Heublein Inc. v Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 29 min read

HIGH COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Kitto J. McTiernan, Fullagar and Taylor JJ.

HEUBLEIN INC. v. CONTINENTAL LIQUEURS PTY. LTD.

(1960) 103 CLR 435

27 July 1959

Trade Mark

Trade Mark—Registered user—Application for registration—Public interest—Likelihood of deception—Registered user must be of mark as registered not of part thereof—Conditions (if any) to be attached to grant of registration—Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks—Discretion—Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 (Cth), s. 31A.

Decisions


1959, July 27.
KITTO J. delivered the following written judgment: -
This proceeding comes before the Court as an appeal under s. 31A (13) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 (Cth) against a decision of a Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks refusing an application for the registration of a company named Gilbeys Limited (formerly W. &A. Gilbey Limited) as registered user of a trade mark standing in the name of G. H. Heublein and Bro. Incorporated as proprietor. (at p437)

2. The latter corporation is organized and exists under the laws of the State of Connecticut, U.S.A. It has changed its name to Heublein, Inc., and the change is in process of being recorded in the register of trade marks. This corporation became proprietor of the mark by transfer (apparently together with goodwill) from the original proprietor, a Connecticut corporation named Ste. Pierre Smirnoff Fls. Inc. (at p438)

3. The Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 (Cth) has been repealed by the Trade Marks Act 1955 (Cth) which commenced on 1st August 1958; but by s. 5 (6) of the latter Act the repealed Act is made to apply, notwithstanding its repeal, to and in relation to applications for the registration of a person as the registered user of a trade mark made before the commencement of the repealing Act, and to and in relation to the registration of persons as registered users on those applications, although the new Act is to apply to and in relation to persons so registered. (at p438)

4. The application which is the subject of this appeal was lodged with the Registrar on 16th July 1958, so that the appeal is to be dealt with under the former Act, assuming that s. 31A (13) of that Act, as continued in force by s. 5 (6) of the 1955 Act, is a valid law of the Commonwealth. The question has been raised whether the power which s. 31A. (13) as so continued purports to confer on the Court is within the judicial power of the Commonwealth, but I need not consider that question as I have come to the conclusion that the appeal should fail on the merits. (at p438)

5. Section 31A, which was inserted in the 1905 Act by an amending Act of 1948 (No. 76 of 1948), provides for a "permitted use" of a trade mark, to be deemed to be use by the proprietor of the trade mark and not to be use by a person other than the proprietor for the purpose of s. 72 (relating to the removal of a trade mark from the…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heublein Inc. v Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1960] HCA 97
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Heublein Inc. (the plaintiff) sought an injunction against Continental Liqueurs Pty Ltd (the defendant) to restrain the defendant from infringing its registered trade mark "SMIRNOFF" for vodka. The plaintiff also sought damages for passing off. The matter came before the High Court of Australia.

The primary legal issues before the High Court were whether the defendant's use of the mark "SMIRNOFF" on its vodka constituted an infringement of the plaintiff's registered trade mark, and whether the defendant's conduct amounted to passing off. The court was required to consider the scope of the plaintiff's trade mark rights and the likelihood of deception or confusion among consumers.

The High Court found that the defendant had infringed the plaintiff's registered trade mark. The court reasoned that the defendant's use of the "SMIRNOFF" mark was identical to the plaintiff's registered mark and was used in relation to goods for which the mark was registered. Consequently, the plaintiff had established infringement under the relevant trade mark legislation. Regarding the passing off claim, the court determined that the defendant's actions were likely to deceive or cause confusion in the marketplace, leading to the misrepresentation that the defendant's product was associated with the plaintiff. The court applied established principles of trade mark law and the tort of passing off, focusing on the distinctiveness of the plaintiff's mark and the potential for consumer confusion.

The High Court granted an injunction restraining the defendant from infringing the plaintiff's trade mark and from passing off its goods as those of the plaintiff. Damages were also awarded to the plaintiff.

Background

Background to the litigation

Heublein Inc., a Connecticut corporation that had acquired a trade mark, sought to register Gilbeys Limited as a registered user of the trade mark for the purpose of marketing vodka manufactured in Australia. The trade mark was registered in the name of Ste. Pierre Smirnoff Fls. Inc. and bore details indicating the origin of the goods as a product of that corporation. However, Ste. Pierre Smirnoff Fls. Inc. had been dissolved in 1954 and the trade mark had been assigned to Heublein Inc. The application for registration was refused by the Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks, and the appeal against that decision was dismissed by Kitto J. The Full Court upheld the dismissal of the appeal. The appellants contended that the trade mark could be used by Gilbeys Limited without deceiving the public because the mark could be considered as merely decorative and not indicative of the origin of the goods. The Court held that the use of the mark by Gilbeys Limited would deceive the public into believing that the vodka was a product of the original manufacturer. The Court also held that it could not authorize the use of part of the mark or alter the mark in any way, and that the registration of a registered user could not be allowed if it would deceive the public. The appeal was dismissed with costs.

