Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer

Link copied
Case Copied 50 min read
DETERMINATION OF APPEAL AGAINST A DECISION OF THE COMMISSION CONSTITUTED BY AN ARBITRATOR
CITATION: Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer [2020] NSWWCCPD 36
APPELLANT: Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd
FIRST RESPONDENT: Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer
SECOND RESPONDENT: Robert Talbot
INSURER: Workers Compensation Nominal Insurer
FILE NUMBER: A1-1066/19
ARBITRATOR: Ms J Toohey
DATE OF ARBITRATOR’S DECISION: 13 September 2019, amended on 1 October 2019
DATE OF APPEAL DECISION: 12 June 2020
SUBJECT MATTER OF DECISION: Application to rely on fresh evidence pursuant to s 352(6) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998; CHEP Australia Ltd v Strickland [2013] NSWCA 351; 12 DDCR 501, alleged factual error: Raulston v Toll Pty Ltd [2011] NSWWCCPD 25; 10 DDCR 156, ‘current work capacity’: Wollongong Nursing Home Pty Ltd v Dewar [2014] NSWWCCPD 55, challenges to credit findings: Devries v Australian National Railways Commission [1993] HCA 78; 177 CLR 472; 112 ALR 641, Fox v Percy [2003] HCA 22; 214 CLR 118; 197 ALR 201; 77 ALJR 989
PRESIDENTIAL MEMBER: Deputy President Michael Snell
HEARING: On the papers
REPRESENTATION: Appellant:
Mr P Macken, solicitor
Leigh Virtue & Associates
First Respondent:
Mr T Ainsworth, solicitor
HWL Ebsworth
Second Respondent:
Ms M Smith, solicitor
Brazel Moore Lawyers
ORDERS MADE ON APPEAL:

1.    The Arbitrator’s determination dated 1 October 2019 is confirmed.

INTRODUCTION AND BACKGROUND

  1. Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd (the employer) operated a business on the Central Coast of New South Wales, carrying out waterproof testing, and associated repairs when leaks were detected. Robert Talbot (the worker) worked full-time for the employer from 3 January 2017. He visited the premises of customers who had issues with water leaks or penetration, tested for leaks, gave quotes, and arranged for contractors to perform remedial works. He carried out banking. He spent much of his time driving a company vehicle to customers’ premises.[1]

    [1] Worker’s statement 24/5/18, [9], [13]–[17], Employer’s Reply (R1 Reply), p 160.

  2. The worker suffered an injury on 7 February 2018. He had carried out an inspection and quote at a customer’s residence. He was parked on a steep incline on a day that was very windy. He stated that he climbed into the driver’s seat of his vehicle, placed the testing equipment, laptop computer and notebooks he had used onto the passenger’s seat, and applied pressure to close the driver’s door. He said the door swung violently towards him, striking his right elbow and crushing it against the door frame.[2] He said he reported the injury to the employer’s administration officer by telephone on the afternoon it happened.[3]

    [2] Worker’s statement 24/5/18, [68]–[74].

    [3] Worker’s statement 24/5/18, [99]–[100].

  3. The worker said that he continued working after the incident. He saw his general practitioner Dr Arndt on 11 February 2018. An x-ray on 12 February 2018 did not show a fracture and he carried on working. The worker stated that Dr Arndt was uninterested in treating a workers compensation matter.

  4. The worker…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd v Workers Compensation Nominal Insu... and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2020] NSWWCCPD 36
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd sought to appeal a decision made by an Arbitrator, arguing that fresh evidence had become available since the arbitration. This evidence was a printout from an internet search which appeared to detail a property sale, and the employer argued that this evidence should be admitted to support their case. The dispute was heard in the New South Wales Civil and Administrative Tribunal.

The court had to determine whether the fresh evidence was admissible under section 352(6) of the Workplace Injury Management and Workers Compensation Act 1998. This involved assessing whether the evidence was not available to the employer prior to the arbitration, whether it could not reasonably have been obtained earlier, and whether its admission was necessary to avoid substantial injustice. Additionally, the court had to consider the relevance and probative value of the document, as well as whether the employer had complied with the procedural requirements outlined in Practice Direction No 6.

The court found that the employer had not provided a schedule or a brief outline of the evidence as required by the Practice Direction. Furthermore, the document's authenticity and probative value were questionable due to the lack of supporting information about its source and reliability. The court noted that documents from the internet could vary greatly in credibility and relevance. The Tribunal concluded that the evidence did not meet the criteria for admissibility under section 352(6) of the Act. The court also highlighted that the document was not logical, probative, or relevant to the facts in issue, and it did not comply with the rules regarding the form of evidence that should be considered by the Tribunal.

The Tribunal confirmed the Arbitrator's determination dated 1 October 2019, dismissing the employer's application to appeal on the basis of the fresh evidence.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Arbitrator’s determination dated 1 October 2019 is confirmed.

Background

Background to the litigation

The case involves an application to rely on fresh evidence in an appeal concerning workers' compensation. The claimant, Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd, had previously been involved in a workers' compensation dispute with an employee. The employee had claimed for injuries sustained at work and received a determination in their favour on 1 October 2019. Subsequently, the employer sought to appeal this decision by relying on fresh evidence, which appears to be a printout from an internet search showing details of a property sale. The document, referred to as the'sale document', includes an address, the owner’s name, an estimated price range, and two transactions in the property’s sales history. The employer has not complied with the requirements set out in Practice Direction No 6, which governs the submission of fresh evidence in such cases.

