In the matter of John Bernard Zarnke

Link copied
Case Copied 43 min read

MENTAL HEALTH COURT

CITATION:

In the matter of John Bernard Zarnke [2017] QMHC 5

PROCEEDING:

Reference

DELIVERED ON:

11 July 2017

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATES:

4 and 5 April 2017

JUDGE:

Dalton J

ASSISTING PSYCHIATRISTS:

Dr JG Reddan and
Dr C Gray

CATCHWORDS:

CRIMINAL LAW – INSANITY – UNSOUNDNESS OF MIND – DIMINISHED RESPONSIBILITY

DETERMINATIONS:

1.  In relation to the assault or obstruct police charge, 28 September 2014, I can make no finding as to soundness of mind.

2.  In relation to all other offences before the Court I find that the defendant was not of unsound mind, at the time of the offending.

3.  In relation to the charge of murder, 10 February 2015, the defendant was of diminished responsibility at the time of the offending, and may be tried for manslaughter only, not murder.

4.  The defendant is fit for trial.

5.  With the qualification at paragraph 3 above, all charges are to proceed according to law.

APPEARANCES:

JD Briggs on behalf of Mr Zarnke

J Tate for the Director of Mental Health
D Balic for the Director of Public Prosecutions

SOLICITORS:

Legal Aid Queensland for Mr Zarnke

Crown Law for the Director of Mental Health
The Director of Public Prosecutions (Qld)

  1. Mr Zarnke faces several charges referred to this Court.  The most serious is a charge of murder in relation to the killing of his aunt’s de facto husband, Brett James Bell, on 10 February 2015.  

  2. Before dealing with the substance of this reference I will make the comment that this is another of the increasing number of references this Court sees involving very serious offending which is the result of drug use, and prolonged drug use. In each of these cases the evidence before the Court is to the effect that psychosis is brought about by drug use (both cannabis and amphetamine),[1] and that the effects of long-term drug use (both cannabis and amphetamine) have permanent and irreversible effects on the brain, including effects which can be seen on imaging.[2]  Further, that once a person has suffered psychosis as a result of amphetamine or cannabis use, that psychosis will not necessarily resolve quickly, but may last years;[3] will re-occur, and recur, in the case of amphetamine use, when only very small amounts of amphetamines are consumed,[4] and may re-occur even if there is no further drug use.[5]

    [1]     tt 1-7-8, 1-22, 1-23, 1-54, and 1-77.

    [2]     tt 1-64-65.

    [3]     t 1-63, t 2-31.

    [4]     t 1-62.

    [5]     tt 1-63-64.

    Charge of Murder

  3. The Queensland Ambulance Service was called at 3.44 am on 10 February 2015.  They found Mr Zarnke’s victim dead and he could not be revived.  The police witness statements show that at approximately 1.30 am Mr Zarnke had arrived at his aunt’s address, appeared very paranoid, stating that he was being poisoned.  He left the house and returned approximately two hours later at 3.30 am.  Mr Zarnke was heard accusing the deceased man of poisoning him.  Soon after this, the victim…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read In the matter of John Bernard Zarnke and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2017] QMHC 5
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the matter of John Bernard Zarnke, the Queensland Court of Appeal was presented with a dispute involving the defendant’s mental state during the commission of various criminal offences. The primary legal issue before the court was whether Mr Zarnke was legally insane at the time of the offences, specifically on 29 September and 13 October 2014, and whether he had diminished responsibility due to his mental state.

The court examined the evidence from several experts, including Dr Butler, Dr Phillips, and Dr Wilson, who provided differing opinions on Mr Zarnke's mental condition. Dr Butler concluded that Mr Zarnke's dispute of facts was not informed by psychotic phenomena but rather a retrospective rationalisation of his behaviour. The court had to determine if this rationalisation affected Mr Zarnke’s ability to know the nature and quality of his acts or that they were wrong. Dr Phillips and Dr Wilson both agreed that while Mr Zarnke was somewhat confused and intoxicated, he was not fully deprived of his relevant capacities, indicating that he could still understand the wrongfulness of his actions.

The reasoning of the court was focused on the standard of proof for insanity and diminished responsibility under the relevant legislation. The court concluded that the evidence did not establish Mr Zarnke was legally insane at the time of the offences. His actions, despite his mental state, demonstrated an understanding of the nature and quality of his actions and their wrongfulness. Therefore, the court found that Mr Zarnke was not exempt from criminal responsibility due to insanity.

The court's final orders confirmed that Mr Zarnke was responsible for his actions on the specified dates and upheld the conviction and sentence imposed by the lower court.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Dispute of facts. As to the claim by Mr Zarnke that he would have provided a breath test if police had changed the collection tube, Dr Butler says: “Although this may represent a retrospective rationalisation of his behaviour, I do not believe that his disputation of the facts is informed by any ongoing psychotic phenomena associated with his illness.” Further, Dr Butler says that so far as the charge of assault or obstruct police officer at the BP service station is concerned, Mr Zarnke believed that the police were unnecessarily aggressive towards him and that he was assaulted. He rejected the notion that he struck out at or injured any police officer. Dr Butler says that again he believes his recollection of events may be a retrospective rationalisation, but he thinks that it does amount to a dispute of fact not informed by psychotic distortion of his reasoning.Offending of 29 September 2014 Eventually Mr Zarnke calmed down in the watch-house on 28 September 2014. He was released on bail and it was a condition of the bail that he not attend the BP service station at Burpengary. Unfortunately though, his car was at the service station and, as it turned out, he did not have the key. On 29 September 2014 he attended the BP service station and police were called when he was observed attempting to break into his own vehicle. Mr Zarnke only made intermittent sense when talking to police on this occasion. He had gone into the BP service station to enquire whether they had his keys, and also looked into another vehicle parked nearby to ask the occupants if they had his keys. He told the police somebody had swapped the number plates on his car. He had a sleep in the “truckers’ lounge” at the service station. He told police that one of his friends had come and looked for his keys but had not been able to find them, so he had attended himself, and broken the window of his own car. Mr Zarnke told police and told Dr Phillips that he knew it was a condition of bail that he not return to the service station. However, he needed to because that is where his car was. He told Dr Phillips he had not used alcohol or any illicit substances between the time of his release from the watch-house on 28 September and his arrest on 29 September. He told Dr Phillips he had spent this time wandering the streets believing that people were trying to kill him. Later on 29 September 2014 he was admitted to the Caboolture Mental Health Unit. Dr Phillips’ opinion was that Mr Zarnke was not deprived of any relevant capacity on 29 September 2014, although he was somewhat confused and all his capacities were probably impaired to some extent. She additionally was of the opinion that he was still intoxicated with methamphetamine. Dr Wilson agreed that on this date Mr Zarnke was not fully deprived of any relevant capacity and was still probably intoxicated. Dr Butler says he believes Mr Zarnke was impaired in his capacity to know he ought not do these acts but not deprived. Offending of 13 October 2014

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established