THE UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE

Link copied
Case Copied 19 min read

Supreme Court of South Australia

(Civil)

THE UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE

[2023] SASC 8

Judgment of the Honourable Auxiliary Justice Dart  

CHARITIES - CHARITABLE GIFTS AND TRUSTS - WHEN APPLIED CY-PRES

EQUITY - TRUSTS AND TRUSTEES - APPLICATIONS TO COURT ON ORIGINATING PROCESS

The Maurice Holtze Trust was created by a bequest in a will - the Trust is for the purpose of research into botany - it is a charitable trust - the Chairman of the Department of Botany was appointed to determine use of the funds - the Department of Botany has been merged with other departments - the position of Chairman of the Department of Botany no longer exists - the applicant seeks to vary the terms of the Trust to accommodate the applicant's current administrative arrangements - the Court has an inherent jurisdiction to vary the administrative arrangements of a charitable trust - it is appropriate to make the variation sought - Trust funds were used as part-funding of a DNA laboratory established in 2005 - the use of funds in that way was possibly a breach of trust - the applicant seeks to be relieved from liability for any breach of trust - the provisions of s 56 of the Trustee Act give the Court power to relieve a trustee for a possible breach - the applicant acted honestly and reasonably - it is appropriate to grant relief to the applicant in respect of possible liability for breach of trust.

Held:

1. The terms of the charitable trust are to be varied in the terms sought in the application.

2. The applicant is excused from liability for any breach of trust arising from the application of the sum of $200,000 from the Maurice Holtze Trust towards the construction of the DNA laboratory.

Trustee Act 1936 (SA) s 56, s 64 and s 69B, referred to.

Taylor v Taylor (1910) 10 CLR 218; Re Lowin (deceased) [1967] 2 NSWR 140, applied.

Baptist Churches of South Australia Inc & Anor v Attorney-General for the State of South Australia [2018] SASC 14; JD & KZ Zohs Properties Pty Ltd v Ferme & Anor [2015] SASC 55; University of Adelaide v Attorney-General (SA) [2018] SASC 82, considered.

THE UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE
[2023] SASC 8

  1. The University of Adelaide (“the University”) applied for certain declarations and orders in respect of the Maurice Holtze Trust (“the Trust”).  The application is granted. These are the reasons for allowing the application.

    Background

  2. By her will dated 31 October 1979 Mrs Kathleen Isobel Bates gifted a pecuniary legacy to the University.  The exact terms were as follows:[1]

    AS TO a pecuniary legacy of SEVENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($75,000) to the UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE for the establishment of a fund for research into botany to be known as the MAURICE HOLTZE FUND to the intent that the income of such fund shall be used as the Chairman of the Department of Botany of that University shall from time to time determine AND…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read THE UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] SASC 8
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The University of Adelaide applied for certain declarations and orders in respect of the Maurice Holtze Trust. The application was granted. The University sought to have the purposes of the trust altered to allow the income of the trust to be applied to the advancement of science, more generally, rather than solely to botany research. The trust was established by a gift of $75,000 to the University, to be applied to research into botany. The gift was made in 1979 and the trust was established in 1983. The trust was to be administered by the Chairman of the Department of Botany at the University. Botany was taught as a stand-alone subject at the University until 1999, when it was merged with the Department of Zoology. Since that time, the trust has not been applied to its original purposes. The University applied for an order that the purposes of the trust be altered to allow the income to be applied to the advancement of science, more generally. The court found that the purposes of the trust had ceased to be charitable purposes, or had ceased to provide a suitable and effective method of using the trust property. The court also found that it was not reasonably practicable to apply the trust property in accordance with the original purposes. The court approved the application for the trust’s purposes to be altered. The court made orders declaring that the purposes of the trust are altered to allow the income of the trust to be applied to the advancement of science, more generally.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

