Granitigard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd
Link copied
CaseCopied
72 min read
Full text
FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA
Granitigard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 81
Citation:
Granitigard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd [2011] FCAFC 81
Appeal from:
Granitgard Pty Ltd ACN 007 427 590 v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd ACN 093 837 337 (No 5) [2010] FCA 313
Parties:
GRANITGARD PTY LIMITED ACN 007 427 590 v TERMICIDE PEST CONTROL PTY LTD ACN 093 837 337
File number:
QUD 134 of 2010
Judges:
KENNY, LANDER AND REEVES JJ
Date of judgment:
27 June 2011
Catchwords:
TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct – passing on of information supplied by someone else – consideration of whether company adopts statements of another through display of a document on website – where company removes headings to the documents
TRADE PRACTICES – misleading or deceptive conduct – how words ‘appraised’, ‘assessed’ and ‘inspected’ understood by the ordinary or reasonable members of a class – words must be viewed in their context as a whole
PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – appeal – whether a Jones v Dunkel inference should be drawn by an appellate court when not drawn at first instance – such an inference does not necessarily establish the contrary position – where trial judge failed to address critical relevant evidence appellate court must do so PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – appeal – whether issues not pleaded at first instance but said to be implicitly pleaded can be relied upon on appeal – appellate court should not be required to conduct an inquiry as to whether issues not explicitly pleaded were raised at first instance COSTS – consideration of appellate court’s power to review indemnity costs orders – consideration of rebuttable presumption in O 23 r 11 of the Federal Court Rules – no mistake of fact or error of principle to warrant review of trial judge’s discretion as to costs
[14] The appellant contends that the primary judge erred in finding that the respondent had discharged the onus of establishing the matters required under the relevant provision.
[15] It was submitted that his Honour failed to give adequate weight to the evidence of the second witness, and that the findings of fact were not reasonably open on the material before the Court.
[16] The respondent, for its part, submits that no error is disclosed, and that the conclusions reached were well within the range of outcomes available to the primary judge.
Consideration
[17] It is convenient to deal first with the question of construction, as the resolution of that issue informs the remaining grounds advanced by the appellant.
[18] For the reasons that follow, we are of the view that the appeal should be allowed in part and the matter remitted for further determination.
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Granitigard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd and more:
In the case of Granitigard Pty Ltd v Termicide Pest Control Pty Ltd, the dispute between the parties centred around allegations of misleading or deceptive conduct under Australian trade practices law. Specifically, Granitigard claimed that Termicide had made false representations about the efficacy and testing of Termicide's termite barrier system, Termiglass, by displaying a CSIRO appraisal on its website. The Federal Court of Australia was tasked with determining whether Termicide had adopted the CSIRO appraisal as its own through the display of the document on its website.
The primary legal issues the court needed to address were whether Termicide had adopted the CSIRO appraisal by merely displaying it on its website and whether the terms "appraised," "assessed," and "inspected" used in the CSIRO document should be understood as synonymous. The court also had to consider whether it could draw a Jones v Dunkel inference regarding evidence not addressed by the trial judge and whether issues not explicitly pleaded at first instance could be relied upon during the appeal. Lastly, the court assessed whether the trial judge's costs order should be reviewed.
The court found that Termicide did not adopt the CSIRO appraisal as its own by merely displaying it on its website. The court held that the continued reproduction and linking to the CSIRO appraisal, along with the presence of the CSIRO Appraisals logo, did not imply adoption. Instead, these actions invited readers to form their own opinions on the worth of Termicide's claims regarding Termiglass. The court also clarified that the terms "appraised," "assessed," and "inspected" were not interchangeable and must be understood in their contextual meaning. The court concluded that neither Termicide nor the CSIRO had represented that Termiglass or the Termiglass Termite Barrier System had been "tested" by the CSIRO.
