Gower and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation)

Link copied
Case Copied 17 min read

Gower and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) [2019] AATA 3947 (6 September 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):     2018/3960          

Re:Julie Gower

APPLICANT

AndAustralian Capital Territory

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Member W Frost

Date of decision:   6 September 2019

Date of

written reasons:     27 September 2019

Place:Canberra

The Respondent is released from the implied undertaking in relation to certain documents in issue between the parties.

............................................................

Member W Frost

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – application for release from implied undertaking in relation to medical reports – whether release from implied undertaking applies – reports to be used for purpose of claims management of accepted condition – whether release from implied undertaking should be granted – release from implied undertaking granted

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975

Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988

Cases

Chin and Comcare [2017] AATA 634

Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Plowman (1995) 183 CLR 10

Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125

Idoport Pty Ltd v National Australia Bank Ltd [2001] NSWSC 648

Liberty Funding Pty Ltd v Phoenix Capital Ltd (2005) 218 ALR 283

Otter Gold Mines Ltd v McDonald (1997) 76 FCR 467

Re Environmental Images Pty Ltd and Australian Trade Commission (1996) 45 ALD 674

Re PJ Beaconsfield Gold NL and Australian Securities Commission; Otter Gold NL & Anor (1998) 183 CLR 10

Re Rana and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2009] AATA 361

Re SAN and Military Rehabilitation and Compensation Commission [2008] AATA 237

Springfield Nominees Pty Ltd and Ors v Bridgelands Securities Ltd and Ors (1992) 38 FCR 217

Von Stieglitz and Comcare [2012] AATA 217

Secondary Materials

General Practice Direction, 28 February 2019

REASONS FOR DECISION

Member W Frost

27 September 2019

INTRODUCTION & BACKGROUND

  1. The Applicant, Ms Julie Gower, made a claim for workers’ compensation for a ‘neck sprain’, or cervical injury. In July 2016, Comcare, who was then the relevant insurer (but which is now the Respondent), accepted the claim (2016 Injury). The 2016 Injury arose as a result of Ms Gower’s employment with ACT Health, which involved the use of a computer keyboard and mouse.

  2. In November 2017, Ms Gower claims to have suffered an injury to her lower back due to her repeated bending and lifting of files in the workplace. Ms Gower applied to Comcare under section 14 of the Safety, Rehabilitation and Compensation Act 1988 (SRC Act) for compensation for ‘aggravation of lumbar sprain’ (Claimed Injury). Comcare initially accepted the Claimed Injury, but it subsequently revoked that decision pursuant to a reconsideration decision made on 18 May 2018. Ms Gower’s employer had argued that the Claimed Injury was not a new injury as a result of a new set of circumstances, but that it was the result of referred pain from the 2016 Injury. In revoking its initial decision, Comcare found that there was insufficient evidence to support a finding that Ms Gower had sustained a new injury to her lower back given her medical history, including the 2016 Injury.

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gower and Australian Capital Territory (Compensation) and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 3947
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The Administrative Appeals Tribunal considered a request by the Australian Capital Territory (the Respondent) to be released from an implied undertaking concerning two medical reports (the Reports) prepared by Dr Mourad. Ms Gower (the Applicant) was the subject of these reports, which related to a 2016 injury and a subsequent claimed injury. The core dispute involved whether the Respondent could use these Reports for the purpose of managing Ms Gower's accepted 2016 injury, beyond their initial purpose in the proceeding concerning the claimed injury.

The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether an implied undertaking applied to the Reports, and if so, whether the Respondent should be released from that undertaking to permit the use of the Reports for claims management of the 2016 Injury. The Tribunal was required to determine if such use would cause prejudice to Ms Gower and whether there were sufficient public interest and administrative justice considerations to justify releasing the Respondent from the undertaking.

The Tribunal reasoned that an implied undertaking did apply to the Reports, as they were obtained by the Respondent through Tribunal summonses and were intended for use in the proceeding. However, the Tribunal found that releasing the Respondent from this undertaking was appropriate. It concluded that Ms Gower would not suffer prejudice, as the Reports were expected to enter the public domain if the matter proceeded to a hearing. Furthermore, the Tribunal considered that allowing the Respondent to use the Reports for claims management of the 2016 Injury was in the public interest and served the administration of justice by promoting efficient and effective use of resources and public funds, and by ensuring Ms Gower received appropriate entitlements and treatment. The Tribunal also noted that refusing the request would likely lead to the Respondent obtaining a separate, duplicative report.

The Tribunal ordered that the Respondent be released from the implied undertaking in relation to the medical reports, allowing their use for the purpose of managing Ms Gower's 2016 Injury. The Tribunal was satisfied that disclosure for this purpose was appropriate, given the Respondent's undertaking to limit access to relevant personnel and the protection of personal information under relevant legislation.

