R v Young

Link copied
Case Copied 4 min read

SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:  R v Young
Citation:  [2020] ACTSC 356
Hearing Dates:  11 December 2020
Decision Date:  11 December 2020
Before:  McWilliam AsJ
Decision:  See [11]
Catchwords:  CRIMINAL LAW – SUPOENAS – Whether legitimate forensic
purpose

Cases Cited: 

Elmaraazey v Capital Lawyers Pty Ltd [2016] ACTSC 54 Gloucester Shire Council v Fitch Ratings [2016] FCA 587 Instyle Estate Agents Gungahlin Pty Ltd v Hambrook [2020]

ACTSC 293
Parties:  The Queen (Applicant)
Megan Young (Respondent)
ACT Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Interested
Party)
Representation:  Counsel
B Hamack (Applicant)
K Ginges (Respondent)
P Dixon (Interested Party)
Solicitors
ACT Government Solicitor (Applicant)
McKenna Taylor (Respondent)
ACT Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions (Interested
Party)
File Number:  SCC 228 of 2020
 McWilliam AsJ: 
2. The subpoena was issued to the Proper Officer, Information Access Team, Prosecution Support at the AFP. The schedule to the subpoena contains the following:

1.       By application in a proceeding filed 24 November 2020, the applicant, being the Chief Police Officer for the Australian Federal Police (AFP), has sought to set aside a subpoena issued on 26 October 2020 in proceedings SCC 228 of 2020.

The subpoena

(a)

Copies of all notes, records, reports, statements, complaints, memoranda, alerts, PROMIS entries, correspondence, or other documents, whether physical or electronic (including audio), referring to the supply or trafficking of amphetamines from 15 Crozier Circuit, Kambah in the Australian Capital Territory in the period 27 March 2019 to 27 March 2020.

(b)

Copies of all notes, records, reports, statements, complaints, memoranda, alerts, PROMIS entries, correspondence, or other documents, whether physical or electronic (including audio), referring to location of stolen gas bottles at 15 Crozier Circuit, Kambah in the Australian Capital Territory in the period December 2019 to 27 March 2020.

(c)

Copies of the affidavit and or other written material relied upon by Police in applying for the search warrant for search of a premises (15 Crozier Circuit, Kambah in the Australian Capital Territory) issued by the Deputy Registrar of the Supreme Court on 27 March 2020, pursuant to section 194 of the Crimes Act 1914 (Cth), limited to references to the supply/trafficking of amphetamines or the possession of stolen gas bottles.

The issue

3.       The only basis argued on the application to set aside the subpoena is that there is no legitimate forensic purpose.

Applicable legal principles

4.       The parties are agreed as to the relevant test. It has been helpfully and succinctly encapsulated in the judgment of Wigney J in the Federal Court of Australia, Gloucester Shire Council v Fitch Ratings [2016] FCA 587 at [22]. Although that is not a decision of this Court, more recent statements in this jurisdiction in relation to applications to set aside subpoenas on the basis of a lack of forensic purpose have in various ways

referred to the authorities cited in that paragraph of Wigney J’s judgment: see, for

example, Elmaraazey v Capital Lawyers Pty Ltd [2016] ACTSC 54 at [44]-[47]; Instyle
Estate…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read R v Young and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] ACTSC 356
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of R v Young, the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory was asked to determine whether a subpoena issued by Megan Young, the respondent, should be set aside. The subpoena sought various documents related to a search warrant issued for a property at 15 Crozier Circuit, Kambah, in the Australian Capital Territory. The applicant, the Chief Police Officer for the Australian Federal Police (AFP), argued that the subpoena should be set aside because there was no legitimate forensic purpose for the requested documents. The ACT Office of the Director of Public Prosecutions was also an interested party in the proceedings.

The central legal issue before the court was whether the subpoena had a legitimate forensic purpose. The court had to decide whether the documents sought were necessary for the respondent to effectively challenge the validity of the search warrant. The test for determining the legitimacy of a forensic purpose was established in previous cases, including Gloucester Shire Council v Fitch Ratings and Elmaraazey v Capital Lawyers Pty Ltd.

The court found that the respondent was entitled to seek the documents to test the evidence supporting the search warrant. The court reasoned that the documents could provide insight into whether the police had a reasonable belief when they applied for the warrant, which was a critical factor in its validity. The court concluded that the respondent's desire to challenge the warrant was not speculative, and the documents could materially assist in that challenge. Therefore, the court declined to set aside the subpoena.

The court's final order was that the application to set aside the subpoena was dismissed. The respondent could proceed with her subpoena to obtain the requested documents, which would help her challenge the validity of the search warrant. The court's decision recognised the respondent's right to seek relevant evidence to support her legal arguments.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case of R v Young concerns a subpoena issued by the respondent, Megan Young, to the Australian Federal Police (AFP) seeking various documents related to an investigation into the supply or trafficking of amphetamines and the location of stolen gas bottles at a specific address in Kambah, Australian Capital Territory, between 27 March 2019 and 27 March 2020. The subpoena also sought the affidavit and other written materials that the police relied upon in applying for a search warrant for the premises in question. The subpoena was issued in the context of proceedings where Ms. Young was a party, and the AFP sought to have the subpoena set aside, arguing that it lacked a legitimate forensic purpose.

