Kable and Secretary, Attorney General's Department

Link copied
Case Copied 9 min read

Kable and Secretary, Attorney General’s Department [2019] AATA 3963 (1 October 2019)

Division:GENERAL DIVISION

File Number(s):      2019/1706

Re:Leanne Kable

APPLICANT

Secretary,And  Attorney General’s Department

RESPONDENT

DECISION

Tribunal:                  Senior Member Damien O'Donovan

Date:1 October 2019

Place:Canberra

The Tribunal affirms the decision under review.

........................................................................

Senior Member Damien O'Donovan

Catchwords

FAIR WORK ENTITLEMENTS – Fair Work Entitlements Guarantee Act - applicant not entitled to advance in respect of redundancy payments – Fair Work Act the governing instrument - entitlement to redundancy pay under section 119 – meaning of small business employer under section 23 - whether company has the requisite number of employees at a particular time

Legislation

Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth)

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth)

REASONS FOR DECISION

Senior Member Damien O'Donovan

1 October 2019

  1. The applicant was an employee of Peter O’Brien Constructions Pty Ltd (POB Constructions).

  2. She commenced employment with that company on 20 February 2012.

  3. In 2017, POB Constructions experienced financial problems and ceased trading around July 2017.  Administrators were appointed on 14 September 2017. On 28 May 2018 liquidators were appointed.

  4. During this period of financial difficulty POB Constructions began to shed staff. Its employees, the applicant among them, did not receive the full entitlements which they were owed.

  5. Claims were made by former employees under the Fair Entitlements Guarantee Act 2012 (Cth) (FEG Act). The FEG Act provides for the Commonwealth to pay advances on account of unpaid employment entitlements to former employees in cases where:

    (a)the employer is insolvent;

    (b)the end of the employment was connected with that insolvency; and

    (c)the former employees cannot get payment of the entitlements from other sources.

  6. The applicant’s claim was submitted to the Department of Jobs and Small Business on 10 April 2018.

  7. From 29 May 2019, following machinery of government changes, the Attorney General’s Department became the respondent.

  8. On 16 November 2018, a delegate of the respondent made a decision under subsection 15(1) of the FEG Act that the applicant was eligible for an advance in respect of unpaid wages, annual leave (including loading), payment in lieu of notice and long service leave.[1] The delegate determined that the applicant was not entitled to an advance in respect of redundancy pay.

    [1] T12, folio 256.

  9. On 10 December 2018, the applicant applied for internal review of the delegate’s decision. On 28 February 2019, a delegate of the respondent made a decision under subsection 39(1) of the FEG Act affirming the original decision (‘the Reviewable Decision’).[2] Again the delegate determined that the applicant was not eligible for an advance in respect of redundancy pay.

    [2] T16, folio 281.

  10. On 27 March 2019, the applicant sought review of the Reviewable Decision in the Administrative Appeals Tribunal (the Tribunal).

  11. In the course of the proceedings, the parties consented to having the application heard on the papers.

  12. In making my decision, I have taken into account the following material:

    (a)Each party’s Statement of Facts, Issues and Contentions;

    (b)The Applicant’s Witness Statement filed with the Tribunal on…

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Kable and Secretary, Attorney General's Department and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2019] AATA 3963
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

This matter concerned an application for an advance under the Fair Work Entitlements Guarantee Act (FEG Act) by an employee of POB Constructions, who sought redundancy payments following the termination of her employment. The Secretary, Attorney-General's Department, was the respondent. The dispute centred on whether POB Constructions qualified as a "small business employer" under the Fair Work Act (FW Act) at the time of the applicant's termination, which would impact her entitlement to redundancy pay.

The primary legal issue before the Tribunal was to determine whether POB Constructions was a small business employer immediately before the applicant's employment was terminated. This determination hinged on whether the company had fewer than 15 employees at that specific time, as defined by section 23 of the FW Act. The Tribunal was required to ascertain the correct date for assessing the number of employees and apply the relevant provisions of the FW Act, particularly section 121 which excludes redundancy pay obligations for small business employers.

The Tribunal found that the applicant's employment was terminated on 10 August 2017. On that date, POB Constructions had 9 employees. The Tribunal noted that the company had begun shedding employees from 7 July 2017, and by 15 July 2017, the number of employees had fallen to 14. Consequently, POB Constructions met the definition of a small business employer from 15 July 2017 onwards. As the applicant's termination occurred when POB Constructions was a small business employer, she was not entitled to redundancy pay under section 119 of the FW Act. The Tribunal emphasised that it had no discretion to select an earlier date, such as 7 July 2017, for the calculation of benefits, and was bound to consider the actual date of termination.

Accordingly, the Tribunal affirmed the decision under review, concluding that the applicant's redundancy entitlement for the purposes of the FEG Act was nil.

Orders

Orders of the court

Background

Background to the litigation

It is in this statutory context that the applicant’s redundancy entitlement must be determined. Critical to that determination is the question: whether or not POB Constructions was a small business employer immediately before the applicant’s employment was terminated. That question is determined by reference to whether POB Constructions had fewer than 15 employees immediately before that event.FACTS Set out below are my factual findings. My findings in relation to termination dates are based on the Entitlement Data Report prepared by the Department which is at ST1. Where there is a conflict between the termination date the relevant employee claims and the termination date that is recorded as ‘verified’, I have taken the later of the dates which is an approach which favours the applicant. I have otherwise accepted the applicant’s evidence as accurate. On 7 July 2017, POB Constructions was unable to continue paying wages. Up until this date the company employed a total of 17 employees plus Peter O’Brien making a total of 18 employees for the purposes of determining whether it was a small business employer. From 7 July 2017, the company began to shed employees. The employees whose employment was terminated prior to the date the applicant was terminated and their dates of termination are set out in the table below. Following the departure of Mr Plane, Mr Thomson, Mr Mulvey and Mr Schumacher, POB Constructions’ number of employees fell from 18 employees on 7 July 2017 to 14 employees on 15 July 2017. By 10 August 2017, the number of employees had fallen to 9. No employee, including the applicant, was given written notice of termination.ANALYSIS There is no dispute that the FW Act is the governing instrument in relation to the applicant.[4] It provides for the payment of redundancy in the event of insolvency. Section 121 of the FW Act excludes the obligation to pay redundancy if the employer is a ‘small business employer’ immediately before the time of the termination or at the time when the person was given notice of the termination. [4] Respondent’s SFIC at [32]. There is no evidence that the applicant was ever given a notice of termination pursuant to section 117 of the FW Act so the relevant date for determining whether POB Constructions is a small business employer is the date of her termination – 10 August 2017. When the applicant had her employment terminated, POB Constructions had only 9 employees. POB Constructions had met the definition of a small business employer since 15 July 2017. Accordingly, immediately before the applicant was terminated, POB Constructions was a small business employer. In these circumstances, the applicant is not entitled to any redundancy payment under the FW Act and therefore her redundancy entitlement for the purposes of section 23 of the FEG Act is nil. The applicant feels that this outcome is unfair and that she is being penalised for her loyalty and empathy which led her to stay on longer than other employees. The applicant contends the date that should be taken into account, for the purposes of determining her FEG entitlements, is 7 July 2017. Unfortunately, the Tribunal has no discretion in this situation. The applicant continued to perform duties until her employment ended on 10 August 2017.[5] Her other FEG entitlements have been calculated to reflect this reality. There is no scope for the Tribunal to determine that a date should be used to calculate benefits which is different from the actual date of the applicant’s termination. Consequently, the decision under review must be affirmed.[5] T4, folio 102.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

Decision

Reasons for decision

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established