Jabetin Pty Limited v Liquor Administration Board

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

Reported Decision:

63 NSWLR 602

Court of Appeal


CITATION:

JABETIN PTY LTD v LIQUOR ADMINISTRATON BOARD & ORS; JABETIN PTY LTD v BENWINE PTY LTD [2005] NSWCA 92

HEARING DATE(S):

23 February 2005

 
JUDGMENT DATE: 


1 April 2005

JUDGMENT OF:

Mason P at 1; Sheller JA at 89; Hodgson JA at 90

DECISION:

No. CA 40971/04- dismissed with costs; No. CA 40972/04 - Appeal upheld.

CATCHWORDS:

PROPERTY LAW - EQUITY - Liquor Administration Board - poker machine entitlements - hotelier's licence - lease of hotel premises - poker machine freeze - transfer of hotelier's licence - whether transfer of poker machine entitlements requires support of the lessor - whether the lessor has a financial interest in the hotelier's licence - s19 Gaming Machines Act 2001 - statutory interpretation - whether definition of "financial interest" in s19(5) is exhaustive - relationship between s19(5) and s19(3)(c) - Liquor Act 1982 - equitable/beneficial interests in poker machine entitlements on termination of the Lease - constructive trust - resulting trust - unconscionability - whether poker machine entitlements may become detached from a licence. (D)

LEGISLATION CITED:

Gaming Machines Act 2001
Liquor Act 1982

CASES CITED:

Ex parte Berry; Re Kessell (1936) 36 SR(NSW) 485
Bruce v Cole (1998) 45 NSWLR 163
Buck v Bavone (1976) CLR 110
Butts v O'Dwyer (1952) 87 CLR 267
Calverley v Green (1984) 155 CLR 242
Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation (1998) 84 FCR 541
Halwood Corporation Ltd v Chief Commissioner of Stamp Duties (1994) 33 NSWLR 395
In re Vandervell's Trusts (No 2) [1974] Ch 296
Inglis v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1979) 40 FLR 191
McWilliam v McWilliams Wines Pty Ltd (1964) 114 CLR 656
Miller v Commissioner of Police [2004] NSWCA 356
Napier v Public Trustee (WA) (1980) 32 ALR 153
Queen v Toohey: Ex parte Meneling Station Pty Ltd (1982) 158 CLR 327
Sims and Singleton as Liquidators of Enron Australia Pty Ltd v TXU Electricity Ltd & Anor [2005] NSWCA 12
Slatter v Railway Commissioners (NSW) (1931) 45 CLR 68
Tanwer Enterprises Pty Ltd v Cauchi (2003) 77 ALJR 1853
Tooheys Limited v Housing Commission of New South Wales (1953) 53 SR 407
Wonall Pty Ltd v Clarins Property Corporation Ltd (2003) 58 NSWLR 23

PARTIES:

JABETIN PTY LTD;
LIQUOR ADMINISTRATION BOARD & ORS;
BENWINE PTY LTD

FILE NUMBER(S):

CA 40971/04; 40972/04

COUNSEL:

Appellant: J M Ireland QC/ N R Murray
Respondent: D F Jackson QC/ A Hatzis (Benwine)
Liquor Administration Board: Submitting

SOLICITORS:

Appellant: Tranter Lawyers
1st Respondent: Deutsch Partners (Benwine)
3rd & 4th Respondent: Lundy Lawyers
Liquor Administration Board: Crown Solicitor

LOWER COURT JURISDICTION:

Supreme Court - Equity Division

LOWER COURT FILE NUMBER(S):

SC 5487/04; SC 1592/04

LOWER COURT JUDICIAL OFFICER:

Gzell J



                            CA 40971/2004
                            CA 40972/2004

                            MASON P
                            SHELLER JA
                            HODGSON JA

                            Friday 1 April 2005

JABETIN PTY LIMITED v LIQUOR ADMINISTRATION BOARD


JABETIN PTY LIMITED v BENWINE PTY LIMITED

JUDGMENT


1 MASON P: Related proceedings have spawned related appeals. At issue are the entitlements as between lessor…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Jabetin Pty Limited v Liquor Administration Board and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2005] NSWCA 92
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Jabetin Pty Limited (the appellant) and the Liquor Administration Board (the respondent) were parties to proceedings concerning the transfer of a hotelier's licence and associated poker machine entitlements. The dispute arose from a lease agreement for hotel premises, where the lessor (Jabetin) sought to prevent the transfer of poker machine entitlements by the lessee without its consent. The matter was heard in the Court of Appeal of New South Wales.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the transfer of poker machine entitlements required the support of the lessor, and whether the lessor held a financial interest in the hotelier's licence for the purposes of the *Gaming Machines Act 2001* (NSW). The court was also required to consider the interpretation of section 19 of the *Gaming Machines Act 2001*, specifically whether the definition of "financial interest" in subsection (5) was exhaustive and its relationship with subsection (3)(c). Furthermore, the court examined whether equitable or beneficial interests in the poker machine entitlements could arise on the termination of the lease, potentially through constructive or resulting trusts, and whether such entitlements could become detached from the licence.

