Fair Work Ombudsman v Bikaner India (WA) Pty Ltd

Link copied
Case Copied 57 min read

Federal Circuit and Family Court of Australia

(DIVISION 2)

Fair Work Ombudsman v Bikaner India (WA) Pty Ltd [2023] FedCFamC2G 20

File number(s): SYG 1182 of 2019
Judgment of: JUDGE HUMPHREYS
Date of judgment: 24 January 2023
Catchwords: INDUSTRIAL LAW – Fair Work Act – Restaurant Industry Award – multiple contraventions of the Act – whether Director accessorily liable – liability determined.
Legislation:

Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) ss 44, 45, 90, 323, 325, 340, 535, 536, 545, 550

Fair Work Regulations 2009 (Cth)

Workers Compensation and Assistance Act 1981 (WA)

Restaurant Industry Award 2010

Cases cited:

Allied Pastoral Holdings Pty Ltd v Commissioner of Taxation [1983] 1 NSWLR 1

Australasian Oil Exploration Ltd v Lachberg [1958] HCA 51

Australian Building and Construction Commissioner v Parker [2017] FCA 564

Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v April International Marketing Services Australia Pty Ltd (No 5) [2010] FCA 17

Australian Securities & Investments Commission v Maxwell (2006) 59 ACSR 373

Australian Securities and Investments Commission v ActiveSuper Pty Ltd (in liq) [2015] FCA 342

Browne v Dunne (1894) 6 R 67

Ezy Accounting 123 Pty Ltd v Fair Work Ombudsman [2018] FCAFC 134

Fair Work Ombudsman v Blue Impression Pty Ltd [2017] FCCA 810

Fair Work Ombudsman v Chatime Australia Pty Ltd [2022] FedCFamCG2 934

Fair Work Ombudsman v Grouped Property Services Pty Ltd (2016) 152 ALD 209

Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr [2018] FCA 5

Martin v Taylor [2000] FCA 1002

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825

Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 55

Seymour v Australian Broadcasting Commission (1977) 19 NSWLR 219

Yorke v Lucas (1985) 158 CLR 661

Division: Division 2 General Federal Law
Number of paragraphs: 197
Date of last submission/s: 13 January 2023
Date of hearing: 14-15 December 2022
Place: Parramatta
Counsel for the Applicant: Mr Power
Counsel for the Respondents: Ms Truong

ORDERS

SYG 1182 of 2019

FEDERAL CIRCUIT AND FAMILY COURT OF AUSTRALIA (DIVISION 2)

BETWEEN:

FAIR WORK OMBUDSMAN

Applicant

AND:

BIKANER INDIA (WA) PTY LTD (ACN 158 171 156)

First Respondent

SUSHIL KUMAR

Second Respondent

order made by:

JUDGE HUMPHREYS

DATE OF ORDER:

24 January 2023

THE COURT ORDERS THAT:

1.A declaration be made that the Second Respondent was involved in the following contraventions of the First Respondent, pursuant to s 550(2) of the Fair Work Act 2009 (Cth) (’the Act”):

(a)section 45 of the Act and clause 20.1 of the Restaurant Industry Award 2010 (“Award”), by failing to pay to Mr Hasan the required minimum rate of pay;

(b)section 45 of the Act and clause 34.1 of the Award, by failing to pay to Mr Hasan the required public holiday penalty rates;

(c)sections 44(1) and 116 of the Act, by failing to pay Mr Hasan for work not performed on a public holiday;

(d)section 45 of the Act and clause 34.2(a)(i) of the Award, by failing to pay to Mr Hasan the required evening penalty rates;

(e)section 45 of the

CaseChat AU logo

Keep reading for free

Create a free CaseChat account to read Fair Work Ombudsman v Bikaner India (WA) Pty Ltd and more:

  • Read every judgment in full
  • Ask AI and get answers linked to paragraphs
  • See how each paragraph was cited in later cases
  • Download judgments as PDF or Word
Continue with Google

One click creates your free account or signs you in.

