Jewell v Magnium Australia Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 72 min read

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA

(DIVISION 2)

Jewell v Magnium Australia Pty Ltd [2025] FedCFamC2G 201

File number: MLG 1325 of 2023
Judgment of: JUDGE CHAMPION
Date of judgment: 20 February 2025
Catchwords:

FAIR WORK – General Protections – Whether the employer dismissed the employee from employment because he had made workplace complaints – Whether the employer dismissed the employee from employment because he was temporarily absent from work because of illness – Where the employer dismissed the employee because of concerns about the employee’s performance and not because of workplace complaints or because he was temporarily absent – General protections claim dismissed

FAIR WORK – Section 323(1) – Requirement for an employer to pay an employee amounts payable to the employee in relation to the performance of work in full at least monthly – Whether employer did not pay the employee’s salary for the final week of his employment during the relevant period – Application as to contravention of s. 323(1) dismissed

FAIR WORK – National employment standards - Where the employer made admissions that it had not made a payment in lieu of notice, paid redundancy pay or paid accrued and unused annual leave to the employee as at the date of dismissal – Where the employer paid those entitlements at a later date –Declarations as to contraventions made

FAIR WORK – Accessorial liability – Where the Second Respondent was not an intentional participant in the primary contravener’s contraventions - Claim against the Second Respondent for accessorial liability dismissed 

Legislation: Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss. 44, 90, 117, 119, 323, 341, 351, 352, 361, 550, 793
Cases cited:

Board of Bendigo Regional Institute of Technical and Further Education v Barclay (2012) 248 CLR 500; [2012] HCA 32

Celand v Skycity Adelaide Pty Ltd (2017) 256 FCR 306; [2017] FCAFC 222

CFMEU v BHP Coal Pty Ltd (2014) 253 CLR 243; [2014] HCA 41

Cigarette & Gift Warehouse Pty Ltd v Whelan (2019) 268 FCR 46; [2019] FCAFC 16

Cummins South Pacific Pty Ltd v Keenan [2020] FCAFC 204

Fair Work Ombudsman v Devine Marine Group Pty Ltd [2014] FCA 1365

Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; [2003] HCA 22

Khiani v Australian Bureau of Statistics [2011] FCAFC 109

Lehrmann v Network Ten Pty Ltd (Trial Judgment) [2024] FCA 369

Pilbrow v University of Melbourne [2024] FCA 1140

Tattsbett  Ltd v Morrow (2015) 233 FCR 46; [2015] FCAFC 62

Transport Workers Union of Australia v Qantas Airways Ltd (2021) 308 IR 244; [2021] FCA 873

Victoria (Office of Public Prosecution) v Grant [2014] FCAFC 184; 246 IR 441

Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCA 671

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 211
Date of last submissions: 20 December 2024
Date of hearing: 16–20 December 2024 
Place: Melbourne
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr White
Solicitor for the Applicant: Jewell Hancock Employment Lawyers
Counsel for the Respondent: Mr Pym
Solicitor for the Respondent: Barry Nilsson
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jewell v Magnium Australia Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] FedCFamC2G 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Jewell v Magnium Australia Pty Ltd, the applicant, Dr Jewell, brought a claim against his employer, Magnium Australia, and its Chief Operating Officer, Mr Cross, alleging wrongful dismissal and other breaches of employment law. The court was required to determine whether Dr Jewell was dismissed because of workplace complaints or due to his absence from work on personal leave, or if the dismissal was based on concerns about his performance and accountability. Additionally, the court considered whether the employer contravened sections of the Fair Work Act regarding payment of salary and other entitlements, as well as claims of accessorial liability against a second respondent.

The central issue before the court was to ascertain the true reasons for Dr Jewell's dismissal. The court examined evidence provided by Mr Cross and other employees, which suggested that Dr Jewell's conduct and behaviours in the workplace were divisive and unsatisfactory. The court found that Mr Cross's decision to dismiss Dr Jewell was influenced by these behaviours and concerns about Dr Jewell's accountability and ability to meet business objectives. The timing of the dismissal, subsequent to Dr Jewell's return from personal leave, further supported the conclusion that the dismissal was not related to his temporary absence due to illness.

The court ruled that Dr Jewell's dismissal was not substantially influenced by the workplace complaints or his temporary absence on sick leave, but rather due to concerns about his performance and accountability. The court also dismissed the claims regarding non-payment of salary and other entitlements as the employer had subsequently paid the due amounts. The claim of accessorial liability against the second respondent was also dismissed as there was no evidence of intentional participation in the contraventions.

