Fink and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department

Link copied
Case Copied 81 min read

Fink and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department [2021] AATA 734 (31 March 2021)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/3393

Re:Gary Fink

APPLICANT

AndSecretary, Attorney-General's Department

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Date:31 March 2021

Place:Melbourne

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

....................[sgd]....................................................

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

Catchwords

EMPLOYMENT - fair entitlements guarantee - entitlement to redundancy payment - when did employment cease - whether Applicant was employed by a small business – the interaction of the Corporations Act and Fair Entitlement Guarantee Act – insolvency principles - decision affirmed.

Legislation

Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth)
Corporations Act 2001
Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012

Fair Work Act 2009

Cases

Toll (FGCT) Pty Ltd v Alphapharm Pty Ltd (2004) 219 CLR 165
Electricity Generation Corporation t/as Verve Energy v Woodside Energy Ltd (2014) 251 CLR 640
Commissioner of Taxation v The Trustee for the Michael Hayes Family Trust [2019] FCAFC 226
Cooper Brookes (Wollongong) Pty Ltd v Federal Commissioner of Taxation (1981) 147 CLR 297
Jones v Matrix Partners Pty Ltd; Re Killarnee Civil & Concrete Contractors Pty Ltd (in liq) (2018) 260 FCR 310
Mi and Secretary, Department of Employment [2016] AATA 419
Bullivant and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department [2020] AATA 2047
Kita and Secretary, Department of Employment [2016] AATA 214
Kable and Secretary, Attorney General’s Department [2019] AATA 3963

Gayed and Secretary, Department of Jobs and Small Business [2019] AATA 1132

REASONS FOR DECISION

Ms A E Burke AO, Member

  1. Mr Fink (the Applicant) is seeking a second tier review of the decision made by the Secretary, Department of Jobs and Small Business (the Respondent) that he was entitled to a Fair Entitlement Guarantee (FEG) advance for wages and annual leave, but was not entitled to a redundancy payment.

  2. On 19 December 2018 the decision-maker at the FEG branch advised Mr Fink he was entitled to an advancement of FEG in the amount of $10,902.67 comprising $490.20 for unpaid wages, $608.47 for annual leave, $9804.00 for payment in lieu of notice (PILN) and $0.00 for redundancy.

  3. On 16 May 2019, following Mr Fink’s request for a review of the determination, the decision maker at the FEG review team determined Mr Fink was entitled to an additional week’s payment for PILN as his Employment Agreement provided for five weeks PILN; but upheld the determination that Mr Fink had no entitlement to redundancy either by reference to his Employment Agreement, or to the Fair Work Act 2009.

  4. On 12 June 2019 Mr Fink sought a review of the FEG branch decision-maker’s determination by this division of the Tribunal. His reasons for seeking a review were that:

    The Fair Entitlement Guarantee (FEG) has determined that I am not eligible for an advance relating to redundancy based on the following reasons:

    my employment contract included the following clause regarding my entitlement to redundancy: 'If you have completed 12 months' continuous service, on termination of your employment in circumstances of genuine redundancy you will be entitled to…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fink and Secretary, Attorney-General's Department and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2021] AATA 734
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an appeal by Mr Fink to the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (AAT) following the refusal of his claim for redundancy pay under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth) (FEG Act). Mr Fink commenced employment with Unlockd Operations Pty Ltd (Unlockd Operations) in January 2016 and was promoted in July 2017. Unlockd Operations was placed into voluntary administration on 12 June 2018, at which time it employed 33 staff, including Mr Fink. Subsequently, on 20 July 2018, Mr Fink's employment was terminated on the grounds of redundancy.

The primary legal issues before the Tribunal were whether Mr Fink was entitled to redundancy pay under the FEG Act, and whether his employment ceased in circumstances that would trigger such an entitlement. This involved considering the interaction between the FEG Act, the Corporations Act 2001 (Cth) (CA), and the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (FW Act), particularly the National Employment Standards (NES). The Tribunal also had to determine the relevant "governing instrument" for Mr Fink's redundancy entitlements.

