shafron v Australian Securities and Investments Commission (2012) 247 CLR 465
Williams v Queensland Building and Construction Commission [2015] QCATA 138

APPEARANCES & REPRESENTATION:

Applicant:

T Sullivan QC and…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd v Queensland Building and Construc... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] QCAT 333
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd and related entities contested the Queensland Building and Construction Commission's (QBCC) decisions to categorise them as 'excluded companies' and to cancel the QBCC licence of John Geoffrey Murphy. The dispute centred on the interpretation of the term 'excluded individual' under the Queensland Building and Construction Commission Act 1999 (QBCC Act). The key issue was whether John Murphy, referred to as 'General Manager' but without formal authority, was considered to control or substantially influence JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd and its related entities. This determination would affect their classification as 'excluded companies' under the QBCC Act.

The court examined the roles and relationships within the companies, particularly focusing on the influence John Murphy held. It considered whether his informal role as 'General Manager' and his familial ties to Geoff Murphy, the sole director and secretary, meant he exercised control or substantial influence over the companies. The court determined that John Murphy's influence did not meet the statutory criteria for being an 'excluded individual' or for the companies to be classified as 'excluded companies'. The court found that the QBCC's decisions were not supported by the evidence regarding John Murphy's actual influence over the companies.

The court concluded that the QBCC's decisions to categorise the companies as 'excluded' and to cancel John Geoffrey Murphy's licence were not justified. The Tribunal set aside these decisions, finding that the QBCC had not correctly interpreted the statutory criteria for 'excluded individual' and 'excluded company'. The court's decision protected the companies and John Geoffrey Murphy from the adverse consequences of being labelled as 'excluded' under the QBCC Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

2. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise Kawana Joinery Co Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

3. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise Burns and Twigg Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

4. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 23 June 2016 to categorise BPM Cowlrick Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

5. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise John Geoffrey Murphy as an excluded individual is set aside.

6. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

7. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise Kawana Joinery Co Pty Ltd as an excluded company is set aside.

8. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise Burns and Twigg Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

