Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd v Hambrook (No. 2)

Link copied
Case Copied 23 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd v Hambrook (No. 2)

Citation:

[2020] ACTSC 293

Hearing Dates:

9 and 14 October 2020

DecisionDate:

Reasons Date:

22 October 2020

26 October 2020

Before:

McWilliam AsJ

Decision:

1.    The subpoenas issued to MGI JOYCE!DICKSON Pty Ltd (ACN 615 645 200), Realist8 Agent Services Pty Ltd (ACN 606 662 408), and Jamie McDonell Real Estate Pty Ltd (ACN 154 243 955) are set aside.

2.    Costs of the application are reserved.

Catchwords:

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – SUBPOENAS – Application to set aside subpoenas issued to the plaintiff’s accountant and corporate entities with a director in common with the plaintiff – whether the subpoenas seek documents beyond the relevant scope of the proceedings – whether legitimate forensic purpose – whether apparent or adjectival relevance

Legislation Cited:

Corporations Act 2002 (Cth) ss 233, 237, 241, 242

Court Procedure Rules 2006 (ACT) r 6604

Cases Cited:

A Pty Ltd v Z [2007] NSWSC 999
Alister v R (1984) 154 CLR 404
Commissioner for Railways v Small (1938) 38 SR (NSW) 564
Elmaraazey v Capital Lawyers Pty Ltd [2016] ACTSC 54
Foyster v Foyster Holdings [2003] NSWSC 881
Jones v University of Canberra (No 3) [2016] ACTSC 186
Lucas Industries Ltd v Hewitt (1978) 18 ALR 555
Portal Software v Bodsworth [2005] NSWSC 1115
Re North Coast Transit Pty Limited [2013] NSWSC 1912
Ryan v Commercial and Residential Developments (SA) Pty Ltd [2013] FCA 656
Spencer Motors Pty Ltd v LNC Industries Ltd [1982] 2 NSWLR 921
Trade Practices Commission v Arnotts Ltd (1989) 88 ALR 90
Zaki Property Pty Ltd v ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 976

Parties:

Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd (ACN 600 193 762) (Plaintiff)

Richard James Hambrook (Defendant)

Representation:

Counsel

Mr D Robens (Plaintiff)

Mr J Masters (Defendant)

Solicitors

Harrington Hall Lawyers

O’Connor Harris & Co

File Number:

SC 502 of 2017

McWilliam AsJ:

  1. The parties to the interlocutory application concerning subpoenas presently before the Court are involved in litigation which is listed for a five-day hearing to commence on 26 October 2020. 

  1. The plaintiff, Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd (ACN 600 193 762) (Instyle), is a company involved in marketing and selling residential real estate, in particular for apartment developments in the Territory. 

  1. The defendant, Mr Richard Hambrook, was a director of Instyle from 18 June 2014 (when the company was registered) to 11 September 2017, when he was removed by way of a company resolution.  The current directors of Instyle are Mr Jaime Farrelly and Mr Jamie McDonell.   Before Mr Hambrook was removed as a director, and save for a period from 17 February 2015 until 15 January 2016, Mr Hambrook was the sole director of Instyle.  He remains a current shareholder.

The substantive proceedings

  1. There are two proceedings listed for hearing together.  In the first (SC 502 of 2017), Instyle is suing Mr Hambrook to recover monies it says Mr Hambrook improperly paid…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd v Hambrook (No. 2) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACTSC 293
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd v Hambrook (No. 2), the plaintiff, Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd, sought to set aside subpoenas issued to its accountant and other corporate entities that shared a director with Instyle. These subpoenas had been issued as part of the proceedings brought by Instyle against Mr Hambrook, who had been a director of the company. Instyle was suing Mr Hambrook to recover monies that it alleged were improperly paid to him during his tenure as a director. The proceedings also involved complex corporate relationships, including a counter-claim by Mr Hambrook for commission and other entitlements, as well as separate proceedings for relief from oppression.

