Lyons v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read
CERTIFICATE OF DETERMINATION OF MEMBER 
CITATION: Lyons v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd [2024] NSWPIC 18
APPLICANT: Bradley Lyons 
RESPONDENT: A & G Engineering Pty Ltd

MEMBER:

Diana Benk

DATE OF DECISION: 12 January 2024
CATCHWORDS:

WORKERS COMPENSATION - Workers Compensation Act 1987; consideration of section 44B; consideration of ‘current work capacity’ under clause 9 of schedule 3 and ‘suitable employment’ under section; Wollongong Nursing Home Pty Limited v Dewar considered; Held – applicant sustained an injury arising out of or in the course of employment with the respondent; applicant has no current work capacity; award for the applicant pursuant to section 36 & 37.

DETERMINATIONS MADE:

The Commission determines:

1.     That the applicant had no current work capacity since 12 May 2022 to 27 February 2023.

2.     That the pre-injury average weekly earnings figure is $1,276.50

3. That the respondent is to pay weekly compensation to the applicant pursuant to ss 36 and 37 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 as indexed from 12 May 2022.

STATEMENT OF REASONS

BACKGROUND

  1. Bradley Lyons (the applicant) sustained injuries to his lumbar spine following a fall at work with A & G Engineering Pty Ltd (the respondent) on 25 November 2015. Liability was accepted on the basis that the applicant was totally unfit for work. Payments appear to have been suspended on 23 December 2015 when the applicant was gaoled.

  2. Following release from gaol on 18 March 2022 the applicant sought treatment and obtained a medical certificate on 12 May 2022 which certified him as having no capacity for work. The applicant then approached the respondent requesting that he be paid weekly compensation.

  3. On 1 June 2022, in response to the claim and following assessment, the respondent denied liability. Internal review was unsuccessful prompting application to the Personal Injury Commission (the Commission) wherein the applicant now seeks an award of weekly payments from 24 December 2015 until 24 December 2020 (referred to as the primary period) based on pre-injury average weekly earnings (PIAWE) of $1,276.50 as adjusted with reference to ss 36, 37 and 38 of the Workers Compensation Act 1987 (the Act). Alternatively, if a finding is made that compensation is not payable whilst in gaol, the applicant claims weekly payments of compensation from 12 May 2022 to 27 February 2023 based on an adjusted PIAWE of $1,463.27 per week and nil capacity for work (referred to as the alternate period).

  4. The matter underwent the usual case management pathway within the Commission. With impasse at conciliation reached, I was requested to determine the matter at arbitration when the applicant was represented by Mr Adhikary instructed by Mr Lehmann and the respondent was represented by Mr Stockley instructed by Mr Michael. Ms Wadick was the insurer representative.

ISSUES FOR DETERMINATION

  1. The parties agree that the following issue remains in dispute:

    (a)    whether the applicant has entitlement to weekly compensation in either the primary or alternate period.

  2. The law relevant to this application is found in the Act.

EVIDENCE

Documentary…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Lyons v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2024] NSWPIC 18
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Lyons v A & G Engineering Pty Ltd involved a claim for workers compensation benefits by the applicant, Lyons, against the respondent, A & G Engineering Pty Ltd. Lyons argued that he sustained an injury arising from his employment with the respondent and that he had no current work capacity, warranting compensation. The respondent contended that Lyons had not provided the required certifications under section 44B of the Workers Compensation Act 1987, and that Lyons had secured employment post-injury, demonstrating his fitness to work. The court was required to determine whether Lyons had sustained an injury in the course of his employment and whether he had no current work capacity as defined under the Act.

The court found that Lyons had failed to comply with the mandatory requirements of section 44B, which demanded the provision of certificates of capacity and declarations of employment status. The court held that the statutory requirement was mandatory and could not be circumvented by a retrospective denial of liability. Consequently, Lyons' claim for benefits during the primary period was rejected. However, the court considered Lyons' alternate claim for benefits from 12 May 2022 to 27 February 2023, noting that Lyons secured employment on 28 February 2023. The court found that Lyons had not provided sufficient evidence to demonstrate that he had no current work capacity during this period, especially considering that he had secured employment. The court held that Lyons had not met the burden of proof required under the Act to establish his entitlement to compensation.

The court concluded that Lyons' claim for workers compensation benefits was unsuccessful. The court held that Lyons had not provided the necessary certifications under section 44B, and that there was insufficient evidence to establish that Lyons had no current work capacity during the relevant period. Consequently, the court dismissed Lyons' claim for weekly compensation benefits.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Section 44B requires the applicant to provide evidence of incapacity and relevantly states: “44B Evidence as to work capacity(1) A worker must provide to the insurer--(a) certificates of capacity in accordance with this section in respect of the period in respect of which the worker is entitled to weekly payments, and(b) a declaration in the form approved by the Authority as to whether or not the worker is engaged in any form of employment or in self-employment or voluntary work for which he or she receives or is entitled to receive payment in money or otherwise or has been so engaged at any time since last providing a certificate under this section.(2) If a decision to reject a claim for weekly payments or to terminate weekly payments is set aside, a worker is not required to comply with this section in respect of any period from the date that the decision took effect until the day on which the decision is set aside.” The respondent submits that the applicant’s claim for weekly benefits during the primary period must fail due to the fact that there is a lack of compliance with s 44B. The applicant maintains that there is no obligation to comply with this section as liability was declined thereby negating the need for certification. I agree with the respondent on this point. The section states that the applicant (worker) “must” provide certification. The requirement is mandatory not discretionary. Review of the section reveals no provision that would relax the above requirement. This statute is clear on this point. I acknowledge the applicant’s submissions that this section should not apply as the claim was ultimately declined. This is true, but the claim was not declined during the primary period and so the compliance obligation remained mandatory until denial on 1 June 2022. I further find that a retrospective denial of liability does not negate the mandatory obligations of the section whilst the claim was accepted as such a denial could not have been forecasted. I find the applicant has failed to meet the mandatory requirements of s 44B and so has not met the criteria for benefit entitlement during the primary period which extends for his entire incarceration. I now will consider the alternate claim between 12 May 2022 to 27 February 2023 noting that the applicant secured employment on 28 February 2023 at a rate greater than his PIAWE. The respondent maintains the applicant was fit for work and demonstrated such fitness by securing that work and that there is no evidence to suggest his fitness level had changed from the point of incarceration until the time that he secured his employment. The applicant submits that the medical evidence of both the treating doctor, neurosurgeon and Dr Doig suggests that the applicant did have varying degrees of incapacity preventing real employment and that the respondent has failed to identify what ‘real employment’ was available to the applicant. For the applicant to be entitled to weekly compensation he must demonstrate during the relevant period that he had “no current work capacity”. The expression, “no current work capacity” is relevantly defined in item 9 of Schedule 3 to the Act as follows:“9 Meaning of ‘current work capacity’ and ‘no current work capacity’(1) An injured worker has current work capacity if the worker has a present inability arising from the injury such that the worker is able to return to the worker’s pre-injury employment, or is able to return to work in suitable employment, but the weekly amount that the worker has the capacity to earn in any such employment is less than the weekly amount that the worker had the capacity to earn in that employment immediately before the injury.(2) An injured worker has no current work capacity if the worker has a present inability arising from an injury such that the worker is not able to return to work, either in the worker’s pre-injury employment or in suitable employment.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.