Bradley and National Disability Insurance Agency

Link copied
Case Copied 15 min read

Bradley and National Disability Insurance Agency [2022] AATA 2884 (7 September 2022)

Division:NATIONAL DISABILITY INSURANCE SCHEME DIVISION

File Number(s):      2020/8122, 2021/0352

Re:Richard Bradley

APPLICANT

AndNational Disability Insurance Agency

RESPONDENT

INTERLOCUTORY Decision

Tribunal:Senior Member K Buxton

Date:7 September 2022

Place:Brisbane

The Tribunal refuses to grant to both the Applicant and the Respondent the release from the substantive obligations (known as the Harman Undertaking) owed with respect to the documents they have, respectively, identified.

It is open to the parties to re-enliven their requests, if necessary, after the closure of the evidence in the review applications.

...............[SGD]...............
Senior Member K Buxton

Catchwords

PRACTICE AND PROCEDURE – implied undertaking – where release from the implied undertaking is to assess the Applicant’s entitlements under the NDIS Act – where documents are produced under compulsion – where Applicant opposed release from the implied undertaking – release from the implied undertaking denied

Legislation
Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
National Disability Insurance Agency Act 2013 (Cth)
Privacy Act 1988 (Cth)
Public Service Act 1999 (Cth)

Cases
Chin and Comcare [2017] AATA 634
Esso Australia Resources Ltd v Plowman [1995] HCA 19
Gower v Australian Capital Territory [2019] AATA 3947
Hearne v Street [2008] HCA 36
Porter v Australian Broadcasting Corporation (No 2) [2021] FCA 1036
Treasury Wine Estates [2020] FCAFC 226

Warner v Comcare [2017] AATA 2709

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member K Buxton

7 September 2022

BACKGROUND

  1. Mr Richard Bradley (‘the Applicant’) has been a participant in the National Disability Insurance Scheme (‘NDIS’) since 15 April 2020 in respect to his diagnosis of Autism Spectrum Disorder (‘ASD’). The Applicant filed his first application with the Tribunal on 6 December 2020, seeking review of a decision made by the National Disability Insurance Agency (‘the Respondent’) dated 3 December 2020.[1] The decision, made under section 100(3) of the National Disability Insurance Scheme Act 2013 (Cth) (‘NDIS Act’), confirmed an earlier decision made by the delegate of the Chief Executive Officer (‘CEO’) of the Respondent Agency on 20 July 2020 which approved a statement of participant supports.[2]

    [1] T-documents received for 2020/8122, T1.

    [2] Ibid, T2.

  2. A second application was filed with the Tribunal on 21 January 2021, seeking review of a decision made by the Respondent dated 20 January 2021.[3] The decision, made under section 100(3) of the NDIS Act, confirmed an earlier decision to not review the Applicant’s plan under section 48 of the NDIS Act.[4] The applications are being considered together.

    [3] T-documents received for 2021/0352, T1.

    [4] Ibid, T2.

  3. During the course of the Tribunal’s alternative dispute resolution process and evidence gathering, the Applicant filed multiple reports, documents, and other evidential material on which he intends to rely. In November 2021, the Tribunal granted the Respondent’s request that summons be issued to eleven of the Applicant’s treating practitioners and of those eleven practitioners, nine provided material in response. The Applicant and Respondent inspected the summons material throughout December 2021.

    THE RESPONDENT’S REQUEST FOR RELEASE FROM THE IMPLIED UNDERTAKING

  4. On…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Bradley and National Disability Insurance Agency and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2022] AATA 2884
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application before the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) between Bradley (the Applicant) and the National Disability Insurance Agency (the Respondent). The dispute centred on whether the parties should be released from an implied undertaking regarding documents produced under compulsion during the AAT proceedings. The Applicant opposed the Respondent's request for release.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether to grant the Applicant's and the Respondent's requests for release from the implied undertaking concerning documents produced in response to a summons. The Tribunal considered Part 5 of its General Practice Direction, which outlines the conditions under which an implied undertaking applies to documents obtained under compulsion, and the circumstances in which it may be released. The Tribunal also referred to the High Court's decision in *Hearne v Street*, which established the principle that documents disclosed under compulsion cannot be used for a purpose other than that for which they were given, without leave of the court.