By continuing you agree to the Terms and Privacy Policy.

Details
Case
[2023] FedCFamC2G 20
Decision Date

CaseChat Overview and Summary

The case of Fair Work Ombudsman v Bikaner India (WA) Pty Ltd involved a dispute between the Fair Work Ombudsman (FWO) and Bikaner India (WA) Pty Ltd, with the FWO alleging that Mr Kumar, a Director of Bikaner, had contravened certain workplace laws. Mr Kumar contested the allegations and denied that any declarations made against Bikaner bound him. The primary issue before the court was whether the FWO could establish a case of accessorial liability against Mr Kumar or if he needed to be proven guilty of the alleged contraventions separately. The court needed to determine if the declarations made against Bikaner in a default judgment could bind Mr Kumar and if the FWO could rely on these declarations to hold him accountable.

The court reasoned that declarations made in a default judgment typically bind all parties involved in the proceedings, provided they had the opportunity to be heard. The court cited several precedents to support this principle, emphasizing that a declaration should not be made unless all interested parties are included in the application. Additionally, the court noted that the absence of a necessary party to the proceedings is a matter of discretion when deciding whether to grant declaratory relief. The court found that the default declarations against Bikaner did bind Mr Kumar as he was a party to the proceedings and had the opportunity to be heard. This conclusion was based on the reasoning that even if Mr Kumar did not actively participate in the proceedings, he was served with the application and could have presented his case.

The court held that the declarations made against Bikaner by way of default judgment were binding on Mr Kumar. This decision was based on the well-established legal principle that declarations bind parties to a proceeding, provided they had the opportunity to be heard. The court granted the orders sought by the FWO, including that Mr Kumar pay the complainant $38,822.68, along with superannuation guarantee charges. The matter was listed for further directions to determine appropriate pecuniary penalties. The court also granted the FWO liberty to apply for enforcement if the orders were not complied with within the specified timeframe.

Background

Background to the litigation

Mr Kumar denies that the declarations made against Bikaner bind him. It is contended that the FWO must prove the alleged contraventions against him and the FWO cannot make out a case of accessorial liability against him.Background It is common ground that at all times from 6 July 2012, Mr Kumar was a Director of Bikaner. From 26 February 2015 to 18 December 2015, Mr Hasan Sharif (“Mr Sharif”) and his wife, Ms Trudi Ann Sharif, were joint Directors of Bikaner, along with Mr Kumar. Mr and Ms Sharif were not called by either party to the proceedings. The Court was advised by Counsel for the FWO that their whereabouts is unknown. Some evidence was admitted as to previous representations made by Mr Sharif to the FWO and the complainant. The Court has given these little, if any, weight other than they may have been said. It is not disputed that in or around March 2015, Mr Sharif, while in Bangladesh, offered the complainant employment with Bikaner and sponsorship by Bikaner for a Temporary Work (Skilled) 457 visa (“Subclass 457 visa”). The complainant alleges that on 28 March 2015, he entered into a contract of employment with Bikaner as a cook, at Bricklane, on a fulltime basis. The contract provided that the complainant would be paid an annual salary of $54,000 per annum for a 40 hour week plus an additional sum for hours worked over 40 hours per week. The complainant was granted a subclass 457 visa on 21 May 2015. He travelled, along with his wife and daughter, to Australia on or around 28 July 2015. He commenced working at Bricklane on or around 3 August 2015.The Fair WOrk ombudsman’s Evidence The FWO called three witnesses, the complainant, Ms Kawathar Girach, an inspector with the FWO, and Mr Shailander Bhatia, an accountant retained by Mr Kumar to do certain work. Each witness was cross-examined. A further witness, Ms Sharissa Thirukumar, gave evidence in an Affidavit but was not required for cross-examination.Evidence of the Complainant The complainant swore two Affidavits, an Affidavit in reply, filed 7 January 2019, and a trial Affidavit, filed 11 December 2020. In his Affidavits, the complainant deposes that he is qualified as a chef. He holds a Bachelor of Commerce in Management and a Diploma of Food Preparation and Culinary Art. Copies of his educational qualifications together with references from various employers. Although Mr Kumar claimed that the complainant was not a cook and had been selling cars prior to coming to Australia, no evidence was produced that indicated the certificates and references were fraudulent. In around March 2015, the complainant was contacted by Mr Sharif who offered him a job as a chef in a restaurant in Perth. He subsequently received a letter of appointment. His employer arranged for a subclass 457 visa to be granted to him. It was a condition of the visa that he work for Bikaner (WA) Pty Ltd. The complainant arrived in Australia around 1 August 2015. On 1 August 2015, he met Mr Kumar at the Bricklane restaurant. Mr Kumar explained that his hours of work would be six days per week, with one day off on either a Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday. He was to work Thursday and Friday, 10:00AM to 11:00PM and on all other days 3:00PM to 11:00PM.