The subpoena aimed to gather documents that would assist Ms. Young in challenging the validity of the search warrant issued for the premises at 15 Crozier Circuit, Kambah. Ms. Young's counsel, Mr. Ginges, argued that the documents were necessary to establish whether the police had a reasonable belief when they applied for the warrant. Without the full context of the documents, Ms. Young contended that it would be challenging to effectively argue that the warrant was not validly issued. Conversely, Mr. Hamack, representing the AFP, argued that the existing material already justified a reasonable belief and that Ms. Young's request was speculative.

The Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory, presided over by McWilliam AsJ, considered the arguments presented. The Court noted that while the material already disclosed to Ms. Young might justify the warrant, the issue of whether the belief was reasonable was not fully resolved. The Court emphasised that the subpoena's purpose went beyond mere speculation or fishing expeditions, as Ms. Young was entitled to test the evidence that formed the basis of the warrant. The Court held that the documents sought through the subpoena could materially assist Ms. Young in arguing the validity of the warrant and, therefore, declined to set aside the subpoena. The application to set aside the subpoena was dismissed.

This case, R v Young, came before the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory on 11 December 2020 before McWilliam AsJ. The matter arose from an application filed on 24 November 2020 by the Chief Police Officer for the Australian Federal Police (AFP), seeking to set aside a subpoena issued on 26 October 2020 in proceedings SCC 228 of 2020. The subpoena sought various documents relating to the supply or trafficking of amphetamines and the location of stolen gas bottles, as well as materials relied upon by the police in applying for a search warrant. The primary argument presented was that there was no legitimate forensic purpose for the subpoena, a contention which was opposed by counsel for the respondent, Megan Young, who argued that the documents sought were relevant to challenging the validity of the search warrant. McWilliam AsJ ultimately found that the documents sought would materially assist in agitating the argument regarding the warrant's validity, thereby declining to set aside the subpoena.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is there a legitimate forensic purpose for the subpoena issued by the respondent, Megan Young, to the Australian Federal Police (AFP)?
2. Does the material sought by the subpoena materially assist the respondent in agitating the argument about the validity of the search warrant?
3. Should the subpoena be set aside on the basis that there is no legitimate forensic purpose?
4. Can the respondent rely on the documents sought in the subpoena to challenge the validity of the warrant on the basis that the officers involved did not have a reasonable belief for obtaining the warrant?
5. Does the respondent have the right to test the evidence disclosed by the AFP as founding the warrant through the subpoena?
6. Does the evidence on the application take the basis for the subpoena beyond mere speculation or fishing?

Held
1. The court concluded that there is a legitimate forensic purpose for the subpoena issued by the respondent, Megan Young, to the Australian Federal Police (AFP). As a result, the application to set aside the subpoena was dismissed.
2. The court found that the material sought by the subpoena materially assists the respondent in agitating the argument about the validity of the search warrant.
3. The court decided that the subpoena should not be set aside on the basis that there is no legitimate forensic purpose.
4. The court ruled that the respondent can rely on the documents sought in the subpoena to challenge the validity of the warrant on the basis that the officers involved did not have a reasonable belief for obtaining the warrant.
5. The court held that the respondent has the right to test the evidence disclosed by the AFP as founding the warrant through the subpoena.
6. The court determined that the evidence on the application takes the basis for the subpoena beyond mere speculation or fishing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In the case of R v Young, the primary issue addressed by the Supreme Court of the Australian Capital Territory was whether the subpoena issued by the respondent, Megan Young, to the Australian Federal Police (AFP) had a legitimate forensic purpose. The court considered this issue against the backdrop of the validity of the search warrant executed at the premises located at 15 Crozier Circuit, Kambah. The court's reasoning began with an examination of the legal principles governing subpoenas and the requirement for a legitimate forensic purpose. The court referred to established authority, such as Gloucester Shire Council v Fitch Ratings [2016] FCA 587, and noted that the test for a legitimate forensic purpose was whether the sought material would materially assist the party in agitating a particular argument. The court underscored that the test does not require the material to justify the argument but merely to assist in agitating it.

The respondent, Megan Young, argued that the documents sought by the subpoena were necessary to challenge the validity of the search warrant, specifically to argue that the officers involved lacked a reasonable belief for obtaining the warrant. Counsel for the respondent contended that the absence of certain evidence could support the argument that the warrant was not based on reasonable grounds. In contrast, counsel for the AFP argued that the material already disclosed sufficiently supported the warrant and that the subpoena was speculative. The court distinguished the current application from a determination of the warrant's ultimate justification, focusing instead on whether the subpoena served a legitimate forensic purpose.

The court held that the respondent was entitled to test the evidence disclosed by the AFP as the foundation for the warrant. The respondent's argument that the documents sought would materially assist in agitating the issue about the warrant's validity was deemed valid, provided that it went beyond mere speculation. The court found that the respondent's request was sufficiently grounded in the evidence already available to the court, thus satisfying the test for a legitimate forensic purpose. Consequently, the court declined to set aside the subpoena.

In reaching its decision, the court emphasized that the application did not require it to determine the merits of the warrant's validity or the reasonableness of the belief held by the officers. Instead, the court's role was limited to assessing whether the subpoena's basis transcended mere speculation and had a legitimate forensic purpose. The court concluded that the evidence on the application substantiated the respondent's claim that the subpoenaed material would materially assist in agitating the argument about the warrant's validity.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a subpoena can be issued to test the evidence supporting a search warrant's validity if it materially assists in agitating the argument about the warrant's legitimacy, provided it does not amount to mere speculation or fishing. The court did not depart from prior authority but reaffirmed the established test for legitimate forensic purpose, ensuring that the subpoena in question met the necessary criteria.