In the matter of Nathan Peter Greenfield

Link copied
Case Copied 49 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:  In the matter of Nathan Peter Greenfield [2017] QMHC 4
PROCEEDING:  Reference
DELIVERED ON:  9 June 2017
DELIVERED AT:  Brisbane
HEARING DATE:  26 September 2016, 5 December 2016, 10 February 2017
JUDGE:  Dalton J
ASSISTING  Dr J Reddan and
PSYCHIATRISTS:  Dr J J Sundin
DETERMINATION: 
1. The defendant was not of unsound mind at the time of

any of the offending.

2.  The defendant may be tried only for manslaughter, not

murder, in relation to the killing of June Danette Wallis.

3. The defendant is fit for trial.

4.  Subject to paragraph 2 above, the criminal matters the

subject of this reference ought to proceed according to
law.

CATCHWORDS: 

MENTAL HEALTH – UNSOUNDNESS OF MIND – INTOXICATION – DIMINISHED RESPONSIBILITY –

SUBSTANTIALLY IMPAIRED
COUNSEL:  J D Briggs on behalf of Mr Greenfield
S J Hamlyn-Harris for the Director of Mental Health
M B Lehane for the Director of Public Prosecutions
SOLICITORS:  Legal Aid Queensland for Mr Greenfield
Crown Law for the Director of Mental Health
The Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)
  1. The matter had a disjointed history in the Court. It was initially set down only for one hour, which time I considered plainly inadequate. It was then set down for another two hours. Unfortunately on that second occasion it was discovered that the reporting and assisting psychiatrists had not been provided with some of the video material. The matter was adjourned again so that submissions could be made and advice taken from the assisting psychiatrists. Part of the difficulties suffered in the matter were, I think, due to the fact that Mr Greenfield engaged a private solicitor who seemed quite inexperienced in Mental Health Court matters, and it was necessary for Legal Aid Queensland to take over the representation of Mr Greenfield after the first hearing date. Another difficulty was that the prosecutor dealing with the matter changed shortly before the hearing and the new prosecutor found that the DPP had not made available all factual material to the Registry and the parties. These difficulties aside, I think there was another matter which compelled the Court to allocate more time to hearing this matter than the time originally provided at the callover. While the reports of the psychiatrists presented a unanimous, or fairly unanimous opinion on most issues, there were underlying complexities in the matter which the unanimous, or near unanimous psychiatric opinion may have disguised to some extent.

    Dr Voita, Report

  2. Dr Voita is Mr Greenfield’s treating psychiatrist. She gave a very detailed report pursuant

    to s 238 of the Mental Health Act 2000 on 22 July 2015. At that stage Mr Greenfield was an in-patient at the High Secure Unit at The Park and had been there since 30 March 2015.

  3. Mr Greenfield was born on 25 April 1980 and at the time of the alleged offences was

    living with his de facto wife and their two children (aged 12 and 14 years). Ms Wallis’s

    father, Paul Wallis, was living in the same…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of Nathan Peter Greenfield and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QMHC 4
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of Nathan Peter Greenfield, the High Court was presented with a case concerning the defendant's mental state and its impact on his criminal responsibility. The dispute centred around whether the defendant's mental health issues, specifically his psychotic delusions and the effects of intoxication, diminished his responsibility for the crime of murder. The primary issue the court had to determine was the extent to which Greenfield's mental condition could be considered in assessing his culpability. This involved evaluating whether his psychotic state was severe enough to diminish his responsibility, particularly given his delusional beliefs about his wife's infidelity and the presence of a perceived threat from Anthony, a correctional officer who was a figment of his imagination.

The court examined evidence from multiple sources, including psychiatric evaluations and witness statements, to understand the severity and nature of Greenfield's mental illness. Dr van de Hoef's testimony highlighted the florid nature of Greenfield's delusions, including his belief that his wife was involved in pornographic activities and his paranoid fears of being targeted by his father-in-law and others. The court also considered the impact of alcohol intoxication on the night of the offence, which further clouded his judgment and potentially exacerbated his delusional thinking. The defence argued that these factors should be taken into account when assessing his criminal responsibility.

The court concluded that while Greenfield suffered from a severe mental illness, the evidence did not sufficiently demonstrate that his mental state at the time of the offence was such that it diminished his responsibility to the extent that it would exclude criminal responsibility. The court found that his actions, driven by delusional beliefs, were still deliberate and premeditated. Consequently, the court ruled that Greenfield was fully responsible for his actions, and his mental health issues, while mitigating factors, did not absolve him of criminal liability. The final orders of the court reflected this determination, upholding the conviction and sentence imposed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As to the future, Dr van de Hoef thought that Mr Greenfield remained a risk to himself and anyone who he took to be the Correctional officer Anthony. I make it clear that there is no evidence that any such person exists. Mr Greenfield needed continued treatment, she thought, in the High Secure Unit. She thought that he was a continuing high risk because of the severity of his illness, the unshakeability of his beliefs and the secrecy with which he had been able to harbour his beliefs prior to the killing. Other Evidence as to Mental State Dr van de Hoef records what Mr Greenfield told the Prison Mental Health Service on 23 March 2015. She notes his assessment as being floridly psychotic with: “… probably psychotic ideas not only of his wife’s infidelity with multiple men (including aboriginals, Anthony the correctional officer, customers of her stable, and police officers) but of her regularly (‘every March’) filming pornographic films with the Gympie police. … along with his seeing her in a film on the computer, and her subsequently hiding the material via the use of ‘modems and filters’.” Dr van de Hoef also gives some extracts from the High Secure records noting that Mr Greenfield expressed a fear that his father-in-law wanted to kill him as revenge and that his wife’s family had “all been in on it” and planned to kill him on the night in question. He is recorded as thinking that his father-in-law was intending to take all his money and property. He drew a picture of his wife with blood streaming from her eyes, In a letter dated 29 November 2016 Dr van de Hoef reviews the numerous witness statements collected by police in relation to this matter. She says that they indicate a number of family members, friends and employees at the bakery noticed worrying changes in Mr Greenfield’s mood and behaviour in the months before the offending, including evidence of intense (delusional) jealousy. Mr Greenfield was verbally abusive and aggressive towards his wife; he threatened to shoot her horses if she left him, and threatened to shoot “the bastard” he believed she was having an affair with. He drove his car at her, braking at the last moment. Several witnesses heard him accuse her of infidelity, increasingly after Christmas 2014, but it must be said as far back as June 2014. A DVO was taken out on 19 February 2015. There was some evidence that Mr Greenfield was following Ms Wallis’s activity on-line and interfering with posts on her Facebook page. His father-in-law, Mr Paul Wallis, told police he thought that Mr Greenfield was mentally ill and had exhorted him to obtain medical help. He was sufficiently worried to have the firearms removed from the house the week before the offending. The police material shows that Mr Greenfield expressed to a number of police officers again and again delusional beliefs in the hours following his arrest. He raised these topics spontaneously, without being asked, an indication in Dr van de Hoef’s view that he was ruminating on these matters.[2] [2] Letter of advice, 10 January 2017. Dispute of Fact?

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established