Regarding the drawing of a Jones v Dunkel inference, the court held that such an inference does not necessarily establish the contrary position. Additionally, the court ruled that it should not be required to conduct an inquiry as to whether issues not explicitly pleaded were raised at first instance. Finally, the court found no grounds to review the trial judge's costs order as there was no mistake of fact or error of principle.
The appeal was dismissed, and Termicide was ordered to pay Granitigard's costs of the appeal on a party and party basis.
Orders
Orders of the court
1. The notice of appeal filed on 21 April 2010 be dismissed.
2. The appellant pay the respondent’s costs of this appeal calculated on a party and party basis.
Note:
Background
Background to the litigation
Despite these deficiencies in its notice of appeal, it did become apparent from Granitgard’s written and oral submissions in this appeal what its complaints were. Before turning to consider those, it is appropriate to set out some of the factual background to explain how the CSIRO Appraisal document came to be on Termicide’s website.Factual background to the CSIRO Appraisal The most convenient way to do that is to reproduce that part of the learned trial judge’s decision where he sets out that factual background. None of this historical material is in dispute in this appeal. Excluding certain irrelevant facts and including some information [in square brackets] to further explain some aspects, his Honour said this (at [31]–[41]):31.Termicide specialises in the provision of termite barrier systems in new residential buildings. It also provides a number of other pest control services, including the provision of chemical treatments. For a number of years, Termicide installed the Granitgard barrier system for builders in South East Queensland, purchasing the requisite components of that system from Granitgard. In 2003 Granitgard changed its business model such that it dealt directly with builders, consigning Termicide to the role of its installation subcontractor. This role was not one acceptable to Mr Paul Jeynes [Termicide’s sole director]. To this end and drawing upon his experience with the Granitgard barrier system he set out to develop an alternative barrier system which might then be used by Termicide. He came to select crushed, recycled glass as the candidate material for use within an alternative barrier system. As a candidate that material had the advantages of being cheap and readily accessible.32.In relation to whether Mr Paul Jeynes’ idea might feasibly be translated into a viable termite barrier system Termicide came to take advice from Dr French [a former CSIRO scientist and an expert on termites in the built environment] and a Mr Schaffer.33.By 2003 Mr Schaffer was in private practice having retired from the CSIRO after having spent a working lifetime employed by that organisation in the field of building materials and systems. For over a quarter of a century, until he retired in 2002, Mr Schaffer had been its technical manager responsible for the evaluation of innovative products in the construction industry. He is a tertiary qualified civil engineer. …34.In 2003, after discussions with Mr Jeynes and inspection of the Vision Glass manufacturing plant, Mr Schaffer advised Mr Jeynes that he believed that his idea for the use of crushed glass as a termite barrier was viable. He also told him that, in order for the product appraisal process to proceed, he should commission some laboratory testing of the proposed crushed glass material so as to validate its performance as a termite barrier. Following this, Dr French’s consultancy [Ecospan Consultancy Services] came to be retained by Termicide.35.Thereafter, Termicide came to seek from the CSIRO an appraisal in respect of a particle barrier system which comprised graded glass screenings which Mr Jeynes came to call Termiglass, together with termite strip shielding which came to be called “Termiglass Quikstrip Shielding” used in accordance with an Australian Standard AS 3660.1-2000 Termite Management Part 1: New Building Work [referred to thereafter in the decision as the 2000 Standard].36.In December 2003 the CSIRO issued the CSIRO Appraisal. In that document the following opinion was expressed:In the opinion of CSIRO Appraisals, Termiglass Termite Barrier System will satisfy the requirements of Australian Standard 3660.1-2000 ‘Terminate management – New building work’ as a suitable physical barrier against subterranean termite entry by use of a screenings system, in conjunction with Quikstrip strip shielding, under the following conditions: … [the conditions set out in the primary decision and do not require mention] …37.A later version of the CSIRO Appraisal, issued in June 2006, updated Building Code of Australia (BCA) references. Subject to this, that document repeated the opinion, quoted above, which had been expressed in respect of the satisfaction of the 2000 Standard. Each of these CSIRO documents, as tendered, evidences the opinions of the CSIRO expressed therein.38.