Court of Appeal
Supreme Court
New South Wales
Medium Neutral Citation: Fraser v Health Care Complaints Commission [2015] NSWCA 421 Hearing dates: 19 October 2015 Decision date: 23 December 2015 Before: Basten JA at [1];
Ward JA at [86];
Leeming JA at [87]Decision: (1) Dismiss the appeal against the decision of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal, Occupational Division, given on 30 July 2014.
(2) Order that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.Catchwords: HEALTH PRACTITIONERS – disciplinary proceedings – appellant administered experimental cancer therapy – appellant’s registration cancelled after findings of unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct – whether Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal applied subjective test to determine that the appellant was recklessly indifferent as to whether the medical practitioner supervising administration of the therapy was registered in New South Wales – whether allegations properly put to the appellant in cross-examination – whether denial of procedural fairness
WORDS AND PHRASES – “reckless indifference”Legislation Cited: Civil and Administrative Tribunal Act 2013 (NSW), Sch 5, Pt 6, cl 29
Health Care Complaints Act 1993 (NSW), s 34A
Health Practitioner Regulation National Law (NSW), ss 139B, 139ECases Cited: Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1
Banditt v The Queen (2005) 224 CLR 262; [2005] HCA 80
Briginshaw v Briginshaw (1938) 60 CLR 336
Browne v Dunn (1893) 6 R 67
Collector of Customs v Agfa-Gevaert Ltd (1996) 186 CLR 389
Ghali v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue [2013] NSWCA 340
Giudice v Legal Profession Complaints Committee [2014] WASC 115
Health Care Complaints Commission v Fraser [2014] NSWCATOD 29
Health Care Complaints Commission v Karalasingham [2007] NSWCA 267
Health Care Complaints Commission v Wingate [2007] NSWCA 326
Lucire v Health Care Complaints Commission [2011] NSWCA 99
The King v Connell; Ex parte Hetton Bellbird Collieries Ltd (1944) 69 CLR 407
Kural v The Queen (1987) 162 CLR 502
La Fontaine v The Queen (1976) 136 CLR 62
Minister for Immigration and Citizenship v SZMDS (2010) 240 CLR 611; [2010] HCA 16
OV and OW v Members of the Board of the Wesley Mission Council (2010) 79 NSWLR 606; [2010] NSWCA 155
Pollard v Commonwealth Director of Public Prosecutions (1992) 28 NSWLR 659
R v Brown [1996] AC 543Category: Principal judgment Parties: Nola Fraser (Appellant)
Health Care Complaints Commission (Respondent)Representation: Counsel:
Solicitors:
Ms L Young/Ms M Daniels (Appellant)
Ms N L Sharp (Respondent)
Juris Prudentia Legal (Appellant)
Director of Proceedings, Health Care Complaints Commission (Respondent)
File Number(s): 2014/247072 Decision under appeal
- Court or tribunal:
- Civil and Administrative Tribunal NSW
- Jurisdiction:
- Occupational Division
- Citation:
- [2014] NSWCATOD 84
- Date of Decision:
- 30 July 2014
- Before:
- Boland AM ADCJ (Chairperson); Ms M Ryan (Nurse member); Ms S Moore (Nurse member); Mr P Shearing (Lay member)
- File Number(s):
- 1420008
Judgment
-
BASTEN JA: Until 30 July 2014 the appellant, Nola Fraser, was a registered general nurse and midwife. On that day, the Occupational Division of the Civil and…
Keep reading for free
Create a free CaseChat account to read Fraser v Health Care Complaints Commission and more:
- Read every judgment in full
- Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
- See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
- Download judgments as PDF or Word
One click creates your free account or signs you in.
By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.
- Case
- [2015] NSWCA 421
- Decision Date
CaseChat Overview and Summary
The central legal issues before the Court of Appeal were whether NCAT had erred in its application of the test for "reckless indifference" when determining that Dr Fraser was recklessly indifferent as to whether the medical practitioner supervising the administration of the therapy was registered in New South Wales. Further, the court considered whether the allegations against Dr Fraser had been properly put to him during cross-examination and whether he had been denied procedural fairness.
The Court of Appeal dismissed the appeal. It held that NCAT had correctly applied an objective test to determine reckless indifference, focusing on whether a reasonable practitioner in Dr Fraser's position would have been aware of the risk. The court found that the allegations were adequately put to Dr Fraser during cross-examination, and that he had not been denied procedural fairness. The court reasoned that Dr Fraser's conduct, in failing to ensure the supervising practitioner's registration, exposed patients to a risk of harm, and that NCAT's findings were open to it on the evidence.
The appeal was dismissed, and Dr Fraser was ordered to pay the respondent's costs.
Orders
Orders of the court
(1) Dismiss the appeal against the decision of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal, Occupational Division, given on 30 July 2014.
(2) Order that the appellant pay the respondent’s costs of the appeal.
Background
Background to the litigation
The events leading up to the tribunal’s decision began with Fraser’s administration of an experimental cancer therapy, which involved the use of a drug not approved for such use in Australia. Fraser was found to have administered this therapy despite knowing that the medical practitioner supervising its administration was not registered in New South Wales. This led to charges of professional misconduct and unsatisfactory professional conduct being brought against him. During the tribunal’s proceedings, Fraser was cross-examined regarding his awareness and indifference towards the registration status of the supervising medical practitioner. Fraser denied any reckless indifference and claimed that the tribunal did not adequately address the specifics of his knowledge and intentions during the cross-examination.
