Gurnett v The Macquarie Stevedoring Co Pty Ltd [No 2]

Link copied
Case Copied 27 min read
95 CLR 106

THE MACQUARIE STEVEDORING COM-

RESPONDENT.

PANY PROPRIETARY LIMITED High Court-Appellate jurisdiction to "give such judgment as ought to have

been given in the first instance "-Appeal from order of the Supreme Court dis- SYDNEY,

missing appeal-Appeal allowed-Costs against respondent-Application for April 23;

indemnity certificate as to costs in Supreme Court-Power of High Court to award-Judiciary Act 1903-1955 (No. 6 of 1903-No. 35 of 1955), S. 37- MELBOURNE,

Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (N.S.W.), 8. 6.*

The appellate power of the High Court under S. 37 of the Judiciary Act 1903- 1955 to substitute for an order made on an appeal to the Supreme Court such order as that court should have made does not enable it to grant to a party who, as a result of its determination, becomes in effect an unsuccessful respond- ent in the Supreme Court an indemnity certificate under S. 6 of the Suitor's Fund Act 1951 (N.S.W.) in respect of the costs of appeal in the Supreme Court which he as a consequence of such determination becomes liable to bear.

So held by McTiernan, Williams, Webb and Taylor J.J., Dixon C.J. dissenting. Section 6 of the Suitors' Fund Act

of the appeal ordered to be paid and 1951 provides :-" (1) Where an appeal

actually paid by the respondent; against the decision of any court on a

(b) the costs of the appeal incurred by question of law succeeds, the court

the respondent: Provided that the determining the appeal may grant to

amount payable from the Fund pur- the respondent thereto or to any one

suant to paragraph (b) of this subsec- or more of several respondents a certi-

tion shall not exceed the amount ficate (hereinafter in this section

payable pursuant to paragraph (a) referred to as an 'indemnity certifi-

hereof: Provided further that the cate').

amount payable from the Fund under (2) Where a respondent to an appeal

or pursuant to any one indemnity has been granted an indemnity certifi-

certificate shall not in any case exceed cate, such certificate shall entitle the

the sum of five hundred pounds or respondent to be paid from the Fund

such other amount as may be fixed in -(a) the whole of the appellant's costs

lieu therof by the Governor by proc-

95 CLR 107

APPLICATION ON MOTION.

By an order of the High Court an appeal in the present case was allowed and a decision in favour of the respondent company given by the Supreme Court of New South Wales was reversed (Gurnett V. Macquarie Stevedoring Co. Pty. Ltd. 1 ) The respondent company MACQUARIE now moved the High Court for the grant of an indemnity certificate STEVEDORING under 8. 6 of the Suitors' Fund Act 1951 (N.S.W.) in respect of the costs of appeal in the Supreme Court which as a consequence of the High Court's order it became liable to pay.

The relevant statutory provisions are fully set out in the judgments of the Court hereunder.

R. W. Fox, for…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gurnett v The Macquarie Stevedoring Co Pty Ltd [No 2] and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[1956] HCA 29
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of *Gurnett v The Macquarie Stevedoring Co Pty Ltd [No 2]* involved an application to the High Court of Australia by the respondent company for an indemnity certificate under section 6 of the *Suitors' Fund Act 1951* (N.S.W.). This application followed a decision by the High Court allowing an appeal and reversing an order of the Supreme Court of New South Wales, which had previously dismissed the appellant's appeal. As a result of the High Court's determination, the respondent company became liable for the costs of the appeal in the Supreme Court.

The central legal issue before the High Court was whether its appellate jurisdiction, which allowed it to substitute such judgment as ought to have been given in the first instance, extended to granting an indemnity certificate under the New South Wales legislation. Specifically, the Court had to determine if it could grant a certificate in respect of costs incurred in the Supreme Court, even though the Supreme Court itself had not been in a position to grant such a certificate due to its erroneous decision. The Court also considered whether the function of granting an indemnity certificate was outside the scope of its appellate power, particularly if it was seen as relating to recoupment from a governmental fund rather than a matter between the parties.

A majority of the High Court (McTiernan, Williams, Webb, and Taylor JJ.) held that the appellate power of the High Court under section 37 of the *Judiciary Act 1903-1955* did not extend to granting an indemnity certificate under section 6 of the *Suitors' Fund Act 1951* (N.S.W.). The majority reasoned that while the High Court could substitute the order that the Supreme Court ought to have made, this power did not encompass the creation of a new right to indemnity from a State fund, which was a function conferred by State legislation upon State courts. They distinguished this from the power to make orders as to costs between the parties, which is a standard part of appellate jurisdiction. The Court noted that the *Suitors' Fund Act* operated in relation to costs incurred in State courts and that the High Court's jurisdiction was not affected by State legislation in this manner, referencing prior authority that the High Court was not a "court" within the operation of the Act for the purpose of granting such certificates in respect of costs incurred in the High Court itself.

Dixon C.J. dissented, taking the view that the appellate power was broad enough to include the grant of an indemnity certificate. His Honour reasoned that the function of granting a certificate was ancillary to the determination of an appeal and was intimately bound up with the disposition of the appeal and the consequential orders as to costs. He argued that to deny the High Court the power to grant the certificate would be to take too narrow a view of its appellate jurisdiction, which ought to extend to making the complete order that the Supreme Court ought to have made, including any ancillary orders provided for by State law. The application for the indemnity certificate was dismissed.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established