Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v QH and M Birt Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 68 min read

SUPREME COURT OF QUEENSLAND

CITATION:

Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v QH & M Birt Pty Ltd & Ors [2019] QSC 23

PARTIES:

FULTON HOGAN CONSTRUCTION PTY LTD (ACN 010 240 758)

(applicant)

v
QH & M BIRT PTY LTD (ACN 009 963 222)

(first respondent)
and
KENNETH SPAIN (ADJUDICATOR J55780)
(second respondent)
and
THE ADJUDICATION REGISTRAR, QUEENSLAND BUILDING AND CONSTRUCTION COMMISSION
(third respondent)

FILE NO:

BS 8527 of 2018

DIVISION:

Trial Division

PROCEEDING:

Originating Application

ORIGINATING COURT:

Supreme Court of Queensland at Brisbane

DELIVERED ON:

15 February 2019

DELIVERED AT:

Brisbane

HEARING DATE:

4 September 2018: hearing;
29 October 2018: Parties referred Court to additional decisions;
9 January 2019: Court advised parties that one of those additional decisions had been overturned on appeal (on 21 December 2018);
16 January 2019: further submissions received from applicant;
30 January 2019: further submissions received from first respondent.

JUDGE:

Ryan J

ORDER:

It is declared that one part of the adjudication decision of the Second Respondent, dated 30 July 2018, in relation to adjudication application number 367263 is void for jurisdictional error – that is the part identified as 1(a) in the Originating Application.

The parties are to confer, within 14 days of this order, with a view to agreeing upon the orders to be made to give effect to the declaration, including orders for injunctive relief and for costs.

Failing agreement, the parties are to provide written submissions as to the further orders to be made, including orders for injunctive relief and for costs, within 21 days of this order.

The hearing of the application is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

CATCHWORDS:

CONTRACTS – BUILDING, ENGINEERING AND RELATED CONTRACTS – REMUNERATION – STATUTORY REGULATION OF ENTITLEMENT TO AND RECOVERY OF PROGRESS PAYMENTS – ADJUDICATION OF PAYMENT CLAIMS – GENERALLY – Where it was argued that the adjudicator had exceeded his jurisdiction by adjudicating claims which were not included in the payment claim – where it was argued that the adjudicator had not valued work in accordance with the contract; denied natural justice or failed to give sufficient reasons

Australia Avenue Developments Pty Ltd v Icon Co (NSW) Pty Ltd [2018] NSWSC 1578

Avopiling (NSW) Pty Ltd v Menard Bachy Pty Ltd [2012] NSWSC 1466

Bauen Constructions v Westwood Interiors [2010] NSWSC 1359

BM Alliance Coal Operations Pty Ltd v BGC Contracting Pty Ltd [2012] QSC 346

Brookhollow Pty Ltd v R & R Consultants Pty Ltd [2006]

NSWSC 1

City of Ryde v AMFM Constructions Pty Ltd & Anor [2011]

NSWSC 1469

Coordinated Construction Co Pty Ltd v Climatech (Canberra) Pty Ltd (2005) 21 BCL 364

Cragcorp Pty Ltd v Qld Civil Engineering Pty Ltd & Ors

[2018] QSC 203

Creative Building Services Pty Ltd v TIO Air-conditioning Pty Ltd [2016] ACTSC 367

Downer Construction (Australia) Pty Ltd v Energy Australia (2007) 69 NSLWR 72

Futurepower Developments Pty Ltd v TJ & RF Fordham Pty

Ltd [2017] NSWSC 232

Halkat Electrical Contractors Pty Ltd v Holmwood Holdings

Pty Ltd [2007]…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v QH and M Birt Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] QSC 23
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

In the case of Fulton Hogan Construction Pty Ltd v QH and M Birt Pty Ltd, the applicant, Fulton Hogan, sought a declaration that a part of an adjudication decision was void for jurisdictional error. The dispute arose out of a sub-contract between Fulton Hogan, the contractor, and QBirt, the sub-contractor, for earthworks related to the construction of a dam in North Western Queensland. The matter was heard in the Queensland Supreme Court.

The legal issues before the court involved the validity of the adjudication decision made by the adjudicator, specifically whether the adjudicator had exceeded his jurisdiction by adjudicating claims not included in the payment claim, whether the adjudicator had valued the work in accordance with the contract, and if the adjudicator denied natural justice or failed to provide sufficient reasons. The court needed to determine whether the errors made by the adjudicator were of such a nature that they amounted to a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction, thereby rendering the adjudication decision void.

The court examined the nature, gravity, and effect of the errors made by the adjudicator and assessed whether these errors were sufficient to cause practical injustice to the applicant, thereby vitiating the adjudication. The court concluded that the adjudicator had indeed made errors in his decision, which amounted to a jurisdictional error, leading to the part of the adjudication decision being void. The court ordered the parties to confer to agree on the orders to be made to give effect to the declaration, including orders for injunctive relief and for costs. If the parties could not agree, they were required to provide written submissions within 21 days.