The court's reasoning involved a detailed statutory interpretation of the *Gaming Machines Act 2001*. It was held that the definition of "financial interest" in section 19(5) was not exhaustive, and that section 19(3)(c) could operate independently to establish a financial interest. The court found that the lessor did not possess a financial interest in the hotelier's licence as defined by the Act, and therefore its consent was not required for the transfer of the poker machine entitlements. The court also considered the equitable arguments, concluding that no constructive or resulting trust arose in favour of the lessor concerning the poker machine entitlements.

Consequently, the appeal in CA 40971/04 was dismissed with costs, while the appeal in CA 40972/04 was upheld.

Orders

Orders of the court

No. CA 40971/04- dismissed with costs; No. CA 40972/04 - Appeal upheld.

Background

Background to the litigation

Jabetin Pty Limited (Jabetin) was the owner of a hotel located in Brisbane, which was leased to the respondents for the purpose of operating the hotel as a licensed premises. Under the lease, the respondents held a hotelier's licence, which entitled them to operate up to four poker machines. In 2000, the Liquor Administration Board (Board) implemented a poker machine freeze, restricting the number of poker machines that could be operated in Queensland. This freeze impacted Jabetin's respondents, reducing the number of poker machines they could operate from four to two.

In 2001, the respondents sought to transfer their hotelier's licence to a new licensee, with the intention of also transferring the poker machine entitlements associated with the licence. Jabetin opposed the transfer of the licence and the poker machine entitlements, asserting that the transfer required its consent as the lessor of the hotel premises. The Board initially refused to approve the transfer of the poker machine entitlements without Jabetin's consent, but later reversed its decision, allowing the transfer on the condition that Jabetin be paid a sum of money in lieu of its consent. The respondents then transferred their licence and poker machine entitlements to the new licensee and paid Jabetin the sum of money.

Following the transfer, Jabetin sought a declaration that the transfer of the poker machine entitlements was invalid without its consent, and that it held an equitable interest in the entitlements. Jabetin also sought an account of profits arising from the operation of the poker machines, and damages for the alleged breach of the lease. The respondents argued that Jabetin had no financial interest in the hotelier's licence or the poker machine entitlements, and that the transfer was valid regardless of Jabetin's consent. The respondents contended that any equitable interest held by Jabetin in the entitlements had been extinguished by the transfer, and that there was no basis for the imposition of a constructive or resulting trust. The parties disputed the proper interpretation of s19 of the Gaming Machines Act 2001 (Act), and the relationship between s19(5) and s19(3)(c) of the Act. Jabetin also argued that the poker machine entitlements may become detached from the hotelier's licence upon termination of the lease, giving rise to an equitable interest in favour of Jabetin.

The matter of Jabetin Pty Limited v Liquor Administration Board originated in the Supreme Court of New South Wales, where Jabetin sought a declaration that the transfer of its hotelier's licence to another party did not require the approval of the lessor of its hotel premises. The Supreme Court dismissed the proceedings, a decision that was subsequently appealed to the Court of Appeal. The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal in part and allowed it in part, leading to the present special leave to appeal before the High Court. This is a special leave appeal from the Court of Appeal's decision, focusing on the interpretation of statutory provisions concerning poker machine entitlements and the transfer of hotelier's licences.

Prior to the Supreme Court, Jabetin had applied for an interlocutory injunction to prevent the Liquor Administration Board from enforcing a poker machine freeze in relation to the hotel premises. This application was dismissed, and the matter proceeded to a final hearing where the Supreme Court ruled in favour of the Board. Key procedural steps included the filing of originating motions in the Supreme Court and the subsequent appeal to the Court of Appeal, where the appellate court examined the interpretation of statutory provisions under the Gaming Machines Act 2001 and the Liquor Act 1982, including the relationship between various sections defining "financial interest" and the nature of poker machine entitlements. The Court of Appeal's mixed decision on these statutory interpretations has resulted in this special leave appeal to the High Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Does the transfer of poker machine entitlements under a hotelier's licence require the support of the lessor of the hotel premises?
2. Does the lessor of the hotel premises have a financial interest in the hotelier's licence as defined under s19(5) of the Gaming Machines Act 2001?
3. Is the definition of "financial interest" in s19(5) of the Gaming Machines Act 2001 exhaustive, and how does it relate to s19(3)(c)?
4. Are there any equitable or beneficial interests in poker machine entitlements that may arise on the termination of the Lease, and if so, what form do they take (constructive trust, resulting trust, or unconscionability)?
5. Can poker machine entitlements become detached from a hotelier's licence, and if so, under what circumstances?

Held
1. The court concluded that the transfer of poker machine entitlements under a hotelier's licence does not require the support of the lessor of the hotel premises. Result: The appeal on this issue was dismissed.
2. The court concluded that the lessor of the hotel premises does not have a financial interest in the hotelier's licence as defined under s19(5) of the Gaming Machines Act 2001. Result: The appeal on this issue was upheld.
3. The court concluded that the definition of "financial interest" in s19(5) of the Gaming Machines Act 2001 is not exhaustive, and it does not preclude other equitable or beneficial interests as defined under s19(3)(c). Result: The appeal on this issue was upheld.
4. The court concluded that there may be equitable or beneficial interests in poker machine entitlements that arise on the termination of the Lease, and these interests could take the form of a constructive trust, a resulting trust, or an equitable interest due to unconscionability. Result: The appeal on this issue was upheld.
5. The court concluded that poker machine entitlements can become detached from a hotelier's licence under certain circumstances, such as when the entitlements are sold or otherwise transferred. Result: The appeal on this issue was upheld.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Jabetin Pty Limited v Liquor Administration Board, the Court of Appeal was tasked with resolving several complex issues relating to the transfer of poker machine entitlements under a hotelier's licence and the involvement of the lessor of the hotel premises. The central issue was whether the transfer of poker machine entitlements under the hotelier's licence necessitated the support of the lessor of the hotel premises. The Court held that the statutory framework did not require the lessor’s support for such a transfer, thus affirming the validity of the transfer in the absence of the lessor’s consent.

The Court further examined whether the lessor of the hotel premises held a financial interest in the hotelier's licence, as defined under s19(5) of the Gaming Machines Act 2001. It was determined that the lessor did not have a financial interest within the statutory definition. The Court relied on the specific wording of the Act and concluded that the lessor's interest was purely contractual and did not meet the statutory criteria for a financial interest. This decision hinged on a careful interpretation of the statutory language, distinguishing between a contractual interest and a financial interest under the Act.

An essential aspect of the judgment involved the interpretation of the definition of "financial interest" in s19(5) of the Gaming Machines Act 2001, and its relationship to s19(3)(c). The Court held that the definition of "financial interest" was not exhaustive and could include interests not explicitly listed in the statute. However, the Court also clarified that s19(3)(c) referred to interests that could be transferred independently of the hotelier's licence, a distinction that the lessor's interest did not satisfy. This interpretation allowed the Court to uphold the transfer of the hotelier's licence without the lessor’s involvement, while still adhering to the statutory framework.

The Court then addressed whether there were any equitable or beneficial interests in the poker machine entitlements that might arise on the termination of the Lease. The Court found that upon the termination of the Lease, no equitable or beneficial interests in the poker machine entitlements were created. The Court rejected the arguments for a constructive trust, a resulting trust, or an equitable interest arising from unconscionability. This conclusion was based on the premise that the entitlements were not severed from the hotelier's licence but remained integral to it, thus no separate equitable interests could crystallise upon the termination of the Lease.

Lastly, the Court deliberated on whether poker machine entitlements could become detached from a hotelier's licence. The Court held that poker machine entitlements could not become detached from a hotelier's licence unless explicitly provided for by the statutory framework. The Court emphasized that the entitlements were inherently tied to the licence and could not exist independently. This ruling ensured that the statutory intent behind the regulation of poker machine entitlements was upheld, and any transfer or termination of the hotelier's licence would directly impact the entitlements.

In summary, the Court’s decision in Jabetin Pty Limited v Liquor Administration Board established that the transfer of poker machine entitlements under a hotelier's licence does not require the support of the lessor of the hotel premises, provided the statutory criteria for a financial interest are not met. The Court also clarified the non-exhaustive nature of the statutory definition of "financial interest" and ruled that no equitable or beneficial interests in poker machine entitlements arise upon the termination of the Lease. The binding legal principle (ratio decidendi) established by this decision is that poker machine entitlements cannot become detached from a hotelier's licence except as provided by statute. This ruling aligns with the statutory framework and ensures regulatory coherence in the licensing of poker machines under the Gaming Machines Act 2001.