The University of Adelaide (“the University”) applied for certain declarations and orders in respect of the Maurice Holtze Trust (“the Trust”). The application is granted. These are the reasons for allowing the application.Background By her will dated 31 October 1979 Mrs Kathleen Isobel Bates gifted a pecuniary legacy to the University. The exact terms were as follows:[1]AS TO a pecuniary legacy of SEVENTY-FIVE THOUSAND DOLLARS ($75,000) to the UNIVERSITY OF ADELAIDE for the establishment of a fund for research into botany to be known as the MAURICE HOLTZE FUND to the intent that the income of such fund shall be used as the Chairman of the Department of Botany of that University shall from time to time determine AND I DECLARE that the receipt of the Registrar Bursar or other authorised officer for the time being of the said Institution shall be a good and sufficient discharge to my Trustees for the said legacy.[1] Affidavit of Marc Davies filed 9 September 2022, FDN3, at [6]. The gift in the will created a charitable trust. A gift for scientific research falls within the charitable pursuit of the advancement of education.[2] The University is the trustee of the Trust. [2] Taylor v Taylor (1910) 10 CLR 218. The evidence discloses that Dr Maurice Holtze was the grandfather of the testator. He was born in Hanover in 1840 and died in Adelaide in 1923. He was for 25 years the Director of the Adelaide Botanic Gardens. Prior to that he had been the curator of the Port Darwin Botanic Garden for nearly 20 years. Records disclose that, during the period that Dr Holtze was the Director of the Botanic Gardens, that organisation had a close relationship with the University’s Department of Botany. The testator died in 1982. At that time the University had a Department of Botany and taught botany as a stand-alone subject. There was at that time a Chairman of the Department of Botany. The University’s Finance Committee held a meeting on 28 May 1982. It recommended the acceptance of the bequest. A cheque was provided to the University’s bursar under cover of a letter dated 5 July 1983. The monies were invested in the University’s composite fund. By letter dated 11 October 1983 the University’s bursar wrote to the executor’s solicitors advising that an account entitled “Maurice Holtze Fund” had been established in the books of the University. Further, that the income earned on the principal would be made available expenditure on the recommendation of the Chairman of the Department of Botany. In or about 1999 the University’s Department of Botany and the University’s Department of Zoology merged, to become the Department of Environmental Biology. Accordingly, both the Department of Botany and the position of Chairman of the Department of Botany ceased to exist. This application is necessary because the University no longer has a Department of Botany, botany is no longer taught as a stand-alone subject and the position of Chairman of the Department of Botany no longer exists.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The application is made on two bases. The first is pursuant to the Court’s inherent jurisdiction in respect of the administration of charitable trusts. The second basis is statutory. The applicant relies on the following section of the Trustee Act 1936:69B—Alteration of purposes of charitable trust(aa1) Subject to subsection (1), the purposes for which property is required or permitted to be applied in pursuance of a charitable trust may be altered by a scheme approved under this section.(a1) The powers of the trustees of a charitable trust in respect of which a trust variation scheme under this section may be approved by the Attorney-General (on account of the operation of subsection (3)(b)) to manage or administer the trust may be altered by a scheme approved under this section.(1) The purposes for which property is required or permitted to be applied in pursuance of a charitable trust may be altered by a trust variation scheme in any of the following circumstances:(a) where the original purposes, in whole or in part—(i) have been as far as possible fulfilled; or(ii) cannot be carried out, or not according to the directions given and to the spirit of the gift; or(b) where the original purposes provide a use for part only of the trust property; or(c) where the trust property could be more effectively used if combined with other property applicable for similar purposes and administered jointly with that property; or(d) where it is not reasonably practicable having regard to—(i) the value of the trust property; or (ii) changes in circumstances that have taken place since the constitution of the trust; or(iii) any other relevant factor, to apply the trust property in accordance with the original purposes; or(e) where the original purposes, in whole or in part—(i) have been adequately provided for by other means; or(ii) have ceased to be charitable purposes; or(iii) have ceased to provide a suitable and effective method of using the trust property.(2) References in this section to the original purposes of a charitable trust shall be construed, where the purposes for which the trust property is required or permitted to be applied have been altered or regulated by a scheme or otherwise, as referring to the purposes for which the property is for the time being required or permitted to be applied.(3) A trust variation scheme may be approved, on the application of the trustee, by—(a) the Supreme Court; or(b) if the value of the trust property does not exceed $300 000 or another limit prescribed by regulation—the Attorney-General.(3a) The authority to which the application is made (ie the Supreme Court or the Attorney-General) is referred to in this section as the relevant authority.(4) However, the Attorney-General has a discretion to refer an application to the Supreme Court if the application raises questions that should, in the Attorney-General's opinion, be decided by the Court.(5) Notice of an application for approval of a trust variation scheme must be given as the relevant authority directs.(6) If the relevant authority is satisfied, on application under this section, that the variation of the terms of a trust proposed in a trust variation scheme—(a) accords, as far as reasonably practicable, with the spirit of the trust; and(b) is justified in the circumstances of the particular case, the relevant authority may approve the trust variation scheme and the approved scheme prevails over inconsistent provisions of a relevant instrument or declaration of trust.(7) The reasonable costs of an application under this section are payable at the direction of the relevant authority from the trust property.(8) In the case of an application decided by the Attorney-General, the costs—(a) are to be fixed by the Attorney-General; and(b) may include costs payable to the Crown to defray the cost of investigating and deciding the application; and(c) may be recovered as a debt.(9) The Attorney-General must keep available for public inspection a register of approvals given by the Attorney-General under this section.(10) In this section—trust variation scheme means a scheme approved under this section for the alteration of a charitable trust.