…39.Having received the original CSIRO Appraisal, Termicide began supplying and installing the Termiglass barrier system in South East Queensland in 2004. Since then Termicide has become the largest supplier of particle physical barrier systems in South East Queensland.40.Prior to the commencement of these proceedings Termicide maintained and it continues to maintain a website, On the evidence to hand, the content and layout of that website has varied over time. In November 2007, under the heading “Termiglass” the following statement was made on the website:Developed with the environment in mind, Termiglass is crushed glass that makes use of a recyclable product (glass). The glass is crushed to a specific shape and density that is too hard to chew, too heavy to move and too small to crawl through.Used in conjunction with Termicide Strip Shielding, the Termiglass System forms a non-toxic physical barrier that eliminates the possibility of concealed entry by termites. Rated number one on environmental attributes the Termiglass System demonstrates significantly reduced environmental loads in comparison with other related termite barriers in Australia.A link with the CSIRO Appraisals logo opened up the CSIRO Appraisal.41.By 2008, in both April and September and, I infer, in between, given the symmetry of content the following statement was being made on that website under the heading “Termiglass; The Natural Solution”:The Termiglass System is the natural solution to termite protection. The crushed glass forms an impenetrable barrier that rates #1 environmentally. It’s (sic) user friendly application and 60 yr durability is why Termiglass is the natural choice.Immediately underneath this statement appeared a link which allowed the downloading in PDF form of the CSIRO Appraisal. In this period it was also possible to go directly on the website to a page which reproduced the content of the CSIRO Appraisal. Further, the statement made in November 2007, quoted above, was still being made.
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
The most convenient way to do that is to reproduce that part of the learned trial judge’s decision where he sets out that factual background. None of this historical material is in dispute in this appeal. Excluding certain irrelevant facts and including some information [in square brackets] to further explain some aspects, his Honour said this (at [31]–[41]):31.Termicide specialises in the provision of termite barrier systems in new residential buildings. It also provides a number of other pest control services, including the provision of chemical treatments. For a number of years, Termicide installed the Granitgard barrier system for builders in South East Queensland, purchasing the requisite components of that system from Granitgard. In 2003 Granitgard changed its business model such that it dealt directly with builders, consigning Termicide to the role of its installation subcontractor. This role was not one acceptable to Mr Paul Jeynes [Termicide’s sole director]. To this end and drawing upon his experience with the Granitgard barrier system he set out to develop an alternative barrier system which might then be used by Termicide. He came to select crushed, recycled glass as the candidate material for use within an alternative barrier system. As a candidate that material had the advantages of being cheap and readily accessible.32.In relation to whether Mr Paul Jeynes’ idea might feasibly be translated into a viable termite barrier system Termicide came to take advice from Dr French [a former CSIRO scientist and an expert on termites in the built environment] and a Mr Schaffer.33.By 2003 Mr Schaffer was in private practice having retired from the CSIRO after having spent a working lifetime employed by that organisation in the field of building materials and systems. For over a quarter of a century, until he retired in 2002, Mr Schaffer had been its technical manager responsible for the evaluation of innovative products in the construction industry. He is a tertiary qualified civil engineer. …34.In 2003, after discussions with Mr Jeynes and inspection of the Vision Glass manufacturing plant, Mr Schaffer advised Mr Jeynes that he believed that his idea for the use of crushed glass as a termite barrier was viable. He also told him that, in order for the product appraisal process to proceed, he should commission some laboratory testing of the proposed crushed glass material so as to validate its performance as a termite barrier. Following this, Dr French’s consultancy [Ecospan