Heathcote and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration)

Link copied
Case Copied 42 min read

Heathcote and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs (Migration) [2025] ARTA 131 (31 January 2025)

Applicant/s:  Yvonne Jean Heathcote       

Respondent:  Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs

Tribunal Number:                2024/9182

Tribunal:Deputy President Burford

Place:Perth

Date of Decision:                31 January 2025

Date of Written Reasons:    14 February 2025

Decision:The decision of the delegate of the Respondent dated 7 November 2024 not to revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s Class BF Transitional (Permanent) visa under s 501CA(4) is set aside and substituted with the decision that the cancellation of the Applicant’s Class BF Transitional (Permanent) visa is revoked under s 501CA(4).

..............................[sgd].........................

Deputy President Burford

CATCHWORDS

MIGRATION – decision of delegate of Minister not to revoke mandatory cancellation of visa – character test – Direction No 110 – primary and other considerations – protection of Australian community – nature and seriousness of criminal offending – risk to the Australian community should the Applicant commit further offences or engage in other serious conduct  – strength, nature and duration of ties to Australia – best interests of children – expectations of the Australian community – extent of impediments if removed – Applicant is a 57-year-old citizen of the United Kingdom – Non-Revocation Decision is set aside

LEGISLATION

Migration Act 1958 (Cth) ss 15, 34(2), 46(1)(d), 189, 197C, 198, 499, 499(1), 500(6B), 500(6L), 501, 501F, 501E, 501E(2), 501(3A), 501(6), 501(6)(a), 501(7), 501(7)(b), 501(7)(c), 501(7)(d), 501CA, 501CA(3), 501CA(4), 501CA(4)(a), 503, 5001, 5001(c)

Migration Reform (Transitional Provisions) Regulations 1994 (Cth)

Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) ss 2.12AA, 2.52(2)(b)

Crimes Act 1914 (Cth) ss 85ZR, 85ZR(2), 85ZR(2)(b), 85ZS(1)(d)(ii)

Australian Citizenship Amendment Act 1984 (Cth)

CASES
Khalil and Respondent for Home Affairs [2019] FCAFC 151

Plaintiff M1/2021 v Minister for Home Affairs [2022] HCA 17; (2022) 275 CLR 582

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services and Multicultural Affairs v Viane [2021] HCA 41; (2021) 274 CLR 398

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs v McQueen [2024] HCA 11 (2024) 94 ALJR 594

Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services v Thornton [2023] HCA 17; (2023) 276 CLR 136

Lesianawai v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2024] HCA 6; (2024) 98 ALJR 475

Re Harrison and Minister for Immigration and Citizenship [2009] AATA 47; (2009) 106 ALD 666

Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286

HZCP v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection (2019) 273 FCR 121

BSJ16 v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2016] FCA 1181

Hambledon v Minister for Immigration and Border Protection [2018] FCA 7

Assistant Minister for Immigration and Border Protection v Splendido [2019] FCAFC 132

RNSQ v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship and Multicultural Affairs [2023] FCA 1111

BHL19 v Commonwealth of Australia (No 2) [2022] FCA 313 followed AJL20 v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 1305

AJL20 v Commonwealth of Australia [2020] FCA 1305

Singh v Minister for Immigration, Citizenship, Migrant Services & Multicultural Affairs [2024] FCA 1273

Webb v Minister for Home Affairs [2020] FCA 831

Uelese v Minister…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Heathcote and Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Aff... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2025] ARTA 131
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Applicant, a 57-year-old UK citizen, sought a review of a decision by a delegate of the Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of her visa. The case was heard by the Tribunal on 8 and 9 January 2025. The Applicant had made representations to the Minister seeking revocation of the visa cancellation within the required time period and was represented by Mr Michael Jones of Michael Jones Solicitor. The Minister was represented by Ms Vanessa Barros Goncalves of Counsel, instructed by Ms Carly Warren of Sparke Helmore.

The issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant passed the character test under s 501(6) of the Migration Act, and if not, whether there was another reason why the visa cancellation decision should be revoked. The Applicant had a serious criminal history, having been convicted of murder in 2009 and sentenced to life imprisonment. However, she had lived in Australia since childhood and presented a low risk of reoffending. The Tribunal had to weigh these considerations against the seriousness of her criminal offending and the expectations of the Australian community.

The Tribunal found that while the Applicant's criminal history was severe, the other factors in her case, such as her long-term residence in Australia and low risk of reoffending, warranted setting aside the decision not to revoke the visa cancellation. The Tribunal also considered the impact of the visa cancellation on the Applicant's family and the impediments to her removal from Australia. Having considered all the circumstances, the Tribunal decided that the decision under review should be set aside and the cancellation of the Applicant's visa should be revoked.

