SUPREME COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY
Case Title: | Jones v University of Canberra (No 3) |
Citation: | [2016] ACTSC 186 |
Hearing Dates: | 5 July 2015 |
DecisionDate: | 5 July 2016 |
Reasons Date: Before: | 27 July 2016 Refshauge J |
Decision: | 1. The strike out applications be listed for hearing on 1 and 2 August 2016 at 10:00am. 2. Leave is granted to the plaintiff to file (in a sealed envelope) and serve a document entitled ‘Provisional Further Amended Statement of Claim’ on or before 15 July 2016. 3. It is directed that the document referred to in Order 2 not be made accessible other than to parties to the proceedings and their legal representatives. 4. The defendants are not required to file any defence until further order. 5. The application by the plaintiff for orders under s 111 of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2011 (ACT) dated 12 May 2016, filed on 13 May 2016, be dismissed with no order as to costs. 6. If the plaintiff, upon review of the orders, is of the opinion that he is inhibited from showing the affidavits of Mr Walshe and Mr Lamont to any person from whom he wishes to obtain an affidavit for use in the strike out proceedings, he may apply to his Honour, on notice to the other parties, to make orders in chambers granting access to any such document by such prospective witnesses, unless any party, having been given that notice, objects. 7. That the plaintiff have leave, in so far as such leave is necessary, and be directed to serve any Notice to Produce he wishes to issue under r 6748 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) to any active party in accordance with the following conditions: a. That the Notice be limited to requiring production of any document that is relevant to the proof of an allegation in any pleading or any facts alleged in any affidavit filed in support of the applications by the defendants to strike out the Statement of Claim; b. A draft of the Notice be circulated by the plaintiff to each active defendant no later than 15 July 2016, inviting any comment as to the width or content of the documents sought to be produced by the Notice; c. The Notice be served on or before 20 July 2016, returnable on 27 July 2016; d. If any defendant applies to strike out the Notice to Produce, that application be filed on or before 26 July 2016 and returnable 1 August 2016 and, upon filing, that defendant is relieved of any obligation to produce any such document referred to in the Notice to Produce until 1 August 2016. 8. The subpoenas lodged on 4 April 2016 need not be answered until further order. 9. The plaintiff, on or before 15 July 2016, file and serve an affidavit setting out any facts on which he proposes to rely to assert that the privilege otherwise attaching to any allegations made in the Provisional Further… |
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Jones v University of Canberra (No 3) and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2016] ACTSC 186
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court meticulously addressed each issue, beginning with the plaintiff's request to file a Provisional Further Amended Statement of Claim. The court granted leave for this document to be filed and served under conditions to ensure that it remained confidential until the privilege claims were resolved. The court also directed that the document be sealed and accessible only to the parties and their legal representatives. The court dismissed the plaintiff’s application for orders under s 111 of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2011 (ACT) without awarding costs. Regarding the recusal of a judge, the court found that it was appropriate to recuse a judge who knew a witness due to potential issues with the witness's credibility.
In terms of non-publication orders, the court clarified that these orders did not preclude the inspection of documents on the court file or the preparation of a case using such information. However, it emphasised that confidential statements could not be provided to potential witnesses without appropriate orders. The court also ruled on the principles governing particulars in pleadings, stating that while the plaintiff was required to provide the best particulars possible, they were not obligated to provide names of witnesses unless absolutely necessary. The court further instructed the plaintiff to particularise and quantify any claims for financial compensation related to the termination of contracts.
The court’s reasoning was grounded in ensuring fairness and efficiency in the proceedings, balancing the need for procedural flexibility with the necessity of maintaining the integrity of the litigation process. It provided detailed directions for the filing and service of further amended pleadings, affidavits, and particulars, ensuring that the case could proceed in an orderly fashion. The court also set specific timelines for various applications and responses, aiming to streamline the process and avoid unnecessary delays.
In conclusion, the court issued a series of orders that not only addressed the immediate procedural challenges but also laid out a clear roadmap for the ongoing litigation. The orders included provisions for the filing of further amended pleadings, the handling of privilege claims, the recusal of a judge, and the provision of further particulars. The court reserved costs for the application for further and better particulars, reflecting its intention to manage the litigation in an efficient and fair manner.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The strike out applications be listed for hearing on 1 and 2 August 2016 at 10:00am.