9. The decision of Queensland Building and Construction Commission dated 1 July 2016 to categorise BPM Cowlrick Pty Limited as an excluded company is set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The following are facts agreed between the parties are accepted by this Tribunal in the absence of evidence to the contrary: (a)On 28 July 1981 JM Kelly (Project Builders) Pty Ltd was incorporated.(b)On 22 February 1984 Geoffrey Murphy was appointed as a director and secretary of Project Builders.(c)From 30 June 1992 until 27 April 2000 John Murphy was a director of Project Builders. (d)On 30 March 1993 John Murphy obtained a licence with the QBCC.(e)In the two years prior to and including 20 June 2016:(i) Project Builders was a ‘construction company’ within the meaning given to that term by section 56AC(7) of the QBCC Act;(ii) Geoff Murphy was the sole director and secretary of Project Builders; (iii) John Murphy was the General Manager of Project Builders.(f)On 20 June 2016:(i) Geoff Murphy, in his capacity as sole director and secretary of Project Builders, resolved to initiate the process of a creditor’s voluntary liquidation for Project Builders;(ii) liquidators were appointed to Project Builders.(g)By notice dated 23 June 2016 (received 28 June 2016) the QBCC informed Geoff Murphy that it proposed to cancel his QBCC licence on the basis that he was an ‘excluded individual’ under section 56AC of the QBCC Act by virtue of his role within Project Builders. (h)Geoff Murphy did not challenge the QBCC’s decision and accepts that from 23 June 2016 that he was an ‘excluded individual’ under section 56AC QBCC Act.(i)On 5 August 1969 JM Kelly Builders Pty Ltd was incorporated. (j)On 5 August 1969 Geoff Murphy was appointed as a director of JM Kelly Builders. (k)On 5 September 2003 Geoff Murphy was appointed secretary of JM Kelly Builders.(l)At all material times JM Kelly Builders was a ‘construction company’ within the meaning given to that term by section 56AC(7) QBCC Act.(m)On or about 27 November 1972 JM Kelly Builders obtained a licence with the QBCC.(n)By notice dated 23 June 2016 (received 28 June 2016) the QBCC notified JM Kelly Builders of its decision to categorise it as an ‘excluded company’ pursuant to section 56AC of the QBCC Act.(o)On 27 June 2016 John Murphy was appointed director of JM Kelly Builders.(p)On 21 June 1979 Kawana Joinery Co Pty Ltd was incorporated.(q)On 1 June 1987 Geoff Murphy was appointed as a director and secretary of Kawana Joinery.(r)On 23 June 1993 Kawana Joinery obtained a licence with the QBCC.(s)At all material times Kawana Joinery was a ‘construction company’ within the meaning given to that term by section 56AC(7) QBCC Act.(t)By notice dated 23 June 2016 (received 28 June 2016) the QBCC notified Kawana Joinery of its decision to categorise it as an ‘excluded company’ pursuant to section 56AC of the QBCC Act.(u)On 27 June 2016 John Murphy was appointed director of Kawana Joinery.(v)On 7 July 2016 John Murphy was appointed secretary of Kawana Joinery.(w)On 31 July 1911 Burns and Twigg Pty Limited was incorporated.(x)On 9 January 1979 Geoff Murphy was appointed as a director and secretary of Burns and Twigg. (y)On or about 21 January 1994 Burns and Twigg obtained a licence with the QBCC.(z)At all material times Burns and Twigg was a ‘construction company’ within the meaning given to that term by section 56AC(7) QBCC Act.(aa)By notice dated 23 June 2016 (received 28 June 2016) the QBCC notified Burns and Twigg of its decision to categorise it as an ‘excluded company’ pursuant to section 56AC of the QBCC Act.(bb)On 27 June 2016 John Murphy was appointed director of Burns and Twigg.(cc)On 7 July 2016 John Murphy was appointed secretary of Burns and Twigg.(dd)On 26 July 2016 Burns and Twigg applied for a review of the QBCC’s decision dated 23 June 2016 to categorise it as an ‘excluded company’.(ee)The current shareholders of Burns and Twigg are:(i) GJ Murphy (a 50% shareholder holding 4000 ordinary shares as trustee);(ii) Anncorp (a 49% shareholder holding 3920 ordinary shares as trustee); and(iii) Anjuin (a 1% shareholder holding 80 ordinary shares).(ff)From 30 June 1992 until 25 May 2017 Geoff Murphy was the sole director of Anncorp. On 29 May 2017, Geoff Murphy ceased to be a shareholder in Anncorp.(gg)From 18 July 1972 until 25 May 2017 Geoff Murphy was a director of GJ Murphy. On 29 May 2017, Geoff Murphy ceased to be a shareholder in GJ Murphy.(hh)Anjuin was placed into liquidation on 20 June 2016.(ii)On 6 April 1982 BPM Cowlrick Pty Limited was incorporated.(jj)On 31 August 1987 Geoff Murphy was appointed as a director and secretary of BPM Cowlrick. (kk)On 21 January 1994 BPM Cowlrick obtained a licence with the QBCC.(ll)At all material times BPM Cowlrick was a ‘construction company’ within the meaning given to that term by section 56AC(7) QBCC Act.(mm)By notice dated 23 June 2016 (received 28 June 2016) the QBCC notified BPM Cowlrick of its decision to categorise it as an ‘excluded company’ pursuant to section 56AC of the QBCC Act.(nn)On 27 June 2016 John Murphy was appointed director of BPM Cowlrick.(oo)On 7 July 2016 John Murphy was appointed secretary of BPM Cowlrick.(pp)On 26 July 2016 BPM Cowlrick applied for a review of the QBCC’s decision dated 23 June 2016 to categorise it as an ‘excluded company’.(qq)The current shareholder of BPM Cowlrick is GJ Murphy Holdings. (rr)From 24 June 1992 until 25 May 2017 Geoff Murphy was the sole director and secretary of GJ Murphy Holdings. On 29 May 2017 Geoff Murphy ceased to be a shareholder in GJ Murphy Holdings.(ss)On 16 February 2016 John Murphy obtained his Open Builder’s Licence.(tt)Project builders changed its name to Collhart Investments Pty Ltd on 17 June 2016.Conclusion

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established