Consultancy Services] came to be retained by Termicide.35.Thereafter, Termicide came to seek from the CSIRO an appraisal in respect of a particle barrier system which comprised graded glass screenings which Mr Jeynes came to call Termiglass, together with termite strip shielding which came to be called “Termiglass Quikstrip Shielding” used in accordance with an Australian Standard AS 3660.1-2000 Termite Management Part 1: New Building Work [referred to thereafter in the decision as the 2000 Standard].36.In December 2003 the CSIRO issued the CSIRO Appraisal. In that document the following opinion was expressed:In the opinion of CSIRO Appraisals, Termiglass Termite Barrier System will satisfy the requirements of Australian Standard 3660.1-2000 ‘Terminate management – New building work’ as a suitable physical barrier against subterranean termite entry by use of a screenings system, in conjunction with Quikstrip strip shielding, under the following conditions: … [the conditions set out in the primary decision and do not require mention] …37.A later version of the CSIRO Appraisal, issued in June 2006, updated Building Code of Australia (BCA) references. Subject to this, that document repeated the opinion, quoted above, which had been expressed in respect of the satisfaction of the 2000 Standard. Each of these CSIRO documents, as tendered, evidences the opinions of the CSIRO expressed therein.38.…39.Having received the original CSIRO Appraisal, Termicide began supplying and installing the Termiglass barrier system in South East Queensland in 2004. Since then Termicide has become the largest supplier of particle physical barrier systems in South East Queensland.40.Prior to the commencement of these proceedings Termicide maintained and it continues to maintain a website, On the evidence to hand, the content and layout of that website has varied over time. In November 2007, under the heading “Termiglass” the following statement was made on the website:Developed with the environment in mind, Termiglass is crushed glass that makes use of a recyclable product (glass). The glass is crushed to a specific shape and density that is too hard to chew, too heavy to move and too small to crawl through.Used in conjunction with Termicide Strip Shielding, the Termiglass System forms a non-toxic physical barrier that eliminates the possibility of concealed entry by termites. Rated number one on environmental attributes the Termiglass System demonstrates significantly reduced environmental loads in comparison with other related termite barriers in Australia.A link with the CSIRO Appraisals logo opened up the CSIRO Appraisal.41.By 2008, in both April and September and, I infer, in between, given the symmetry of content the following statement was being made on that website under the heading “Termiglass; The Natural Solution”:The Termiglass System is the natural solution to termite protection. The crushed glass forms an impenetrable barrier that rates #1 environmentally. It’s (sic) user friendly application and 60 yr durability is why Termiglass is the natural choice.Immediately underneath this statement appeared a link which allowed the downloading in PDF form of the CSIRO Appraisal. In this period it was also possible to go directly on the website to a page which reproduced the content of the CSIRO Appraisal. Further, the statement made in November 2007, quoted above, was still being made.
Decision
Reasons for decision
Thus, for the purposes of this representation issue, so far as it relates to para 8(e), the critical issue is whether Termicide, or more particularly the CSIRO, in its Appraisal document, made a statement to the effect that the Termiglass Termite Barrier System (not Termiglass itself) had been “tested by the CSIRO”.The decision below on the representations in issue In relation to the representations pleaded in paras 8(c) and 8(d), the learned trial judge concluded that Termicide did not merely act as “a postman” (a term taken from the decision of French J in Gardam v George Willis & Co (1988) 82 ALR 415 at 427) in reproducing the CSIRO Appraisal document on its website, but neither did it do anything to adopt the CSIRO Appraisal document as its own. Specifically, he said (at [57]–[58]):The continued reproduction of the CSIRO Appraisal and of the link to that document tells both in favour of the drawing of an inference of adoption and against that conclusion. To borrow from Gardam v George Willis & Co, I accept that Termicide is not just “a postman”. A postman has an occupational role that allows the inference readily to be drawn that he or she is disinterested in the mail being conveyed and the contents of that mail. Termicide is clearly not disinterested in that sense. Yet the reproduction of and the link to the CSIRO Appraisal are also consistent with an inference that