FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Haslam v Money for Living (Aust) Pty Ltd [2008] FCA 1536
CORRIGENDUM
MARY ANN HASLAM, BERNARD DICKENS, PHYLLIS LESLIE DICKENS, DELIA LEMON, ESTELL SYLVIA SMITH, THE ESTATE OF ELAINE GAINSFORD, EDWARD JAMES GAINSFORD, ATHOL EASTERBROOK and YVONNE GRAY v MONEY FOR LIVING (AUST) PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 107 611 218), MFL PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 111 105 125), STEPHEN O'NEILL, GARY DENNIS O'NEILL, JOLANTA SIMONE OLSZEWSKI, PERMANENT MORTGAGES PTY LTD (ACN 097 176 362), PERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMTED (ACN 000 001 007), LATROBE INVESTMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 416 211), CASH FLOW KING PTY LTD (ACN 108 343 853), PATRICK O'DONNELL, BILL KAFALTIS, JASON TALEB, KERRILI PTY LTD (ACN 097 980 222) (TRADING AS DIAKOU FAIGEN (A FIRM)), REGISTRAR OF TITLES, MKM CAPITAL PTY LTD (ACN 111 776 464), RECORDER OF TITLES, THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF VICTORIA, THE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF TASMANIA and STABLE TECHNOLOGIES PTY LTD (ACN 062 528 545)
VID 1468 OF 2005
MIDDLETON J
16 OCTOBER 2008 (CORRIGENDUM 11 DECEMBER 2008)
MELBOURNE
IN THE FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
VICTORIA DISTRICT REGISTRY
VID 1468 OF 2005
BETWEEN:
MARY ANN HASLAM
First ApplicantBERNARD DICKENS
Second ApplicantPHYLLIS LESLIE DICKENS
Third ApplicantDELIA LEMON
Fourth ApplicantESTELL SYLVIA SMITH
Fifth ApplicantTHE ESTATE OF ELAINE GAINSFORD
Sixth ApplicantEDWARD JAMES GAINSFORD
Seventh ApplicantATHOL EASTERBROOK
Eighth ApplicantYVONNE GRAY
Ninth ApplicantAND:
MONEY FOR LIVING (AUST) PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 107 611 218)
First RespondentMFL PROPERTY HOLDINGS PTY LTD (ADMINISTRATORS APPOINTED) (ACN 111 105 125)
Second RespondentSTEPHEN O'NEILL
Third RespondentGARY DENNIS O'NEILL
Fourth RespondentJOLANTA SIMONE OLSZEWSKI
Fifth RespondentPERMANENT MORTGAGES PTY LTD (ACN 097 176 362)
Sixth RespondentPERPETUAL TRUSTEE COMPANY LIMTED (ACN 000 001 007)
Seventh RespondentLATROBE INVESTMENT SERVICES AUSTRALIA PTY LIMITED (ACN 007 416 211)
Eighth RespondentCASH FLOW KING PTY LTD (ACN 108 343 853)
Ninth RespondentPATRICK O'DONNELL
Tenth RespondentBILL KAFALTIS
Eleventh RespondentJASON TALEB
Twelfth RespondentKERRILI PTY LTD (ACN 097 980 222) (TRADING AS DIAKOU FAIGEN (A FIRM))
Thirteenth RespondentREGISTRAR OF TITLES
Fourteenth RespondentMKM CAPITAL PTY LTD (ACN 111 776 464)
Fifteenth RespondentRECORDER OF TITLES
Sixteenth RespondentTHE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF VICTORIA
Seventeenth RespondentTHE COMMISSIONER OF STATE REVENUE OF TASMANIA
Eighteenth RespondentSTABLE TECHNOLOGIES PTY LTD (ACN 062 528 545)
Nineteenth Respondent
JUDGE:
MIDDLETON J
DATE OF ORDER:
16 OCTOBER 2008
WHERE MADE:
MELBOURNE
CORRIGENDUM
1.In paragraph 13 of the reasons for judgment after “9 December 2004” and the words “Mortgage entered into between” delete “Elaine Gainsford” and insert “MFLPH”.
2.In paragraph 14 of the reasons for judgment after “23 December 2004 Mortgage entered into between” delete “Estell Smith” and insert “MFLPH”.
3.In paragraph 15 of the reasons for judgment after “22 March 2005 Mortgage entered into between” delete “Athol Easterbrook and Yvonne Gray” and insert “MFLPH”.
I certify that the preceding three (3) numbered paragraphs are a true copy of the Corrigendum to the Reasons…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Haslam v Money for Living (Aust) Pty Ltd and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2008] FCA 1536
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issue was the interpretation of Clause 1.9 of the mortgage and its effect on the priority of interests. The retirees argued that Clause 1.9 did not specifically refer to Perpetual or indicate any existing mortgagee, and therefore did not consent to a later mortgage overriding their interests. Perpetual, on the other hand, contended that the registration of the mortgage simultaneously with the transfer of land meant that the retirees' interests were only created upon registration and were subject to the mortgage. The court had to ascertain whether Clause 1.9 affected the factual position of when the mortgage and lease were created, and whether the registration of the mortgage and transfer of land determined the priority of interests.