The Tribunal reasoned that the implied undertaking, also known as the Harman Undertaking, continues even after an application has been finalised. It noted that seeking a release to induce the Applicant to discontinue their application was not a proper basis. Furthermore, documents that might be used to make a complaint about a practitioner could also fall outside the scope of the undertaking if they are not used in the course of the review. The Tribunal concluded that there was no pressing need to determine the release requests at that stage of the proceedings.

Consequently, the Tribunal refused the applications to release either party from the substantive obligations owed with respect to the identified documents. The parties were advised that it remained open to them to re-enliven their requests if necessary, after the closure of evidence in the review applications.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

After the Tribunal hearing, documents used in that hearing will no longer be the subject of an implied undertaking and it will not be necessary to determine the requests for release.[36] Seeking a release to induce the Applicant to discontinue his application before the Tribunal is not a proper basis. Similarly, those documents for which the Applicant seeks a release in order to make a complaint about a practitioner may also no longer be caught by the undertaking. Any documents not used in the course of the review, but which the parties submit should nonetheless be the subject of a release, can be identified prior to the Tribunal’s final decision in this review and dealt with at that time. It may be that no documents will ultimately fall into this category and, as there is no pressing need to determine this issue now, the Tribunal declines to release either party from the substantive obligations (known as the Harman Undertaking) owed with respect to the documents identified above.[36] Hearne v Street, [96]. CONCLUSION The applications to release either party from the substantive obligations (known as the Harman Undertaking) owed with respect to the documents identified above are therefore refused at this stage of the proceedings. It is open to the parties to re-enliven their requests, if necessary, after the closure of the evidence in the review applications.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The issue for the Tribunal to consider is whether the Applicant’s and the Respondent’s requests for release from implied undertaking with respect to the summons documents are to be granted.CONSDIERATION Part 5 of the Tribunal’s General Practice Direction provides:[19][19] Administrative Appeals Tribunal General Practice Direction, part 5. 5.2 If you or the decision-maker have obtained a document provided under compulsion in an application before the AAT, you, the decision-maker and any person to whom the document is given, by implication, undertake to the AAT that the document will not be used for any purpose other than the purpose for which it was given to us unless:(a) the document was received in evidence by us in the application and the confidentiality of the document is not protected by an order under section 35 of the AAT Act or by another statutory provision; or(b) we give you or the decision-maker permission to use the document for another purpose.5.3 Documents to which the implied undertaking applies include:(a) documents lodged under section 37 or 38AA of the AAT Act;(b) documents lodged pursuant to a direction given by us (for example, expert reports or witness statements); and(c) documents produced in response to a summons issued by us.The implied undertaking continues even after an application has been finalised. Breach of the implied undertaking by using the documents for another purpose may constitute a criminal offence under section 63 of the AAT Act on the basis that it could, if the AAT were a court of record, constitute a contempt of court. The majority of the High Court in Hearne v Street (‘Hearne v Street’)[20] set out the following principle in relation to the implied undertaking and explored circumstances in which it ceases to be relevant:[21] Where one party to litigation is compelled, either by reason of a rule of court, or by reason of a specific order of the court, or otherwise, to disclose documents or information, the party obtaining the disclosure cannot, without the leave of the court, use it for any purpose other than that for which it was given unless it is received into evidence (emphasis added). The types of material disclosed to which this principle applies include documents inspected after discovery, answers to interrogatories, documents produced on subpoena, documents produced for the purposes of taxation of costs, documents produced pursuant to a direction from an arbitrator, documents seized pursuant to an Anton Piller order, witness statements served pursuant to a judicial direction and affidavits…It is common to speak of the relevant obligation as flowing from an "implied undertaking”. [20] [2008] HCA 36.[21] Ibid, [96] – [97]. The court also noted that, whilst described in the language of an implied undertaking, the parties owed a substantive obligation to treat the documents in this way.[22] The Court described the broad types of material disclosed to which this principle applies, including documents produced on subpoena, documents produced pursuant to directions, witness statements and affidavits.[23] [22] Ibid, [106]. [23] Ibid, [96].