Himone and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)
Link copied
CaseCopied
77 min read
Full text
Himone and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2022] AATA 4142 (1 November 2022)
Division:GENERAL DIVISION
File Number: 2022/6699
Re:LaetynSebastrian Himone
APPLICANT
AndMinister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs
RESPONDENT
Decision
Tribunal:Member D. Cosgrave
Date of Decision: 1 November 2022
Date of Written Reasons: 6 December 2022
Place:Brisbane
Pursuant to section 43 of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth), the Tribunal affirms the decision made by the delegate of the Respondent dated 10 August 2022 to not revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s visa.
...........[sgd].................
Member D. Cosgrave
Catchwords
MIGRATION – Non-revocation of a mandatory visa cancellation – citizen of New Zealand – Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa – failure to pass good character test – substantial criminal record – whether another reason why the mandatory visa cancellation should be revoked – Ministerial Direction No. 90 applied – decision affirmed
Direction No. 90 – Visa refusal and cancellation under section 501 and revocation of a mandatory cancellation of a visa under section 501CA
CONTENTS
REASONS FOR DECISION
INTRODUCTION
BACKGROUND
OFFENDING HISTORY AND SENTENCING JUDGE’S COMMENTS
LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK
ISSUES
Character test
Another Reason?
The Direction
EVIDENCE
Documentary evidence
Witnesses
Applicant’s evidence
Evidence of Nader Narouz
Evidence of May Faumi
Evidence of Eroni Wilkersea Tara
Evidence of Taufusi Loretta Togia Moe
Evidence of Mario Rizzeri
Evidence of Timoci Tara
Expert Evidence of Dr Sam Calvin
THE TRIBUNAL’S CONSIDERATION OF THE EVIDENCE
The Oral Evidence
Documentary Evidence
PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONS
Primary Consideration 1: Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct
Grounds of appeal
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Himone and Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicu... and more:
The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered the case of Himone and the Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs concerning the non-revocation of a mandatory visa cancellation. The applicant, a New Zealand citizen, had his Class TY Subclass 444 Special Category (Temporary) visa mandatorily cancelled under section 501(3A) of the *Migration Act 1958* (Cth) due to having a substantial criminal record, specifically being sentenced to a term of imprisonment of more than 12 months and serving a full-time sentence. The applicant sought revocation of this cancellation, but a delegate of the Minister decided not to revoke it. The Tribunal was asked to review this non-revocation decision.
The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was whether there was "another reason" why the mandatory visa cancellation should be revoked, as contemplated by section 501CA(4) of the Act. This required the Tribunal to assess the applicant's character, taking into account his offending history, the circumstances of his offences, his background, and any evidence of remorse or rehabilitation, in light of Ministerial Direction No. 90. The Tribunal also had to consider the protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct.
The Tribunal reasoned that while the applicant had a difficult childhood marked by poverty, parental abandonment, and domestic violence, and that a sentencing judge had acknowledged his immaturity and reduced capacity for decision-making, these factors did not outweigh the seriousness of his adult offending. This offending included aggravated break and enter, assault, and affray, which involved violence, threats, and significant harm to the victim and his young children. The Tribunal noted inconsistencies in the applicant's accounts of his offending and drug use, and found that while some evidence of remorse was present, it was accompanied by hesitation. Applying the principles from *Thornton v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs* [2022] FCAFC 23, the Tribunal focused on the applicant's adult offending and concluded that the primary consideration of protecting the Australian community from serious conduct was paramount.