The court found that Clause 1.9 did not refer specifically to Perpetual or indicate any existing mortgagee, and therefore did not consent to a later mortgage overriding the retirees' interests. The court also found that Clause 1.9 did not affect the ascertainment of the factual position of when the mortgage and lease were created. If the lease was created prior to the mortgage, then Clause 1.9 would have no impact on the issues raised in the proceeding. If the lease was created after the mortgage, then Perpetual would be entitled to priority assuming the subsequent arrangement was a lease for the purposes of the relevant statutes and came within the scope of Clause 8 of the common provisions of the mortgages. The court further found that the registration of the mortgage simultaneously with the transfer of land did not affect the priority of the retirees' interests as tenants in possession.
The orders of the court were that the parties were to confer and file submissions on the orders sought, including as to costs, by a specified date. If the parties could not agree, they were to file submissions on the orders sought.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The parties confer, and thereafter on or before 4.00pm on 30 October 2008 file and serve minutes of orders sought (including as to costs), or in the event of no agreement, submissions on the orders sought, in light of the above reasons.
Background
Background to the litigation
Full text does not contain this section.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Full text does not contain this section.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Full text does not contain this section.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
Established by: MIDDLETON J
Clause 1.9 did not refer specifically to Perpetual or to any existing mortgagee. I do not consider that cl 1.9 could be construed as a consent by the retirees that a later mortgage could override the interests of the retirees as tenants in possession. Equally, I do not construe cl 1.9 as necessarily indicating that any lease was in existence prior to the mortgage. In my view, cl 1.9 does not affect or impact upon an ascertainment of the factual position of when the mortgage and lease were created in the case of each retiree. If the lease was created prior to the mortgage being given, then cl 1.9, insofar as the retiree’s interest was concerned, would have no impact on the issues raised in this proceeding. If the lease was created after the mortgage in any given case then, as the consent of Perpetual was not given, cl 1.9 would have no impact on the issues raised in this proceeding, and Perpetual would be entitled to priority assuming the subsequent arrangement was in fact ‘a lease’ for the purposes of ss 66 and 77 of the TLA (and the equivalent provisions of the LTA) and comes within the scope of cl 8 of the common provisions of the mortgages.REGISTRATION OF TRANSFER OF LAND AND MORTGAGE As I have already mentioned, it was contended by Perpetual that prior to registration of the transfer of land, any lease by MFLPH would create, at best, a tenancy by estoppel binding on MFLPH and the lessee (the retiree vendor), but not Perpetual. The subsequent transfer it was contended, funded by Perpetual’s advance, could not feed that estoppel at Perpetual’s expense. Perpetual submitted that the mortgage was registered simultaneously with the transfer, with the result that the purchaser/mortgagor never obtained unencumbered title enabling the creation of a tenancy (referring to Abbey National Building Society v Cann [1991] 1 AC 56 at 93; Allsop v Marshall (1942) 59 WN (NSW) 159 at 161-162; Austin Construction Co (Australia) Ltd v Becketts Holdings Pty Ltd (1958) 75 WN (NSW) 444 at 447; Sogelease Australia Ltd v Boston Australia Ltd (1991) 26 NSWLR 1 at 5-8). Perpetual relied principally on Abbey to argue that the interest of the retirees as tenants in possession was only created upon registration of the transfer. Because a mortgage was registered at the same time, Perpetual argued, the interest of a tenant in possession is only in the registered proprietor’s equity of redemption and any such interest of the retirees is subject to the mortgage. Perpetual submitted that, in Abbey, it was the purchaser’s reliance on mortgage funds which demonstrated that the transactions were simultaneous and that, in the present case, the conclusion that the mortgage and purchase were simultaneous arises not from proof that the particular mortgage funds were required for the particular purchase, but from the following facts:(a) the Money for Living entities were in the business of buying and selling properties;(b)during the period between purchase and on-sale, the relevant Money for Living entity was responsible for paying the annuity to the retiree;(c)Money for Living’s only source of funding to make the up-front payments and pay the annuities necessary to its ongoing business was sale proceeds generated by MFL and proceeds of mortgage loans granted by MFLPH, paid directly to MFL by way of loan;(d)in most cases, the payment was made by MFL to the relevant retiree on the same day that the payment was made by Perpetual to MFL;(e)funds on settlement were usually paid to the retiree, any existing mortgagee of the retiree’s interest, and the retiree’s solicitors; and(f)while payments by Perpetual were made to MFL and not MFLPH (the borrower), that occurred because MFLPH had no bank account at the relevant time, and money received by MFLPH was paid straight to MFL and recorded as a loan from MFLPH to MFL. MFL paid MFLPH’s expenses (including its liability to make up-front and ongoing payments to retirees).