CM and National Disability Insurance Agency [2024] AATA 3308 (21 August 2024)
Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION
File Number(s):2022/5756
2023/1743Re:CM
APPLICANT
AndNational Disability Insurance Agency
RESPONDENT
AndKT
OTHER PARTY
INTERLOCUTORY DECISION
Tribunal:Deputy President Mischin
Date:21 August 2024
Place:Perth
The Tribunal DIRECTS that:
(a)Within 14 days the Applicant file with the Tribunal and serve on the Respondent and the Other Party a copy of all Family Court Orders he considers relevant to the question of the use the Tribunal may make of documents OP4, OP5 and OP9;
(b)Subject to the Tribunal receiving further information, documents OP4 and OP5 ought not to be received into evidence by the Tribunal, as potentially being subject to a ‘Harman’ undertaking to the Family Court of Australia;
(c)Subject to further information and relevance, document OP9, and the Affidavit to Support Application for Intervention Order (Domestic) sworn by the Other Party on 18 May 2020, may be received into evidence by the Tribunal.
......................[Sgd]..................................................
The Hon. Michael Mischin, Deputy President
CATCHWORDS
NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME – Interlocutory application – documents filed by Other Party – whether subject to Harmon undertaking – whether should be received by Tribunal
LEGISLATION
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth)National Disability Insurance Scheme (Children) Rules 2013 (Cth)
CASES
Angas Securities Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2021] WASAT 134
Bruce v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2022] FedCFamC2G 106
Chin v Comcare (2017) 160 ALR 176
Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Plowman (1995) 183 CLR 10
Gower v Australian Capital Territory [2019] AATA 3947
Hearne v Street (2008) 235 CLR 125
Otter Gold Mines Ltd v McDonald (1997) 76 FCR 467
Porter v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (No 2) [2021] FCA 1036
Prudential Assurance Co Ltd v Fountain Page Ltd [1991] 3 All ER 878
Sandy v Yindjibarndi Aboriginal Corporation [No 5] [2020] WASC 470
Skewes v City of Rockingham [2014] WASAT 14Thornton v Workcover Corporation of South Australia [2009] FamCA 449
SECONDARY MATERIALS
Administrative Appeals Tribunal General Practice Direction, Part 5
REASONS FOR INTERLOCUTORY DECISION
Deputy President the Hon. Michael Mischin
21 August 2024
BACKGROUND
The issue before the Tribunal is whether, and to what extent, certain documents filed by the Other Party, or supplied by the Other Party to the Respondent, should be received into evidence by the Tribunal.
The Applicant is the father of two children, to whom I shall refer as ‘Child 1’ and ‘Child 2’, now ten and eight years old respectively. Both children are participants in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (NDIS).
The Other Party is the mother of the children.
The Applicant and the Other Party are estranged and, at the time of these proceedings before the Tribunal, various legal actions were in progress between and involving them, materially a parenting order proceeding in the Family Court of Australia (Family Court) and an Intervention Order (Domestic) proceeding in the Magistrates Court of [redacted].
The Tribunal has before it…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read CM and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2024] AATA 3308
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The legal issues before the Tribunal were whether the Applicant had established the existence of a *Harman* undertaking in relation to documents OP4, OP5, and OP9, and if so, whether special circumstances warranted releasing the Applicant from that undertaking to permit their use in the NDIS Tribunal proceedings. The Applicant contended that these documents originated from Family Court orders made in proceedings between himself and the Other Party, suggesting they were subject to such an undertaking.
The Tribunal considered the Applicant's submissions regarding Family Court orders from March 2021 and February 2022, which he asserted led to the creation of OP4, OP5, and OP9. The Tribunal noted that it is for the court or tribunal to which documents are produced to release a party from an implied undertaking, and that the test for such release involves demonstrating "special circumstances." While acknowledging that courts can exercise discretion to allow documents to be used in tribunal proceedings, the Tribunal expressed reservations about the existence of a *Harman* undertaking for the Affidavit, noting it was created and filed by the Other Party and not objected to.
Consequently, the Tribunal directed the Applicant to file all relevant Family Court Orders within 14 days. The Tribunal indicated that, subject to further information, documents OP4 and OP5 ought not to be received into evidence due to potential *Harman* undertaking restrictions. However, document OP9 and an Affidavit to Support Application for Intervention Order were considered potentially admissible, subject to further information and relevance.
Orders
Orders of the court
Background
Background to the litigation
Evidence
Evidence Before The Court
Decision
Reasons for decision
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
It is for the Court, or the Tribunal, to which the documents have been produced to release a party from the implied undertaking.[7] The test for whether a party should be released from the implied undertaking in relation to a document is whether ‘special circumstances’ exist which affords a reason for modifying or releasing the obligation.[8] It has been accepted that a Court is able to exercise its discretion to release parties from the implied undertaking to allow specific documents to be used in Tribunal proceedings.[9] [7] Prudential Assurance Co Ltd v Fountain Page Ltd [1991] 3 All ER 878 at 885.[8] Hearne at [107]; Angas Securities Ltd and Western Australian Planning Commission [2021] WASAT 134 at [47].[9] see Thornton v Workcover Corporation of South Australia [2009] FamCA 449 at [81]-[99], and Bruce v Victorian WorkCover Authority [2022] FedCFamC2G 106.CONSIDERATION The Applicant’s contention that OP4, OP5 and OP9 were subject to an implied undertaking is founded on several orders he says were made by the Family Court during proceedings involving him and the Other Party. In support of this he quotes in his submissions extracts from three orders as follows:(a)An Order made on 25 March 2021 that:[10][10] Applicant’s Written Submissions paragraph 5. A copy of the full order appears in the First Application Supplementary T-Documents as part of ST1 at pages 163-168 and in the Second Application T-Documents as T5 at pages 28-33.2.The parties do all such things as may be reasonably required to enable a Family Assessment to be carried out with respect to the competing applications for parenting orders before the Court, with such Assessment and the Report arising thereafter:a.To include interviews with the children and, at the discretion of the expert, observed interaction of the children with any relevant adult person in addition to the parties as the expert considers appropriate;b.To be carried out by Ms [AC] of [redacted]…This, presumably, is said to have resulted in OP4.(b)An Order made on 26 March 2021:[11]1.That until further order the children [Child 2] and [Child 1] shall spend time with the father as follows:a.For a period of 8 visits commencing on 27 March 2021 from 12noon [sic] until 4.00pm on Saturday or Sunday of each week with such time to be supervised by Mr [FM]…This, presumably, is said to have resulted in OP9.(c)An Order made on 1 February 2022 that:[12]1. An updated Family Assessment Report be prepared by Ms [AC]…This, presumably, is said to have resulted in OP5.[11] Applicant’s Written Submissions paragraph 6. A copy of the full order appears in the First Application Supplementary T-Documents as part of ST1 at pages 169-173 and in the Second Application T-Documents as T6 at pages 34-38.[12] Applicant’s Written Submissions paragraph 7. A copy of the full order appears in the First Application Supplementary T-Documents as part of ST1 at pages 179-185 and in the Second Application T-Documents as T8 at pages 42-48.