Orders

Orders of the court

Full text does not contain this section.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The Tribunal does not consider that Ms Gower would suffer prejudice if the Reports are used by the Respondent for claims management purposes in relation to the 2016 Injury. For the reasons set out above, the Tribunal is satisfied that the Reports are to be used for the legitimate purpose of assisting in ensuring Ms Gower’s entitlements under the SRC Act are correct and that she is receiving the required treatment for the 2016 Injury. Reports publicly available after being taken into evidence The Reports were prepared with the view to them becoming evidence in this proceeding and were, accordingly, expected to enter the public domain when they were taken into evidence at a future hearing by the Tribunal. In this regard, section 35(5) of the Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 sets out that ‘it is desirable…that evidence given before the Tribunal and the contents of documents received in evidence by the Tribunal should be made available to the public and to all the parties’. The fact that this proceeding may not reach a hearing (if, for instance, it was to settle beforehand) should not be determinative of a question of whether to release a party from the implied undertaking if there are good reasons to do so in advance of a document being taken into evidence. Public interest and administration of justice To refuse the Respondent’s request to be released from the implied undertaking would see the unnecessary future duplication of time and resources for the same effect: a report that provides a contemporary assessment of the 2016 Injury. It would also preclude the Respondent from using the Reports for the legitimate reason of effectively and efficiently managing the 2016 Injury to ensure that Ms Gower is receiving the appropriate entitlements under the SRC Act and the necessary associated treatment. Such an outcome would not be in the public interest or ensure the proper administration of justice. To this end, the Reports have an undeniable relevance and importance to assist in the ongoing management of Ms Gower’s 2016 Injury, such that the Respondent should not be precluded from their use for that purpose, including because it is the most efficient and effective course in the circumstances. Utilisation of the Reports in relation to the 2016 Injury will also assist in the correct application of public funds towards Ms Gower’s associated entitlements under the SRC Act. To this end, if the Tribunal did not release the Respondent from the implied undertaking, having regard to Dr Mourad’s assessment of Ms Gower in the Reports, it is highly likely that the Respondent will procure a separate report specifically in relation to the 2016 Injury, and most likely again from Dr Mourad, that the Respondent is able to use for the purpose of its management of the 2016 Injury, without requiring a release from the Tribunal. Plainly, such a course would neither be an efficient nor effective use of the Respondent’s time or of public finances. It would also require Ms Gower to attend a further medical assessment largely covering the same subject matter as the Reports. For these reasons, the Tribunal considers that it is in the public interest and consistent with the administration of justice to release the Respondent from the implied undertaking. Disclosure of personal and sensitive information

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Reports contain personal and sensitive information about Ms Gower’s medical history and circumstances. Disclosure of this information is protected pursuant to legislation such as the Information Privacy Act 2014 (ACT). Additionally, the Respondent has undertaken to only provide the Reports to those managing the 2016 Injury, such as claims managers and rehabilitation providers. As a result, the Tribunal is satisfied that disclosure of the material in the Reports for claims management purposes is appropriate following the release of the Respondent from the implied undertaking. DECISION An implied undertaking applies in relation to the Reports, namely the medical reports of Dr Mourad dated 4 January and 4 February 2019, which were provided to the Respondent’s representative for their use in the present proceeding regarding the Claimed Injury. Having regard to all of the circumstances, the Tribunal considers it to be an appropriate exercise of its discretion to release the Respondent from the implied undertaking so as to allow the Respondent to use the Reports for the ‘collateral or ulterior purpose’ of managing the 2016 Injury. Accordingly, for the reasons set out above, the Tribunal allows the Respondent’s request to be released from the implied undertaking in relation to the Reports.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The circumstances in Warner can be distinguished from the current proceeding before the Tribunal. Here, the Respondent acknowledged that it is bound by the implied undertaking and did not seek to rely on the power under section 58 of the SRC Act to claim that there is no need for it to be released. More importantly, and unlike in Warner, the Respondent put forward good reasons for it to be released from the implied undertaking in relation to the Reports. CONSIDERATIONTribunal’s discretion and basis for implied undertaking The Tribunal has broad discretion in determining whether to release a party from an implied undertaking in a proceeding. In this way, the matters that can be considered are wide-ranging.[16] [16] Liberty Funding at 289-290. The implied undertaking applies to the Reports because they were based on medical records of Ms Gower obtained by the Respondent pursuant to summonses issued by the Tribunal. These records may have been able to be obtained by the Respondent with the consent of Ms Gower, but this consent apparently was not sought by the Respondent before it requested the issuing of summonses for those records. The first of the Reports was also the subject of a direction of the Tribunal for it to be filed and served in the proceeding by the Respondent. Part 5.2 of the General Practice Direction of the Tribunal dated 28 February 2019 prohibits the use of documents provided under compulsion ‘for any purpose other than the purpose for which it was given’ to the Tribunal, unless the documents were received in evidence or the Tribunal gives permission to do so. Uncertainty about relatedness between 2016 Injury and Claimed Injury The uncertainty about whether there is a link between the 2016 Injury and the subsequent Claimed Injury is a critical issue in this proceeding. That is, whether Ms Gower’s Claimed Injury was caused by a new set of circumstances or whether it is referrable to her 2016 Injury. This uncertainty also existed in the course of Comcare’s consideration of, and decision regarding, the Claimed Injury. That is one of the reasons why the Respondent’s representative procured an assessment of Ms Gower by an orthopaedic surgeon, which is set out in Dr Mourad’s Reports. The Reports therefore contain an assessment of the 2016 Injury and Dr Mourad’s opinion regarding its connection to the Claimed Injury. In this regard, apart from the Reports, there has been no assessment by an orthopaedic surgeon of Ms Gower’s 2016 Injury. As a result, the Reports prepared for this proceeding are highly relevant to the accepted claim in relation to the 2016 Injury, including its proper diagnosis and prognosis; its connection with Ms Gower’s employment; and her treatment requirements. Allowing the Respondent to use the Reports for the purpose of managing the 2016 Injury will enable it to consider whether its assessment of the 2016 Injury remains current, which in turn will assist in the allocation of appropriate entitlements under the SRC Act and the required treatment to assist Ms Gower’s recovery. Therefore, even if the 2016 Injury and the Claimed Injury are separate and distinct from each other, which is the finding of Dr Mourad in the Reports, the Tribunal is satisfied that the Respondent should be released from the implied undertaking to facilitate the proper and effective management of the 2016 Injury in circumstances where one of the main reasons the Reports came into existence was to identify the connection, if any, between those injuries. Prejudice