The Tribunal reasoned that Mr Fink's redundancy entitlement was governed by his Employment Agreement, which stipulated that upon termination in circumstances of genuine redundancy after 12 months of continuous service, he would be entitled to redundancy pay in accordance with the NES. The Tribunal found that the CA was not a "governing instrument" for employment and its provisions were irrelevant to assessing entitlement under the FEG Act, nor did they impact the operation of the FW Act. Consequently, the Tribunal concluded that Mr Fink's Employment Agreement provided him with a right to redundancy payment under the NES, meaning he was not entitled to an advance for redundancy under the FEG Act.

The Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, upholding the refusal of Mr Fink's claim for redundancy pay under the FEG Act.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

At the hearing of this application on 14 October 2020 by video, Mr Fink was represented by Mr C E A Hibbard of counsel, instructed by McGrath Nicol Liquidators. Ms R W Sweet of counsel, instructed by Ms Cooke of HWL Ebsworth Lawyers, appeared for the Attorney General. The Attorney General lodged a set of paginated documents under s 37 of Administrative Appeals Tribunal Act 1975 (Cth) (the T-Documents) and the Applicant gave evidence at the hearing. BACKGROUND / EVIDENCE On 4 January 2016 Mr Fink commenced work with Unlockd Operation as a Product Manager and on 1 July 2017 was promoted to a Senior Product Manager. Unlockd Operations was described as an Australian-based technology start-up that had developed and patented a unique advertising and content serving process for Android smart phones. On 12 June 2018 Unlockd Operation was placed into voluntary administration. At the time the company employed 33 staff, including Mr Fink. In a document prepared for the Tribunal, the Liquidators advised:By way of background, ….. were appointed voluntary administrators of Unlockd Operations Pty Ltd (Unlockd Operations) (part of a group of company’s [sic] operating a technology start up business) by the company’s directors on 12 June 2018. At that time the company employed 33 staff, including Mr Fink. The Administrators undertook an immediate assessment of the financial position of the company and in light of limited available resources, promptly commenced a strategy to offer the business for sale as a going concern. This approach was pursued to comply with their statutory obligation to endeavour to preserve the business and the employment of its staff as fully as possible or, as far as possible, realise the assets for a greater return than a liquidation. However, as part of the Administrators’ initial assessment of the Group’s operations, the Administrators formed the view that there were insufficient funds available to maintain the full workforce employed on 12 June 2018, and consequently 11 employees were terminated on 13 June 2018. In the two weeks following, another eight staff were made redundant on various dates and two resigned from their employment. The staff that had met the one-year service requirement to claim redundancy have claimed and been paid for these entitlements by the Respondent. Those staff that were retained beyond the end of June 2018 were critical to the success of the attempts to sell the business as a going concern. Regrettably the going concern sale process did not elicit a sustainable offer for the business and on 20 July 2018 the employment of the majority of the remaining 12 staff, including Mr Fink, was terminated on the ground of redundancy. After the Applicant’s FEG claim for redundancy was refused a review was sought (under s.37 of the FEG Act), however FEG determined to uphold its original decision in disallowing Mr Fink’s claim for redundancy. This resulted in the current appeal to the AAT. In summary, this is a situation where the employees of the same company, subject to employment contracts with near identical provisions with respect to entitlement to redundancy, being dismissed within approximately five weeks of each other in the course of an insolvency appointment are being treated entirely inconsistently as a result of the approach being taken by the Respondent.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

The FEG Act clearly states that a person's redundancy pay entitlement is the amount of redundancy pay the person is entitled to under the governing instrument from the employer for termination of the employment. The Tribunal found Mr Fink’s redundancy entitlements were governed by his Employment Agreement at clause 9.10, which stated that if you have completed 12 months' continuous service, on termination of your employment in circumstances of genuine redundancy you will be entitled to redundancy pay in accordance with the National Employment Standards (the NES) as contained in the FW Act. Whilst much was made by the applicant about the impacts of the CA, the CA is not a “governing instrument” for employment; and its provisions are irrelevant when assessing entitlement to an advance under the FEG Act. Additionally, the Tribunal found that the provision of the CA has no bearing on the operations of the FW Act. Therefore, the Tribunal found that Mr Fink’s Employment Agreement, on a plain reading of the words, provided him with a right to a redundancy payment in accordance with the provisions of the NES as contained in the FW Act. And, as such, he was not entitled to an advance for redundancy under the FEG Act. DECISION The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

