Godden v State of Queensland

Link copied
Case Copied 35 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Godden v State of Queensland & Ors [2016] QSC 224

PARTIES:

ALAN LESLIE GODDEN

(plaintiff)

v
STATE OF QUEENSLAND

(first defendant)
NORTHBUILD CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD
(ACN 011 063 764)
(second defendant)
GOLD COAST CITY COUNCIL
(third defendant)
NORTHBUILD FM PTY LTD
(ACN 127 455 547)
(fourth defendant)
KEENTEX PTY LIMITED
(ACN 003 887 036)
(fifth defendant)    

FILE NO:

BS4171 of 2011

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Applications

DELIVERED ON:

5 October 2016

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

13 September 2016

JUDGE:

Mullins J

ORDER:

1. The period of limitation for bringing this proceeding against the fifth defendant is extended to and including 27 November 2014.

2. The plaintiff must on or before 4pm on 21 October 2016 amend the second further amended statement of claim to remove the description of the earthworks and civil works that the fifth defendant was retained to perform as “construction of retention basin complete”.

3. There is liberty to each of the plaintiff and the fifth defendant to apply on three days’ notice in writing to the other.

CATCHWORDS:

LIMITATION OF ACTIONS – EXTENSION OR POSTPONEMENT OF LIMITATION PERIOD – EXTENSION OF TIME IN PERSONAL INJURIES MATTERS – KNOWLEDGE OF MATERIAL FACTS OF DECISIVE CHARACTER – GENERALLY – where plaintiff injured when his motorcycle slid on dust or debris dropped on the road by trucks or vehicles from nearby construction site – where the plaintiff sued the owner of the site and the builder about a week prior to the expiry of the limitation period – where two and one-half years later the builder identified the earthworks subcontractor as a possible defendant – where the plaintiff was granted leave to commence proceedings for liability for personal injury against that subcontractor – where plaintiff sued subcontractor within one year after the builder identified the subcontractor as a possible defendant – where the subcontractor pleads that the plaintiff’s claim is time-barred – where the plaintiff applies to extend the limitation period – whether material fact of decisive nature was not within the means of knowledge of the plaintiff before one year prior to suing the subcontractor – whether limitation period should be extended


Limitation of Actions Act
1974 (Qld), s 30, s 31
Motor Accident Insurance Act 1994 (Qld), s 5

Brisbane South Regional Health Authority v Taylor (1996) 186 CLR 541, considered
Lawes v Nominal Defendant [2008] 1 Qd R 369; [2007] QCA 367, considered
State of Queensland v Stephenson (2006) 226 CLR 197; [2006] HCA 20, followed
Wood v Glaxo Australia Pty Ltd [1994] 2 Qd R 431; [1993] QCA 114, followed

COUNSEL:

R A I Myers for the plaintiff

M S Trim for the fifth defendant

SOLICITORS:

Shine Lawyers for the plaintiff

Clyde & Co for the fifth defendant

  1. By application filed on 11 July 2016, the plaintiff seeks an extension of the period of limitation to 27 November 2014 for his claim against the fifth defendant for damages for personal injuries sustained by the…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Godden v State of Queensland and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2016] QSC 224
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

Godden, the plaintiff, brought an action against the State of Queensland, the defendant, seeking damages for injuries sustained in a motorcycle accident caused by dust or debris dropped on the road by trucks or vehicles from a nearby construction site. The plaintiff sued the owner of the site and the builder about a week prior to the expiry of the limitation period, and two and one-half years later the builder identified the earthworks subcontractor as a possible defendant. The plaintiff then sued the subcontractor within one year after the builder identified the subcontractor as a possible defendant. The subcontractor pleaded that the plaintiff’s claim was time-barred, and the plaintiff applied to extend the limitation period.

The court had to determine whether a material fact of decisive nature was not within the means of knowledge of the plaintiff before one year prior to suing the subcontractor, and whether the limitation period should be extended. The plaintiff conceded that amendments were required to the statement of claim to reflect the role of the fifth defendant on site leading up to the time of the accident as subcontractor to do earthworks and civil works, but not restricted to the retention basin. The court held that the plaintiff’s claim against the fifth defendant was on the basis that, at the time of the accident, the fifth defendant was performing earthworks and civil works pursuant to the construction of retention basin subcontract which the plaintiff admits was not carried out until after the accident. Therefore, the plaintiff could not succeed on its statement claim as presently formulated against the fifth defendant.

The court found that the fifth defendant’s vehicles were on site in May 2008, and some of the job dockets that relate to invoice 1567 are arguably consistent with the fifth defendant undertaking earthworks or civil works, apart from mere hire of vehicles. The court also found that the remittance advice from Northbuild to the fifth defendant in respect of a payment of $115,556.10 made on 16 May 2008 in respect of invoice 1496 dated 31 March 2008, and the subcontract payment assessments in respect of the two progress claims, are not easily reconcilable with the description of this work in paragraph 17 of Mr Rodi’s affidavit, if it was intended to convey that a subcontract for a value of $304,577.38 was for hourly hire work only.

