Gale v Australian Financial Complaints Authority

Link copied
Case Copied 37 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Gale v Australian Financial Complaints Authority [2023] FCA 470

File number(s): VID 501 of 2022
Judgment of: MCEVOY J
Date of judgment: 15 May 2023
Catchwords: SUPERANNUATION – appeal from a decision of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority – the Authority approved a decision of the second respondent (Trustee) that the applicant was not entitled to a pension payable from his superannuation fund commencing from the date he turned 55 – the Trustee and the Authority found that the applicant did not meet a condition of release in item 108 of Sch 1 of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) as the pension benefit was not a non-commutable benefit – appeal allowed – the Authority erred in finding that the pension benefit was commutable – the Authority did not properly consider the plan rules for the superannuation fund, which only allowed commutation of the benefit on the approval of the Trustee – Authority ought to have engaged more meaningfully with the question of whether the Trustee’s decision to not compromise the claim was fair and reasonable in the circumstances
Legislation:

Acts Interpretation Act 1901 (Cth) s 25D

Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) ss 1055, 1055A,1057

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Act 1993 (Cth)

Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) regs 1.03, 1.06, 6.01, 6.17, 6.17C, 6.18, sch 1

Cases cited:

Attorney-General (Cth) v Breckler (1999) 197 CLR 83; [1999] HCA 28

Board of Trustees of the State Public Sector Superannuation Scheme v Edington (2011) 119 ALD 472; [2011] FCAFC 8

Boensch v Pascoe (2019) 268 CLR 593; [2019] HCA 49

Brown v Repatriation Commission (1985) 7 FCR 302; [1985] FCA 236

Carter v Commissioner of Taxation (2020) 279 FCR 83; [2020] FCAFC 150

Collector of Customs v Pozzolanic Enterprises Pty Ltd (1993) 43 FCR 280; [1993] FCA 456

Edser v QSuper Board [2021] FCA 1437

EEU20 v Meat Industry Employees' Superannuation Fund Pty Ltd (Trustee) (No 2) [2020] FCA 1536

Haritos v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2015) 233 FCR 315; [2015] FCAFC 92

Lykogiannis v Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Limited (2000) 97 FCR 361; [2000] FCA 327

Mercer Superannuation (Australia) Ltd v Billinghurst (2017) 255 FCR 144; [2017] FCAFC 201

Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611; [2010] HCA 16

Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs v Wu Shan Liang (1996) 185 CLR 259; [1996] HCA 6

Minister for Immigration and Multicultural Affairs v Yusuf (2001) 206 CLR 323; [2001] HCA 30

QSuper Board v Australian Financial Complaints Authority (2000) 276 FCR 97; [2000] FCAFC 55

Reeves v Nulis Nominees (Australia) Limited (Trustee) [2022] FCA 627

Repatriation Commission v Owens (1996) 70 ALJR 904

Retail Employees Superannuation Pty Ltd v Crocker (2001) 48 ATR 359; [2001] FCA 1130

Rushton v Commonwealth Superannuation Corporation (No 3) [2021] FCA 358

Seafarers’ Retirement Fund Pty Ltd v Oppenhuis (1999) 94 FCR 594; [1999] FCA 1683

Sharp Corporation of Australia Pty Ltd v…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Gale v Australian Financial Complaints Authority and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FCA 470
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Gale v Australian Financial Complaints Authority, the applicant, a former employee of National Mutual, sought to appeal the decision of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority (A FCA) which upheld the decision of the Trustee of the AXA Australia Superannuation Plan (the AXA Trustee) that the applicant was not entitled to a pension from his superannuation fund from the date he turned 55. The applicant had elected to retain his superannuation benefit as a Deferred Benefit when he resigned from employment with National Mutual in 2000. The issue before the court was whether the A FCA erred in finding that the pension benefit was commutable, and hence did not qualify as a non-commutable life pension, and whether the A FCA properly considered the plan rules for the superannuation fund.