2. Leave is granted to the plaintiff to file (in a sealed envelope) and serve a document entitled ‘Provisional Further Amended Statement of Claim’ on or before 15 July 2016.
3. It is directed that the document referred to in Order 2 not be made accessible other than to parties to the proceedings and their legal representatives.
4. The defendants are not required to file any defence until further order.
5. The application by the plaintiff for orders under s 111 of the Evidence (Miscellaneous Provisions) Act 2011 (ACT) dated 12 May 2016, filed on 13 May 2016, be dismissed with no order as to costs.
6. If the plaintiff, upon review of the orders, is of the opinion that he is inhibited from showing the affidavits of Mr Walshe and Mr Lamont to any person from whom he wishes to obtain an affidavit for use in the strike out proceedings, he may apply to his Honour, on notice to the other parties, to make orders in chambers granting access to any such document by such prospective witnesses, unless any party, having been given that notice, objects.
7. That the plaintiff have leave, in so far as such leave is necessary, and be directed to serve any Notice to Produce he wishes to issue under r 6748 of the Court Procedures Rules 2006 (ACT) to any active party in accordance with the following conditions:
a. That the Notice be limited to requiring production of any document that is relevant to the proof of an allegation in any pleading or any facts alleged in any affidavit filed in support of the applications by the defendants to strike out the Statement of Claim;
b. A draft of the Notice be circulated by the plaintiff to each active defendant no later than 15 July 2016, inviting any comment as to the width or content of the documents sought to be produced by the Notice;
c. The Notice be served on or before 20 July 2016, returnable on 27 July 2016;
d. If any defendant applies to strike out the Notice to Produce, that application be filed on or before 26 July 2016 and returnable 1 August 2016 and, upon filing, that defendant is relieved of any obligation to produce any such document referred to in the Notice to Produce until 1 August 2016.
8. The subpoenas lodged on 4 April 2016 need not be answered until further order.
9. The plaintiff, on or before 15 July 2016, file and serve an affidavit setting out any facts on which he proposes to rely to assert that the privilege otherwise attaching to any allegations made in the Provisional Further Amended Statement of Claim, to be filed that day, has been lost or waived.
10. The plaintiff advise the fourth defendant, on or before 15 July, whether he is required for cross-examination on his affidavit.
11. The defendants have leave to amend their application to strike out the Statement of Claim, on or before 20 July 2016.
12. The defendants have leave to file and serve any affidavits on which he/she/it intends to rely in support of their applications to strike out the Statement of Claim on or before 1:00pm on 25 July 2015.
13. The plaintiff has leave to file and serve any further affidavits in response to any affidavits filed by the defendants on or before 1:00pm on 29 July 2016.
14. The former sixth defendant have leave to appear at the hearing on 1-2 August 2016 if it wishes to attend.
15. As to the request by the fourth defendant of the plaintiff for particulars of the Statement of Claim requested by letter dated 1 June 2016:
(a) In relation to 2.1(a), the plaintiff is not required to provide further names but may do so after discovery.
(b) In relation to 2.1(d), the plaintiff is to make further answer which deletes the word ‘included’;
(c) In relation to 2.1(f) of the letter of 1 June, the plaintiff is not required to provide further particulars;
(d) In relation to 4.1(e) and 4(f), the plaintiff must provide a better answer to explain what is meant by ‘support’;
(e) In relation to 4.1(g), if the pleading is amended, this information will need to be particularised;
(f) In relation to 5.1(c), leave is granted to the fifth defendant to reformulate the request for further and better particulars;
(g) In relation to 5.1(f), leave is granted to the fifth defendant to reformulate the request for further and better particulars;
(h) In relation to 6.1(a), if the plaintiff is seeking financial compensation for the termination of the current or immediately past contract, the loss must be particularised and quantified;
(i) In relation to 6.3, if the plaintiff is seeking financial compensation for the termination of the current/immediately past contract, the loss must be particularised and quantified.
16. The costs of the application for the production of further and better particulars are reserved.
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi