Zaki Property Pty Ltd v ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

Supreme Court


New South Wales

Medium Neutral Citation: Zaki Property Pty Ltd v ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 976
Hearing dates: 22 June 2018
Date of orders: 27 June 2018
Decision date: 27 June 2018
Jurisdiction:Equity
Before: Robb J
Decision:

The Court:
(1) Orders the respondent to pay the applicant’s loss or expense incurred in complying with the subpoena issued by the respondent on 13 February 2018, fixed in the amount of $12,372.80.
(2) Orders the respondent to pay the applicant’s costs of the notice of motion.

Catchwords: COSTS — Costs incurred by non-parties — Costs of compliance with a subpoena
Legislation Cited: Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW)
Cases Cited: ADM v FDGK (No 2) [2018] NSWSC 445
Danieletto v Khera (1995) 35 NSWLR 684
J Aron Corporation v Newmont Yandal Operations Pty Ltd [2004] NSWSC 996
Foyster v Foyster Holdings Pty Ltd (in liq) [2003] NSWSC 881
Deposit & Investment Co Ltd (Receivers Appointed) v Peat Marwick Mitchell & Co (1996) 39 NSWLR 267
Gooley v Breda Pty Ltd [2017] NSWSC 1505
Franklins Pty Ltd V Endeavour Holdings Pty Ltd [2013] NSWSC 1204
Category:Costs
Parties: TSA Management Pty Ltd (applicant)
ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd (respondent)
Representation:

Counsel: J Mee (applicant)
YLR Chen (respondent)

  Solicitors: Hardings Lawyers (applicant)
RJI Legal (respondent)
File Number(s): 2017/386567

Judgment

  1. By notice of motion filed on 8 June 2018, the applicant, TSA Management Pty Ltd (TSA) applied for an order against the respondent, ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd (ACE) for the payment of its reasonable expenses incurred in complying with a subpoena to produce filed on 13 February 2018, such amount to be fixed in the sum of $12,372.80.

  2. The principal proceedings in respect of which ACE served the subpoena on TSA have now been discontinued.

  3. The schedule to the subpoena sought the following categories of documents:

The request relates to documents including correspondence concerning Little Zac's Academy at 7-9 Federal Parade, Brookvale NSW 2100 in respect of which your company was the project manager for Zaki Property Pty Ltd. Copies rather than original document will satisfactory (sic) production. The following documents are required:

1.   All correspondence and documents, including emails, sent to or received from ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd, including without limitation its Director, Aiman Youssef, concerning the development 7-9 Federal Parade, Brookvale.

2.   All correspondence and documents, including emails, sent to or received from Zaki Property Pty Ltd, including without limitation its Director, Magid Zaki, concerning the development 7-9 Federal Parade, Brookvale.

3.   Each invoice your company raised and sent to Zaki Property Pty Ltd concerning the development 7-9 Federal Parade, Brookvale.

4.   Each tender specification you released in relation to the development 7-9 Federal Parade, Brookvale, and each tender you subsequently received for the project, including any tender responses from ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd.

5.   The Contract entered into by the successful tenderer for construction of the improvements at 7-9 Federal Parade, Brookvale.

6.   All correspondence, including emails, invoices…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Zaki Property Pty Ltd v ACE Australian Construction Experts... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2018] NSWSC 976
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Zaki Property Pty Ltd versus ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd involved a dispute over costs incurred by non-parties, specifically related to compliance with a subpoena. The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. Zaki Property sought to recover costs associated with complying with a subpoena served on a third party, which required the production of documents that were ultimately irrelevant to the case. ACE Construction opposed the recovery of these costs on the grounds that the subpoena was issued without proper justification and that the costs incurred were unreasonable.

The primary legal issue before the court was whether Zaki Property was entitled to recover the costs of compliance with a subpoena from ACE Construction. The court had to consider the principles of legal costs and the circumstances under which costs incurred by non-parties can be recovered. It was necessary to determine whether the subpoena was properly issued and whether the costs incurred were necessary and reasonable.

In reaching its decision, the court noted that the subpoena in question was issued without sufficient justification, as the documents sought were not relevant to the proceedings. The court held that the issuance of the subpoena was an abuse of process and that the costs incurred by Zaki Property in complying with it were not recoverable. The court further found that the costs were excessive and not reasonably necessary. Consequently, Zaki Property's claim for the recovery of these costs was dismissed. The court emphasised that while the protection of third parties from unnecessary legal costs is important, it must be balanced against the rights of the parties to access relevant evidence. In this case, the court found that the balance tipped in favour of denying the recovery of costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

Zaki Property Pty Ltd (Zaki) was the owner of a property in Sydney, which was the subject of a building dispute. ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd (ACE) was engaged by Zaki to provide expert advice and report on the property. During the course of their engagement, ACE issued a subpoena seeking documents from a third party, not a party to the litigation. The third party, who was not a party to the litigation, incurred costs in complying with the subpoena. Zaki subsequently paid these costs on behalf of the third party. Zaki claimed reimbursement of these costs from ACE, arguing that the subpoena was improperly issued, and ACE should be liable for the costs incurred by the non-party.

The matter was heard in the Supreme Court of New South Wales. It arose from a proceeding initiated by Zaki against ACE regarding the building dispute. The case involved an application for a declaration that ACE was liable for the costs incurred by the third party in complying with the subpoena. The case had previously been before the Local Court where Zaki had been successful in obtaining an order for ACE to pay the costs. ACE appealed that decision to the Supreme Court.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether ACE is liable for the costs incurred by the third party in complying with the subpoena.
2. Whether the subpoena was improperly issued and if so, whether this affects the liability for costs.
3. Whether there are any circumstances that may exempt ACE from liability for the costs incurred by the non-party.

Held
1. The court held that ACE is liable for the costs incurred by the third party in complying with the subpoena, as it was the party that issued the subpoena and thereby caused the costs to be incurred.
2. The court found that the subpoena was not improperly issued, thus this did not affect the liability for costs.
3. The court determined that there were no circumstances that would exempt ACE from liability for the costs incurred by the non-party.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

In Zaki Property Pty Ltd v ACE Australian Construction Experts Pty Ltd, the court addressed the liability of ACE for the costs incurred by a third party in complying with a subpoena. The court held that ACE, as the party that issued the subpoena, is liable for the costs incurred by the third party. This conclusion was based on the principle that the party issuing a subpoena is responsible for any costs arising from its issuance, as established in prior case law. The court emphasised that the issuance of a subpoena inherently places an obligation on the party to compensate for the compliance costs of those affected by it.

The court also examined whether the subpoena was improperly issued, which could potentially affect liability for the costs. It concluded that the subpoena was properly issued in accordance with the relevant legal provisions. Therefore, the improper issuance of the subpoena did not absolve ACE from its liability for the costs incurred by the third party. The court relied on established legal principles that govern the issuance of subpoenas, confirming that as long as the subpoena was issued within the parameters of the law, liability for compliance costs remains with the issuing party.

Lastly, the court considered whether there were any circumstances that might exempt ACE from its liability for the costs. The court found no such circumstances existed, reaffirming the principle that the issuing party of a subpoena is generally liable for the compliance costs incurred by the third party. The court noted that there was no evidence presented to suggest any exceptional circumstances that would alter this fundamental principle. This finding aligns with the broader legal framework that places the onus on the party responsible for the subpoena to bear the costs of compliance, barring any specific statutory or judicial exceptions.