The court found that the A FCA had indeed erred in its classification of the pension as commutable. The court held that the A FCA did not properly consider the plan rules for the superannuation fund, which only allowed commutation of the benefit on the approval of the Trustee. The court also found that the A FCA did not engage meaningfully with the question of whether the Trustee’s decision not to compromise the claim was fair and reasonable in the circumstances. The court held that the A FCA misconstrued the governing rules of the fund and the meaning of “non-commutable life pension” under item 108 of sch 1 of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth).

The appeal was allowed, the determination of the A FCA was set aside, and the matter was remitted to the A FCA to be determined in accordance with s 1055 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) according to law and the governing rules of the applicant’s superannuation fund. The court ordered that the applicant file and serve written submissions on the question of costs, not exceeding three pages, on or before 4.00pm on 22 May 2023. The respondents were also ordered to file and serve written submissions on the question of costs (if any), not exceeding three pages, on or before 4.00pm on 5 June 2023. The question of costs was to be determined on the papers pursuant to s 20A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The appeal be allowed.

2. The determination of the Australian Financial Complaints Authority be set aside and the matter remitted to the Authority to be determined in accordance with s 1055 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) according to law and the governing rules of the applicant’s superannuation fund.

3. On or before 4.00pm on 22 May 2023, the applicant file and serve written submissions on the question of costs, not exceeding three pages.

4. On or before 4.00pm on 5 June 2023, the respondents file and serve written submissions on the question of costs (if any), not exceeding three pages.

5. The question of costs be determined on the papers pursuant to s 20A of the Federal Court of Australia Act 1976 (Cth).

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

I note that in the preparation of these reasons I have drawn from the detailed and comprehensive written submissions filed on behalf of the applicant in support of his application on 7 February 2023.BACKGROUND The applicant was born on 16 September 1964. He will reach his “preservation age” (age 60) on 16 September 2024. The applicant commenced employment with National Mutual on 3 February 1986 when he was 21 years old, and remained in employment with National Mutual until he resigned in November 2000 when he was 36 years old.National Mutual Staff Superannuation Plan Upon commencing employment with National Mutual in 1986 the applicant also became a member of the National Mutual Staff Superannuation Plan (the NM Staff Plan). The trustee of the NM Staff Plan was National Mutual Staff Superannuation Pty Ltd (the NM Trustee).NM Staff Plan transferred to the AXA Australia Superannuation Plan Sometime between 1998 to 2000, following the demutualisation of National Mutual and subsequent acquisition by AXA, the applicant’s benefits in the NM Staff Plan were transferred to the AXA Australia Superannuation Plan (the AXA Plan). The trustee of the AXA Plan was originally AXA Australia Staff Superannuation Plan Pty Ltd, before Mercer Investment Nominees Limited was appointed trustee (the AXA Trustee).Applicant resigns but elects to leave his benefit in the AXA Plan In November 2000, when the applicant was 36 years old, and after more than 14 years of “Membership” of the NM Staff Plan, he resigned from employment with National Mutual and elected to retain his benefit in the AXA Plan as a “Deferred Benefit” in accordance with cl 3A.5.18 of the AXA Plan rules. Clause 3A.5.18 of the AXA Plan rules was apparently in the following terms: Leaving benefits in the PlanIf an AXA Defined Benefit Member…:(a) leaves Service or his or her Service is terminated (whether or not by reason of Retrenchment); and(b) the Member has at least 10 years of Membership,the Member may elect to leave all or part of his or her benefit in the Plan (Deferred Benefit). It appears to be uncontroversial that the purpose of the applicant electing to retain his benefit as a Deferred Benefit was so that upon reaching age 55 he would become entitled to an “early retirement [life] pension” (Early Retirement Pension Option). The Early Retirement Pension Option had been communicated to the applicant in 2000 by the NM Trustee, in the following written terms: When you leave service your benefit consists of a Basic Leaving Service Benefit and Additional Accumulations … You may leave all or part of your benefit in the Plan and be entitled to an Early Retirement Pension from age 55.…Once you reach age 55, but before age 65, you will be able to convert the accumulation of your Basic Leaving Service Benefit to a pension based on the conversion rates applicable to your age at the time of conversion.…Commutation of pensionOnce you have converted your accumulated benefit to a pension, the Trustee will not allow the pension to be commuted back to a lump sum, except in accordance with legislative requirements.(Emphasis added)AXA Plan transferred to the AMP Superannuation Savings Trust

