Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Lavars v Gillis [2018] NSWSC 1912 Hearing dates: 4 December 2018 Date of orders: 13 December 2018 Decision date: 13 December 2018 Jurisdiction: Common Law Before: Davies J Decision: (1) I order pursuant to UCPR r 28.5 that the present proceedings be heard together with proceedings 2017/352141, 2017/170694, 2017/346984 and 2017/370856.
(2) The evidence in each of the proceedings is, subject to the rules of evidence, evidence in the other proceedings.
(3) The defendants are to pay the plaintiff’s costs of the motion.Catchwords: CIVIL PROCEDURE – hearings – order that proceedings be heard together – UCPR r 28.5 – proceedings against defendant solicitors retained by each plaintiff in relation to the termination of their employment – where application made by one plaintiff but supported by other plaintiffs - whether common questions – whether rights to relief arise out of the same transactions - all plaintiffs allege negligence and breach of fiduciary duty – overwhelming similarity of pleadings – risk of inconsistent credit findings if proceedings heard separately – time and cost savings if proceedings heard together – where all proceedings at similar stage of preparedness – where cross-admissibility of evidence can be dealt with so as to prevent forensic disadvantage to defendant
CIVIL PROCEDURE – notices to produce – before hearing – relevance to a fact in issueLegislation Cited: Civil Procedure Act 2005 (NSW) s 56
Evidence Act 1995 (NSW) ss 56, 97, 98
Federal Court Rules 2011 (Cth) O 29 r 5
Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 2005 (NSW) rr 21.10, 28.5Cases Cited: Ghose v CX Reinsurance Company Ltd [2010] NSWSC 110
Humphries v Newport Quays Stage 2A Pty Ltd [2009] FCA 699Texts Cited: Nil Category: Procedural and other rulings Parties: Daniella Lavars (Plaintiff)
Michael Joseph Gillis (First Defendant)
David Thomas Newey (Second (Defendant)
Gana Holdings Pty Ltd (Third (Defendant)
Corey Wittenberg (Respondent)
Louise Murphy (Respondent)
William Lawson (Respondent)
Stuart Moore (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
T M Faulkner (Plaintiff)
P A Horvath (Defendants)
M Rosenblatt (Other Respondents)
Laxon Lex Lawyers (Plaintiff)
Kennedys (Defendants)
S R Legal Pty Ltd (Other Respondents)
File Number(s): 2017/77032 Publication restriction: Nil
Judgment
-
The plaintiff sues the defendants, a firm of solicitors, in respect of a retainer she had with them between 2009 and 2012. The plaintiff had been an employee with St George Bank. When St George Bank and Westpac merged, the plaintiff’s employment with St George was terminated on 8 December 2009. The solicitors were retained to act for her when disputes arose with regard to her employment, and ultimately to act for her when her employment was terminated.
-
Proceedings were commenced in the Federal Court on 15 January 2010. The solicitors also acted for a number of other employees in a similar position to the plaintiff.
-
Various offers were exchanged between the plaintiff and Westpac to settle the Federal Court proceedings. Ultimately those negotiations did not produce a settlement. On 14 October 2014 the Federal Court gave judgment generally in favour…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Lavars v Gillis and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2018] NSWSC 1912
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The court was required to determine whether the proceedings shared common questions of law or fact, whether the rights to relief arose out of the same transactions, and whether there was a risk of inconsistent credit findings if the proceedings were heard separately. The court also had to consider the time and cost savings of hearing the proceedings together and the similarity in the stage of preparedness of all proceedings. Additionally, the court needed to assess whether the cross-admissibility of evidence could be managed to avoid any forensic disadvantage to the defendant.
The court found that the proceedings shared common questions of law and fact, and the rights to relief arose out of the same transactions. The pleadings were overwhelmingly similar, and there was a significant risk of inconsistent credit findings if the proceedings were heard separately. The court also noted the potential for time and cost savings and the similar stage of preparedness of all proceedings. Furthermore, the court determined that the cross-admissibility of evidence could be managed effectively to prevent any forensic disadvantage to the defendant. Therefore, the application was granted, and the proceedings were ordered to be heard together.
Background
Background to the litigation
The plaintiffs sought an order under UCPR r 28.5 that their proceedings be heard together. This application was made by one plaintiff but was supported by the other plaintiffs. The plaintiffs argued that there were common questions of fact and law in all the proceedings, and that the rights to relief arose out of the same transactions. They further contended that there was a risk of inconsistent credit findings if the proceedings were heard separately, and that there would be significant time and cost savings if the proceedings were consolidated. All the proceedings were at a similar stage of preparedness, and the plaintiffs argued that the cross-admissibility of evidence could be managed to prevent any forensic disadvantage to the defendant solicitors.
The case came before the court following an application by one of the plaintiffs for an order under UCPR r 28.5 that the proceedings be heard together. The application was supported by the other plaintiffs. The court had to consider whether the proceedings involved common questions of fact and law, whether the rights to relief arose out of the same transactions, and whether there were other factors that would justify the consolidation of the proceedings. The plaintiffs argued that the similarity of the pleadings, the risk of inconsistent credit findings, and the potential for time and cost savings supported the consolidation of the proceedings. The defendant solicitors opposed the application, arguing that there were differences in the factual circumstances of each case that warranted separate hearings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Whether the proceedings involve common questions of fact and law.
2. Whether the rights to relief in the proceedings arise out of the same transactions.
3. Whether there are other factors that justify the consolidation of the proceedings, including the risk of inconsistent credit findings and the potential for time and cost savings.
4. Whether the cross-admissibility of evidence can be managed to prevent any forensic disadvantage to the defendant solicitors.
Held
1. The court held that the proceedings involve common questions of fact and law, as all plaintiffs allege negligence and breach of fiduciary duty and the pleadings are overwhelmingly similar.
2. The court concluded that the rights to relief in the proceedings arise out of the same transactions, specifically the termination of the plaintiffs' employment.
3. The court found that other factors justify the consolidation of the proceedings, including the risk of inconsistent credit findings if the proceedings are heard separately, and the potential for time and cost savings if the proceedings are heard together.
4. The court held that the cross-admissibility of evidence can be managed to prevent any forensic disadvantage to the defendant solicitors.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court considered the application under UCPR r 28.5 to order that the proceedings be heard together. It noted that the proceedings against the defendant solicitors, retained by each plaintiff in relation to the termination of their employment, involve common questions of fact and law. The plaintiffs' allegations of negligence and breach of fiduciary duty are fundamentally the same, and their pleadings exhibit an overwhelming similarity. This commonality suggests that the proceedings are suitable for consolidation under the rules of civil procedure.
Further, the court examined whether the rights to relief in the proceedings arise out of the same transactions. It concluded that since all plaintiffs were terminated by the same entity and under similar circumstances, their claims arise from the same set of transactions, supporting the argument for consolidation.
The court also considered other factors justifying consolidation, including the risk of inconsistent credit findings if the proceedings are heard separately. Given the similarity of the facts and the legal issues, there is a significant risk that different outcomes could be reached in separate hearings, leading to potential inconsistencies. Additionally, the court acknowledged the potential for time and cost savings if the proceedings are heard together, especially since all proceedings are at a similar stage of preparedness.
Lastly, the court addressed the issue of cross-admissibility of evidence. It determined that appropriate measures can be taken to manage the evidence so as to prevent any forensic disadvantage to the defendant solicitors. This could include measures such as limiting the scope of cross-examination and ensuring that evidence is introduced in a manner that does not unfairly prejudice the defendants. The court found that these measures would sufficiently protect the defendants' rights while still allowing for the efficient administration of justice.