The Tribunal's decision was based on a detailed consideration of the Applicant's personal circumstances and the relevant legislative provisions. The Tribunal concluded that, despite the seriousness of the Applicant's criminal history, the other factors in her case warranted a favourable outcome. The Tribunal's decision was made in accordance with the Migration Act and relevant case law, and the Minister's decision not to revoke the visa cancellation was set aside.

Background

Background to the litigation

The Applicant is a 57-year-old citizen of the United Kingdom. On 8 October 2009, the Applicant was convicted of murder in the Brisbane Supreme Court following a jury trial and was sentenced to life imprisonment with parole eligibility after serving 15 years. The Applicant was granted lifetime parole on 3 September 2024. On the same day, she was taken into immigration detention where she remained until the decision of the Tribunal. On 7 November 2024, a delegate of the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa under s501CA(4) of the Migration Act. The Applicant was notified of that decision via email to her then representative on 8 November 2024. On 11 November 2024, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision not to revoke the visa cancellation.

The Applicant made representations to the Minister requesting revocation on 17 July 2020. The Applicant appeared before the Tribunal at a hearing on 8 and 9 January 2025. The hearing was conducted in person at the Sydney Registry of the Tribunal. The Applicant was represented by Mr Michael Jones of Michael Jones Solicitor who appeared in person. The Minister was represented by Ms Vanessa Barros Goncalves of Counsel, instructed by Ms Carly Warren of Sparke Helmore. The Minister’s Representatives also appeared in person. The Tribunal admitted several documents into evidence and took evidence from multiple witnesses including the Applicant and members of her family. Submissions from both parties were received on the issue of the legal consequences of the decision and extent of impediments if removed.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Sub-section 501CA(4) of the Migration Act provides that a mandatory cancellation may be revoked if: (a)the Applicant makes representations in accordance with the invitation to do so given by the Minister under s 501CA(3); and (b)the decision-maker is satisfied that:(i) the Applicant passes the character test (as defined by section 501); or (ii) there is another reason why the mandatory cancellation should be revoked. THE HEARING AND THE EVIDENCE The Applicant appeared before the Tribunal at a hearing on 8 and 9 January 2025. The hearing was conducted in person at the Sydney Registry of the Tribunal. At the time of the hearing, the Applicant was in immigration detention at Villawood Hill Detention Centre. The Applicant was represented by Mr Michael Jones of Michael Jones Solicitor who appeared in person. The Minister was represented by Ms Vanessa Barros Goncalves of Counsel, instructed by Ms Carly Warren of Sparke Helmore. The Minister’s Representatives also appeared in person. The Tribunal admitted the following documents into evidence:·Applicant's Updated Bundle of Evidence (filed by the Applicant on 19 December 2024) (Exhibit A1); ·G-Documents G1 - G54, pages 1 – 424 (filed by the Respondent on 25 November 2024) (Exhibit R1);·Tender Bundle TB1 – TB2, pages 1 – 83 (filed by the Respondent on 3 December 2024) (Exhibit R2).·G The Applicant gave evidence and was cross-examined at the hearing. The Tribunal also took evidence from the following witnesses:·Ms Sue Whitehouse, the Applicant’s sister;·Ms Jodie Heathcote, the Applicant’s daughter;·Dr Luke Hatzipetrou, Clinical Psychologist;·Ms Kiara Heathcote, the Applicant’s granddaughter;·Ms Alarna Heathcote, the Applicant’s daughter;·Ms Erin Cameron, Sisters Inside;·Ms Rachel Bates, a friend of the applicant and prospective employer. With the exception of the Applicant all witnesses gave evidence via telephone. At the conclusion of the hearing the parties were invited to make post-hearing submissions on the issue of the legal consequences of the decision and extent of impediments if removed. This invitation was issued following submissions from the Applicant that a legal consequence of the decision would be that due to the operation of Special Return Criterion 5001, the Applicant would not be permitted to return to Australia and that this should weigh in favour of revoking the visa cancellation. Submissions from the Minister were received on 16 January 2025 (Respondent’s supplementary submissions). On 22 January 2025 the Applicant provided brief written submissions in reply (Applicant’s reply).THE APPLICANT’S CONDUCT AND OFFENDING The Applicant’s offending history is set out in the Australian Criminal Intelligence Commission ‘Check Results Report’ dated 8 May 2020.[21][21] R1, G6, pages 46 – 47. As noted above, on 8 October 2009, the Applicant was convicted of murder in the Brisbane Supreme Court following a jury trial. She was sentenced to life imprisonment and made eligible for parole after serving 15 years.