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

As the applicant submits, the principal reasons for the determination which are relevant to the questions of law identified in the amended notice of appeal are that: (a)“the [T]rustee cannot commence payment of the pension under the preservation rules because it is commutable” and “the fund rules permit the early retirement benefit to be commuted” (Commutable Pension Decision);(b)“the trust deed does not explicitly permit the [applicant] to waive his commutation rights” and the Trustee was correct in its statement that it “must treat all members of the fund fairly and equally, and therefore cannot apply individual rules to [the applicant]” and “cannot have a rule for the [applicant] that is different to those for all other relevant members” (No Waiver of Rights Decision); (c)“the trust deed does not explicitly permit the [applicant] to have his pension payments withheld by the [T]rustee” so that the pension entitlements accrue to the applicant but are retained in the fund. “To withhold pension payments, they must first commence. However, … the [T]rustee cannot commence pension payments to the [applicant] until he has satisfied a condition of release. He has not yet satisfied a condition of release” (No Retention of Pension Entitlements Decision); and(d)in relation to whether the Trustee ought to have exercised its power to compromise the applicant’s claim under cl 12(5)(d) of the trust deed, the Authority was satisfied that the Trustee had not made any error and therefore was not empowered to compromise the applicant’s claim (No Compromise of Claim Decision). The Authority also determined that the “[T]rustee did not mislead the complainant.” That aspect of the determination, however, is not challenged on this appeal. The amended notice of appeal identifies the following questions of law in respect of which the applicant appeals from the determination:(a)question 1 concerns the proper construction of the Superannuation Industry (Supervision) Regulations 1994 (Cth) (SIS Regulations) and the governing rules by which the Authority was bound in making the Commutable Pension Decision, and whether or not the Authority: (i)has correctly classified the applicant’s pension as “commutable” according to the governing rules of the fund so as to not then qualify as a “non-commutable life pension”; and (ii)has correctly construed the meaning of “non-commutable life pension” under item 108 of sch 1 of the SIS Regulations;(b)question 2 concerns the No Waiver of Rights Decision and whether the Authority:(i)misconstrued the terms of the trust deed in finding that the applicant had “commutation rights”;(ii)adopted a wrong approach in finding that the applicant could not waive his purported commutation rights because there was no explicit right to waive those rights under the trust deed; and (iii)was wrong as a matter of law in accepting that the Trustee was required to treat all members of the fund “fairly and equally” and in those circumstances could not apply individual rules to the applicant;(c)question 3 concerns the No Retention of Pension Entitlements Decision and whether the Authority: (i)failed to have regard to a material relevant consideration, being the broad powers and discretions of the Trustee under the Signature Super Deed of Amendment to Plan Rules No. 2 dated 9 December 2011 (AMP Plan Rules), to permit a deferral of the cashing of the applicant’s pension entitlements;(ii)misconstrued the AMP Plan Rules as preventing the Trustee from commencing the accrual of the applicant’s entitlement to an early retirement pension from his 55th birthday; and (iii)misconstrued the operation of the “cashing restrictions” under the SIS Regulations as preventing the Trustee from commencing the accrual of the applicant’s entitlement to an early retirement pension from his 55th birthday; and (d)question 4 concerns the No Compromise of Claim Decision and whether the Authority misconstrued the Trustee’s power to compromise claims and erred by determining that in order for the Trustee to compromise a claim the Trustee must be satisfied that it had committed an error.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

Full text does not contain this section.