HS South Brisbane Pty Ltd v United Voice

Link copied
Case Copied 70 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

HS South Brisbane Pty Ltd v United Voice [2019] QSC 274

PARTIES:

HS SOUTH BRISBANE PTY LTD ACN 167 150 638

(Plaintiff)  

v

UNITED VOICE (FORMERLY LIQUOR HOSPITALITY & MISCELLANEOUS WORKERS UNION) (ABN 19 845 540 893)

(Defendant)

FILE NO/S:

BS No 13598 of 2017

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Determination of separate question

DELIVERED ON:

8 November 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

26 September 2019

JUDGE:

Bowskill J

ORDER:

The answer to the separate question, “[w]hether, as a matter of law, the reference to loss and damage in sections 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) is properly to be construed as pleaded in paragraph 9(b) of the further amended defence” is no, although the proper construction of ss 185 and 186 reflects some elements of that pleading.

The parties will be heard in relation to the formal orders and declarations to be made, consequent upon the answer to the separate question; in relation to the application to strike out parts of the statement of claim; and in relation to costs.

CATCHWORDS:

STATUTES – ACTS OF PARLIAMENT – INTERPRETATION – PARTICULAR WORDS AND PHRASES – GENERALLY – where a building on the defendant’s land encroaches upon the plaintiff’s land by intrusion in or upon the soil of the plaintiff’s land – where the encroachment was created prior to the defendant becoming the owner of the land, and the defendant did not know, and had no reasonable means of becoming aware, of the existence of the encroachment – where the plaintiff brings proceedings seeking payment by the defendant of compensation under Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) ss 184, 185 and 186 for loss and damage resulting from the encroachment, including additional construction costs incurred following discovery of the encroachment – where the defendant contends that, on the proper construction of s 185 and s 186 of the Property Law Act, inter alia, the compensation that may be awarded to an adjacent owner is limited to compensation for the grant of title to the encroaching owner, and loss or damage to the adjacent owner’s title, or interest in their land; but does not extend to consequential losses which may be incurred because of the encroachment, and does not extend to loss and damage incurred because of an encroachment which was not caused by the encroaching owner’s conduct – determination of the separate question, under r 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999, whether, as a matter of law, the reference to loss and damage in ss 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) is to be construed as pleaded by the defendant – analysis of the context and purpose of the relevant provisions of part 11, division 1 of the Property Law Act – consideration of s 185 of the Property Law Act, including the breadth of the discretion conferred by the section and the meaning of “compensation” in s 185(1)(a) – consideration of s 186 of the Property Law Act, including analysis of…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read HS South Brisbane Pty Ltd v United Voice and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 274
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of HS South Brisbane Pty Ltd v United Voice was before the Queensland Supreme Court. The plaintiff, HS South Brisbane Pty Ltd, sought compensation for loss and damage resulting from a building on the defendant’s land encroaching on the plaintiff’s land. The encroachment was present prior to the defendant becoming the owner of the land and the defendant was unaware of the encroachment.

The legal issue before the court was whether the compensation sought by the plaintiff, which included additional construction costs incurred following the discovery of the encroachment, was recoverable under sections 185 and 186 of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld). The defendant argued that the compensation was limited to the grant of title to the encroaching owner, and loss or damage to the adjacent owner’s title, or interest in their land, but did not extend to consequential losses incurred because of the encroachment, and did not extend to loss and damage incurred because of an encroachment which was not caused by the encroaching owner’s conduct. The court was also required to determine whether, as a matter of law, the reference to loss and damage in sections 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) of the Property Law Act is to be construed as pleaded by the defendant.

The court held that the proper construction of sections 185 and 186 of the Property Law Act reflects some elements of the defendant’s pleading, but the answer to the separate question was no. The court considered the context and purpose of the relevant provisions of part 11, division 1 of the Property Law Act and the meaning of “compensation” in section 185(1)(a) and the reference to “minimum” compensation in section 186. The court also considered the factors relevant to the exercise of the discretion under sections 185 and 186.

The court will hear the parties in relation to the formal orders and declarations to be made, consequent upon the answer to the separate question; in relation to the application to strike out parts of the statement of claim; and in relation to costs.

Orders

Orders of the court

The answer to the separate question, “[w]hether, as a matter of law, the reference to loss and damage in sections 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) is properly to be construed as pleaded in paragraph 9(b) of the further amended defence” is no, although the proper construction of ss 185 and 186 reflects some elements of that pleading.

The parties will be heard in relation to the formal orders and declarations to be made, consequent upon the answer to the separate question; in relation to the application to strike out parts of the statement of claim; and in relation to costs.

Background

Background to the litigation

HS South Brisbane Pty Ltd (HSSB) brought proceedings against United Voice, seeking compensation for a building on United Voice's land that encroached upon HSSB's land. The encroachment existed prior to United Voice becoming the owner of the land and was unknown to United Voice. HSSB sought compensation under sections 184, 185, and 186 of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld), which includes compensation for loss and damage resulting from the encroachment and additional construction costs incurred following the discovery of the encroachment. United Voice contended that the compensation that may be awarded to an adjacent owner is limited to compensation for the grant of title to the encroaching owner, loss or damage to the adjacent owner’s title, or interest in their land; but does not extend to consequential losses incurred because of the encroachment, and does not extend to loss and damage incurred because of an encroachment which was not caused by the encroaching owner’s conduct.

HSSB initiated proceedings in the Supreme Court of Queensland, Brisbane. The matter was heard on an application for determination of a separate question under rule 483 of the Uniform Civil Procedure Rules 1999. The separate question was whether, as a matter of law, the reference to loss and damage in sections 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) is to be construed as pleaded by United Voice in paragraph 9(b) of the further amended defence. The court was required to analyse the context and purpose of the relevant provisions of part 11, division 1 of the Property Law Act and consider the meaning and breadth of the discretion conferred by sections 185 and 186.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether, as a matter of law, the reference to loss and damage in sections 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) is properly to be construed as pleaded in paragraph 9(b) of the further amended defence.
2. What formal orders and declarations should be made, consequent upon the answer to the separate question.
3. Whether parts of the statement of claim should be struck out.
4. What orders should be made in relation to costs.

Held
1. The court held that the reference to loss and damage in sections 185(2)(d) and 186(2)(b) of the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld) is not properly to be construed as pleaded in paragraph 9(b) of the further amended defence.
2. Formal orders and declarations, the striking out of parts of the statement of claim, and orders in relation to costs will be determined upon further submissions from the parties.
3. The application to strike out parts of the statement of claim remains undecided pending further submissions.
4. Orders in relation to costs will be determined upon further submissions from the parties.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court embarked on a detailed analysis of the statutory provisions and their context within the Property Law Act 1974 (Qld). It considered the breadth of the discretion conferred by sections 185 and 186, focusing on the meaning of "compensation" in section 185(1)(a) and the reference to "minimum" compensation in section 186. The court examined the purpose of the relevant provisions of Part 11, Division 1 of the Act and how these sections should be interpreted in the context of an encroachment created prior to the defendant's ownership. The court concluded that while the defendant's interpretation of the scope of compensation had some merits, it did not fully align with the statutory language and purpose. The proper construction of sections 185 and 186 includes considerations of consequential losses which may be incurred because of the encroachment, but this does not extend to loss and damage incurred because of an encroachment not caused by the encroaching owner's conduct. The binding principle established by this decision (ratio decidendi) is that compensation under sections 185 and 186 encompasses consequential losses due to an encroachment, but not those unrelated to the encroaching owner's actions. The court distinguished certain interpretations of the statute that did not account for the broader context and purpose of the relevant provisions.