Ultimately, the Tribunal affirmed the delegate's decision not to revoke the visa cancellation. The Tribunal found that the applicant had not demonstrated that there was another reason to revoke the mandatory cancellation, and that the seriousness of his criminal conduct and the need to protect the Australian community were overriding factors.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
On 1 November 2022 the Tribunal affirmed the affirmed the decision under review. The Tribunal now publishes the reasons for its decision. Unless the context indicates otherwise, passages quoted in bold font are emphasis added by the Tribunal.BACKGROUND The Applicant is a 21 year-old New Zealand citizen, born in 2001, who first arrived in Australia in November 2002. The Applicant’s travel history is summarised below[2]:[2] Exhibit 1, G Documents, G30, page 253. G documents are so named because they are provided under s 501G of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth). They consist of documents in the possession or control of the Respondent relevant to the making of a reviewable decision. They usually accompany the Minister’s written notice regarding a visa cancellation, refusal, or non-revocation. ·6 November 2002: arrived in Australia;·10 September 2003: departed Australia;·8 October 2003: arrived in Australia;·7 November 2009: departed Australia;·5 December 2009: arrived in Australia;·22 October 2010: departed Australia;·26 January 2011: arrived in Australia;·1 July 2012: departed Australia; and·31 July 2012: arrived in Australia. On 19 February 2021, the Applicant’s visa was mandatorily cancelled under s 501(3A) of the Migration Act 1958 (Cth) (“the Act”).[3] [3] Exhibit 1, G3, page 15. The cancellation occurred because he had a substantial criminal record, as he had been sentenced to a term of imprisonment of more than 12 months and was serving a sentence of imprisonment on a full-time basis in a custodial institution, for an offence against a law of the Commonwealth, a State or Territory (ss 501(6)(a) and 501(7)(c) of the Act).[4] [4] Exhibit 1, G5, Attachment 3, page 24. On 22 February 2021, the Applicant requested revocation of the cancellation of his visa. On 10 August 2022, a delegate of the Minister decided, under s 501CA(4) of the Act, not to revoke the visa cancellation decision (“non-revocation decision”)[5].[5] Exhibit 1, G4, page 23. On 18 August 2022, the Applicant asked the Tribunal to review that decision[6].[6] Exhibit 1, G2, page 3. The Tribunal must decide this application within 84 days of the Applicant being properly notified of the non-revocation decision.[7] On 1 November 2022 the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. [7] Section 500(6L) of the Act.OFFENDING HISTORY AND SENTENCING JUDGE’S COMMENTS The Tribunal acknowledges the Full Federal Court of Australia’s decision in Thornton v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 23 (“Thornton”). The Applicant was born in 2001 and the Tribunal has focused on the Applicant’s post-2001 adult offending. The following is a tabularised summary of the Applicant’s adult offending and conviction history: The balance of the Applicant’s offending history occurred when he was under the age of 18. While New South Wales legislation may differ from Queensland’s in regard to childhood offences and juvenile offending, adopting a conservative application of Thornton here means the Applicant benefits from not having his juvenile offending considered.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The Tribunal also has specific regard to the following comments by Judge O'Rourke:"I am prepared to accept an immaturity and a reduced capacity for mature decision-making (on the basis of his age, known background and criminal conduct itself and its motivation) played some role in the offending behaviour.The offender also has had a transient and difficult childhood filled with poverty and parental abandonment. It is not one that any child deserves. Fortunately for him he has had his grandmother who has been willing and able to step into that void but this was also not without its difficulty including the presence of domestic violence in the home and moving from home to home with different carers. I have taken that all into account of what he has had to endure and I do accept that it reduces his moral culpability to some extent.In relation to the question of remorse, he has pleaded guilty and written a letter to the Court, he did not give evidence before me. The subjective material tendered is replete with his acceptance of wrongdoing, disgust for what he did and insight into the cowardly nature of his offending. I also note however, his protestations of remorse for the earlier matter. Overall though I do find some evidence of genuine remorse, but with some hesitation."[14][Emphasis added][14] Ibid, pages 58-59. See also Exhibit 1, G9, pages 62-63. The Applicant’s adult offending can be categorised under the following areas:(a)Offences involving violence – breaking and entering, assault and affray; and(b)An offence of possessing prohibited goods in prison.LEGISLATIVE FRAMEWORK Section 25(1)(a) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (“the AAT Act”) and s 500(1)(ba) of the Act are the sources of the Tribunal’s jurisdiction in this matter. Section 501(3A) of the Act, read in conjunction with ss 501(6) and 501(7) of the Act, obliges the Minister to cancel a person’s visa if the Minister is satisfied the person does not pass the character test and is serving a full-time sentence of imprisonment. The ‘character test’ is defined in s 501(6) of the Act and a person does not pass it if they have a ‘substantial criminal record’ as defined by s 501(7). This includes if they are sentenced to a term of imprisonment of 12 months or more: s 501(7)(c). Under s 501CA(3) of the Act, the Minister is obliged to give notice of a cancellation decision as soon as practicable after it is made, and to invite the affected person to make representations about revocation. Provisions relating to the form and process of those representations are found in reg 2.52 of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth). Section 501CA(4) of the Act confers a discretionary power upon the Minister to revoke the original decision, if the person whose visa has been cancelled makes representations in accordance with the invitation, and the Minister is satisfied that the person passes the character test, or there is another reason why the original decision should be revoked.ISSUES Character test