On 12 June 2018 Unlockd Operation was placed into voluntary administration. At the time the company employed 33 staff, including Mr Fink. In a document prepared for the Tribunal, the Liquidators advised:By way of background, ….. were appointed voluntary administrators of Unlockd Operations Pty Ltd (Unlockd Operations) (part of a group of company’s [sic] operating a technology start up business) by the company’s directors on 12 June 2018. At that time the company employed 33 staff, including Mr Fink. The Administrators undertook an immediate assessment of the financial position of the company and in light of limited available resources, promptly commenced a strategy to offer the business for sale as a going concern. This approach was pursued to comply with their statutory obligation to endeavour to preserve the business and the employment of its staff as fully as possible or, as far as possible, realise the assets for a greater return than a liquidation. However, as part of the Administrators’ initial assessment of the Group’s operations, the Administrators formed the view that there were insufficient funds available to maintain the full workforce employed on 12 June 2018, and consequently 11 employees were terminated on 13 June 2018. In the two weeks following, another eight staff were made redundant on various dates and two resigned from their employment. The staff that had met the one-year service requirement to claim redundancy have claimed and been paid for these entitlements by the Respondent. Those staff that were retained beyond the end of June 2018 were critical to the success of the attempts to sell the business as a going concern. Regrettably the going concern sale process did not elicit a sustainable offer for the business and on 20 July 2018 the employment of the majority of the remaining 12 staff, including Mr Fink, was terminated on the ground of redundancy. After the Applicant’s FEG claim for redundancy was refused a review was sought (under s.37 of the FEG Act), however FEG determined to uphold its original decision in disallowing Mr Fink’s claim for redundancy. This resulted in the current appeal to the AAT. In summary, this is a situation where the employees of the same company, subject to employment contracts with near identical provisions with respect to entitlement to redundancy, being dismissed within approximately five weeks of each other in the course of an insolvency appointment are being treated entirely inconsistently as a result of the approach being taken by the Respondent. On 20 July 2018 Mr Fink was terminated on the grounds of redundancy, at which point the company employed fewer than 15 staff. On 17 October 2018, following an unsuccessful attempt to sell the business, McGrath Nicol were appointed as liquidators of Unlockd Operations. The Administrators’ Report to Creditors dated 10 October 2018 outlines the key events leading to the appointment of Administrators. It advises:On 20 September 2017, Google temporarily disabled AdMob serving to Unlockd, and alleged that the app was not in compliance with AdMob policies. AdMob services were re-enabled on 20 October 2017. On 23 January 2018 Google notified Unlockd that it had until 31 March 2018 to amend its app, or risk being denied access to AdMob. Company records indicate that on 2 March 2018 Google notified Unlockd that it had formed the view that the Unlockd apps also contravened Google Play policies.The parties were ultimately unable to reach a negotiated solution, and in early April 2018 Unlockd Limited and its UK subsidiaries sought an injunction in the UK High Court preventing Google from banning its access to the Google Play Store and AdMob. The UK injunction was granted on 9 May 2018, and a similar injunction was sought and granted by the Australian Federal Court on 31 May 2018.As it [sic] typical for a start-up technology business Unlockd invested significantly in the commercialisation of its patented technology and as such incurred significant operating losses since its formation in 2015. For this reason, equity funding was critical to fund its day to day operations and ongoing expansion. Whilst the Group intended to publicly list in May 2018, the IPO plans were placed on hold following escalation of the dispute with Google, given its potential impact on the Group's business model and financial position.In the absence of a public equity raise, Unlockd concurrently commenced a business sale and private capital raise process with its existing shareholders during May 2018 to raise funds to enable the business to continue trading and pursue its action against Google. Some shareholders provided conditional funding commitments, but ultimately on 11 June 2018 the capital raise failed when insufficient funding commitments were able to be secured.The Directors consider that the aforementioned actions taken by Google led to the Group's demise such that subsequent capital raising required to fund the ongoing operations and Google Proceedings was ultimately materially undersubscribed. The Directors reviewed Unlockd Australia's position and determined that the Australian entities were insolvent and resolved to appoint voluntary administrators…The Administrators consider that the primary reason for Unlockd Australia's failure was the unresolved dispute with Google, given Unlockd's access to Google's Play Store and AdMob platforms was critical to its business model. The dispute and subsequent legal action impeded Unlockd Australia's capacity to raise sufficient capital for the business to continue to trade.