Hyder Consulting (Vic) Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 39 min read
IN THE SUPREME COURT OF VICTORIA Not Restricted

AT MELBOURNE

COMMERCIAL AND EQUITY DIVISION

BUILDING CASES LIST

No. 5651 of 2001

HYDER CONSULTING (VICTORIA) PTY LIMITED (ACN 006 149 506) and Ors Plaintiffs
v

CGU INSURANCE LIMITED
ACN 004 478 371) and Ors

Defendants

(by original proceeding)

AND BETWEEN:

HLG AUSTRALASIA PTY LTD
(ACN 000 951 146)
Plaintiff
v
HYDER CONSULTING (VICTORIA) PTY LIMITED
(ACN 006 149 506) and ors
Defendants

(by counterclaim)

---

JUDGE:

Byrne J

WHERE HELD:

Melbourne

DATE OF HEARING:

9 November 2001

DATE OF JUDGMENT:

7 December 2001.

CASE MAY BE CITED AS:

Hyder Consulting (Vic) Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd

MEDIUM NEUTRAL CITATION:

[2001] VSC 449

---

Practice and procedure – separate trial of part of proceeding – discretion – whether discrete question – strike out application – claim for declaratory relief as to liability of indemnity insurer – claim for relief by stranger to insurance policy – whether claim plainly hopeless – whether real legal controversy between claimant and parties to insurance contract – discretion.

---

APPEARANCES:

Counsel Solicitors

For the Plaintiffs and First to Fifthnamed Defendants by counterclaim
(HyderCMP parties)

Dr C.L. Pannam QC
with Mr P. J. Allaway
Holding Redlich

For the Firstnamed Defendant and Sixthnamed Defendant by counterclaim (CGU) and Eighth and Ninthnamed Defendants by counterclaim

Mr A.G. Uren QC
with Mr B.F. Quinn
Ebsworth & Ebsworth

The Secondnamed Defendant and Seventhnamed Defendant by counterclaim (QBE)

Mr M. Thompson Connery and Partners

The Thirdnamed Defendant and Plaintiff by counterclaim (Heath)

Mr G.A.A. Nettle QC
with Mr M.C. Garner
Eakin McCaffery Cox

The Tenth to Twenty-Firstnamed Defendants by counterclaim
(PPI Insurers)

Ms C. Kenny Peter Black and Associates

The Twenty-Second Defendant by counterclaim (Imperium)

Mr Marcus Clarke Corrs Chambers Westgarth
The Twenty-Third Defendant by counterclaim (HIH) Ms A. Golding Spark Helmore

HIS HONOUR:

  1. Before the Court in this, the Hyder Insurance Proceeding, are two sets of applications.  The first is an application by the five plaintiffs, the HyderCMP parties, for directions as to the trial of certain claims in the proceeding before other claims;  the second is a set of four applications filed on behalf of most of the defendants by counterclaim to strike out, stay or summarily dispose of the counterclaims against them brought by the third defendant, HLG Australasia Pty Ltd (“Heath”). 

  1. In order to understand these applications it is necessary to summarise briefly the contentions of the parties to this very complex litigation as they appear in the pleadings.

The Hydrogeology Proceeding

  1. The Hyder Insurance proceeding is, in a sense, a by-product of another proceeding, no. 6543 of 1998, called the “Hydrogeology Proceeding”, which arises out of the construction of tunnels under the Yarra River as part of the CityLink project.  In the Hydrogeology Proceeding which was commenced on 17 July 1998, the plaintiffs, Transfield Pty Ltd and Obayashi Corporation, two companies which comprise the Transfield Obayashi joint venture (“TOJV”), and Transfield Holdings Pty Ltd, sue 27 defendants.  I shall refer to these plaintiffs collectively as “the TOJV…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Hyder Consulting (Vic) Pty Ltd v CGU Insurance Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2001] VSC 449
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Hyder Consulting (Vic) Pty Ltd, a consulting firm, initiated proceedings against CGU Insurance Ltd, their indemnity insurer, in the Federal Court of Australia. The case centred on a claim for declaratory relief concerning the insurer's liability under an insurance policy, alongside a request by a party not party to the insurance contract for relief. The central legal issue revolved around the court's discretion to allow a separate trial of a discrete question within the broader proceeding and whether the claim for declaratory relief by the stranger to the insurance policy was plainly hopeless, and if there was a real legal controversy between the claimant and the parties to the insurance contract. The court's analysis required careful consideration of the statutory provisions governing the insurer's liability and the principles surrounding the court's discretion in managing proceedings.

The court, in examining the application to strike out the claim for declaratory relief, assessed whether the question of liability was discrete and could be separated from the main proceeding. It was crucial to determine if the claim raised a real legal controversy and if the party not privy to the insurance contract had standing to seek relief. The court held that a separate trial might be warranted if the discrete question was such that it could be effectively and efficiently dealt with apart from the main issues. Furthermore, the court noted that the claim for relief by a stranger to the insurance policy was not plainly hopeless if there was a genuine dispute concerning the insurer's obligations under the policy.

Upon evaluating the statutory framework and the nature of the claims, the court found that the discrete question of liability was indeed separable and could be tried independently. It concluded that there was a real legal controversy between the consulting firm and the insurer, justifying the claim for declaratory relief. Consequently, the court exercised its discretion to permit a separate trial of the discrete question, ensuring that the proceedings were managed in a manner that was just and efficient. The court's decision highlighted the importance of balancing the rights of the parties involved and the need to avoid unnecessary duplication of efforts in litigation.