Decision
Reasons for decision
On 10 August 2022, a delegate of the Minister decided, under s 501CA(4) of the Act, not to revoke the visa cancellation decision (“non-revocation decision”)[5].[5] Exhibit 1, G4, page 23. On 18 August 2022, the Applicant asked the Tribunal to review that decision[6].[6] Exhibit 1, G2, page 3. The Tribunal must decide this application within 84 days of the Applicant being properly notified of the non-revocation decision.[7] On 1 November 2022 the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review. [7] Section 500(6L) of the Act.OFFENDING HISTORY AND SENTENCING JUDGE’S COMMENTS The Tribunal acknowledges the Full Federal Court of Australia’s decision in Thornton v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs [2022] FCAFC 23 (“Thornton”). The Applicant was born in 2001 and the Tribunal has focused on the Applicant’s post-2001 adult offending. The following is a tabularised summary of the Applicant’s adult offending and conviction history: The balance of the Applicant’s offending history occurred when he was under the age of 18. While New South Wales legislation may differ from Queensland’s in regard to childhood offences and juvenile offending, adopting a conservative application of Thornton here means the Applicant benefits from not having his juvenile offending considered. On 18 December 2020, before Her Honour Judge O’Rourke of the District Court of New South Wales, the Applicant was sentenced in relation to a conviction for aggravated break and enter and commit serious indictable offence contrary to section 11 (2) of the Crimes Act and received a 25% discount for:"… the utilitarian value of the plea and an ultimate acceptance of responsibility and willingness to facilitate the course of justice."[10][10] Exhibit 1, G8, page 48. For the purposes of this decision, it is relevant to quote at length from Judge O'Rourke's decision regarding the penalty for the offence:"The signed agreed facts are as follows. The offender's date of birth is [REDACTED] 2001. There are two unknown males who are co-offenders in the matter who have not been located or charged. The victim is NV[11]. [11] Anonymised as it is personal identifier, per ‘Guideline on the Disclosure and Non-Disclosure of Personal Information in AAT Decisions‘.The victim resides at X[12] with his wife and their three children. [12] Ibid.On 25 November 2019 at approximately 3:13 p.m. the offender and the two unknowns arrived at the premises in a vehicle. The offender and one of them went to the front door while the other one remained in the car. They knocked on the door, waited for a few minutes, return to the vehicle and left. About three and a bit hours later at 6:32pm they all arrived again at the premises in the same car and again one remained in the vehicle while the offender and the other unknown approached the front door of the house, knocked on it, waited a few minutes then returned to the vehicle and left. At approximately 8:13pm., the offender and the two unknowns arrived again at the same premises in the car. The offender and the unknown again approached, knocked on the door, while the other unknown male remained in the car. At this time the victim was home with his two daughters aged 10 and 9. One was in the rear study and the other was in the living room. The victim's wife was at that time overseas.The victim responded to the knock and walked towards the front door, he heard a male voice say “Delivery, delivery”. The victim opened the front door whilst the flyscreen door remained closed. The offender and one of the unknown males were at the door, the unknown holding a big box and the offender holding a clipboard. The offender said “You have to sign the papers before we can give you the parcel”. As a result the victim opened the flyscreen and the offender handed him a pen and a clipboard to sign. As he was preparing to do that, to sign the paper, one of the offenders punched him to the left side of the face near his eye and due to the force of the punch the victim’s face began to bleed and he was knocked back into the house and fell onto the floor. The offender and the unknown male entered the house and continued to punch and kick the left side of his body and head whilst the victim was on the floor and he attempted to protect himself by covering his face with his hands. The offender then placed a black handled knife approximately 30 centimetres long to the victim’s neck and said “Where is your wife” to which he replied, “I don’t know” and the offender said, “You’re lying”. They then punched and kicked the victim again and the offender repeated “You’re lying to me”. The offender then told the victim to sit on the sofa to which he complied and he was there with his younger daughter. The victim’s face was covered with a balaclava and a large blanket and the other was also covered in a blanket. One of them went to sleep whilst covered in the blanket. At some stage the blanket was temporarily removed off one of the daughters by the unknown male whilst he was holding a knife and he showed her three photographs, one of which was of her parents. He asked her questions about the people depicted and she said that she did not know who they were. Her head and body were covered again with the blanket and she went back to sleep. At this time the other unknown was walking around the house.The offender continued to ask the victim where his wife was and the victim told the offenders to take what they want and then to leave. They then began to search through the house. All of this was occurring whilst the other daughter had locked herself in a room at the back of the house. She heard the offenders inside the room and her father yelling. She was scared and sat in the corner of the room and as the offenders were searching the house they attempted to open the door to her room, however it was locked. About an hour later the offender and an unknown male returned to the living room where the victim and his daughter were seated and said, “If you call the police I’ll come back and shoot you and your children”. At approximately 9.15pm the offender and the unknown left the premises and returned to the car. When the victim heard the front door close he took the blanket and balaclava off his head and checked on both of his daughters, one of the daughters had got the assistance of a neighbour who had called the police and police attended shortly after. The victim was taken to Liverpool Hospital by an ambulance to receive treatment for his injuries and sustained a laceration to his left eye, a broken nose and bruising to the left side of his body. On 2 December 2019 he still had swelling to his left eye which impaired his vision, he was suffering from ongoing pain in his left shoulder and there remained bruising on the left side of his body. The offender’s fingerprint was located or identified on the exterior panel of the front door above the keyhole. On 10 December 2019 he was arrested, cautioned and charged and was offered the opportunity to participate in a recorded interview with the police which he accepted. During that interview the offender stated a denial, saying he was sick and at home on the day of the offence, that he had never been to [location redacted] before. He had never been in a black Dodge before and he had never been to the said premises before, that it was not him in the CCTV footage stills which were shown to him, that he had no idea why his fingerprints were located on the front door of the premises and that he does not know the victim nor the family.Here the features of relevance are the offender was 18 years of age; it involved some planning and clearly premeditated by the several trips being occasioned to the property; his entry was gained by the use of trickery; it occurred at about 8pm at night; the house was occupied by its owner with two young female children; it was committed in company with other assailants; that violence was inflicted upon the victim and threats made to him and his daughter; injuries were sustained to the victim; it was not of short duration; the motivation was financial and the offender played a significant if not principal role.Here the serious indictable offence is assault occasioning actual bodily harm and injuries were sustained. I also note that the circumstance of aggravation averred was armed with an offensive weapon. It is well established that the Crown does not have to allege every aggravating circumstance to be relied upon in the indictment providing of course the charge alleges the offence was committed in circumstances of aggravation. So accordingly a sentencing Court is entitled to take into account matters of aggravation not specifically alleged in the indictment without infringing De Simoni principles: R v Li (NSWCCA 9 July 1997, unreported) ; Josefski v R [2010] NSWCCA 41 at [19]. Here, there was also the aggravating features of at least knowing persons were present and committed in company. Considering all matters relevant to the objective gravity of the offence before the Court, including the role the offender played, the lead up to the break and enter, the motivation, the injuries sustained to the victim and the fact that young female children were involved, I have determined that the offending falls above mid-range of seriousness for the aggravated break and enter.In relation to substance abuse between the age of 13 and 14 he reported using around 600 milligrams of non-prescribed codeine per day. Between the age of 14 and 15 he would drink one case of beer, he says, a week and at age 18 experimented with cocaine. The offender reported to Ms Robinson of Community Corrections initially that he was using cocaine on a regular basis and then on the second occasion that he met her, he admitted to falsifying his drug use on that occasion to get a lighter sentence. It was confirmed in evidence today that this is what had indeed occurred and this occurred on the second occasion.In relation to his mental health, Ms Hawil who is a psychologist, was of the opinion that the offender meets the criteria for a diagnosis of conduct disorder, childhood onset type and intermittent explosive disorder. She stated that the offender began displaying characteristics of conduct disorder prior to the age of 10 with repetitive and persistent patterns of violating age-appropriate school norms and rules and anger problems starting in primary school. His parental rejection, neglect, inconsistent child-rearing practices, harsh discipline, physical abuse, lack of supervision, early institutional living, frequent changes of care givers, large family size, parental criminality, peer rejection, association with delinquent groups and exposure to violence are all risk factors common with individuals with childhood onset disorder. In relation to the intermittent explosive disorder, Ms Hawil stated that the offender’s recurrent behavioural outbursts represent a failure to control aggressive impulses that began in primary school. “It is clear that the offender has trouble controlling his impulses and he does not consider the consequence of his actions when angry however expressed that he can feel remorse afterwards.”He reported to Community Corrections that frustrations from his childhood have developed into emotional resentment."
