Inquest into the death of Michael Richard Hall

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read

CORONERS COURT OF THE AUSTRALIAN CAPITAL TERRITORY

Case Title:

Inquest into the death of Michael Richard Hall

Citation:

[2019] ACTCD 2

Hearing Dates:

24 to 26 September 2018

DecisionDate:

28 February 2019

Before:

Coroner Boss

Recommendations:

[61]

Legislation Cited:

Australian Road Rules

Coroners Act 1997 (ACT)

Crimes Act 1900 (ACT)

Legislation Act 2001 (ACT)

Road Transport (Road Rules) Regulation 2017 (ACT)

Road Transport (Safety and Traffic Management) Act 1999 (ACT)

Cases Cited:

Director of Public Prosecutions v Spong [2018] ACTCA 37

George v Rockett [1990] HCA 26

The Queen v Coroner Maria Doogan; ex parte Peter Lucas-Smith & Ors; the Queen v Coroner Maria Doogan & Ors; ex parte Australian Capital Territory [2005] ACTSC 74

Parties:

Counsel Assisting the Coroner

The Australian Capital Territory

Dragon Face Pty Ltd

Anna Haslock

Representation:

Mr K Archer as Counsel Assisting the Coroner, instructed by Mr M Kamarul of the ACT Coroner’s Court.

Ms K Musgrove for the Australian Capital Territory, instructed by ACT Government Solicitor.

Ms A Upton for Dragon Face Pty Ltd.

Mr C Lynch for Ms Anna Haslock, instructed by Snedden Hall & Gallop Lawyers.  

Mr J Stewart for Mr Shegu Bobb.

File Number:

CD 80 of 2017

CORONER BOSS: 

Scope of Enquiry

  1. The death of Michael Richard Hall was reported to me, an ACT Coroner, on 31 March 2017. The death was reported to me because Mr Hall died in circumstances engaging the coronial jurisdiction and requiring the coroner to hold an inquest into the death.

  2. The primary legislation regulating my tasks as a Coroner is the Coroners Act 1997 (“the Act”). However, that statute is not a Code and I retain all the powers at common law of a coroner which do not conflict with the provisions of the Act.

  3. I am required by section 52 of the Act to make findings in relation to the manner and cause of death of a person whose death has been reported to me, and whether a matter of public safety is found to arise in connection with the inquest.

  4. It has been a long recognised common law function of coroners to also make comments and recommendations on appropriate matters, and certain provisions of the Act such as section 57 complement that power. That section also provides a process whereby I may report my findings to Government, and the Government may respond via the Legislative Assembly to my report. However, as the ACT Supreme Court said in The Queen v Coroner Maria Doogan; ex parte Peter Lucas-Smith & Ors; the Queen v Coroner Maria Doogan & Ors; ex parte Australian Capital Territory [2005] ACTSC 74 (“The Queen v Maria Doogan”) at [28], I am not authorised “to conduct a wide-ranging inquiry akin to that of a Royal Commission, with a view to exploring any suggestion of a causal link, however tenuous, between some act, omission or circumstance and the cause or non-mitigation” of the death of Mr Hall.

  5. Unlike other Australian jurisdictions, I am not prohibited by statute from…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Inquest into the death of Michael Richard Hall and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] ACTCD 2
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This case concerns an inquest into the death of Michael Richard Hall, held before a coroner in the ACT. The inquest arose from Mr Hall's death following a motor vehicle accident. The coroner had reasonable grounds to believe that Mr Hall's death was caused by an indictable offence, specifically negligent driving causing death. The legal issues before the court were whether the coroner was correct in his belief that Mr Hall's death was caused by an indictable offence, and if so, whether the coroner had correctly applied the relevant sections of the Coroners Act 2007 (ACT) in determining how to proceed with the inquest.

The court found that the coroner had correctly identified that Mr Hall's death was caused by an indictable offence, specifically culpable driving under section 29 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). The court noted that the standard of negligence required to found a successful prosecution under this section was high, as established in Director of Public Prosecutions v Spong. The court also found that the coroner had correctly applied the relevant sections of the Coroners Act in determining how to proceed with the inquest, specifically sections 58 and 58A. The coroner had notified the Director of Public Prosecutions of his belief that an indictable offence had been committed, and had not proceeded with the inquest until the Director of Public Prosecutions had presented an indictment against the accused person.

The court concluded that the coroner had correctly exercised his discretion under the Coroners Act in determining how to proceed with the inquest. The court found that the coroner had not erred in law or in fact in his decision to refer the matter to the Director of Public Prosecutions, and that the inquest should be stayed until such time as the Director of Public Prosecutions had presented an indictment against the accused person. The court also found that the coroner had correctly limited the inquest to establishing only the facts necessary for the Director of Public Prosecutions to present an indictment.

In conclusion, the court upheld the coroner's decision to refer the matter to the Director of Public Prosecutions, and found that the coroner had correctly exercised his discretion under the Coroners Act in determining how to proceed with the inquest. The court stayed the inquest until such time as the Director of Public Prosecutions had presented an indictment against the accused person, and limited the inquest to establishing only the facts necessary for the Director of Public Prosecutions to present an indictment.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 58 of the Act relevantly provides:58 Procedure where evidence of indictable offence or indictment to be presented(1)Subsection (3) applies if, during an inquest or inquiry, a coroner has reasonable grounds for believing that, having regard to the evidence given at the inquest or inquiry, a person mentioned at the inquest or inquiry has committed an indictable offence.(2)For subsection (1), the coroner must have regard to—(a)the admissibility at trial of the evidence given at the inquest or inquiry; and(b)whether the director of public prosecutions, or a person who may be affected by the referral to the director of public prosecutions of evidence relevant to the alleged offence, is, or has been, given the opportunity to present or give evidence in connection with the alleged offence. (3)The coroner—(a)must, by written notice, tell the director of public prosecutions about the coroner’s belief; and(b)for a related indictable offence—must not proceed further with the inquest or inquiry until the day worked out under section 58A, other than to establish the following facts:(i)for an inquest—the death of a person, the person’s identity and the date and place of the person’s death; (ii)for an inquiry—the date and place of a fire or disaster. (4)Subsection (5) applies if, during an inquest or inquiry—(a)the director of public prosecutions, by written notice, tells the coroner holding the inquest or inquiry that an indictment will be presented against a person for a related indictable offence in relation to— (i)the death of a person who is the subject of the inquest; or(ii)the matter the subject of the inquiry; or(b)the Attorney-General presents an indictment against the person for a related indictable offence. (5)The coroner must not proceed further with the inquest or inquiry until the day worked out under section 58A unless the coroner limits the inquest or inquiry to establishing only the facts mentioned in subsection (3) (b) (i) or (ii). (6)A coroner must not continue holding an inquest or inquiry if satisfied that the inquest or inquiry should not be continued. (7)In this section:related indictable offence, in relation to an inquest or inquiry, means an indictable offence that raises the issue of whether a person caused a death, suspected death, fire or disaster the subject of the inquest or inquiry. The Act does not define the meaning of “an indictable offence”. Section 190 of the Legislation Act 2001 (ACT) defines indictable offence as an offence that is punishable by imprisonment for longer than two years. The only offence with a penalty of more than two years that criminalises negligent driving causing death is the offence of culpable driving, created by section 29 of the Crimes Act 1900 (ACT). That section relevantly provides: In Director of Public Prosecutions v Spong [2018] ACTCA 37 the Court of Appeal noted that the standard of negligence required to found a successful prosecution under this section was high.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established