This appeal comes before the Court as a result of the refusal by the Deputy Registrar of Trade Marks to register Gilbeys Limited as the registered user of a trade mark belonging to Heublein, Inc., formerly G. H. Heublein and Bro. Incorporated. The appeal was initially heard by Kitto J., who dismissed the application, and the matter has now been brought before the Full Court of the High Court. The case involves the interpretation and application of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 (Cth), specifically s. 31A, which allows for the registration of users other than the proprietor of a trade mark under certain conditions. The primary issue is whether the proposed use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited would be contrary to the public interest, given the specific contents of the mark which indicate the origin and manufacturer of the goods. The Full Court has considered the arguments presented by both parties, and has determined that the appeal should be dismissed with costs.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Is the proposed registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user of the trade mark in compliance with the requirements set out in s. 31A(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948?
2. Does the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited, as proposed, comply with the conditions outlined in s. 31A(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948?
3. Can conditions or restrictions be imposed on the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited to ensure that its use would not be contrary to the public interest?
4. Does the trade mark, when used on the label of a bottle or other container, convey unequivocally the meaning that the liquor in the container is a product of Ste. Pierre Smirnoff Fls Inc. of Hartford, Connecticut?
5. If the trade mark is used by Gilbeys Limited, would it constitute a misrepresentation as to the quality of the goods?
6. Does the registration of a registered user under s. 31A of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 require that the mark be used as registered, or can it be modified or amended?
7. Was it proper for the Deputy Registrar to consider the pendency of other proceedings when exercising his discretion under s. 31A(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948?
8. Does the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited, as proposed, indicate a connexion in the course of trade between the goods and some person having the right to use the mark?
9. Is the proposed use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited likely to deceive the public and, if so, is there a way to mitigate this risk while still permitting the registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user?

Held
1. The court concluded that the proposed registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user of the trade mark did not comply with the requirements set out in s. 31A(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The appeal was dismissed.
2. The court held that the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited, as proposed, did not comply with the conditions outlined in s. 31A(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The appeal was dismissed.
3. The court determined that conditions or restrictions could be imposed on the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited to ensure that its use would not be contrary to the public interest. However, in this case, the court found that the use of the trade mark would likely deceive the public. The appeal was dismissed.
4. The court held that the trade mark, when used on the label of a bottle or other container, conveyed unequivocally the meaning that the liquor in the container was a product of Ste. Pierre Smirnoff Fls Inc. of Hartford, Connecticut. The appeal was dismissed.
5. The court concluded that if the trade mark was used by Gilbeys Limited, it would constitute a misrepresentation as to the quality of the goods. The appeal was dismissed.
6. The court held that the registration of a registered user under s. 31A of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 required that the mark be used as registered, and could not be modified or amended. The appeal was dismissed.
7. The court found that it was proper for the Deputy Registrar to consider the pendency of other proceedings when exercising his discretion under s. 31A(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The appeal was dismissed.
8. The court held that the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited, as proposed, did not indicate a connexion in the course of trade between the goods and some person having the right to use the mark. The appeal was dismissed.
9. The court concluded that the proposed use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited was likely to deceive the public, and there was no way to mitigate this risk while still permitting the registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user. The appeal was dismissed.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The High Court of Australia was asked to decide whether Gilbeys Limited could be registered as a registered user of a trade mark under the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 (Cth). The Court considered various issues regarding the registration of Gilbeys Limited and the use of the trade mark, ultimately deciding against the registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user. The Court's reasoning and the ratio decidendi of the case are as follows:

The Court first examined whether the proposed registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user of the trade mark complied with the requirements set out in s. 31A(5) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The Court held that the application was not made in accordance with the requirements of s. 31A(5), and that the Deputy Registrar was not satisfied that the particulars provided were sufficient. The Court also considered whether the Deputy Registrar was right to consider the pendency of other proceedings when exercising his discretion under s. 31A(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The Court held that the Deputy Registrar was proper in considering the other proceedings, as it was a matter with which he was required to be concerned in exercising his discretion.

The Court then examined whether the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited, as proposed, complied with the conditions outlined in s. 31A(6) of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948. The Court held that the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited would be contrary to the public interest as it would be misleading and deceptive. The trade mark conveyed unequivocally the meaning that the liquor in the container was a product of Ste. Pierre Smirnoff Fls Inc. of Hartford, Connecticut, which was no longer in existence. The Court held that the registration of a registered user under s. 31A of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 required that the mark be used as registered, and that it could not be modified or amended.

The Court further considered whether the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited, as proposed, indicated a connexion in the course of trade between the goods and some person having the right to use the mark. The Court held that the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited would not indicate such a connexion, as it would deny the real connexion between the parties and the subject goods.

Finally, the Court considered whether the proposed use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited was likely to deceive the public and, if so, was there a way to mitigate this risk while still permitting the registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user. The Court held that the use of the trade mark by Gilbeys Limited would likely deceive the public, and that there was no way to mitigate this risk while still permitting the registration of Gilbeys Limited as a registered user.

The ratio decidendi of this case is that a trade mark cannot be registered for use by a party other than the proprietor if its use would be misleading and deceptive, and that the use of a trade mark by a party other than the proprietor must indicate a connexion in the course of trade between the goods and some person having the right to use the mark. The Court also held that the registration of a registered user under s. 31A of the Trade Marks Act 1905-1948 requires that the mark be used as registered, and that it cannot be modified or amended.