The matter came before the court as an application for leave to rely on fresh evidence in support of an appeal against a workers' compensation determination. This appeal was against the Arbitrator's decision dated 1 October 2019. The employer, Gradan Bathrooms Pty Ltd, filed an application to appeal the Arbitrator's decision, seeking to introduce a printout from an internet search as fresh evidence. The application did not adhere to the procedural requirements outlined in Practice Direction No 6, particularly concerning the submission of a schedule, a copy, an outline, and reasons for the unavailability of the fresh evidence. The court was tasked with determining whether the employer could rely on this fresh evidence to appeal the Arbitrator's decision.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Practice Direction No 6 relevantly provides:“Fresh evidence, additional evidence14. Fresh evidence, or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against will only be accepted on appeal with the leave of the Presidential member (s 352(6) of the 1998 Act). Leave will not be granted unless the Presidential member is satisfied that: (a) the evidence concerned was not available to the party, and could not reasonably have been obtained by the party, before the proceedings concerned, or(b) that failure to grant leave would cause substantial injustice in the case.15. If a party seeks to rely on fresh evidence, or evidence in addition to or in substitution for the evidence received in relation to the decision appealed against they must provide: (a) a schedule of the fresh, additional or substituted evidence;(b) a copy of the fresh, additional or substituted evidence;(c) a brief outline of the fresh, additional or substituted evidence;(d) the reasons why the fresh, additional or substituted evidence was not in the proceedings before the Arbitrator, and(e) submissions on why the fresh, additional or substituted evidence should be admitted or rejected on appeal.” The fresh evidence involved appears to be a print-out of a page from an internet search, from a site that describes itself as “app.pricefinder.com.au”. On its face, the document gives an address of a property, the owner’s name, an estimated price range and two transactions in the property’s sales history (by price and date). For convenience I will refer to it as the ‘sale document’. It is attached to the employer’s Application to Appeal. The employer has made no attempt to comply with Practice Direction No 6. I infer this document represents a copy of the fresh, additional or substituted evidence on which it seeks leave to rely. Contrary to the Practice Direction there is no schedule describing what it is. There is no brief outline of the document. The employer’s submission appearing below describes, to an extent, the submission the employer seeks to make on the basis of the sale document. The submission states the document could not reasonably have been obtained before the arbitration. It makes no submission about why this is so. An initial point that should be made is that there is nothing that supports the authenticity or probative value of the document. Documents downloaded from the internet can range from documents of a persuasive and serious nature to documents that are of little or no probative value. Frequently the source of a document will help to indicate its probative value, for example documents from a government authority with responsibility for record keeping, a respected dictionary or an academic source. Allsop P in Onesteel Reinforcing Pty Ltd v Sutton referred to r 15.2 of the Workers Compensation Commission Rules 2010 (now 2011) which provides that “evidence should be logical and probative, be relevant to the facts in issue and the issues in dispute, not be based on speculation or unsubstantiated assumptions, nor should it be in the form of unqualified opinions”. His Honour stated:“The rules of evidence do not apply. Thus, there is no prohibition on hearsay material and opinion evidence. Nevertheless, as the cases discussed by McColl JA show, the Commission is required to draw its conclusions from material that is satisfactory, in the probative sense, in order that it act lawfully and in order that conclusions reached by it are not seen to be capricious, arbitrary or without foundational material …”.[58] (excluding citations)[58] [2012] NSWCA 282, [2]–[3].

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the employer is entitled to rely on the printout from an internet search as fresh evidence in the appeal.
2. Whether the employer has complied with the procedural requirements for submitting fresh evidence as outlined in Practice Direction No 6.
3. Whether the fresh evidence, if admitted, would lead to a substantial injustice if not considered in the appeal.

Held
1. The employer is not entitled to rely on the printout from an internet search as fresh evidence in the appeal as it failed to comply with the procedural requirements for submitting such evidence as outlined in Practice Direction No 6.
2. The employer has not complied with the procedural requirements for submitting fresh evidence as outlined in Practice Direction No 6.
3. The fresh evidence, if admitted, would not lead to a substantial injustice if not considered in the appeal.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court examined the employer's application to rely on fresh evidence in the form of a printout from an internet search. The printout, referred to as the 'sale document,' was intended to provide information about a property's address, owner's name, estimated price range, and sales history. The court noted that the employer had not complied with Practice Direction No 6, which requires a detailed submission on fresh evidence, including a schedule, copy, brief outline, reasons for non-availability, and submissions on admissibility. The employer's submission was inadequate as it did not include a schedule, brief outline, or reasons for non-availability, nor did it address the probative value or authenticity of the document.

The court emphasised that documents downloaded from the internet can vary greatly in probative value and authenticity, and that the source of the document can indicate its reliability. Allsop P in Onesteel Reinforcing Pty Ltd v Sutton highlighted that the Commission must draw its conclusions from satisfactory, probative material to act lawfully. Given the employer's failure to comply with Practice Direction No 6, the court found that the employer was not entitled to rely on the fresh evidence.

Regarding the employer's argument that the fresh evidence could not reasonably have been obtained before the arbitration, the court did not find it necessary to address this point due to the procedural non-compliance. The court also concluded that the fresh evidence, if admitted, would not lead to a substantial injustice in the appeal, as the employer had not demonstrated how the sale document would alter the outcome of the appeal. The court confirmed the Arbitrator’s determination, dismissing the employer's application for leave to rely on the fresh evidence.