The court concluded that the material fact of decisive nature that the fifth defendant was performing earthworks and civil works pursuant to the construction of retention basin subcontract was not within the means of knowledge of the plaintiff before one year prior to suing the subcontractor. The court held that the limitation period should be extended, and made an order extending the period of limitation for bringing this proceeding against the fifth defendant to and including 27 November 2014. The court also ordered that the plaintiff must on or before 4pm on 21 October 2016 amend the second further amended statement of claim to remove the description of the earthworks and civil works that the fifth defendant was retained to perform as “construction of retention basin complete.” The court further granted liberty to each of the plaintiff and the fifth defendant to apply on three days’ notice in writing to the other.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The period of limitation for bringing this proceeding against the fifth defendant is extended to and including 27 November 2014.

2. The plaintiff must on or before 4pm on 21 October 2016 amend the second further amended statement of claim to remove the description of the earthworks and civil works that the fifth defendant was retained to perform as “construction of retention basin complete”.

3. There is liberty to each of the plaintiff and the fifth defendant to apply on three days’ notice in writing to the other.

Background

Background to the litigation

Full text does not contain this section.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

As the plaintiff’s claim against the fifth defendant is on the basis that, at the time of the accident, the fifth defendant was performing earthworks and civil works pursuant to the construction of retention basin subcontract which the plaintiff admits was not carried out until after the accident, the plaintiff cannot succeed on its statement claim as presently formulated against the fifth defendant. During the hearing of the application for extension of the limitation period, the plaintiff conceded amendments were required to the statement of claim to reflect the role of the fifth defendant on site leading up to the time of the accident as subcontractor to do earthworks and civil works, but not restricted to the retention basin. The fifth defendant did not concede that such foreshadowed amendment did not add a new cause of action.The evidence of the fifth defendant’s on site role in March-May 2008 In 2008 BJR Plant Hire was a separately incorporated company with the same directors, Mr and Mrs Rodi, as the fifth defendant. BJR Plant Hire was deregistered under s 601AB of the Corporations Act 2001 on 16 January 2011. Mr Rodi has sworn an affidavit for the purpose of the applications that endeavours to explain the differing roles of BJR Plant Hire and the fifth defendant at the site. Mr Rodi deposes to factual matters that are the basis for the fifth defendant’s defence. Mr Rodi refers to the job dockets numbered between 564 and 588 and dated between 8 and 29 May 2008 and job dockets numbered 4118 and 4120 dated respectively 6 and 12 May 2008 which are listed in the tax invoice 1567 as all relating to hourly hire work undertaken by BJR Plant Hire for Northbuild Civil Pty Ltd. It is difficult to reconcile Mr Rodi’s allegation that BJR Plant Hire undertook this work with the contents of invoice 1567 which is headed in the name of the fifth defendant, although it has a stylised “BJR” on the invoice under which are the words “Plant Hire & Civil Construction”. The job dockets numbered between 564 and 588 appear to come from a pre-printed docket book that shows the name of the supplier as “BJR Plant Hire & Civil Construction A division of Keentex Pty Ltd”. Both the job dockets and invoice 1567 therefore support the plaintiff’s allegation that it was the fifth defendant’s vehicles that were on site in May 2008. Some of the job dockets that relate to invoice 1567 are also arguably consistent with the fifth defendant undertaking earthworks or civil works, apart from mere hire of vehicles. Job docket number 573 dated 15 May 2008 refers to “dig out wet spot in driveway, load spoil, load good fill” and also “cart fill”. Job docket number 575 dated 16 May 2008 claims for two labourers in connection with “retain carpark entrance” and there is also a reference to “dig wet area in bus lane” and “cart fill”. Amongst the documents disclosed to the plaintiff by the second defendant was a remittance advice from Northbuild to the fifth defendant in respect of a payment of $115,556.10 made on 16 May 2008 in respect of invoice 1496 dated 31 March 2008. That is supported by the second defendant’s document entitled “Subcontract Payment Assessment” in respect of invoice 1496 being progress claim number 1 for subcontract C002S01 with the fifth defendant. That shows the contract value for excavation and cut and shaping batters as $155,180 in respect of which the payment of $115,555.10 was made with retention held of $8,534.90. Progress claim number 2 in relation to the same subcontract shows an extensive number of variations which appear to relate to surface preparation. The total value of the variations was $149,397.38. The revised subcontract value was shown as $304,577.38. Progress claim number 2 was made on 25 April 2008 in respect of which a payment was made by the second defendant of $127,259.87 and retention held was $8,216.86. The subcontract payment assessments in respect of the two progress claims are not easily reconcilable with the description of this work in paragraph 17 of Mr Rodi’s affidavit, if it was intended to convey that a subcontract for a value of $304,577.38 was for hourly hire work only:“Since all hourly hire work was invoiced on the day of the work (that was the usual way these invoices were issued in my business), this tells me that the date on the subcontract payment assessments of 31 March 2008 and 25 April 2008 (numbered 1496 and C002S01 PC2) would also have likely been the dates by which the work in those payment assessments work was undertaken.”

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.