Union Bank of Australia v Harrison, Jones & Devlin Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 65 min read
11 CLR 492

UNION BANK OF AUSTRALIA

DEFENDANTS,

HARRISON, JONES AND DEVLIN LTD.

ON APPEAL FROM THE SUPREME COURT OF

NEW SOUTH WALES. Probate Act 1890 (N.S. W.) (54 Vict. No. 25), secs. 15, 17, 19, 20-Judgment

Creditors Remedies Act 1901 (No. 8), secs. 10, 2--Administration-Action against one of several executors-Sale by sheriff under fi. fa. - Effect of bargain SYDNEY,

and sale by sheriff to pass equity of redemption in real and personal estate of Aug. 24, 25,

testator - Power of one co-executor to dispose of real and personal estate of 26 Sept. 8.

Under sec. 15 of the Probate Act 1890 real estate vests in the executors as joint tenants, in the same way as personal estate. Sec. 20 provides that an executor shall have the same rights and be subject to the same duties, with respect to real estate of the testator, that executors theretofore had or were subject to with reference to personal assets.

11 CLR 493

Held, that the intention of the Act was to place real and personal estate upon the same footing as regards actions for the recovery of debts due by the

The appellants, who were mortgagees in possession under mortgages of station property and stock, brought an action against one of the two executors of the mortgagor to recover the amount due under the mortgage, and obtained judgment for want of a plea. At the date when the action was brought, and up to the time when judgment was recovered, the other executor was out of the jurisdiction. A writ of fieri facias was taken out by the appel- lants, and the sheriff, in execution of the writ, sold to the appellants the right, title and interest of the testator at the date of his death, and the right, title and interest of his executors in the real and personal property included in the mortgages. A deed of bargain and sale was subsequently executed by the sheriff in favour of the appellants. Prior to appellants going into posses- sion, the executor who was out of the jurisdiction mortgaged his beneficial interest in the station to the respondents, who brought a redemption suit against the appellants alleging that the deed of bargain and sale executed by the sheriff was inoperative and that the appellants were liable to account as mortgagees.

Held, that the equity of redemption in the real and personal property included in the mortgage passed to the appellants.

Decision of A. H. Simpson, C.J. in Eq.: Harrison, Jones and Devlin Ltd. v. Union Bank of Australia, 10 S.R. (N.S.W.), 266, reversed in part, and affirmed in part.

APPEAL by the defendants from SO much of the decree of A. H. Simpson, C.J. in Eq., as declared that a deed of bargain and sale of 18th September 1899 did not operate to vest in the appellants the lands therein mentioned, freed from all right and equity of redemption therein of Dugald Campbell McGregor, deceased, or of his executors. The late…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Union Bank of Australia v Harrison, Jones & Devlin Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1910] HCA 44
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Union Bank of Australia v Harrison, Jones & Devlin Ltd involved an appeal from the Supreme Court of New South Wales concerning the effect of a sheriff's sale of a testator's real and personal estate. The Union Bank, as mortgagees, had obtained a judgment against one of the two executors of the mortgagor and subsequently purchased the testator's equity of redemption in the mortgaged property at a sheriff's sale. The respondents, who held a subsequent mortgage over one executor's beneficial interest, argued that the sheriff's deed was inoperative and that the bank should account as mortgagees.

The central legal issues before the court were whether the sheriff's sale and subsequent deed of bargain and sale effectively transferred the equity of redemption in both the real and personal property of the testator to the Union Bank, and whether one of two co-executors could, through a sheriff's sale following a judgment against them, dispose of the testator's real estate. This required the court to interpret the provisions of the Probate Act 1890 (N.S.W.), particularly sections 15, 17, 19, and 20, which dealt with the vesting and administration of a testator's real estate.

The court reasoned that under the Probate Act 1890, real estate vested in executors in the same manner as personal estate, and executors were to have the same rights and duties concerning real estate as they previously had concerning personal assets. This meant that a judgment against one executor could bind the testator's personal assets, and the sheriff's sale of these assets was valid. However, regarding real estate, while the Act intended to place it on a similar footing for debt recovery, the court found that the sheriff's conveyance could not be considered more effective than a conveyance by the executor himself. The court concluded that, despite the broad language of the Act, a single executor could not, by virtue of a judgment against them, convey the testator's real estate without the concurrence of the other executor, and therefore the sheriff's sale was ineffectual to pass the equity of redemption in the real estate.

The Full High Court reversed in part the decision of the Chief Judge in Equity. It held that the sheriff's sale and deed of bargain and sale were effective to pass the equity of redemption in the personal property of the testator to the Union Bank. However, it affirmed the decision that the conveyance was inoperative to pass the equity of redemption in the real estate, meaning the bank had not acquired a good title to the land.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established