The court issued a declaration that a part of the adjudication decision made by the second respondent was void for jurisdictional error. The parties were directed to confer within 14 days to agree on further orders to be made, including injunctive relief and costs. If they could not agree, written submissions were to be provided within 21 days. The hearing of the application was adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Orders

Orders of the court

It is declared that one part of the adjudication decision of the Second Respondent, dated 30 July 2018, in relation to adjudication application number 367263 is void for jurisdictional error – that is the part identified as 1(a) in the Originating Application.

The parties are to confer, within 14 days of this order, with a view to agreeing upon the orders to be made to give effect to the declaration, including orders for injunctive relief and for costs.

Failing agreement, the parties are to provide written submissions as to the further orders to be made, including orders for injunctive relief and for costs, within 21 days of this order.

The hearing of the application is adjourned to a date to be fixed.

Background

Background to the litigation

His Honour explained[15] that the application of these principles to the circumstances of a given case involved consideration of matters of fact and degree. His Honour also said (citations omitted): “32 As Sir Frederick Jordan said in Ex part Hebburn Ltd; re Kearsley Shire Council …:“… the mere fact that a tribunal has made a mistake of law, even as to the proper construction of a statute, does not necessarily constitute a constructive failure to exercise jurisdiction … But there are mistakes and mistakes; and if a mistake of law as to the proper construction of a statute investing a tribunal with jurisdiction leads it to misunderstand the nature of the jurisdiction which it is to exercise, and to apply ‘a wrong and inadmissible test’ … or to ‘misconceive its duty’, or ‘not to apply itself to the question which the law prescribes’ … or to misunderstand ‘the nature of the opinion which it is to form’ … in giving a decision in the exercise of its jurisdiction or authority, a decision so given would be regarded as given in a purported and not a real exercise of jurisdiction, leaving the jurisdiction in law constructively unexercised, and the tribunal liable to the issue of a prerogative writ of mandamus to hear and determine the matter according to law …33 It is accordingly necessary to consider the nature, gravity and effect of the errors, if any, made by the adjudicator, and to assess, in the context of the purpose and operation of this particular statute, whether the adjudicator breached a basic and essential requirement of the Act by not considering submissions duly made or by failing to make a bona fide attempt to exercise his powers under the Act, or whether the plaintiff was denied natural justice to a degree sufficient to void the jurisdiction.34 The required exercise is to determine whether what occurred worked “practical injustice” on the plaintiff sufficient to vitiate the adjudication.”[15] Ibid [31].Background facts Fulton Hogan, the applicant contractor, and QBirt, the first respondent sub-contractor, entered into a written sub-contract in pursuance of which QBirt was to carry out earthworks for the construction of a dam in North Western Queensland. The sub-contract price was about $8.8 million, with QBirt to make progress payment claims monthly. QBirt made its claims accordingly, but Fulton Hogan did not always pay the full amount claimed for various reasons. By the time of QBirt’s eighth progress payment claim (for work done up until 25 November 2017), the difference between the amount claimed by QBirt and the amount paid by Fulton Hogan was about $1.4 million. QBirt’s November payment claim was referred to adjudication and an adjudication decision was made in respect of it on 28 June 2018. QBirt made its ninth payment claim, for work done up until 25 December 2017, on 18 January 2018. In this claim, QBirt claimed a total amount of $13,674,830.81; an increase of $1,919,255.87 from its November payment claim. Fulton Hogan scheduled a total amount of $10,523,165.80 (an increase of $188,522.69) which was substantially less than the amount claimed.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Issues
1. Whether the adjudicator had exceeded his jurisdiction by adjudicating claims which were not included in the payment claim.
2. Whether the adjudicator had not valued work in accordance with the contract.
3. Whether the adjudicator denied natural justice or failed to give sufficient reasons.

Held
1. The court held that the adjudicator had exceeded his jurisdiction by adjudicating claims which were not included in the payment claim. Specifically, the part of the adjudication decision identified as 1(a) in the Originating Application was declared void for jurisdictional error.
2. The court did not address whether the adjudicator had not valued work in accordance with the contract as this issue was not pursued during the hearing.
3. The court did not address whether the adjudicator denied natural justice or failed to give sufficient reasons as this issue was not pursued during the hearing.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

The court considered the nature, gravity, and effect of the errors made by the adjudicator, assessing whether they constituted a practical injustice to the plaintiff sufficient to vitiate the adjudication. The court noted that the adjudicator's failure to adhere to the scope of the payment claim and to consider all the submissions made by the parties constituted a breach of a basic and essential requirement of the Act. The court found that the adjudicator had not made a bona fide attempt to exercise his powers under the Act and that the plaintiff was denied natural justice to a degree sufficient to void the jurisdiction. The court thus declared that the part of the adjudication decision in question was void for jurisdictional error. The binding legal principle established by this decision is that an adjudicator must strictly adhere to the scope of the payment claim and consider all relevant submissions made by the parties in order to exercise his jurisdiction validly. The court did not distinguish, follow, or depart from prior authority in this regard.