FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Interchase Corporation Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 7 min read

[1997] QCA 201

COURT OF APPEAL

DEMACK J
DOWSETT J

MACKENZIE J

Appeal No 4241 of 1997

FAI GENERAL INSURANCE Appellant (Fifth

Respondent) COMPANY LIMITED

and

INTERCHASE CORPORATION LIMITED Respondent (Plaintiff)

BRISBANE
..DATE 16/06/97
170697 T2/SJ3 M/T COA130/97
DOWSETT J: In this action the plaintiff sues the first and
second defendants for damages for breach of duty. Those
defendants had a policy of professional indemnity insurance
with the fifth defendant. For some time before the fifth
defendant was joined as a defendant, it was intimately
connected in the conduct of the action, acting in concert
with the first and second defendants. It then concluded
that it had a basis for declining cover and did so.

When the plaintiff discovered this, it sought leave to join the fifth defendant in the action, seeking against it a declaration that it was obliged to indemnify the first and second defendants in connection with any judgment recovered against them. This order was made, and the fifth defendant participated in the action for some weeks thereafter, but then lodged an appeal against the decision. The fifth defendant now seeks to stay the action as against it pending determination of the appeal.

Since the completion of argument, as has been said by the presiding Judge, we have ascertained that it will be possible to expedite hearing of the appeal so that it will be heard at the end of July. The application should now be seen in that light.

The fifth defendant advances two main reasons for seeking a stay. The first is that the plaintiff is in liquidation and will not be able to meet any order for costs incurred in taking steps in the action whilst awaiting determination of the appeal. However, in the course of argument, counsel 170697 T2/SJ3 M/T COA130/97

conceded that there was only a limited amount of work likely
to be performed in that time and that therefore only a
relatively small amount in costs is likely to be incurred.
Further, the plaintiff is shown to have access to sufficient
funds held by a wholly owned subsidiary and available for
this purpose. This ground for granting a stay therefore
appears to be lacking in substance.

The second ground is that the joinder has widened the issues in the litigation to include issues arising between the first and second defendants on the one side and the fifth defendant on the other concerning the issue of indemnity. It is a little difficult to comprehend the full effect of this extension of the issues. One can well understand, however, that the first, second and fifth defendants would not be keen to allow the plaintiff access to documents concerning these issues if that could be avoided.

The cause of action asserted by the plaintiff against the fifth defendant is, in some respects, novel, although there is appellate authority supporting the plaintiff's position in South Australia and Victoria. I am, however, concerned that the plaintiff should not obtain any unfair advantage from the commencement of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Interchase Corporation L... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1997] QCA 201
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of FAI General Insurance Company Ltd v Interchase Corporation Ltd, the plaintiff sought damages from the first and second defendants for breach of duty, with the fifth defendant being the professional indemnity insurer of the first and second defendants. The fifth defendant had initially been closely involved in the litigation but later declined to provide cover and was subsequently joined as a defendant. The plaintiff sought a declaration that the fifth defendant was obliged to indemnify the first and second defendants in relation to any judgment recovered against them. The fifth defendant appealed against the decision to join it in the action and sought a stay of the proceedings against it pending the determination of the appeal.

The court had to decide whether to grant the fifth defendant's application for a stay of the proceedings. The fifth defendant advanced two main reasons for seeking a stay: the plaintiff's potential inability to meet any order for costs incurred during the appeal and the widening of the issues in the litigation due to the joinder of the fifth defendant. The court considered these arguments and decided that a stay was appropriate to prevent the plaintiff from obtaining an unfair advantage if the appeal was successful. The court also noted that the appeal would be expedited, allowing for a timely determination.

The court decided to stay the plaintiff's action against the fifth defendant to the extent of excusing the fifth defendant from making disclosure of documents in the action, pending determination of the appeal against the order joining the fifth defendant in the proceedings. The court emphasised that this stay was not intended to restrict the plaintiff's right to resort to other lawful means of obtaining access to such documents. The court also ordered that the costs of the application be borne by the plaintiff and the fifth defendant as costs in the cause of the appeal, while reserving the costs of the appearance of the third, fourth, and sixth defendants for later determination.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established