Fowler v Commissioner of Taxation

Link copied
Case Copied 69 min read

FEDERAL COURT OF AUSTRALIA

Fowler v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 1040

Citation: Fowler v Commissioner of Taxation [2012] FCA 1040
Parties: MICHAEL PATRICK FOWLER v COMMISSIONER OF TAXATION OF THE COMMONWEALTH OF AUSTRALIA
File number: VID 992 of 2010
Judge: KENNY J
Date of judgment: 21 September 2012
Catchwords:

TAXATION — employee share schemes — where director received options to unissued shares in lieu of cash remuneration — date on which director acquired right to shares — where grant of options conditional on the shareholders’ approval — where approval was expected — nature of right acquired — meaning of “right” in Division 13A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) — right for the purposes of Division 13A acquired only upon the shareholders’ approval — Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) s 139G.

TAXATION — administrative penalties — failure to take reasonable care to comply with a taxation law — where no amount returned in respect of options granted in lieu of cash remuneration — where taxpayer mistaken as to date right to shares acquired — where no evidence of enquiries into tax treatment of options — reasonable care test distinct from reasonably arguable position test — administrative penalty justified — Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth) s 284-90.

Legislation: Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth)
Taxation Administration Act 1953 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001 (Cth)
Cases cited: Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (NT) (2009) 239 CLR 27
Commissioner of Taxation v McWilliam [2012] FCAFC 105
Green v Crusader Oil NL (1985) 10 ACLR 120
Laybutt v Amoco Australia Pty Ltd (1974) 132 CLR 57 Hilder v Dexter [1902] AC 474
Kingston v Keprose Pty Ltd (1987) 11 NSWLR 404 Commissioner of Taxes (Qld) v Camphin (1937) 57 CLR 127
O’Neill v O’Connell (1946) 72 CLR 101 at 129
Adamson v Hayes (1973) 130 CLR 276
Re Henderson’s Caveat [1998] 1 Qd R 632
Forder v Cemcorp Pty Ltd (2001) 51 NSWLR 486
McWilliam v McWilliam’s Wines Pty Ltd (1964) 114 CLR 656
Brown v Heffer (1967) 116 CLR 344
Perri v Coolangatta Investments Pty Ltd (1982) 149 CLR 537
Butts v O’Dwyer (1952) 87 CLR 267
Kennedy v Vercoe (1960) 105 CLR 521
Legione v Hateley (1983) 152 CLR 406
KLDE Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Stamp Duties (Qld) (1984) 155 CLR 288
Baden Pacific Ltd v Portreeve Pty Ltd (1988) 14 ACLR 677
Affinity Health Ltd v Chief Commissioner of State Revenue(NSW) (2005) 60 ATR 1
Hill End Gold Ltd v First Tiffany Resource Corporation [2010] NSWSC 375
GPT RE Ltd v Lend Lease Real Estate Investments Ltd [2005] NSWSC 964
Lend Lease Real Estate Investments Ltd v GPT RE Ltd [2006] NSWCA 207
Dekala Pty Ltd (in liq) v Perth Land & Leisure Ltd (1987) 17 NSWLR 664
Australian Securities and Investments Commission v Carey (No 6) (2006) 153 FCR 509
Bahr v Nicolay [No 2] (1988) 164 CLR 604
Handbury Holdings Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (2008) 74…
CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fowler v Commissioner of Taxation and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2012] FCA 1040
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fowler v Commissioner of Taxation involved Mr Fowler, a non-executive director and later non-executive chairman of Nexus, contesting the tax treatment of options granted to him in lieu of cash remuneration. Nexus, a public company, had instituted an employee share option plan in 2003 and later in 2006, resolved to grant directors options in lieu of cash fees. The main issues before the Court were the identification of the date on which Mr Fowler acquired rights under the options for the purposes of Division 13A of the Income Tax Assessment Act 1936 (Cth) and the rate of the administrative penalty imposed on Mr Fowler for failure to take reasonable care in complying with taxation laws.

The Court held that Mr Fowler acquired rights under the options only upon the shareholders’ approval, as the grant of options was conditional on such approval. The nature of the right acquired under Division 13A was construed as a right to acquire a share in a company, and thus, the right was acquired only when the option was vested, which in this case, was upon shareholders' approval. The Court also upheld the administrative penalty imposed on Mr Fowler for failure to take reasonable care to comply with taxation laws, noting that as a director of a public company, Mr Fowler should have made enquiries into the tax treatment of the options. The penalty was justified as Mr Fowler failed to keep records of important matters connected with the transaction and made no enquiries regarding the tax treatment of the options.

The Court dismissed Mr Fowler's application and ordered that the Commissioner file a draft form of any further order by a specified date, with any submissions on costs to be filed by the parties within the same timeframe.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The application be dismissed.

2. On or before 4:30 pm on 28 September 2012, the respondent file a draft form of any further order.

3. On or before 4:30 pm on 28 September 2012, the parties file any submissions on costs that they wish to make, having regard to the reasons for judgment delivered today.

Note: Entry of orders is dealt with in Rule 39.32 of the Federal Court Rules 2011.