The legal issues before the court centred on whether the subpoenas were beyond the relevant scope of the proceedings, and whether they served a legitimate forensic purpose. The subpoenas sought documents from the plaintiff's accountant and other entities that shared a director with Instyle. The court had to determine whether these subpoenas sought documents that were relevant to the matters at hand and whether they served a legitimate purpose in the context of the proceedings. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the subpoenas had apparent or adjectival relevance to the case.

The court found that the subpoenas in question sought documents that were beyond the relevant scope of the proceedings. The subpoenas did not serve a legitimate forensic purpose and did not have apparent or adjectival relevance to the issues in dispute. As such, the subpoenas were set aside. The costs of the application were reserved for later determination. This decision highlights the importance of ensuring that subpoenas are narrowly tailored to the issues in the proceedings and serve a legitimate purpose.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The subpoenas issued to MGI JOYCE!DICKSON Pty Ltd (ACN 615 645 200), Realist8 Agent Services Pty Ltd (ACN 606 662 408), and Jamie McDonell Real Estate Pty Ltd (ACN 154 243 955) are set aside.

2. Costs of the application are reserved.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

There are two proceedings listed for hearing together. In the first (SC 502 of 2017), Instyle is suing Mr Hambrook to recover monies it says Mr Hambrook improperly paid to himself when he was a director, over the period between 2 July 2015 and 11 September 2017. The claim is brought in equity for breach of fiduciary duty and under the Corporations Act 2002 (Cth) (the Corporations Act) for breach of director’s duties. Instyle is seeking statutory compensation or equitable remedies in the alternative In defence of the claim, Mr Hambrook admits that he caused Instyle to make certain payments to him but denies that any of the payments were improper. Further, Mr Hambrook counter-claims, by way of set-off, the payment of commission to which he says he was contractually entitled. The claimed commission relates to three developments for which contracts had been exchanged prior to Mr Hambrook’s termination as director, described in the pleading as sales in the following developments: As at the date of Mr Hambrook’s termination, Mr Hambrook had not been paid the commission to which he says he is lawfully entitled, and it has not been paid since. Mr Hambrook further seeks employment entitlements such as payment in lieu of notice, and severance pay. Separate proceedings (SC 303 of 2018) have been commenced by Mr Hambrook against Instyle. In those proceedings, and pursuant to s 233 of the Corporations Act, Mr Hambrook seeks relief from oppression in his capacity as a minority shareholder of Instyle. He alleges that Instyle was entitled to the payment of commissions totalling approximately $680,000 in each of the three developments referred to in the counter-claim and above (at [5]). The companies involved in the developments said to give rise to the payment of commission are: If 3 Property Group and Lifestyle Homes paid Instyle the commission Mr Hambrook asserts should have been paid, that would in turn have allowed the payment of a significant dividend to Instyle’s shareholders. Besides Mr Hambrook, the shareholders of Instyle are: In order to better understand the detail of the underlying dispute giving rise to the subpoenas, it is also important to note that Stormer and KFT are significant shareholders in 3 Property Group. As a consequence, Mr Farrelly and Mr Kelly are effectively the main shareholders in 3 Property Group. Mr Farrelly is its director. With regard to Lifestyle Homes, KFT is its sole shareholder and Mr Kelly is its sole director. At a practical level then, while Mr Hambrook would benefit significantly from 3 Property Group and Lifestyle Homes paying commission to Instyle (assuming a dividend was then paid to Instyle’s shareholders), Mr Farrelly and Mr Kelly would not benefit, as the said companies would effectively be paying themselves and otherwise diluting their funds in paying Mr Hambrook and JMRE. The primary relief sought by Mr Hambrook, in what I will describe as the oppression suit, is that pursuant to s 233(j) of the Corporations Act, the present directors of Instyle be required to use their best endeavours to call in the payment of the outstanding commissions to Instyle. If that does not occur, Mr Hambrook seeks: