J D & K J Zohs Properties Pty Ltd v Ferme

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

SUPREME COURT OF SOUTH AUSTRALIA

(Civil)

J D & K J ZOHS PROPERTIES PTY LTD v FERME & ANOR

[2015] SASC 55

Judgment of The Honourable Justice Stanley

7 April 2015

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - POWERS, DUTIES, RIGHTS AND LIABILITIES OF TRUSTEES - LIABILITY FOR BREACH OF TRUST

PROCEDURE - COSTS - DEPARTING FROM THE GENERAL RULE - ORDER FOR COSTS ON INDEMNITY BASIS

Claim by the executor of a deceased estate that a former executor indemnify her for losses suffered by the estate as a result of his breach of duty while acting as an executor of the estate. 

The deceased died on 28 October 2006. The defendants, as the sole executors and trustees, obtained a grant of probate of the deceased’s will on 4 July 2007. The principal asset of the estate was two parcels of farming land. On 20 June 2014 the defendants entered into a contract for the sale of the land as vendors, to Jason and Kimberley Zohs as purchasers. On 4 July 2014 Mr and Mrs Zohs assigned their right, title and interest in the contract to the plaintiff by a Deed of Assignment. On 9 July 2014 the plaintiff executed a Memorandum of Transfer. The second defendant executed the Memorandum of Transfer but the first defendant failed to do so. When the first defendant failed to do so, the plaintiff instituted these proceedings on 7 August 2014. The plaintiff sought a declaration as to the validity and enforceability of the contract and orders for specific performance together with a claim for damages, interest and costs. On 4 September 2014 the Court made an order for specific performance of the contract and an order pursuant to s 40 of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) appointing the second defendant to execute the Memorandum of Transfer on behalf of the first defendant. These orders were made with the consent and support of the second defendant. The Court ordered that there be a separate hearing of the plaintiff’s claim for damages. That claim was for losses by way of damages, interest and costs suffered as a result of the failure to settle earlier on the contract for the sale of the land.

On 22 October 2014 the second defendant compromised the plaintiff’s outstanding claims in an agreed amount of $55,000 paid from the estate to the plaintiff.  On 24 October 2014 the Court ordered that the remaining claims for relief by the plaintiff against the defendants in this action be dismissed with no orders as to costs between the plaintiff and the defendant but that the action continue in relation to the relief sought by the second defendant against the first defendant. The relief sought is in the nature of an order that the first defendant pay the costs of and incidental to these proceedings of the second defendant on an indemnity basis or, in the alternative, on a solicitor/client basis, and an order that the first defendant indemnify the second defendant for the $55,000…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read J D & K J Zohs Properties Pty Ltd v Ferme and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2015] SASC 55
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

J D & K J Zohs Properties Pty Ltd v Ferme is a case in which the executor of a deceased estate sought indemnification from a former executor for losses incurred due to a breach of trust. The deceased passed away on 28 October 2006, and the defendants, as executors and trustees, obtained a grant of probate on 4 July 2007. The estate’s principal asset was two parcels of farming land, which were sold to the plaintiffs on 20 June 2014. However, one of the executors failed to execute the Memorandum of Transfer, leading to the current proceedings. The legal issues before the court were whether the first defendant was liable to indemnify the second defendant for the losses and costs incurred due to his breach of duty and, if so, the appropriate basis for the indemnity.

The court found that the first defendant was indeed liable to indemnify the second defendant for the losses and costs. The court reasoned that the first defendant’s actions constituted a breach of trust, which entitled the second defendant to indemnity on an indemnity basis. The court noted that the first defendant had failed to execute the transfer as required, resulting in a delay that caused the estate to incur additional costs and interest. Furthermore, the court rejected the first defendant’s arguments that his conduct was not the cause of any loss or that he acted honestly and reasonably, as these were not supported by the evidence. The court concluded that the first defendant must indemnify the second defendant for the sum of $55,000, plus interest from 22 October 2014, and the second defendant’s legal costs on an indemnity basis.

In summary, the court found that the first defendant was liable to indemnify the second defendant for the losses and costs incurred due to his breach of trust. The court ordered that the first defendant must pay the second defendant the sum of $55,000, plus interest from 22 October 2014, and the second defendant’s legal costs on an indemnity basis. The court’s decision was based on the evidence presented and the applicable legal principles governing trustees’ duties and liabilities.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