Evidence

Evidence Before The Court

The FWO called three witnesses, the complainant, Ms Kawathar Girach, an inspector with the FWO, and Mr Shailander Bhatia, an accountant retained by Mr Kumar to do certain work. Each witness was cross-examined. A further witness, Ms Sharissa Thirukumar, gave evidence in an Affidavit but was not required for cross-examination.Evidence of the Complainant The complainant swore two Affidavits, an Affidavit in reply, filed 7 January 2019, and a trial Affidavit, filed 11 December 2020. In his Affidavits, the complainant deposes that he is qualified as a chef. He holds a Bachelor of Commerce in Management and a Diploma of Food Preparation and Culinary Art. Copies of his educational qualifications together with references from various employers. Although Mr Kumar claimed that the complainant was not a cook and had been selling cars prior to coming to Australia, no evidence was produced that indicated the certificates and references were fraudulent. In around March 2015, the complainant was contacted by Mr Sharif who offered him a job as a chef in a restaurant in Perth. He subsequently received a letter of appointment. His employer arranged for a subclass 457 visa to be granted to him. It was a condition of the visa that he work for Bikaner (WA) Pty Ltd. The complainant arrived in Australia around 1 August 2015. On 1 August 2015, he met Mr Kumar at the Bricklane restaurant. Mr Kumar explained that his hours of work would be six days per week, with one day off on either a Monday, Tuesday or Wednesday. He was to work Thursday and Friday, 10:00AM to 11:00PM and on all other days 3:00PM to 11:00PM. The complainant, however, was instructed by Mr Kumar that he was to fill in his time sheets as follows:1. Thursdays and Fridays: 12:00PM till 2:00PM and 5:00PM to 10:00PM;2. Saturdays and Sundays: 3:00PM till 10:00PM;3. All other days 5:00PM till 10:00PM. The above amounts to a total of 38 hours per week. It was claimed that it was said to the complainant that the discrepancy between the actual and recorded hours of work was because there was a limit on the number of hours he was allowed to work on his Subclass 457 visa. Mr Kumar explained the complainant’s wage would be $1,634.00 per fortnight. This would be paid into the complainant’s bank account. However, after receiving his wages, the complainant was to repay in cash $434.00 to either Mr Kumar, or if he was unable to pay Mr Kumar, to put the money in an envelope and give it to the restaurant manager, Ms Jasvir Kaur. He asked Mr Kumar what he needed to make this payment back and was told “it is the procedure for your visa”. At the restaurant, the complainant worked with Mr Sharif, who was Head Chef. He also worked with Tarun Kumar. Mr Kumar visited the restaurant at least 4-5 days per week. When there, Mr Kumar greeted and seated customers, took orders and bought order dockets to the kitchen. Mr Kumar also watched food being prepared and inspected the food before it went out to the customer. The complainant deposes that he took no sick days from 3 August 2015 to 9 February 2016. Although he worked over 50 hours per week, he always signed the time sheet for 38 hours.

