Flanagan v Commissioner of Fair Trading

Link copied
Case Copied 28 min read

CITATION: Flanagan v Commissioner of Fair Trading [2004] NSWADT 166
DIVISION: General Division
PARTIES: APPLICANT
Steven Peter Flanagan
RESPONDENT
Commissioner for Fair Trading
FILE NUMBER: 043140
HEARING DATES: 15/07/2004
SUBMISSIONS CLOSED: 08/10/2004
DATE OF DECISION:
08/13/2004
BEFORE: Montgomery S - Judicial Member
APPLICATION: Motor Dealer - grant of licence - Motor Dealers Act - motor dealer - grant of licence
MATTER FOR DECISION: Principal matter
LEGISLATION CITED: Administrative Decisions Tribunal Act 1997
Motor Dealers Act 1974
CASES CITED: Drake v Minister for Immigration and Ethnic Affairs (1979) 2 ALD 60
Hughes and Vale Proprietary Limited v State of New South Wales and Others [1955] 93 CLR 127
Jasmin v Commissioner of Police NSW police Service [2001] NSWADT 45
New South Wales Bar Association-v-Evatt (1968) 117
Sakellis v Officer in Charge of Police Paddington (1968) 88 WN (PT 1)(NSW)
Young Taek Chong v Tomazin (1994) ASC 56-283
Ziems-v-Prothonotary of the Supreme Court of NSW (1957) 97 CLR 279
REPRESENTATION: APPLICANT
S Hall, solicitor
RESPONDENT
J Coss, solicitor
ORDERS: 1. The Commissioner’s determination to cancel Mr Flanagan’s licence is affirmed.; 2. The Commissioner’s determination to disqualify Mr Flanagan from holding a licence under the Act for seven years is set aside. In its place the order is made that Mr Flanagan is disqualified from holding a licence under the Act for two years.

1 This is an application by Steven Peter Flanagan for review of a decision by a delegate of the Commissioner for Fair Trading (“the Commissioner") to cancel his licence as an auto-dismantler.

Background

2 Mr Flanagan was granted a motor dealer's licence in the class auto-dismantler (MD18329) under the Motor Dealers Act 1974 (“the Act") on 10 January 2002. The Licence was due to expire on 10 February 2005. Mr Flanagan trades as Machinery Drive Wreckers in Tweed Heads South.

3 On 4 November 2003 a delegate of the Commissioner issued a Notice to Show Cause under Section 20D of the Act. In the Notice, the delegate of the Commissioner stated that he had reasonable grounds to believe that:

            (a) within the meaning of section 20D(l)(dl)(ii) of the Act, within the preceding 10 years, Mr Flanagan had been found guilty of receiving or of being in unlawful possession of a motor vehicle part;

            (b) within the meaning of section 20D(1)(b) of the Act, Mr Flanagan had been convicted of an offence against the Act;

            (c) within the meaning of section 20D(1)(j) of the Act, Mr Flanagan is not a fit and proper person to continue to hold a licence.

4 The details were particularised in a Schedule to the Notice.

5 On 24 November 2003, Mr Flanagan responded to the Notice. On 5 May 2004 the Manager Fair Trading Investigations with the Office of Fair Trading (“OFT”), Mr Malcolm Finger, under delegation from the Commissioner determined to cancel Mr Flanagan's licence and to disqualify him from holding a licence under the Act for seven years. Mr Finger provided detailed reasons for his decision.

6 It is not in dispute…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Flanagan v Commissioner of Fair Trading and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2004] NSWADT 166
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Flanagan v Commissioner of Fair Trading involved the respondent, the Commissioner of Fair Trading, who sought to cancel the appellant’s licence and disqualify him from holding a licence under the Act for seven years, due to the appellant’s involvement in a dishonest business practice. The appellant, Mr Flanagan, challenged the severity of these penalties, arguing for a lesser period of disqualification. The matter was brought before the court to determine the appropriateness of the penalties imposed.

The court was tasked with determining whether the penalties imposed by the Commissioner were justified and proportionate to the offence committed by Mr Flanagan. The central issue was whether the seven-year disqualification period was appropriate, considering the nature of the dishonest conduct and the appellant’s personal circumstances. The court had to weigh the need to protect the public against the potential overreach of the penalties imposed.

In delivering the judgment, the court affirmed the Commissioner’s decision to cancel Mr Flanagan’s licence but found that the seven-year disqualification period was excessive. The court reasoned that while the appellant’s conduct warranted a significant penalty, a two-year disqualification period was sufficient to achieve the objectives of deterrence and protection of the public, while also considering the appellant’s personal circumstances. Consequently, the court set aside the seven-year disqualification and substituted it with a two-year disqualification period.

The court's final orders were that the Commissioner’s determination to cancel Mr Flanagan’s licence was affirmed. However, the determination to disqualify him from holding a licence under the Act for seven years was set aside and replaced with an order disqualifying him for two years. This decision balanced the need for public protection with the principles of proportionality and fairness.

Orders

Orders of the court

1. The Commissioner’s determination to cancel Mr Flanagan’s licence is affirmed.; 2. The Commissioner’s determination to disqualify Mr Flanagan from holding a licence under the Act for seven years is set aside. In its place the order is made that Mr Flanagan is disqualified from holding a licence under the Act for two years.

Background

Background to the litigation

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established