This is a claim by the executor of a deceased estate (“the second defendant”) that a former executor (“the first defendant”) indemnify her for losses suffered by the estate as a result of his breach of duty while acting as an executor of the estate. Background The deceased died on 28 October 2006. The defendants, as the sole executors and trustees, obtained a grant of probate of the deceased’s will on 4 July 2007. The will left the residuary estate to six beneficiaries, including the first defendant, in equal shares. The principal asset of the estate was two parcels of farming land. On 20 June 2014 the defendants as executors of the estate, entered into a contract for the sale of the land as vendors, to Jason and Kimberley Zohs as purchasers. The purchase price was $1.4 million. On 4 July 2014 Mr and Mrs Zohs assigned their right, title and interest in the contract to the plaintiff by a Deed of Assignment. On 9 July 2014 the plaintiff executed a Memorandum of Transfer. The second defendant executed the Memorandum of Transfer but the first defendant failed to do so. On 18 July 2014 the plaintiff, by letter from its solicitors, required the first defendant to execute the Memorandum of Transfer by 5 p.m. on 23 July 2014. A further demand to execute the transfer was made by letter of 30 July 2014. When the first defendant failed to do so, the plaintiff instituted these proceedings on 7 August 2014. The plaintiff sought a declaration as to the validity and enforceability of the contract and orders for specific performance together with a claim for damages, interest and costs. On 4 September 2014 the Court made an order for specific performance of the contract and an order pursuant to s 40 of the Trustee Act 1936 (SA) appointing the second defendant to execute the Memorandum of Transfer on behalf of the first defendant. These orders were made with the consent and support of the second defendant. The Court ordered that there be a separate hearing of the plaintiff’s claim for damages. That claim was for losses by way of damages, interest and costs suffered as a result of the failure to settle earlier on the contract for the sale of the land. Settlement of the sale of the land occurred on 23 September 2014. On 3 October 2014 in separate proceedings between the defendants, the Court ordered that the grant of probate to the defendants be revoked with effect from 24 October 2014 and that a new grant of probate be issued to the second defendant only. That fresh grant of probate was issued to her on 3 November 2014. However, on 22 October 2014 the second defendant compromised the plaintiff’s outstanding claims in an agreed amount of $55,000 paid from the estate to the plaintiff. On 24 October 2014 the Court ordered that the remaining claims for relief by the plaintiff against the defendants in this action be dismissed with no orders as to costs between the plaintiff and the defendant but that the action continue in relation to the relief sought by the second defendant against the first defendant. The relief sought is in the nature of an order that the first defendant pay the costs of and incidental to the proceedings of the second defendant on an indemnity basis or, in the alternative, on a solicitor/client basis, and an order that the first defendant indemnify the second defendant for the $55,000 paid to compromise the plaintiff’s claims.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

In any event, he says his conduct was not the cause of any loss or damage to the estate. Finally, in the alternative, he submits that in the event his conduct did constitute a devastavit, he acted honestly and reasonably and ought fairly to be excused for the breach pursuant to s 56 of the Trustee Act. The evidence at trial The trial proceeded on affidavits pursuant to 6SCR 168 and 6SCR 209. The Court received evidence from the second defendant by way of the following affidavits:·Affidavit of Kimberley Jane Zohs sworn on 7 August 2014[10] ·Affidavit of Mary-Lee Hutchins sworn on 7 August 2014 ·Affidavit of Henry Ringwood sworn on 20 August 2014 ·Affidavit of Henry Ringwood sworn on 29 August 2014 ·Affidavit of Barnaby Hugh Grant sworn on 13 August 2014 ·Affidavit of Mary-Lee Hutchins sworn on 2 September 2014 ·Affidavit of Rebecca Jennette Crawford sworn on 22 October 2014·Affidavit of Henry Ringwood sworn on 18 December 2014 ·Affidavit of Jennette Heather Ferme sworn on 2 September 2014[11]·Affidavit of Travis Leon Le Riche sworn on 19 February 2015[10] Only the first three paragraphs of the Exhibit KJZ 6 to the affidavit were admitted into evidence.[11] This affidavit was filed in the separate proceedings between the defendants in Ferme v Crawford (SCCIV-14-1203). No affidavits have been filed by or on behalf of the first defendant. Findings of fact I make the following findings: By letter dated 4 March 2014 the first defendant wrote to the solicitor acting for the executors purporting to exercise the right conferred by clause 12 of the Share-Farming Agreement to purchase part of the land the subject of the agreement, namely, Section 258 in the Hundred of Koolunga. The option was expressed to be subject to finance. The letter further proposed that the remainder of the land be sold by expression of interest.[12][12] Letter from Murray Ferme to the attention of Paul Boylan dated 4 March 2014. On 26 March 2014 the defendants were advised by their solicitor that the entitlement to purchase the land given by clause 12 of the agreement applied to the whole of the land and not to part of the land. Upon receipt of this advice the defendants authorised their solicitors to offer the land for sale.[13][13] Affidavit of Rebecca Jennette Crawford sworn on 22 October 2014 at [33] – [34]. Item 15 of the Schedule to the Land Contract provided that the settlement day was 15 June 2014.[14] [14] Affidavit of Kimberley Jane Zohs sworn on 7 August 2014 (Exhibit KJZ 3). On 21 June 2014 the first defendant and his wife retained solicitors to act for them in connection with the Share-Farming Agreement.[15] [15] Affidavit of Jennette Heather Ferme sworn on 2 September 2014 at [36]. On or about 23 June 2014 solicitors for the purchasers advised the solicitors for the executors that it would take the purchasers more than 10 days to put their finance in place and be ready for settlement under the contract.[16] [16] Affidavit of Rebecca Jennette Crawford sworn on 22 October 2014 (Exhibit RJC 7).

Decision

Reasons for decision

Those losses are constituted by the sum of $55,000 paid by way of compromise and interest calculated thereon from 22 October 2014 and the second defendant’s costs of these proceedings on an indemnity basis. Conclusion I would make the following declarations:1.The first defendant is not entitled to receive distribution of his equal share of the residuary estate of Mavis Jean Smart deceased from the second defendant as executor of the estate until such time as the first defendant pays into the estate, by payment to the second defendant as executor of the estate:1.1 the sum of $55,000 plus interest thereon from 22 October 2014; and 1.2 the second defendant’s legal costs of the proceedings on an indemnity basis. 2.In lieu of the first defendant paying into the estate by payment to the second defendant as executor of the estate the sums referred to in paragraph 1.1 and 1.2 above, the second defendant is at liberty to calculate the first defendant’s share of the residuary estate and distribute the residuary estate to the other residuary beneficiaries on the footing that the sums referred to in paragraph 1.1 and 1.2 above are set off against the share of the residuary estate that the first defendant otherwise would be entitled to receive.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.