Decision

Reasons for decision

The Court has already found that the termination letter of 18 December is a later fabrication. The Court is reasonably satisfied that this was an attempt to create a document that supported a false narrative that the complainant was terminated before he injured himself at work and thus the reason for the termination was not related to the workers’ compensation claim. The Court is satisfied the contravention was made out.Conclusion The Court is reasonably satisfied that Mr Kumar was involved in, within the meaning of s 550 of the Act, in each of the contraventions set out above. The Court grants the orders set out at the beginning of this judgement including, pursuant to s 545(2)(b) of the Act, that Mr Kumar pay to the applicant, on a joint and several liability basis, within 28 days of this order, the sum of $38,822.68 to the complainant. Further, Mr Kumar pay, also within 28 days, on behalf of the complainant, to the complainant’s nominated superannuation fund, superannuation guarantee charges due in respect of the unpaid wages of $38,822.68. The matter will be listed for directions as regards the filing of evidence to enable the Court to determine appropriate pecuniary penalties for the contraventions found proven. Should any of the orders made not be complied with, The Court grants the FWO liberty to apply on 3 days’ notice.

Ratio Decidendi

Legal Principle Established

For the reasons indicated, in relation to rejecting the evidence of Mr Sushil Kumar, the Court also rejects Ms Kaur’s evidence to the extent that it supports that of Mr Kumar, and prefers the evidence of the complainant. The Court does not accept her evidence that the complainant was given a termination notice on 18 December 2015. The Court also finds that she has tailored her evidence to support that of Mr Kumar.Do the Default Declarations against Bikaner bind Mr Sushil Kumar? On behalf of the FWO, it was submitted that the declared contraventions made against Bikaner, by way of default judgement, entered by Gilmore J bind all parties to the proceedings: (see; Martin v Taylor [2000] FCA 1002 at [32], citing Australasian Oil Exploration Ltd v Lachberg [1958] HCA 51). Courts have resisted making declarations based on admissions where there is a possibility of inconsistent factual findings being made: (see; Australian Competition and Consumer Commission v April International Marketing Services Australia Pty Ltd (No 5) [2010] FCA 17). Reference was also made to Fair Work Ombudsman v Lohr [2018] FCA 5 (“Lohr") in which Bromwich J considered the effect of declarations made by way of default judgement against a primary contravener on an alleged accessory to the contraventions. At [22], Bromwich J stated:Given the weight of the authority that suggests that declarations are binding on all parties to a proceeding provided that they have been given an opportunity to be heard, the only barrier to that legal position applying in this case was the reasoning of the primary judge as to the effect of [rules]… proper inquiry was not directed to the operation of the rules of Court in relation to how a default judgment can be entered, including as to orders and declarations, but, rather, was directed to the legal effect of a declaration once made, relying upon the terms of those rules. The trigger mechanism for making such declarations does not and cannot operate to confine their legal effect and impact. It was submitted that the following principles were referred to:1. Firstly, it is well established that a declaration should not generally be made unless all persons interested in the declaration are made parties to the application (and therefore, have the opportunity to be heard): (see; Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd (No 6) [2015] FCA 825 at 942);2. Secondly, a decision whether to grant or refuse declaratory relief in the absence of a necessary party is a matter of discretion: (see; Mineralogy Pty Ltd v Sino Iron Pty Ltd [2017] FCAFC 55 at 443); and3. Declarations only bind parties to a proceeding: (see; Martin v Taylor [2000] FCA 1002 at [32]). In finding that the declarations were binding upon Mr Lohr, the accessory to those proceedings, Bromwich J held that while Mr Lohr had not been legally represented at the time, it was sufficient that Mr Lohr was served with the default application, and therefore had the opportunity to be heard and present his case in opposition to the application, even when he did not in fact attend the hearing: (see; Lohr at [21]-[22]).