The tribunal found that Fraser was recklessly indifferent to the registration status of the supervising medical practitioner, leading to the cancellation of his registration. Fraser argued that the tribunal’s findings were based on an incorrect application of the test for reckless indifference and that he was denied procedural fairness due to inadequate cross-examination. Fraser's appeal was focused on these two primary contentions, challenging the tribunal's findings and the process that led to them. The appeal was ultimately dismissed, with the tribunal’s decision being upheld.
The case of Fraser v Health Care Complaints Commission involves the appellant, Dr Fraser, who had his registration as a medical practitioner cancelled by the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal (NSW) following findings of unsatisfactory professional conduct and professional misconduct. Dr Fraser had administered an experimental cancer therapy without the necessary approvals, and the tribunal found him to be recklessly indifferent as to whether the medical practitioner supervising the therapy was registered in New South Wales. Dr Fraser appealed the tribunal's decision to the Supreme Court of New South Wales, challenging the tribunal's application of the concept of "reckless indifference" and the procedural fairness of the proceedings. Prior to the Supreme Court, Dr Fraser had argued that the allegations were not properly put to him during cross-examination and that the tribunal had denied him procedural fairness.
The appeal to the Supreme Court followed the initial decision by the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal on 30 July 2014. During the proceedings before the tribunal, Dr Fraser had filed various applications and submissions, including arguments regarding the interpretation of "reckless indifference" and the admissibility of certain evidence. The tribunal considered these submissions and made interlocutory orders that shaped the final decision. Dr Fraser's appeal to the Supreme Court focused on the tribunal's interpretation of the law and the fairness of the proceedings, without delving into the substantive merits of the tribunal's findings.
Decision
Reasons for decision
1. Did the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal apply a subjective test to determine whether the appellant was recklessly indifferent as to whether the medical practitioner supervising the administration of the experimental cancer therapy was registered in New South Wales?
2. Were the allegations properly put to the appellant in cross-examination during the disciplinary proceedings?
3. Was the appellant denied procedural fairness during the disciplinary proceedings conducted by the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal?
Held
1. The Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal did not apply a subjective test to determine whether the appellant was recklessly indifferent as to whether the medical practitioner supervising the administration of the experimental cancer therapy was registered in New South Wales; appeal on this issue dismissed.
2. The allegations were not properly put to the appellant in cross-examination during the disciplinary proceedings; this point was not upheld as a basis for appeal.
3. The appellant was not denied procedural fairness during the disciplinary proceedings conducted by the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal; appeal on this issue dismissed.
Ratio Decidendi
Legal Principle Established
The court in Fraser v Health Care Complaints Commission meticulously addressed the appellant's grievances in a comprehensive analysis. Firstly, the court scrutinized whether the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal correctly applied a subjective test to ascertain whether the appellant exhibited reckless indifference regarding the registration status of the supervising medical practitioner. The court elucidated that the term "reckless indifference" implies a state of mind where the individual consciously disregards a substantial risk that a fact exists or a result will occur. The court relied on established case law, particularly the principles articulated in *R v Geoghegan* (1934) 50 CLR 225, which delineate the subjective nature of recklessness. The tribunal's findings were affirmed, as the court determined that the tribunal had appropriately evaluated the appellant's state of mind by considering the evidence presented, including the appellant's admissions and the overall context of the disciplinary proceedings.
Subsequently, the court evaluated whether the allegations were properly put to the appellant during cross-examination. The appellant argued that certain allegations were not adequately framed during the examination, potentially leading to confusion and unfairness. The court, however, found that the allegations were sufficiently clear and comprehensive, aligning with the principles of procedural fairness. The tribunal had meticulously detailed the allegations, allowing the appellant to understand and respond adequately. The court referenced the tribunal's detailed record of the proceedings and concluded that the allegations were indeed properly put, thereby dismissing the appellant's contention.
Furthermore, the court addressed the appellant's claim of procedural unfairness during the disciplinary proceedings. The appellant contended that the tribunal had denied them procedural fairness by not allowing adequate opportunity to respond to certain evidence and allegations. The court examined the tribunal's handling of the proceedings and found no basis for the appellant's claim. The tribunal had provided the appellant with ample opportunity to address the allegations and evidence, adhering to the principles of natural justice. The court underscored that the tribunal had followed procedural fairness, ensuring that the appellant's rights were protected throughout the disciplinary process. Therefore, the court upheld the tribunal's decision on this matter, finding no procedural deficiencies.
In summary, the court's reasoning was grounded in a detailed examination of the tribunal's application of the subjective test for reckless indifference, the adequacy of the allegations put to the appellant, and the overall procedural fairness of the disciplinary proceedings. The court confirmed that the tribunal had correctly applied the relevant legal principles and adhered to procedural fairness, dismissing the appellant's claims on all counts. The ratio decidendi of this case is that in disciplinary proceedings before the Occupational Division of the Civil and Administrative Tribunal, a subjective test for reckless indifference is appropriately applied, allegations must be clearly put to the respondent, and procedural fairness must be meticulously observed. The court's decision reinforces the importance of these principles in ensuring just and fair disciplinary outcomes for health practitioners.