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
In particular, the Tribunal notes the following:(a)New South Wales Department of Corrective Services case note report dated 6 October 2020[47]:[47] Exhibit 1, G11, page 84."Impact – (the Applicant) identified his victim had lost part of his eyesight due to the offences. He stated he thought he had mentally impacted him by making him feel unsafe in his own home.""Offence map – (the Applicant) said hat [sic] he can recall, they did not know the victim. He said they wanted money and he acknowledged a drug debt. He appeared to limit his knowledge and engagement at this stage, and due to AVL restrictions CCO terminated interview.""CCO asked (the Applicant) to consider more impact – he had not noted anything about the younger victims in the offence, and to consider life at time and leading up to offence."(b)New South Wales Department of Corrective Services case note report dated 7 October 2020[48]:[48] Exhibit 1, G11, page 85."(The Applicant) when challenged, retracted some of his previous statements. He was still minimal on some details he confessed he was trying to make others look better and for him to take the blame out of loyalty. He said he had asked his uncle to provide CCO with incorrect details the time of the offence which he apologised for. (The Applicant) did not agree with all the police facts, stating he had felt forced to agree or it would have gone to trial which he thought would have been worse."“He said he heard about the "opportunity" through his acquaintances and agreed to take part due to his financial situation. He said he thinks he was asked to be involved because the others knew about his situation. [The Applicant] said he felt tempted as it was easy money to help his family ($20,000).”“[The Applicant] recalled just before the offence he felt nervous. He said he thought about his family and their struggles and how much this would help. [The Applicant] stated he was the person to knock on the door, CCO asked if it was not his plan how he became the leader in that aspect. He said he was unaware and denied punching the male victim.”“Impact – CCO asked about apology letter which he had allegedly completed, he said he would be happy to provide it to CCO. CCO asked if he had thought any more about who his offences impacted. He said the victim would now feel unsafe in his own home. CCO asked about younger victims, [the Applicant] denied there were younger victims in the house despite police facts.”“AOD – CCO challenged [the Applicant] on his drug use since information from Frank Baxter was conflicting. He said he had lied about his use when he was younger thinking he would get a better sentence. CCO challenged if he was under the influence of AOD on the night of offences as previously stated, he denied he was.”“[The Applicant] apologise for being untruthful towards CCO and promised he would be truthful next interview. He said he was nervous.”(c)New South Wales Department of Corrective Services case note report dated 12 October 2020[49]:[49] Exhibit 1, G11, page 86.“Impact – [the Applicant] handed CCO letter which he had written to the magistrate outlining his remorse and regret. In his letter he stated he is accountable for his actions, feels shame and considers his actions to have had physical and physiological effect on his victim and the victims family. He stated his actions being "cowardly" and "disgusting". He stated his desire to change and to become a mentor for youth through Rap4Change and Team Jesus.”“Update to IAF/offence map – [the Applicant] apologised to CCO could for false information previously stated. He said he had never used drugs in his life and had only stated (SIC) drug use as a means to receive a lighter sentence.”“He said he did not know the victim or why the victim was chosen; [the Applicant] stated the reason he led the way and knocked on the door first was to make sure the plan went ahead as he needed the money for his family.”“He agreed with his first statement of needing the money to support his family.”“[The Applicant] added he had now asked his uncle to tell the truth only, as he had previously asked him to lie about his substance abuse issues. CCO reminded him the SAR is his report and it needs to be truthful or he may not get the help he needs"(d)Dr Calvin’s report dated 26 June 2022[50]:"History obtained from the client as to the reason for the offending behaviour (The Applicant) was a reluctant historian and not keen to discuss his past offending. There were some inconsistencies in the history and the documents provided. (The Applicant) attributed the serious offences to alcohol intoxication. There was no evidence to suggest that psychiatric factors directly contributed to the offending.”[50] Exhibit 1, G23, page 223.PRIMARY CONSIDERATIONS Primary Consideration 1: Protection of the Australian community from criminal or other serious conduct