FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Humphries v Newport Quays Stage 2A Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 699
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – applications under O 29 r 5 of Federal Court Rules for eight proceedings to be tried at same time – relevant factors in determining whether appropriate that proceedings be tried at same time
Held: applications refused – considerable difficulties in terms of procedural rulings and rulings on evidence would follow trial of all proceedings together.
Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) ss 56, 97, 98
Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth) s 23
Federal Court Rules O 29 r 5Fox v Olsen [1999] SASC 411 referred to
PETER JOHN HUMPHRIES v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222, MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301, REBECCA MCFARLANE and URBAN CONSTRUCT PROJECT MARKETING PTY LTD ACN 095 779 699
SAD 153 of 2008MANUEL PIPINIAS v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222, MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301, MAXWELL BARBER, TRAVIS BARBER and LARISSA BARBER
SAD 150 of 2008ANNA KATHRYN HUMPHRIES v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222 and MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301
SAD 152 of 2008WARWICK PRESTWOOD v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222 and MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301
SAD 154 of 2008MARK STEPHEN JAMES and CATHERINE JOAN JAMES v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222, MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301 and MAX BARBER
SAD 184 of 2008RANDOLPH NICHOLAS BOLTON CARPENTER v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222, MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301 and HUBERT GERARD THEUNENS
SAD 208 of 2008DEBRA LIZABETH GAZ and GENE LAWRENCE GAZ v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222, MC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301 and HUBERT GERARD THEUNENS
SAD 18 of 2009LUDWIG JOCHMANN and TRACY BOTTRELL v NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222 and MAXWELL BARBER
SAD 37 of 2009BESANKO J
29 JUNE 2009
ADELAIDE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
SOUTH AUSTRALIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
SAD 153 of 2008
BETWEEN: PETER JOHN HUMPHRIES
Applicant
AND: NEWPORT QUAYS STAGE 2A PTY LTD ACN 117 374 222
First RespondentMC MARINA SOUTH LTD ACN 121 362 301
Second RespondentREBECCA MCFARLANE
Third RespondentURBAN CONSTRUCT PROJECT MARKETING PTY LTD ACN 095 779 699
Cross-respondent
JUDGE:
BESANKO J
DATE OF ORDER:
12 JUNE 2009
WHERE MADE:
ADELAIDE
THE COURT ORDERS THAT:
1.The application by the applicant for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2.The applicant pay the costs of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first, second and third respondents and Urban Construct Project Marketing Pty Ltd ACN 095 779 699.
Note:Settlement and entry of orders is dealt with in…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Humphries v Newport Quays Stage 2A Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2009] FCA 699
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the court included whether there were sufficient common issues of fact and law among the various proceedings to justify a single trial or coordinated trials, and whether it would be appropriate to appoint a lead case or to require the parties to abide by the outcome of a test case. The court considered the submissions of both parties, noting that while there were common themes in the applicants' allegations, there were also variations in the details of the representations made. The court also noted that some issues, such as those relating to promotional materials, would likely not be in dispute.
The court concluded that while there were common issues, it was not possible to determine the exact degree of commonality at that stage. It found that it was not apparent how evidence from one proceeding would be relevant or admissible in another. The court also rejected the idea of a lead case or a test case, as there was no agreement between the parties on these matters. The court ordered that the application for the orders sought by the applicants be refused, and that the applicants pay the costs of the respondents who appeared and opposed the application.
The court's decision was based on its assessment of the commonality of issues, the admissibility of evidence in different proceedings, and the lack of agreement between the parties on the use of a lead or test case. The court's refusal of the orders and imposition of costs was a reflection of these considerations. The final orders of the court were that the applicants' application for the orders sought be refused, and that the applicants pay the costs of the respondents.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The application by the applicant for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2. The applicant pay the costs of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first, second and third respondents and Urban Construct Project Marketing Pty Ltd ACN 095 779 699.
Note:
1. The application by the applicant for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2. The applicant pay the costs of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first and second respondents.
Note:
1. The application by the applicants for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2. The applicants pay the costs of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first, second and third respondents.
Note:
1. The application by the applicant for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2. The applicant pay the costs, if any, of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first, second and third respondents.
Note:
1. The application by the applicants for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2. The applicants pay the costs, if any, of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first, second and third respondents.
Note:
1. The application by the applicants for the orders sought as set out in the document which is tab 2 to the agreed book of documents be refused.
2. The applicants pay the costs of the respondents who appeared on the application and opposed it, being the first and second respondents.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
The matter came before the court on an application made by the applicants for certain orders against the respondents. The application was opposed by the respondents, who argued against the granting of the sought orders. The court heard submissions from both parties and considered the relevant legal principles and precedents. The court also examined the submissions regarding the admissibility of evidence from one applicant in another applicant's proceeding and the possibility of a "lead case" to address common issues.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: BESANKO J
The respondents handed up, as an aide memoire, a schedule summarising each applicant’s allegations as to the representations made to him or her. While a representation about Stage 3 of the development (that is, that it would proceed and when that would take place) is a common theme, there are variations in what was allegedly said on that topic. Furthermore, there are other and different representations alleged in some of the proceedings. For example, some of the applicants allege that there were representations made about the benefits of investing in the development.Consideration of relevant factors The proceedings are broadly of a similar nature, and there are common issues of fact, and probably law, in the proceedings. At the same time, not all issues are common issues and it is difficult to be precise as to the degree of commonality. Furthermore, some weight must be given to the respondents’ submission that a number of common issues such as the facts relating to newsletters, the scale model and the brochure will not be in dispute. It is appropriate to proceed on the basis that there will be witnesses called by the applicants who will be common to each proceeding. The valuer and town planner fall into this category. There was a good deal of debate before me about whether an applicant in one proceeding could give evidence in another applicant’s proceeding. Counsel for the respondents referred to the general section in the Evidence Act 1995 (Cth) s 56 (evidence that is relevant is admissible) and s 97 (evidence that a person had, or has, a tendency) and s 98 (evidence making it improbable that events occurred coincidentally). Counsel for the applicants submitted that an applicant would not be called in another applicant’s proceeding to prove tendency or improbability of coincidence. He submitted that the evidence of an applicant in another applicant’s proceeding would be relevant to the first and second respondent’s state of mind. Clearly, it is not for me to rule on this point at this stage. However, on the submissions made to me on the applications, it is not apparent to me how the evidence of an applicant in one proceeding will be relevant and admissible in another applicant’s proceeding. I have no information about the witnesses the vendor respondents are likely to call. It is fair to proceed on the basis that there are likely to be some witnesses called by the vendor respondents who will be common to some or all of the proceedings. There are three sets of real estate agents who are respondents. Clearly, their evidence will not be common to all the proceedings. There have been two attempts to have in effect a “lead case” and both have failed because the case selected has settled. There is no agreement between the parties to abide the outcome of a test case, or to be bound by the findings and conclusions with respect to common questions of fact and law. Having said that, I think it is likely that parties in later trials will not contest findings made in earlier trials unless they have further or different evidence not called at the earlier trials.