The court's final orders were that Dr Jewell's general protections claim was dismissed, and the application regarding contravention of section 323(1) of the Fair Work Act was dismissed. Declarations were made as to the contraventions of the National Employment Standards, and the claim for accessorial liability against the second respondent was also dismissed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Mr Cross’ evidence was that members of Magnium’s technology team had difficulties working with Dr Jewell.Mr Cross’ perception of Dr Jewell was supported by evidence from others in Magnium’s technology team In Khiani v Australian Bureau of Statistics [2011] FCAFC 109, a Full Court held at [31] that it is not necessary for an employer to prove that the reasons for which it acted were procedurally or substantively fair. Magnium need not prove that Dr Jewell’s divisive behaviours were of such a grade that they provided a sound, defensible or well-founded reason for his dismissal. It may be, however, that if the reasons a decision-maker advances for having acted as he did are illogical or irrational, do not withstand scrutiny or are formed “wrongly or unfairly”, the court should infer that the decision-maker did not in fact form those opinions or act because of the reasons advanced (Wong v National Australia Bank Limited [2021] FCA 671, [83]). Magnium called substantial evidence that not only did Mr Cross have a view that Dr Jewell had engaged in divisive behaviours in the workplace, but Mr Cross’ state of mind had a foundation in the reports of at least three other members of Magnium’s small technology team of just five employees. When assessing Mr Cross’ evidence as to whether he was genuinely concerned that Dr Jewell had engaged in divisive workplace behaviours such that I might accept he would be motivated to dismiss him because of those behaviours, the proposition that he genuinely held the view that Dr Jewell was divisive derives significant probative support from the fact that three other employees in a small business — Mr Dera, Mr Belgrade and Mr Vlachos — gave evidence that they held views broadly corroborative of Mr Cross’ view that Dr Jewell engaged in divisive workplace behaviour. Necessarily, their views as members of Dr Jewell’s immediate team were going to shape Mr Cross’ view as the COO. Mr JP Dera was an engineer and one member of that small technology team. Mr Dera reported to Dr Jewell from November 2021 until September 2022. He gave evidence that he expressly requested a change in reporting responsibilities in September 2022 because he did not consider he could continue to report to Dr Jewell. Mr David Belgrade performed maintenance work. He gave evidence that he had been suspended from work for two weeks for driving a forklift without a licence, but Dr Jewell had driven a forklift without a licence and considered himself “exempt from the rules”. From October 2022 he had asked Mr Cross if he could be excused from attending plant “walk arounds” because he did not want to be around Dr Jewell anymore. Mr Belgrade was critical of Dr Jewell because he said that Dr Jewell could not discriminate between minor and major safety issues. Mr Belgrade complained that the team’s time and Dr Jewell’s energy was mis-directed to minor issues, such as bolts at the plant not being wholly flush with the ground but protruding 2-3 millimetres. Dr Jewell was asked to mark his safety concerns with pink paint. Mr Belgrade observed that Dr Jewell made “100+” marks using pink spray paint throughout the factory premises, marking areas that Dr Jewell considered safety concerns. Following this incident, Mr Belgrade said that he “lost complete trust in him as a leader of the project” because he could not differentiate between significant and minor issues.