what Termicide is doing is not adopting the CSIRO Appraisal but rather inviting the reader to read that document and then form his or her own opinion as to the worth of claims that Termicide does itself state on its website. The presence of the “CSIRO Appraisals” logo is also, in my opinion, a neutral factor. It certainly alerts the reader to the fact that this product and system has been appraised by the CSIRO but, objectively, does not, without more, carry with it the necessary implication that the publisher is adopting all or any particular one of the CSIRO’s opinions. This is not to deny that a publisher aware of the favourable contents of such a report and of the standing of a body such as the CSIRO is inherently likely to be aware of a strong probability that a reader who cares to look will regard that report as corroborative of statements the publisher has separately made itself on the website about the product and system. There is though no express adoption and the likelihood of awareness just mentioned is not to be equated with a necessary implication flowing from an objective assessment of the website content, reading it as a whole and in context. In the absence of Termicide’s own language on its website either directly or indirectly suggesting an adoption, I am not persuaded that, by maintenance or reproduction alone, it has otherwise adopted as its own the representations alleged in para 8(c) and para 8(d) of the 2nd further amended statement of claim. Those representations are representations of the CSIRO, not Termicide. In short, in the face of the pleaded denial that Termicide has made these representations Granitgard has not made out this aspect its pleaded case.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
As to the question whether Termicide had represented that the CSIRO had tested the Termiglass Termite Barrier System, its counsel submitted that it did not make any such representation. He submitted that the only statement that related to testing in the CSIRO Appraisal document was a statement that Ecospan Consulting Services was conducting a trial. It stated: “a trial has started and will be monitored during the term of the validity of this Technical Assessment”. As such, he submitted it was not open to find that either Termicide or the CSIRO had represented that Termiglass or the Termiglass Termite Barrier System had been “tested by the CSIRO”. He submitted that, when one read the CSIRO Appraisal document as a whole, it was clear that the CSIRO had drawn a distinction between “testing” and “assessing” or “appraising”. Finally, he submitted that an objective reading of the CSIRO Appraisal document did not suggest that the CSIRO had “tested” or purported to test the Termiglass Termite Barrier System, as distinct from “assessed” or “appraised” it.Consideration of the representation issue – adoption by reproduction Both counsel agreed that the question whether Termicide adopted the CSIRO Appraisal document as its own is a question of fact to be determined on all the relevant circumstances of the case. This generally accords with what the High Court said in Butcher v Lachlan Elder Realty Pty Ltd (2004) 218 CLR 592; [2004] HCA 60 (“Butcher”) where the Court emphasised the need to look at the whole of the conduct of the person making the alleged representation to assess whether he or she was merely communicating information provided by another without adopting or endorsing it: see at [39]–[40] per Gleeson CJ, Hayne and Heydon JJ. In his decision in Butcher, McHugh J relevantly described the question as “whether the corporation assumed responsibility for or adopted (or endorsed or used its name in association with) the information so that it would be reasonable for a recipient to rely on the information”: see at [115]. Putting aside any advantages a trial judge may have in assessing the credibility of the witnesses or having the benefit of seeing the entirety of the evidence viewed as a whole, this Court is in as good a position as the learned trial judge to draw its own conclusions on a question of fact such as this: see Fox v Percy (2003) 214 CLR 118; [2003] HCA 22 (“Fox v Percy”) at [23]–[25] and [66]–[68]. Moreover, when this Court is conducting an appeal by way of rehearing such as this, it is required to conduct its own thorough examination of the record and to correct any errors of law or fact that it considers have occurred: see Seven Network Ltd v News Ltd (2009) 182 FCR 160; [2009] FCAFC 166 at [87]. These considerations apply with particular force in this instance because the learned trial judge’s decision on this question of fact did not involve any assessment of the credibility of the witnesses before him and, instead, it was confined to an assessment of the use Termicide made of the CSIRO Appraisal document on its website.