Decision

Reasons for decision

On 7 November 2024, a delegate of the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa under s501CA(4) of the Act (the Reviewable Decision).[14] The Applicant was notified of that decision via email to her then representative on 8 November 2024.[15] This is the reviewable decision before the Tribunal.[14] R1 G3.[15] R1, G2. On 11 November 2024, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision not to revoke the visa cancellation.[16] [16] R1, G1. As the application was made within nine days after notification, it complied with the time limit set by s 500(6B) of the Migration Act. The Tribunal was required by s 500(6L) of the Migration Act to make a decision in relation to this application by no later than 31 January 2025. In considering the application for review, the issues for the Tribunal are:(a)whether the Applicant passes the character test, as defined by s 501(6) of the Migration Act; and(b)if the Applicant does not pass the character test, whether the Tribunal is satisfied that there is another reason why the Cancellation Decision should be revoked.[17][17] See s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act. The Applicant’s case is a complex one. As discussed further below, murder is an offence of the most serious kind presenting a risk of serious harm to the community and the community would expect the Applicant’s visa to remain cancelled. However, she presents a low risk of reoffending and has lived in Australia since she was an infant. She has very close ties to the community through her large Indigenous family. Balancing the considerations in such matters is not an easy task. For the reasons outlined below, having considered all the circumstances of the Applicant’s case and having weighed the relevant matters raised in Direction no.110, the Tribunal has decided that the decision under review should be set aside and the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa should be revoked.VISA CANCELLATION ON CHARACTER GROUNDS The Migration Act provides special powers for the Minister to refuse or cancel visas on character grounds. In some circumstances, such as where a visa is cancelled on character grounds, that cancellation decision can be revoked by the Minister or by the Tribunal on review. These powers generally involve consideration of whether a person passes the character test, and if they do not, consideration of whether there is another reason that the decision to cancel a visa should be revoked. The question for determination by the Tribunal is whether the Reviewable Decision not to revoke the mandatory cancellation of the Applicant’s visa was the correct or preferable one on the material before the Tribunal.[18] [18] Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (repealed) (AAT Act), ss 2A, 33 and 43; Administrative Review Tribunal Act 2024 (Cth) (ART Act) ss 9, 54, 56(1)(a); Administrative Review Tribunal (Consequential and Transitional Provisions No 1) Act 2024 (Cth) (ART Consequential Act No 1), s 3 and Sch 16 Item 24; See also Shi v Migration Agents Registration Authority [2008] HCA 31; (2008) 235 CLR 286 at [140].

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The Applicant made representations to the Minister requesting revocation on 17 July 2020.[13] Regulation 2.52(2)(b) of the Migration Regulations 1994 (Cth) (Migration Regulations) provides that any such representations must be made within 28 days after the person is given the invitation under s 501CA(3) of the Migration Act. The Applicant made representations seeking revocation within the prescribed period and using the Department’s template revocation request and personal circumstances forms. Accordingly, the Tribunal is satisfied that the Applicant made representations in accordance with the invitation for the purposes of s 501CA(4)(a) of the Migration Act. [13] R1, G5, page 27; G10, page 80 (signed 6 June 2020); ASFIC at [5]. The Applicant was granted lifetime parole on 3 September 2024 and was taken into immigration detention where she remained. On 7 November 2024, a delegate of the Minister refused to revoke the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa under s501CA(4) of the Act (the Reviewable Decision).[14] The Applicant was notified of that decision via email to her then representative on 8 November 2024.[15] This is the reviewable decision before the Tribunal.[14] R1 G3.[15] R1, G2. On 11 November 2024, the Applicant applied to the Tribunal for review of the decision not to revoke the visa cancellation.[16] [16] R1, G1. As the application was made within nine days after notification, it complied with the time limit set by s 500(6B) of the Migration Act. The Tribunal was required by s 500(6L) of the Migration Act to make a decision in relation to this application by no later than 31 January 2025. In considering the application for review, the issues for the Tribunal are:(a)whether the Applicant passes the character test, as defined by s 501(6) of the Migration Act; and(b)if the Applicant does not pass the character test, whether the Tribunal is satisfied that there is another reason why the Cancellation Decision should be revoked.[17][17] See s 501CA(4) of the Migration Act. The Applicant’s case is a complex one. As discussed further below, murder is an offence of the most serious kind presenting a risk of serious harm to the community and the community would expect the Applicant’s visa to remain cancelled. However, she presents a low risk of reoffending and has lived in Australia since she was an infant. She has very close ties to the community through her large Indigenous family. Balancing the considerations in such matters is not an easy task. For the reasons outlined below, having considered all the circumstances of the Applicant’s case and having weighed the relevant matters raised in Direction no.110, the Tribunal has decided that the decision under review should be set aside and the cancellation of the Applicant’s visa should be revoked.VISA CANCELLATION ON CHARACTER GROUNDS The Migration Act provides special powers for the Minister to refuse or cancel visas on character grounds. In some circumstances, such as where a visa is cancelled on character grounds, that cancellation decision can be revoked by the Minister or by the Tribunal on review.