Background

Background to the litigation

The two main issues before the Court concerned the identification of the date on which Mr Fowler acquired relevant rights for the purposes of Division 13A (which has since been repealed) and, assuming that 30 November 2006 was the correct date, the rate of the administrative penalty imposed on Mr Fowler.THE FACTS GIVING RISE TO THE APPEALS Nexus – previously called eNTITy1 Limited – was a public company under s 9 of the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (“Corporations Act”) and was first listed for quotation on the Australian Securities Exchange (“ASX”) on 8 September 2000. When still known as eNTITy1 Limited, the company adopted a constitution (“the constitution”). Mr Fowler was appointed a non-executive director of Nexus on 11 April 2000 and continued as such until 16 November 2007, when he was appointed the non-executive chairman of the board. Shortly after Mr Fowler’s appointment to the board in April 2000, Nexus commenced to conduct the business of oil and gas exploration and production. It was conducting that business in 2006 when the issue of directors’ options first arose, although at that time the company had not yet engaged in the commercial production of oil and gas. At all material times, Tess Aust, an incorporated company and a resident of Australia for the purposes of the ITAA 1936, was the trustee of the Fowler Family Trust. The Fowler Family Trust was a trust established by deed and a tax resident of Australia for the purposes of the ITAA 1936. At all material times, Mr Fowler was an associate of Tess Aust within the meaning of s 139GE of the ITAA 1936. Nexus instituted an employee share option plan in November 2003. At an annual general meeting on 27 November 2003, the shareholders of Nexus passed an ordinary resolution to approve the issue of options under the Nexus Energy Employee Share Option Plan (“ESOP”). The ESOP was governed by the ESOP Rules (“the Rules”). The resolution was in the following terms:That for the purpose of Exception 9(b) in ASX Listing Rule 7.2 and for all other purposes, the shareholders of Nexus approve the issue of Options under the Employee Share Option Plan as detailed in the Explanatory Memorandum which accompanies and forms part of the Notice. About three years later, the issue of the grant of directors’ options in lieu of cash fees arose. There was a board meeting on 26 July 2006, the minutes of which recorded that, at that meeting, the board passed a resolution in the following terms:Accordingly, IT WAS RESOLVED to increase base director’s fees to $60,000 per annum and the chairman’s fees to $120,000 per annum effective immediately. It was also resolved that directors would be entitled to take part or all of their remuneration in the form of options priced on the same basis as under the ESOP scheme and subject to any shareholder and other approvals required. Directors were to notify the chairman of their preferred mix of remuneration. The company’s managing director, Mr Tchacos, subsequently prepared a paper, which was entitled “2006 Employee Share Scheme and Board Options Recommendation” and dated 9 September 2006. The paper recommended the issue of options to employees under the ESOP and the issue of options to members of the board in lieu of cash remuneration.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Full text does not contain this section.

Decision

Reasons for decision

Full text does not contain this section.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

As to penalty, the Commissioner’s fundamental propositions were that: (1) Mr Fowler had a shortfall amount within the meaning of s 284-80 of Schedule 1 to the TAA as a result of a false and misleading statement in his return for the 2007 income year; (2) having regard to Mr Fowler’s position as a company director and the size and nature of the options transaction, it would have been reasonable to expect him to have made enquiries about the tax treatment of options; and (3) since Mr Fowler made no enquiries and failed to keep records of important matters connected with the transaction, a penalty for failure to take reasonable care was justified. On this basis, Mr Fowler was liable to pay an amount of administrative penalty of $48,336.75 for the 2007 income year pursuant to s 284-75 of Schedule 1 to the TAA.CONSIDERATION Primary taxDivision 13A rights Division 13A of the ITAA 1936 is concerned with the acquisition of a share or a right under an employee share scheme, as defined in s 139C set out above. There is no statutory definition of the “right” with which the Division is concerned. The nature of this right must be discerned from the text of Division 13A: see Alcan (NT) Alumina Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Territory Revenue (NT) (2009) 239 CLR 27 at 46-47 [47]. The legislative history of Division 13A is also indicative. The text of Division 13A indicates that the “right” to which its provisions refer is a “right to acquire a share in a company”. Thus, it is only possible for a taxpayer to make an election under s 193E if the rights acquired by the taxpayer satisfy the necessary conditions for “qualifying rights”. Section 139CD(1)(b) indicates that, for there to be a qualifying right, there must first be a right to acquire a share in a company as well as the satisfaction of the relevant specified conditions in that section. Various other provisions of Division 13A support this construction of the intended meaning of the word “right” in the Division: see, for example, ss 139DD, 139FC(1), 139F, 139FE, 139FF, 139G. Further, the predecessor provision to Division 13A, s 26AAC of the ITAA 1936, specifically referred to a “right to acquire a share in a company”. An immediate and unconditional option to acquire shares constitutes a right to acquire shares for the purposes of Division 13A. In this circumstance, in the ordinary case, when an option over unissued shares is granted, s 139G(c) will be satisfied. This conclusion follows from the nature of an option of this kind and is in accordance with authority: see Commissioner of Taxation v McWilliam [2012] FCAFC 105 (“McWilliam”). Options conditional on third party approval An option over unissued shares is a contract made by a company that, if certain conditions are met, it will issue or allot the shares, if and when the option-holder exercises the option. The option-holder is free to decide whether to require the issue or allotment at a future time. See, for example, Green v Crusader Oil NL (1985) 10 ACLR 120 (“Green v Crusader Oil”) at 124; Laybutt v Amoco Australia Pty Ltd (1974) 132 CLR 57 (“Laybutt”) at 76; and Hilder v Dexter [1902] AC 474 at 482-483. If the option-holder decides to exercise the option, then the option-holder is contractually obliged to pay for the shares at the exercise price. The essential terms of an option include: (1) the exercise price; (2) the identification of the subject matter of the option; and (3) the exercise period. It is only when the option-holder is in fact able to exercise the contractual right inherent in an option to acquire the shares that the option-holder can be said to have acquired the option. This cannot occur until the option is granted or “vested”.