Decision

Reasons for decision

If Dr Jewell had provided a basis of design document that Mr Cross regarded as satisfactory on 19 April 2023, Mr Cross might have stepped back from the decision he had already “pretty well made” — the rebuttable presumption might have been rebutted — but that did not occur. What is my conclusion as to the reasons for the dismissal? I am satisfied that Magnium has proved that Dr Jewell’s workplace complaints within the meaning of s. 341(1)(c)(ii) were not a substantial and operative reason for his dismissal. The substantial and operative reasons for Mr Cross’ decision was that, by the time of the Twenty-Ninth and Thirtieth Complaints, Mr Cross had formed an un-shiftable view of Dr Jewell as a divisive presence at Magnium, as someone who was not accountable for outcomes and was not going to assist Magnium to move ahead with its business goals. Magnium has proved that it was the “positive” reasons that actuated Mr Cross to dismiss Dr Jewell from employment. The fact that the decision was taken on about 27 March 2023 and not acted upon until 21 April 2023 was a product of Dr Jewell’s absence on personal leave and Mr Cross’ genuine belief that he could not move to dismiss Dr Jewell while he was on personal leave. Dr Jewell provided the “basis of design” document on 19 April 2023. It did not change the decision Mr Cross had already made. Because Dr Jewell had returned from personal leave, Dr Jewell’s personal leave was no longer an impediment to Mr Cross acting to dismiss Dr Jewell. There was then a lapse of 24 hours in which Mr Cross took no action. As a matter of strict chronology, after Dr Jewell provided the “basis of design” document he made the Twenty-Ninth Complaint and the Thirtieth Complaint. Dr Jewell submitted I might draw an inference from the fact that as a matter of strict chronology Mr Cross dismissed Dr Jewell “abruptly” after the Twenty-Ninth Complaint and the Thirtieth Complaint and not in an available 24 hour period between Dr Jewell’s provision of the “basis of design” document he regarded as unsatisfactory and Dr Jewell’s making of the Twenty-Ninth and Thirtieth Complaints. Dr Jewell had only just returned from sick leave. The events occurred sufficiently close together that I do not draw any inference that Mr Cross acted because of the final two complaints because in the chronology of events they occurred later than the provision of the basis of design document. Although I am concerned with Mr Cross’ state of mind and not that of Ms Save, Ms Save was particularly impressive witness, closely involved with both Dr Jewell and Mr Cross in the final week of Dr Jewell’s employment, 17 April – 21 April 2023. Ms Save’s evidence gave no support to a contention that it was either the Twenty-Ninth Complaint or the Thirtieth Complaint that actuated Mr Cross to dismiss Dr Jewell from employment. On 21 April 2023, after he received the redundancy letter, Dr Jewell recorded a telephone conversation he had with Ms Save. In its relevant part, the recording was as follows:Daniel Jewell:So, I mean, I don't understand how it's reached the point where: we had a discussion yesterday and you asked me for dot points, which I gave you, and we were supposed to then be having a meeting next Friday, and I've received a letter of redundancy today, which is also immediately after I made a formal complaint… against Clayton.Jane Save:Yes… well, that's.. got.. absolutely.. nothing.. to.. do.. with it as they're two separate things. I think Clayton's been working on this, you know for, for a while even if you would go back Daniel to last November when you were thinking of leaving, we were still discussing, you know, can we change the role to suit? How do we make this.. work for the business. What should you be doing? Is consultancy a better way to move? So look, I think it's been ongoing for a long time and yeah, he just made the decision this morning…

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

It may be that Mr Cross’ concerns were “liable to criticism” because commercial aspirations to get the reactor up and running as soon as possible had to occur within acceptable safety parameters. The issue on a general protections’ application is not whether Mr Cross’ criticism of Dr Jewell was fair or unfair. Suffice to say, I accept that Mr Cross genuinely perceived that Dr Jewell’s decision unilaterally to seek further engineering advice — “without my permission” — about the need to register a pressure vessel was “backpedalling”, not progressing Magnium to a position where it could turn on the reactor and an example, as Mr Cross saw it, of Dr Jewell not taking accountability for business outputs. Dr Jewell’s failure to provide operational documents Mr Cross said that the “most critical” issue for him as to failure of Dr Jewell to take accountability for outputs was his failure to provide a process document detailing the operational requirements for the plant which would enable Magnium to turn on the chemical reactor. Mr Cross’ state of mind was that he needed Dr Jewell to sign off on the operational documents before Magnium could turn on the reactor. On (Friday) 24 March 2023 Mr Cross said that Dr Jewell assured him that documentation “detailing the operational requirements of plant” would be completed by Monday 27 March 2023. Mr Cross referred to the process document he expected as a “basis of design” document. Mr Cross’ evidence was that it was the fact that Dr Jewell had assured him he would provide – and then did not provide – the basis of design document in accordance with his assurance on Monday, 27 March 2023 which led him to dismiss Dr Jewell from employment. In fact, on 27 March 2023, Dr Jewell provided a medical certificate that he was unfit for work for a week. As it happened, Dr Jewell was absent from work for longer from 27 March 2023 until 14 April 2023. Mr Cross’ evidence was that, when he did not receive the basis of design document in late March 2023, he “pretty well made” the decision” to dismiss Dr Jewell from employment. Mr Cross said (T206:L11–12):When I got the medical certificate, that was when my mind turned to re- examine everything again, and that decision was pretty well made about that time. Mr Cross said that there was a gap of time between taking the decision to dismiss Dr Jewell in late March 2023 and implementing that decision on 21 April 2023 because he could not “go behind medical certificates” (T205:L14). Although the law broadly stated is that an employer may not dismiss an employee because he is temporarily absent on sick leave, Mr Cross’ evidence (which I accept) was that it was his view that he could not dismiss an employee while he was on sick leave and, therefore, he could not implement a decision “pretty well made” until Dr Jewell returned to work after his personal leave. In my analysis, Mr Cross’ evidence was to the effect that Dr Jewell’s non-provision of the basis of design document on 27 March 2023 — contrary to the assurances that Mr Cross believed Dr Jewell had provided on Friday, 24 March 2023 — was the straw that broke the camel’s back. He had lost confidence that Dr Jewell was the person be able to progress the project as required and was going to be accountable for progressing Magnium’s technological project. An incomplete “basis of design” document